You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stadium
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stadium


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
hastingseagle67 Flag 03 Apr 14 1.10pm

So we can grow into a slightly bigger club and establish ourselves as a mid table premiere league club, cos let's face it we will never break into the top 6. Boooorrrring !!!
A couple of seasons messing around in the top league, maybe a flirt with relegation or two, that we survive. Then the disappointment of the drop. A couple of seasons in the championship flirting with the play offs, then a fantastic promotion season. That will do me. Mid table - schmid table !

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 03 Apr 14 1.41pm

Quote Lyons550 at 02 Apr 2014 7.34pm

Quote adrian b at 02 Apr 2014 3.16pm


Brighton and their owners are stating they are a big club with a big future. It may cost money, but they believe. What about us? Stand up if you believe in Palace. Stay sitting if you want a small club forever. Thank god A. J. Wait had the foresight and subsequent chairman have followed his lead.

Keep sitting Lyons550! It's done Brighton the world of good. For all their crap, they have a better ground than us. Happy?

f***ing fat lot of good its doing them. I agree about the need to build but we must do so pragmatically...


 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Apr 14 1.50pm

Quote Catfish at 02 Apr 2014 5.59pm

Quote est1905 at 02 Apr 2014 5.28pm

Quote girvinator at 02 Apr 2014 5.22pm

Pretty sure SP has two plans for the stadium both short term and long. One for a Palace in the Championship and one for a Premiership Palace.

The ground still needs work regardless of what league its just being in the Prem means more work can be done quicker due to funds, expansions will be bigger. Facilities better etc due to the extra demand.

A tricky situation for the board definitely. Also they dont want any construction reducing the stadium size on a temporary basis whilst we are still in the Prem.

I know for a fact if we stay up 1 mil is getting put in undersoil heating this summer.

Well that's a first as Palace have repeatedly applied for planning permission to install under soil heating over the years and has always been denied. Noades applied at least twice as did Jordan. I do not know what the grounds for refusal were but I do know the club have wanted to install it at Selhurst Park for years and not been allowed.
It's not even that expensive to install. Certainly not the £1m you mention. Most of the labour costs will be already covered by our own groundstaff who are already on the pay role



Probably the usual reason - didn't offer the Croydon council planning committee members a big enough back hander.


Planing consent for under-soil heating? Are you sure? Do you have a link for this that would prove me wrong?

Croydon may have turned down an application based on non compliance with building, electrical or other like regulations or on health and safety grounds; otherwise, I would be surprised if a decent under-soil heating system properly fitted would need Council approval. Perhaps previous boards have attempted to instal a cheap [and potentially dangerous] system?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Apr 14 1.59pm

Quote martin2412 at 02 Apr 2014 10.03pm

Quote silvertop at 02 Apr 2014 4.25pm

Quote adrian b at 02 Apr 2014 2.52pm

Quote rikz at 02 Apr 2014 2.46pm

Quote adrian b at 02 Apr 2014 2.34pm


Here we go again. So Palace need to stay up to justify a new stadium? Na, if that were the case then Palace wouldn't have built anything yet. Like the roads, build them and see the traffic come after. It always does and so it will again. It's all aquestion of faith. Those who say we should wait to build have no faith in our club. Hideous!


^^^ this
We could of easily got 35k at home this season with selling tickets on the door, okay alot would be day trippers and a few away fans in the home end but its what you get at a lot of other grounds in the premier league, and it would be worth it for the extra income the club would get

Yep


Nope - unless the local planning authority say yep. It's all well and good saying we should expand to accommodate 35k + but the LPA have to approve it first. When we last applied to rebuild the ground with c42k seats, the LPA agreed a plan but limited to an increased capacity of only 600. As I said when I last posted on this, there will have to have been a complete sea change from the 1990s and the club may also have to finance a lot of public realm changes to deal with increased numbers, parking, road use, public transport etc as a condition for any significant increase in capacity. This takes time and a long term financial commitment which we are only likely to meet if we stay up.

I don't understand this at all. Why would they only grant permission for another 600 thinking the infrastructure is insufficient to cope ? I have been in Selhurst with over 50,000 in there, and regular crowds of between 30 - 40,000 when the transport system was about the same as it is now. Probably the health & safety brigade strike again.


Correct. Different time; different rules.

For instance, the Burnley match preceded Hillsborough and the Taylor Report. Also, s106 of the Town and Country Planning Act came into force in 1990 - this is the one empowering the LPA to insist on improvements to public realm as a condition for granting consent for major developments.

I should also add that LPA's are not consistent throughout the country. While Liverpool were happy to allow their team in red consent to demolish a row of Victorian houses to accomodate a grand new stand, that does not serve as an authority requiring Croydon to follow suit. LPAs have wide discretion to take into account local factors.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 03 Apr 14 2.21pm

Quote adrian b at 03 Apr 2014 1.41pm

Quote Lyons550 at 02 Apr 2014 7.34pm

Quote adrian b at 02 Apr 2014 3.16pm


Brighton and their owners are stating they are a big club with a big future. It may cost money, but they believe. What about us? Stand up if you believe in Palace. Stay sitting if you want a small club forever. Thank god A. J. Wait had the foresight and subsequent chairman have followed his lead.

Keep sitting Lyons550! It's done Brighton the world of good. For all their crap, they have a better ground than us. Happy?

f***ing fat lot of good its doing them. I agree about the need to build but we must do so pragmatically...



There are plenty clubs that have bigger grounds than us that are in the divisions below, never full and white elephants. If you read what I said I agree we need to redevelop/expand...just that we do it pragmatically and in an affordable manner.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 04 Apr 14 2.03pm

Bit confused now Lyon. What having a stadium that can accommodate more fans than the season's average got to do with white elephants? Whatyer saying, unless every seat is taken up there's a white elephant? I think if a team is watched by 20,000 in a ground for 30,000, or by 35,000 in a 45,000 seater then all's well. No need to panic about building a stadium for the future. Unless, of course, you do not think there is a future. A bleak thought. I prefer to be positive, look to a big future and let Selhurst be a testament to that.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 04 Apr 14 2.11pm

What would people like a redeveloped selhurst to look like, id love to see the main stand look like the crystal palace from outside

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 04 Apr 14 2.11pm

But what is a "big future" for Palace. Surely you've got to admit that we are never going to win the premiere league, so what's the point of finishing tenth or eleventh every season. Where's the emotion that comes with the highs and lows of relegation and promotion. The only good thing I could foresee would be the chance that you might make the odd cup final, but that's very hit and miss.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Holmesdale Nick Flag South Croydon 04 Apr 14 2.21pm

I think the best way would be ground share at Chelsea for a season whilst Selhurst Park is completely redeveloped.

 


Fitter Fans Group 2. No. 17

Welling Eagle Flag Welling 04 Apr 14 2.22pm

Quote hastingseagle67 at 04 Apr 2014 2.11pm

But what is a "big future" for Palace. Surely you've got to admit that we are never going to win the premiere league, so what's the point of finishing tenth or eleventh every season. Where's the emotion that comes with the highs and lows of relegation and promotion. The only good thing I could foresee would be the chance that you might make the odd cup final, but that's very hit and miss.


Right boys stop trying to become an established prem team. Just get us relegated back to the championship!

 

Plane Flag Bromley 04 Apr 14 2.27pm

Quote hastingseagle67 at 04 Apr 2014 2.11pm

But what is a "big future" for Palace. Surely you've got to admit that we are never going to win the premiere league, so what's the point of finishing tenth or eleventh every season. Where's the emotion that comes with the highs and lows of relegation and promotion. The only good thing I could foresee would be the chance that you might make the odd cup final, but that's very hit and miss.


Fvck it, we might as well shut up shop now and sell the ground and disband the team, as should every club outside the top three.

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 04 Apr 14 4.54pm

Being a successful team in the premiere league produces a very strange breed of fan. The type of fan who expects success rather than appreciates it . I'm a great believer that you enjoy success much more when you haven't had it all the time. Yes let's enjoy this season in the top league and maybe one or two more, but let's not forget the times a couple of seasons ago when we were getting 12-15 thousand gates of true die hard Palace fans. Building a bigger stadium may well attract more fans,and bring more success, but they would be the kind of fans who would turn on us at the first signs of failure, and it would be the kind of success that would make us stale and complacent.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Username Flag Horsham 04 Apr 14 5.26pm

Quote hastingseagle67 at 04 Apr 2014 2.11pm

But what is a "big future" for Palace. Surely you've got to admit that we are never going to win the premiere league, so what's the point of finishing tenth or eleventh every season. Where's the emotion that comes with the highs and lows of relegation and promotion. The only good thing I could foresee would be the chance that you might make the odd cup final, but that's very hit and miss.

Maybe I'm old fashioned but I'd be happy being secure in the Prem, taking the odd scalp off a big club, beating our rivals (if they make it this far) and giving the cups a good go.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

rikz Flag Croydon 04 Apr 14 9.04pm

We've never even stayed in the premier league longer than a season so how can anyone say its boring id rather go down and chase promotion.
I'd much rather stay up and watch us bring in better quality players, watching better quality football,causing a few upsets here and there, trying to break in the top 10, having good cup runs and maybe one day having a go in Europe.

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 04 Apr 14 9.10pm

just staying up and doing one stand at a time would please me, maybe being linked with a few players during the world cup and even better getting a few, would like four different stands to, hate the bolton type stadiums, to clinical, prefer two/ three and four tiers and maybe one massive holt end!

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 04 Apr 14 9.38pm

Quote rikz at 04 Apr 2014 9.04pm

We've never even stayed in the premier league longer than a season so how can anyone say its boring id rather go down and chase promotion.
I'd much rather stay up and watch us bring in better quality players, watching better quality football,causing a few upsets here and there, trying to break in the top 10, having good cup runs and maybe one day having a go in Europe.


You put forward a good case and make it sound appealing, but not for me I'm afraid, i need the pain to appreciate the glory and keep it real.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 08 May 14 9.01am

There was some previous talk about the spinning Selhurst round 90 degrees and extending the Holmesdale to become a stand. Anyone know if this has been ruled out?

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 08 May 14 9.22am

Quote hastingseagle67 at 04 Apr 2014 4.54pm

Being a successful team in the premiere league produces a very strange breed of fan. The type of fan who expects success rather than appreciates it . I'm a great believer that you enjoy success much more when you haven't had it all the time. Yes let's enjoy this season in the top league and maybe one or two more, but let's not forget the times a couple of seasons ago when we were getting 12-15 thousand gates of true die hard Palace fans. Building a bigger stadium may well attract more fans,and bring more success, but they would be the kind of fans who would turn on us at the first signs of failure, and it would be the kind of success that would make us stale and complacent.

Well, with any luck we'll get relegated next season then, then we can have the club all to ourselves again.

Edited by Proper_Gander (08 May 2014 9.23am)

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 08 May 14 11.15am

[Link]

How about this as a stadium design? What could be more appropriate for a club called Crystal Palace? Could also be used for concerts. This is in New Zealand and is the worlds only covered stadium with natural turf. The pitch is irrigated by a water system that channels water from the roof. The capacity is over 30,000 even without the corners being used. As well as being a football stadium it would be a major venue in its own right.

Edited by Catfish (08 May 2014 11.33am)

Edited by Catfish (08 May 2014 11.43am)

image.jpg Attachment: image.jpg (53.89Kb)

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 08 May 14 11.37am

Quote Catfish at 08 May 2014 11.15am

[Link]

How about this as a stadium design? What could be more appropriate for a club called Crystal Palace? Could also be used for concerts.

Edited by Catfish (08 May 2014 11.33am)


image.jpg Attachment: image.jpg (69.18Kb)

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stadium