You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth
November 22 2026 7.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexander Sörloth


Page 25 of 32 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >
manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 18 Sep 20 9.30pm

If this transfer and fee are true than I think it’s good business we have our money back that we paid for him, with a bit extra, which will go to another signing. For whatever reason Sorloth couldn’t cut it in Premier league, be it game time, the weight of the transfer fee we paid for him, the speed of the game. only he knows He has had one good season in a league nowhere near the standard of the premiership. There is no guarantee that he is going to cut the mustard at Leipzig

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Sep 20 11.18pm

Just out on interest have you seen the loan deal, or the documents in respect of the sale to RLBand distribution of proceeds ?

As ALL the chat on here has been speculation I don't see a working knowledge of contract law is relevant unless a copy of the documents are in hand.

At the end of the day it will be much less of a waste of money than Wickham and IMO Benteke.


Originally posted by palace99


If Bats scores 15 goals by xmas and someone bids £50m for him in Jan window, he is a Chelsea player so we get fcuk all. Yes Chelsea would have to break the loan deal, but it can be done.

As Sorloth had already refused to return to Turkey he broke the loan not Palace.

I am amazed we have agreed a 50:50 split.

The Turks paid £5m for a 2 year loan which predominantly just covers his wages. I suspect this was being paid in installments too. I am amazed we've paid them more than £5m to cover that payment.
It's irrelvant that they had a purchase clause - it could only be activated after the 2nd season and he has only played one. Yes £11m is better than i expected, but clearly £16m is a lot better.

Anybody who says this is a good deal knows nothing about contract law - and there were many on here who thought we'd get zero only a few weeks ago

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Sep 20 11.26pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Just out on interest have you seen the loan deal, or the documents in respect of the sale to RLBand distribution of proceeds ?

As ALL the chat on here has been speculation I don't see a working knowledge of contract law is relevant unless a copy of the documents are in hand.

At the end of the day it will be much less of a waste of money than Wickham and IMO Benteke.


I agree with you Owen.

Clearly it was relevant what clauses were in the contract. It has become the basis of some kind of chess game with four players that each had radically different objectives.

We just don’t know the details of the stratagems. And how the contract created the playing field.

 

Den1923 Flag 19 Sep 20 3.38pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I agree with you Owen.

Clearly it was relevant what clauses were in the contract. It has become the basis of some kind of chess game with four players that each had radically different objectives.

We just don’t know the details of the stratagems. And how the contract created the playing field.

Yes I agree also, this whole situation is somewhat speculative because we do not really know exactly what the loan deal was in terms of the small print etc, clearly the fact that we could not break the deal was an error and has to be down to the CP legal department and its advisors, no doubt the truth will come out eventually but in the meantime it is what it is and we just have to be grateful that we are getting something back and as far as Sorloth is concerned we really did not give him enough support as a club to adjust from the Norwegian league to the pace of the PL but as I have already said it is what it is and we have to move on hopefully quickly!

 

Jacey Flag 19 Sep 20 4.33pm

Our Alex is getting very discerning these days!!

[Link]

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 19 Sep 20 6.17pm

Hi
as Ive stated, from club info, Sorlorth was wanted out of the Club by Roy, Roy did not want him back, Roy has a history of not understanding a NO 9 players role... stick him on the wing... So the deal was about as close as a transfer that he would not come back and Sorlorth stated in Norway papers what he thought about the way he was treated.. The Club brought Sorlorth for the future, but Roy threw his toys of our pram, because he wanted some one else. Understand the LFC history with his time there...too


Originally posted by Den1923

Yes I agree also, this whole situation is somewhat speculative because we do not really know exactly what the loan deal was in terms of the small print etc, clearly the fact that we could not break the deal was an error and has to be down to the CP legal department and its advisors, no doubt the truth will come out eventually but in the meantime it is what it is and we just have to be grateful that we are getting something back and as far as Sorloth is concerned we really did not give him enough support as a club to adjust from the Norwegian league to the pace of the PL but as I have already said it is what it is and we have to move on hopefully quickly!

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 20 Sep 20 2.28am

and " club info " is what exactly?

Must be difficult for you to fuel your Roy hatred when we have 6 points from two games, best ever start in PL, but confident you'll find a way

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Hi
as Ive stated, from club info, Sorlorth was wanted out of the Club by Roy, Roy did not want him back, Roy has a history of not understanding a NO 9 players role... stick him on the wing... So the deal was about as close as a transfer that he would not come back and Sorlorth stated in Norway papers what he thought about the way he was treated.. The Club brought Sorlorth for the future, but Roy threw his toys of our pram, because he wanted some one else. Understand the LFC history with his time there...too


Edited by HKOwen (20 Sep 2020 2.30am)

Edited by HKOwen (20 Sep 2020 2.31am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

palace99 Flag New Mills 20 Sep 20 12.45pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

You may know about contracts but you don’t know about this one.

Eddie - not only are you showing your lack of knowledge re contracts you clearly don't understand how loans work re previous comments (using your logic Swansea can command a % of fee if Liverpool sell Brewster).

I'll keep it simple - a player can only be owned by 1 club at a time. Sorloth is owned by Palace so all negotiations should be with us. A bit like a house owner renting his home out and then decides to sell.

Clearly the loan deal adds a complication but it doesn't change the fact, Sorloth is our player.

Yes people are reasonably happy we are almost getting our money back (we paid adds on for staying up in seasons 1 and 2) and it is clearly better than the 6m Euro deal but we have proved yet again poor negotiators.

Don't bother replying, your opinion is irrelevant

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 20 Sep 20 12.49pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Just out on interest have you seen the loan deal, or the documents in respect of the sale to RLBand distribution of proceeds ?

As ALL the chat on here has been speculation I don't see a working knowledge of contract law is relevant unless a copy of the documents are in hand.

At the end of the day it will be much less of a waste of money than Wickham and IMO Benteke.


what a stupid comment. Clearly there was no clause re distribution of proceeds re a sell as if there was there would be no need to negotiate the split.

It is due to not having these clauses that has created the complications.

How hard is it to understand that???

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Sep 20 5.01pm

Originally posted by palace99

what a stupid comment. Clearly there was no clause re distribution of proceeds re a sell as if there was there would be no need to negotiate the split.

It is due to not having these clauses that has created the complications.

How hard is it to understand that???

What a rude and patronising response. You have absolutely no idea what was or was not in the contract and the negotiations could have been for any number of reasons.

If you wish to patronise people kindly make sure that you are on solid ground first to avoid ending up looking like a dork

 

Jacey Flag 20 Sep 20 8.21pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

What a rude and patronising response. You have absolutely no idea what was or was not in the contract and the negotiations could have been for any number of reasons.

If you wish to patronise people kindly make sure that you are on solid ground first to avoid ending up looking like a dork

Midland,

A dork.Haven't heard that term before.Did you mean dick??

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 Sep 20 8.28pm

Originally posted by palace99

Eddie - not only are you showing your lack of knowledge re contracts you clearly don't understand how loans work re previous comments (using your logic Swansea can command a % of fee if Liverpool sell Brewster).

I'll keep it simple - a player can only be owned by 1 club at a time. Sorloth is owned by Palace so all negotiations should be with us. A bit like a house owner renting his home out and then decides to sell.

Clearly the loan deal adds a complication but it doesn't change the fact, Sorloth is our player.

Yes people are reasonably happy we are almost getting our money back (we paid adds on for staying up in seasons 1 and 2) and it is clearly better than the 6m Euro deal but we have proved yet again poor negotiators.

Don't bother replying, your opinion is irrelevant

I think many on here may suggest your opinion is irrelevant

 

the.universal 20 Sep 20 9.25pm

Originally posted by palace99

Eddie - not only are you showing your lack of knowledge re contracts you clearly don't understand how loans work re previous comments (using your logic Swansea can command a % of fee if Liverpool sell Brewster).

I'll keep it simple - a player can only be owned by 1 club at a time. Sorloth is owned by Palace so all negotiations should be with us. A bit like a house owner renting his home out and then decides to sell.

Clearly the loan deal adds a complication but it doesn't change the fact, Sorloth is our player.

Yes people are reasonably happy we are almost getting our money back (we paid adds on for staying up in seasons 1 and 2) and it is clearly better than the 6m Euro deal but we have proved yet again poor negotiators.

Don't bother replying, your opinion is irrelevant

It’s like a Schrodinger’s Cat situation where he’s partly ours and partly theirs.

 


Vive le Roy!

EddieMac Flag 20 Sep 20 11.16pm

Originally posted by palace99

Eddie - not only are you showing your lack of knowledge re contracts you clearly don't understand how loans work re previous comments (using your logic Swansea can command a % of fee if Liverpool sell Brewster).

I'll keep it simple - a player can only be owned by 1 club at a time. Sorloth is owned by Palace so all negotiations should be with us. A bit like a house owner renting his home out and then decides to sell.

Clearly the loan deal adds a complication but it doesn't change the fact, Sorloth is our player.

Yes people are reasonably happy we are almost getting our money back (we paid adds on for staying up in seasons 1 and 2) and it is clearly better than the 6m Euro deal but we have proved yet again poor negotiators.

Don't bother replying, your opinion is irrelevant

I like to give everyone in life the benefit of the doubt because only god knows what issues they have in their personal life, but did anyone ever tell you that come across like someone with the IQ of a flip flop?


Edited by EddieMac (20 Sep 2020 11.16pm)

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 21 Sep 20 2.36am

Originally posted by palace99


If Bats scores 15 goals by xmas and someone bids £50m for him in Jan window, he is a Chelsea player so we get fcuk all. Yes Chelsea would have to break the loan deal, but it can be done.

As Sorloth had already refused to return to Turkey he broke the loan not Palace.

I am amazed we have agreed a 50:50 split.

The Turks paid £5m for a 2 year loan which predominantly just covers his wages. I suspect this was being paid in installments too. I am amazed we've paid them more than £5m to cover that payment.
It's irrelvant that they had a purchase clause - it could only be activated after the 2nd season and he has only played one. Yes £11m is better than i expected, but clearly £16m is a lot better.

Anybody who says this is a good deal knows nothing about contract law - and there were many on here who thought we'd get zero only a few weeks ago

I’d imagine the football club know a fair bit more than you about the ins and outs of the contract. The fact is that Trabzonspor had an option to buy now or an obligation to buy should he play more than 50% of next seasons games. So in essence he was their player for 6 million. Plus they would be due compensation if the loan was broken because we have already received a loan fee. To avoid a protracted dispute involving 2 clubs and an unhappy player it’s easier for all parties to just split the profits and sell while his value is high. We keep the loan fee which was about 4 million and then get 10 more which covers his transfer and the bonuses we owed. Trabzonspor get 10 as well which means they get 6 after the loan fee. Everyone is happy, they get to say it’s 50/50 and clear some of their debts and we get 14 million for a player we paid near enough 14 million for.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 21 Sep 20 2.42am

OK end of bell, if you want to go down that road.

If you could read properly you would see I have separated the original loan documents from any others relating to sale transaction by use of a comma and the word "or ".

Others on here have highlighted what a complete knob you are so no need for me to go there.

I pity anyone who has to actually engage with you in person.

COYP

Originally posted by palace99

what a stupid comment. Clearly there was no clause re distribution of proceeds re a sell as if there was there would be no need to negotiate the split.

It is due to not having these clauses that has created the complications.

How hard is it to understand that???

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 21 Sep 20 4.43am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

What a rude and patronising response. You have absolutely no idea what was or was not in the contract and the negotiations could have been for any number of reasons.

If you wish to patronise people kindly make sure that you are on solid ground first to avoid ending up looking like a dork


Outstandingly appropriate use of the word “dork.” Well done, Sir.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 21 Sep 20 6.28am

Originally posted by EddieMac

I like to give everyone in life the benefit of the doubt because only god knows what issues they have in their personal life, but did anyone ever tell you that come across like someone with the IQ of a flip flop?


Edited by EddieMac (20 Sep 2020 11.16pm)

You don't apply that principal to Schlupp, who you loved to tell everyone only completed one pass against Southampton, which nobody believed. Following Saturday, he was awesome and many peoples MOM.

 

EddieMac Flag 21 Sep 20 8.06am

Originally posted by Painter


You don't apply that principal to Schlupp, who you loved to tell everyone only completed one pass against Southampton, which nobody believed. Following Saturday, he was awesome and many peoples MOM.

I certainly don’t apply that to Schlupp because I have made up my mind on him over a few seasons and even after a decent game on Saturday I still hold the same opinion of him. I don’t think he is a very good football player.

I know he set up Townsend perfectly on Saturday for his goal and il take my hat off to him for his effort but nearly everything he did after that resulted in him losing the ball at the end. In my view there is no point in beating 3 men then giving the ball away, it may catch the eye of the fans but it’s pointless if it ends up with giving the ball away.

I can see why Roy plays him and we always look more balanced as a team because he is left footed but in my opinion he is a squad player not regular starter.

Do you think I just make up random facts about Jeff Schlupp to make myself feel good? He completed 1 pass against Southampton and that is a fact. Thiago completed 75 for Liverpool yesterday in 1 half of football.


Edited by EddieMac (21 Sep 2020 8.09am)

 

Den1923 Flag 21 Sep 20 11.48am

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Hi
as Ive stated, from club info, Sorlorth was wanted out of the Club by Roy, Roy did not want him back, Roy has a history of not understanding a NO 9 players role... stick him on the wing... So the deal was about as close as a transfer that he would not come back and Sorlorth stated in Norway papers what he thought about the way he was treated.. The Club brought Sorlorth for the future, but Roy threw his toys of our pram, because he wanted some one else. Understand the LFC history with his time there...too

I'm sorry, but how do you get access to such information that is so personal. Clearly Roy is a well respected and competent manager who understands every aspect of game and how it is played, therefore to say he does not understand the role of a No:9 is unkind, unjust and unwarranted.


 

Page 25 of 32 < 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth