This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Belmont
Do you have a negative view of yourself because of the words and actions of angry white men ( if that is what you are). If the only issue we have is the mis pronouncing of a T I think we are in a good place. I wasn’t talking about my own views. I was talking about other people’s views. The angry scenes this week have been by young black people. When you have the same demographic of white people doing the same you can ask the question. The T’s weren’t pronounced at all. This is a barrier in professional life, whatever your skin colour. Part of the issues are bringing down barriers. Same expectations along with opportunities based on merit for everyone. No favouritism.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I wasn’t talking about my own views. I was talking about other people’s views. The angry scenes this week have been by young black people. When you have the same demographic of white people doing the same you can ask the question. The T’s weren’t pronounced at all. This is a barrier in professional life, whatever your skin colour. Part of the issues are bringing down barriers. Same expectations along with opportunities based on merit for everyone. No favouritism. I dd ask the question the other day when I drew a parallel with the poll tax riots.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
No black people are marching against your comment about growing up in South London and understanding why people view the whole of the black community the same based on the actions of some AND the actions of three people. No they aren't. That is a convenient position for you to take. Have you been marching? If so, what did you march for exactly? What personal grievance have you got? A dodgy copper in another country accidentally kills a convicted multiple armed robber in custody. How does that justify all this?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
No black people are marching against your comment about growing up in South London and understanding why people view the whole of the black community the same based on the actions of some AND the actions of three people. Ok. So what’s your view of bringing back stop and search for the good of the whole black community to get rid of the knives, knife culture, killings, assaults, fear, negative image and publicity?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Ok. So what’s your view of bringing back stop and search for the good of the whole black community to get rid of the knives, knife culture, killings, assaults, fear, negative image and publicity? I would put in policy for the police for the good of the whole community, do you somehow thunk that the black community doesn't know there is an issue with knife crime.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
I dd ask the question the other day when I drew a parallel with the poll tax riots. Yes we’ll I’ve just said young black people, not black people who stay well clear of trouble, and the anti poll tax white people rioting were the usual crusty unemployed or unemployable. Anyone with any sense and a career they’d rather not damage with a criminal record would stay clear of any rioting like this. Most of the young black people were of college age.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
No they aren't. That is a convenient position for you to take. Have you been marching? If so, what did you march for exactly? What personal grievance have you got? A dodgy copper in another country accidentally kills a convicted multiple armed robber in custody. How does that justify all this? How many people in the black community have you actually spoken to to form this opinion of why people are marching? Before you ask I can quote how many and could even give you names if you wanted who in turn have spoken to other people and so on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
I would put in policy for the police for the good of the whole community, do you somehow thunk that the black community doesn't know there is an issue with knife crime. No. But there is an objection to stop and search. Unless you have stop and search and proper penalties, along with the longer term measures of community stuff, there will continue to be knife crime. This will help and stop a minority damaging things for the majority, which is kind of what you’re saying. All these things should be in debate anyway, and should have been anyway.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
How many people in the black community have you actually spoken to to form this opinion of why people are marching? Before you ask I can quote how many and could even give you names if you wanted who in turn have spoken to other people and so on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
How many people in the black community have you actually spoken to to form this opinion of why people are marching? Before you ask I can quote how many and could even give you names if you wanted who in turn have spoken to other people and so on. I’d genuinely like to know why people are marching. No need for names. I expect their to be valid reasons why people marched, along with things nothing to do with Britain, or just because, as is usual with protests. Of course your acquaintances might all have valid reasons. I’m genuinely interested because, like I say, this is for debate and what’s at stake, rather than virtue signalling nonsense and middle class promises to be this or that (for a few days) before hypocrisy is back in full swing again.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
No. But there is an objection to stop and search. Unless you have stop and search and proper penalties, along with the longer term measures of community stuff, there will continue to be knife crime. This will help and stop a minority damaging things for the majority, which is kind of what you’re saying. All these things should be in debate anyway, and should have been anyway. Yes there is some objection within the black community but they are only a spokesman for themselves no one else as I am for myself and you are for yourself. I always get the impression (and of course I could be wrong) that when a question like that is asked people think because one black person has said something that means we all think the same way. Before you say anything I am not applying that to you it's a just a general observation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Fair enough no I haven't been marching and my personal grievances are the grouse generalisations about the black community based on the actions of some, a fact you can understand growing up in south london, I grew up in south london and I can't understand it. Now you answer my question as fairs fair.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
So there should be mistrust of the whole of black culture by the actions of some, there is knife crime for sure there are other issues that we could debate for sure but if people have a mis trust of the whole of black culture based on the actions of some that is why people are marching. This is the point. What really bemuses me is yes, I generally have a negative view of the black community I’ll happily admit that but that’s purely based on my own experiences not some made up notion of racism. I grew up in south London and actually only left last year, I therefore grew up surrounded by black contemporaries and my experience is so called stereotypes are often well earned such as the lack of father figures, glorification of gang lifestyles, general disregard for typically British values, negative attitudes towards women and actually general negative attitude towards white people. I grew up with some social fads including happy slapping, rapping about crime and mugging, ducking mugging was a genuine fad and it wasn’t white kids promoting it and very rarely in my experience practicing it. We had the London riots too but I won’t get into that. I find it shocking there is no admission of willingness to address these issues from the black community and in fact often see this deflected as racism which is infuriating. If experiences of black people need to be acknowledged surely my own have validity too? In spite of this and yes in spite of this I still am very aware of my own biases, my unconscious bias and maintain good relationships with black friends and colleagues, let alone the wide variety of other cultures and ethnicities we have in society. Ethnicity and culture very rarely factor or feature in my day to day experiences, thoughts or decisions if ever. When the missus bought home a cat I wouldn’t of named it bleeding Wilf (even with the whole Arsenal/Evertongate) if i was so inclined. I most certainly don’t have a negative view of ALL black people I’d happily participate in a dialogue about race and would actively participate in promoting equality but this is not a reality however. Left wing media have pummelled people with a one sided, absolute narrative around these issues which has completely distorted the reality and therefore any ability to actually resolve social issues. I would be absolutely slammed for stating this elsewhere which I find astonishing. Whilst so many will disagree with me, I strongly believe and mpredict there will be no strides made towards social harmony with the current status quo. You may get some concessions for certain groups and many halfwits towing the line, although perhaps better to have them on that side, but it will be entirely disingenuous and superficial. You can’t possibly change people with half a brains views and opinions through coercion, you can make them comply butneed to have open discussion from both sides to achieve progress.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
If you expect me to say it's like the late 70s where bigoted skins are roaming the streets or there are national front matches going I won't because it isn't it is more subtle than that I will give you a very small example. On these boards there was discussion of how these recent riots would make employers and landlords think twice about dealings with black people in general, when I tried to point out the historic poll tax riots that where predominantly white people were rioting and would white people be viewed the same by employers etc, the replies very specifically drew a distinction in terms of it wasn't white people doing the rioting it was crusties or agitators. So basically if black people are involved in something like rioting they/we are viewed as a collective if white people do that it is only the perpetrators are singled out and described in differing ways and not as a collective. If people get themselves a criminal record by rioting, can that be discrimination if they dont get a job. Whatever colour they are as that's the only way it can impact an offer of a job I reckon.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
Yes there is some objection within the black community but they are only a spokesman for themselves no one else as I am for myself and you are for yourself. I always get the impression (and of course I could be wrong) that when a question like that is asked people think because one black person has said something that means we all think the same way. Before you say anything I am not applying that to you it's a just a general observation. Then at some point the usual suspects have to be shouted down. I think that for a situation that’s gone on and allowed to go on for so long, including by politicians in fear of being branded racist by loony lefties, it might be expected that stereotypes occur, people are fearful or take precautions by keeping out of the way. A young lad I know was mugged for his watch at knifepoint by 3 black lads the same age. How did he pay for his watch? Not privilege. His paper round money. This knife stuff needs to be ended. Not good for anyone. The community movement to end knife crime needs to go further.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
If you expect me to say it's like the late 70s where bigoted skins are roaming the streets or there are national front matches going I won't because it isn't it is more subtle than that I will give you a very small example. On these boards there was discussion of how these recent riots would make employers and landlords think twice about dealings with black people in general, when I tried to point out the historic poll tax riots that where predominantly white people were rioting and would white people be viewed the same by employers etc, the replies very specifically drew a distinction in terms of it wasn't white people doing the rioting it was crusties or agitators. So basically if black people are involved in something like rioting they/we are viewed as a collective if white people do that it is only the perpetrators are singled out and described in differing ways and not as a collective. Just to point out that it was mostly the poorer sections of our communities , plus antagonists/activists, plus Middle class hangers on that were involved in the poll tax riots. Colour was irrelevant. As for your second point, if you believe that black people were not involved in the rioting and that it was activists then let’s sort the perpetrators out, because however you describe it, it’s not right. Protesting against something fine, rioting wrong, breaching lockdown by ALL present, white or black, stupidly wrong and putting lives at risk.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Part of the grievance is that British and Americans have benefited from black slavery. There’s the difference. It’s a terrible part of history. It’s in the past, although in America there’s some who still view blacks as a lower species. You then have a load of whites, or people of colour, a term I don’t like for a few reasons, in free Britain with all its opportunities, wanting Britain to fall or suffer because of colonialism. Colonialism that would’ve happened by anyone else if Britain wasn’t there first. Of course, the elephant in the room is that the white European powers purchased the majority of black slaves from black tribal chiefs in Africa. Whilst it is abhorrently wrong for anybody to 'own' anybody else, I feel it is often forgotten that certain black chiefs also benefitted from the disgusting process. I believe that the rulers of Benin today are descended from those same black chiefs (I will be accepting of any counter information to that point).
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Belmont
Fair enough no I haven't been marching and my personal grievances are the grouse generalisations about the black community based on the actions of some, a fact you can understand growing up in south london, I grew up in south london and I can't understand it. Now you answer my question as fairs fair. Do I actually need to ask people personally about why they marched? Do I think the police in America should do more to root out rogue cops? Yes Do I think his killing was about racism? No. Do I think that Britain has any of those problems? No Do I think Britain is one of the most tolerant places in the world? Yes. Do I find it offensive when Black people think I should kneel or be accused of racism? You are damn right I do. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (06 Jun 2020 12.41pm)
|
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
This is the point. What really bemuses me is yes, I generally have a negative view of the black community I’ll happily admit that but that’s purely based on my own experiences not some made up notion of racism. I grew up in south London and actually only left last year, I therefore grew up surrounded by black contemporaries and my experience is so called stereotypes are often well earned such as the lack of father figures, glorification of gang lifestyles, general disregard for typically British values, negative attitudes towards women and actually general negative attitude towards white people. I grew up with some social fads including happy slapping, rapping about crime and mugging, ducking mugging was a genuine fad and it wasn’t white kids promoting it and very rarely in my experience practicing it. We had the London riots too but I won’t get into that. I find it shocking there is no admission of willingness to address these issues from the black community and in fact often see this deflected as racism which is infuriating. If experiences of black people need to be acknowledged surely my own have validity too? In spite of this and yes in spite of this I still am very aware of my own biases, my unconscious bias and maintain good relationships with black friends and colleagues, let alone the wide variety of other cultures and ethnicities we have in society. Ethnicity and culture very rarely factor or feature in my day to day experiences, thoughts or decisions if ever. When the missus bought home a cat I wouldn’t of named it bleeding Wilf (even with the whole Arsenal/Evertongate) if i was so inclined. I most certainly don’t have a negative view of ALL black people I’d happily participate in a dialogue about race and would actively participate in promoting equality but this is not a reality however. Left wing media have pummelled people with a one sided, absolute narrative around these issues which has completely distorted the reality and therefore any ability to actually resolve social issues. I would be absolutely slammed for stating this elsewhere which I find astonishing. Whilst so many will disagree with me, I strongly believe and mpredict there will be no strides made towards social harmony with the current status quo. You may get some concessions for certain groups and many halfwits towing the line, although perhaps better to have them on that side, but it will be entirely disingenuous and superficial. You can’t possibly change people with half a brains views and opinions through coercion, you can make them comply butneed to have open discussion from both sides to achieve progress. Excellent post
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Do I actually need to ask people personally about what they marched? Do I think the police in America should do more to root out rogue cops? Yes Do I think his killing was about racism? No. Do I think that Britain has any of those problems? No Do I think Britain is one of the most tolerant places in the world? Yes. Do I find it offensive when Black people think I should kneel or be accused of racism? You are damn right I do. Ok fair enough you are entitled to believe what you believe, but you stated with such surety why I was wrong I would have thought you would have had some more factual evidence to back it up than that, but I'll leave this one there as we will end up going round in circles.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.