You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 27 of 27 << First< 23 24 25 26 27
BarEagle Flag Monmouth 14 Jan 20 4.27pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Good point, I have been thinking/saying this for a while.

Our strikers do get a bad press but it's not as if they are all missing one-on-one's from being played in every week or open goals, we rarely create clear cut opportunities.

A bit of magic from Wilf, Andros or Jordan, a penalty, a Schlupp or PvA rocket, most of our goals seem to come from half-chances.

The only thing I can think of to counter this is that Benteke got 17 his first season and Bats a few in not many games last.

Even so, we are lacking any playmaking in the middle of the park.


Owen Garvan. Really?

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Jan 20 4.35pm

Roy gets us playing when we need to. Otherwise, he has us on a leash.

It's true we don't score many. Partly that's because we don't try to for large parts of many games.

I doubt Roy even particularly wanted us to score before Arsenal did om Saturday.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 14 Jan 20 4.51pm

Originally posted by Uphill

The negative comments about him do not surprise me.

Over the past ten years Palace have not nurtured what skilful talent they've had. Think of Michael Hughes, Ben Watson, Owen Garvan, Barry Bannon, etc. We don't play in a style that encourages creativity and the fans show no understanding or patience either.

Consider, why have we only scored 20 goals in 22?

The uninitiated will say incompetent strikers but the reality is lack of service. With a 'destructive midfield' of the likes of Milivojevic, Kouayate, etc it will always be so.
What passes they manage to provide are usually of the 'suicide' variety to a marked man who has no option but to offload immediately.

I feel sorry for Tosun, he will probably go the way of Gayle, Murray - frustratingly chasing after bits and scraps.

In short Meyer should be encouraged and played in his correct position.

Hughes was brilliant for Palace. As was Watson.

Garvan and Bannan. Average. Actually in fairness Barry did pretty well, considering.

However, I'd struggle to put any of those in the category of 'creative talent'.

Bostock, Zaha, Moses, Bolasie, yes. Fully nurtured (with the exception of bostock, prat). So not sure what the point is here.

If Meyer was a foot taller and more physical he'd be a regular. As it is, there's a reason we got him in on a free without any competition.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2020 4.52pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

pssguy Flag 14 Jan 20 5.05pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

He'd slot straight into Arsenal, Leicester or Man Citys side without a fuss and then people would be complaining why he didnt play like that for us!

Get real. As a kid he was outstanding but once he had to hack it with men he just couldn't. Either at Schalke or here.

A very small proportion of players have left Palace unappreciated and gone on to have stellar careers elsewhere

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 14 Jan 20 10.40pm

A look at his stats suggests that he was fairly prolific in his late teens but after appearing in the Olympics in 2016 this dried up and his form in the two years before joining us was very scratchy with no goals or assists.
ie pretty much what we've seen.

 

Aray Flag South London 14 Jan 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Hughes was brilliant for Palace. As was Watson.

Garvan and Bannan. Average. Actually in fairness Barry did pretty well, considering.

However, I'd struggle to put any of those in the category of 'creative talent'.

Bostock, Zaha, Moses, Bolasie, yes. Fully nurtured (with the exception of bostock, prat). So not sure what the point is here.

If Meyer was a foot taller and more physical he'd be a regular. As it is, there's a reason we got him in on a free without any competition.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2020 4.52pm)

He's the same size as Cabaye, near enough. And he is a giant compared to Torriera at Arsenal. It isn't his size that is the problem. But I agree he's not physical enough.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 15 Jan 20 1.54am

Was mentioned before, Messi and his compatriots at Barcelona is not that "bulked up" so what is the point? Play Meyer where he should be played - not put him out on the wing.
With him and Riedewald we now have two clever ball-players in our squad - use them and use them in their proper positions.

 

bangkokeagle Flag bangkok 15 Jan 20 2.34pm

Not sure Michael Hughes was a Max Meyer type player. Tough tackling midfielder, though he could spray a pass. Thought he was brilliant for us. Meyer is a bet meh.

 


'It's unbelievable and, in many ways, it's believable' Tony Popovic

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 15 Jan 20 6.31pm

People overrate Meyer because we’re crying out for a player of his ilk, albeit with more quality. He’s not a bad player, but he is average.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 15 Jan 20 6.32pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Hughes was brilliant for Palace. As was Watson.

Garvan and Bannan. Average. Actually in fairness Barry did pretty well, considering.

However, I'd struggle to put any of those in the category of 'creative talent'.

Bostock, Zaha, Moses, Bolasie, yes. Fully nurtured (with the exception of bostock, prat). So not sure what the point is here.

If Meyer was a foot taller and more physical he'd be a regular. As it is, there's a reason we got him in on a free without any competition.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2020 4.52pm)

Yep.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 Jan 20 8.43am

Originally posted by TomThePalaceFanatic

People overrate Meyer because we’re crying out for a player of his ilk, albeit with more quality. He’s not a bad player, but he is average.

Play him in his natural position, stick with him and confidence will blossom. He is quality whatever many here says...like a certain Riedewald that was written off by most fans.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jan 20 12.42pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Play him in his natural position, stick with him and confidence will blossom. He is quality whatever many here says...like a certain Riedewald that was written off by most fans.

I tend to agree, the odd thing is he plays alongside two strong defensive minded midfielders but still is expected to play like another one. So, they are either not covering enough of the park or we simply are not good enough to play without a strong 3

 

General Flag 16 Jan 20 8.59pm

Originally posted by TomThePalaceFanatic

People overrate Meyer because we’re crying out for a player of his ilk, albeit with more quality. He’s not a bad player, but he is average.

Can you let us all know what you think Meyer should be better at to make him not average?

Then we can find a similar player with the qualities you demand Meyer needs to actually improve our team over.

Then we can see how much that player is worth. And what his wages are. And what club he is at. And whether said player would come to us or whether we have ever had a player like that. Or ever will.

Cheers

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 16 Jan 20 11.04pm

Originally posted by General

Can you let us all know what you think Meyer should be better at to make him not average?

Then we can find a similar player with the qualities you demand Meyer needs to actually improve our team over.

Then we can see how much that player is worth. And what his wages are. And what club he is at. And whether said player would come to us or whether we have ever had a player like that. Or ever will.

Cheers

he's on a fat wage and is only decent in flashes - can't handle the physical side - he's not as good as McArthur - I think like the rest that we need a midfielder who can has some attacking flair but who doesn't get overpowered in games, not easy to find one without breaking the bank but that's the aim - and it shouldn't be that hard to get better value for money than we're getting for Meyer - we have Luka in the anchor role so I can't see Meyer getting his chance playing deep, and I very much doubt he'd flourish in that role as some are suggesting.

 

Page 27 of 27 << First< 23 24 25 26 27

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread