You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Good bye Roy


Page 24 of 36 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Feb 24 3.26pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Oh Lordy, are you my wife?!

Yes, and you do have a small p****.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 07 Feb 24 3.34pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Olise may be out for the remainder of the season. Eze might too. We haven't won a single game this season without them and I agree we likely would have more points if they'd stayed fit for longer, but they haven't and Roy has stuck steadfastly to playing a team with no creativity in their absence. It's not just about his unwillingness to play Franca or one of the other side-lined players but it's also been his inability to find an alternative method of creating opportunities in their absence, whether that be reverting to 442 with OE and JPM, using the wings more and bombarding teams with crosses, etc.

I'm not an experienced manager, but when Olise and Eze are out Roy looks clueless. They are likely both out for a long period. He never solved the conundrum when Wilf was out in his previous reign. Will another manager improve things? Who knows, but we need fresh ideas and right now a new manager might at least galvanise the fans and players who are all looking increasingly downtrodden. Sticking with the same horse midrace is a worthy statement, but not when it's gone lame. Load the gun Steve, it's time to put the old horse out of its misery.

This is obviously the conundrum that the board have.

There is no right answer.

There is always the chance of a new manager bounce but even with that, I believe that the statistical success of changing managers in a relegation battle is poor.

Clearly, what Hodgson has done without our best players has failed. That could be tactics or simply that they aren't good enough.
I think he has to try something new with what we have now.

If that fails, then we are left with desperate options.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (07 Feb 2024 3.35pm)

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 07 Feb 24 3.53pm

Couldn't agree more with this post. Those clamouring for Paddy, Derry, Popovic or Jedinak to replace a vastly experienced manager who we have now, must be mad. It's a last roll of the dice, but I honestly think the last chance we had of significantly changing anything was the January transfer window. Our attacking options are no better than before. SP and the board have gambled that we have enough. All 3 relegated teams changed their manager last year and failed with the new manager.

Sam Allardyce is as much as a dinosaur as Roy, and more of a busted flush. He failed miserably with West Brom and couldn't wait to get away from us asap. Probably because he knew the board wouldn't back him.

As far as I'm concerned, we probably already have as good a option as we are going to get, to keep us up. At best that is 50/50.

Roy should have left at the end of last season, but once again that rests with SP and the board. Many of us pointed it out before the season started that the squad wasn't strong enough. If we go down, to me the blame rests purely with the Board.

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Cloud cuckoo land stuff.

Big Sam is past it now, and the idea that any number of former players are suddenly going to rescue us is ridiculous.

Unless there is a clearly better option than what we have, then I say we should carry on with Hodgson.

It should be remembered that we have actually won two of our last four games. The difference in our performances came down to having star players available and the calibre of opposition.

Brentford and Sheffield were games we should win. Arsenal and Brighton, like it or not, were not.

It's clear that our injury problems have been the route of our poor performance this season. Had we had a full squad available, we would have more points and there would be no frenzy about sacking the manager. That is a fact.

As it is. There is no certainty that any change in management will improve results.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (07 Feb 2024 12.16pm)

Edited by fish mitten (07 Feb 2024 3.54pm)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Feb 24 4.09pm

Originally posted by est1905

You have completely missed his point (or just chosing to ignore because its not want you want to hear). What he is getting at is the main reason for our poor form is a terrible injury list that has gone on all season so far. Had we had Olise and Eze and Doucoure available for the whole of this season we would be 8 to 10 points better off and no one would be talking about relegation whether they hate Roy's style of football or not. That is a fact.
I'd only agree with the 'see you in the Championship next season' comment if the injury problems go on for the rest of the season.

This is part of a post I put earlier this afternoon on another thread:

"We have 15 games left to play. We've only managed 3 wins and 3 draws in our last 15 and we had Eze and Olise for the last 2 wins. in other words we had one win in that run without the two of them being on the pitch and that one win (Burnley) saw Eze come on for the last 30 minutes to provide the assist for Mitchell's last minute goal.
If we look at the 15 games to come and the results in the reverse fixtures earlier this season, we had
- 2 wins v Wolves (h) and Man U (away)
- 4 draws v Fulham (h), Forest (h), West Ham (away) and Man C (away)
- 9 (yes NINE) defeats."

The above are facts (not opinions). Another fact is that Hodgson was in charge of all of those last 15 games.

With Olise out, possibly for the rest of the season, and both Eze and Guehi out for the next few weeks, I would suggest that, given, Hodgson's record in the reverse fixtures (and the probability that, on paper at least, the more winnable games are those coming up) relegation is looking a genuine possibility if Hodgson stays and continues to stick to his Plan A (which seems to be his only plan). Indeed, it is possible, given the results in the reverse fixtures and the improved form of the two teams we beat, that we could fail to win a single game in the rest of this season.

Allowing Hodgson to continue is IMO, (and yes that's an opinion) the riskier of the two options in light of the above facts.

 

redshift Flag Toronto 07 Feb 24 4.19pm

This is a defining moment. Looks like we will have Roy for Chelsea and since expectations regarding the outcome of this game are low this would be the time to throw out the usual 'Plan A' and go with something different. It's a free pass to try to change the narrative because no one will blame him if it fails. At least no more than now.

Munoz and Wharton have had more time to seat in; if we were to come out with some of the kids (meaning the players recently acquired that Roy has refused to play) it might change things up enough to get us a result.

Just throwing the usual suspects out there and expecting a different result will show that Roy really doesn't know what he is doing any longer. He needs to grab onto this as the opportunity it is. Just my two cents.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

PatrickA Flag London 07 Feb 24 4.19pm

If Cooper doesn’t join at this stage then I can’t see who else will.
Certainly not Potter nor Lopetagui who are the other high profile out of work managers.
It may be that we are in a bizarre situation that Roy is willing to step down, but can’t because we find a replacement we want or can get.
In which case Roy is a reluctant manager and when fans shout ‘Hodgson Out!’ he can legitimately respond ‘If Only!’
Maybe in a year or so there will be another documentary in which case Parish will say it was all under control and in Sunak’s words ‘We had a plan’

 

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Feb 24 5.11pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This is obviously the conundrum that the board have.

There is no right answer.

There is always the chance of a new manager bounce but even with that, I believe that the statistical success of changing managers in a relegation battle is poor.

Clearly, what Hodgson has done without our best players has failed. That could be tactics or simply that they aren't good enough.
I think he has to try something new with what we have now.

If that fails, then we are left with desperate options.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (07 Feb 2024 3.35pm)

That's the crux though, he's had ample opportunities to try something new and the best he came up with was playing three centre-backs and five defensive minded players in front of them. I just don't see him changing anything unless he absolutely has to and expecting that he will is increasingly becoming more a plea to the Gods than any real belief. As the much cited cliché goes, doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results is the sign of insanity (a bit like me constantly refreshing the news to see if Roy's been sacked yet!)

 

The Dolphin Flag 07 Feb 24 5.37pm

Whatever happens and whoever he picks on Monday the whole crowd needs to put its antagonism to one side and support the team like never before.
That support could get us a result and so the team need to know they will get applauded not booed all the way through.
Chelsea are awful and there for the taking!

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 07 Feb 24 5.51pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Whatever happens and whoever he picks on Monday the whole crowd needs to put its antagonism to one side and support the team like never before.
That support could get us a result and so the team need to know they will get applauded not booed all the way through.
Chelsea are awful and there for the taking!


Absolutely Dolphin. We must support the team whatever our opinions about the manager and the Board. In return, though, the players have to put a shift in and show it means something to them.

 

PatrickA Flag London 07 Feb 24 6.06pm

If it's like Liverpool there will be cheers.
If it's like Bournemouth there will be boos.
Both ended in defeats,but they were very different in nature.
Fans want to see players giving their all and giving it a go.


Originally posted by doombear


Absolutely Dolphin. We must support the team whatever our opinions about the manager and the Board. In return, though, the players have to put a shift in and show it means something to them.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 07 Feb 24 9.11pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

That's the crux though, he's had ample opportunities to try something new and the best he came up with was playing three centre-backs and five defensive minded players in front of them. I just don't see him changing anything unless he absolutely has to and expecting that he will is increasingly becoming more a plea to the Gods than any real belief. As the much cited cliché goes, doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results is the sign of insanity (a bit like me constantly refreshing the news to see if Roy's been sacked yet!)

Roy is so stubborn he’ll keep doing the same thing regardless. He won’t change, his approach to each game won’t change and the outcomes are unlikely to change too. The longer Roy stays the less opportunities there will be for a different outcome.

TL I think you’ve hit the nail on the head.

 

PatrickA Flag London 07 Feb 24 9.12pm

Roys pre Chelsea match press conference is at 1.30pm.
I wonder if the journalists will ask proper questions or instead focus on VAR, the weather and other unrelated Palace matters.

 

PatrickA Flag London 07 Feb 24 9.13pm

1.30pm tomorrow I should add.

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 07 Feb 24 10.23pm

He must know that if we get spanked by Chelsea he's gone. Hoping he goes youth, all out attack, nothing to lose, he'll get paid anyway. Plaers in their right positions for once.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 07 Feb 24 10.43pm

Originally posted by CPFC1965

He must know that if we get spanked by Chelsea he's gone. Hoping he goes youth, all out attack, nothing to lose, he'll get paid anyway. Plaers in their right positions for once.

We need damage limitation, no way can he go youth all out attack. We will lose but it’s defend, defend, defend to have any chance with our quality prem players missing. No manager would have a chance with our remaining players in my opinion. We are doomed!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Feb 24 10.46pm

I suspect that Mr Hodgson will be in situ until the end of the season and will receive a rapturous reception at his last game at Selhurst Park.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 07 Feb 24 11.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

I suspect that Mr Hodgson will be in situ until the end of the season and will receive a rapturous reception at his last game at Selhurst Park.

I hope so.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 08 Feb 24 12.32am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Whatever happens and whoever he picks on Monday the whole crowd needs to put its antagonism to one side and support the team like never before.
That support could get us a result and so the team need to know they will get applauded not booed all the way through.
Chelsea are awful and there for the taking!

Chelsea are not there for the taking. In the same way Brighton weren’t either. Although that doesn’t stop people making silly statements, I suppose

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Romford-Eagle Flag Romford 08 Feb 24 1.14am

How long does it take for Parish to show Roy the door...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 08 Feb 24 2.03am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Roys pre Chelsea match press conference is at 1.30pm.
I wonder if the journalists will ask proper questions or instead focus on VAR, the weather and other unrelated Palace matters.


They are not allowed.

The system is rigged they select media they want and sort of scripted to a point otherwise that person wont get access again in the future.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Page 24 of 36 < 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy