You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the season
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player of the season


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 14 Apr 14 5.29pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Apr 2014 5.08pm

my votes

1. Speroni
2. Dann, this the defence really solidified when he got here

3. Jedinak, always great consistent effort

Doing very well but only 9 games.

 

jpegnall Flag Surrey 14 Apr 14 5.34pm

Speroni...

A few others have come close... Jedi for me made too many mistakes in the early part of the season with sloppy passes. JS has been nearly faltless so far - no crucial mistakes and plenty of crucial saves.

 

Mstrobez Flag 14 Apr 14 5.36pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 5.29pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Apr 2014 5.08pm

my votes

1. Speroni
2. Dann, this the defence really solidified when he got here

3. Jedinak, always great consistent effort

Doing very well but only 9 games.

Exactly, Joe Ledley has been great as well but not enough games to judge the whole season.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 14 Apr 14 5.38pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 4.16pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 3.00pm

Quote Plane at 14 Apr 2014 2.07pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 1.58pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 11.21am

Quote Leicestershireeagle at 14 Apr 2014 10.51am

Ward, Speroni and Jedinak.

Don't know who though. Jedinak is so instrumental in our game; he had the week or the week before, and may still do now, the most interceptions in EUROPE. Speroni has saved us so many times, and Ward' step up to this level has been brilliant.

Don't think I'd grumble if it was any of them.

Ive been very underwhelmed by Jedi this year.


33 Starts suggests you know very little about Football.

That's apparent just by reading any of his posts.


So he has been amazing all season has he. His stats are very high because on a good day he is an absolute beast and wins the ball so much, but some games this year have been appalling and he has gifted the opposition goals on many occasion.

Name those Games.?
We have only let in 39.!!
We have the 5th best defence in the League.
My previous comment stacks up.

Edited by Bill Glazier (14 Apr 2014 4.16pm)


I cant name the games tbf most were Holloway matches. Stoke, Man UTD (Mistake led to pen), Swansea, Fulham, Newcastle and Norwich. I think are the games. Don't get me wrong on a whole he has been fine but no way player of the year. Jules, Ward, Delaney or Puncheon for me.

 

est1905 Flag 14 Apr 14 5.50pm

For consistency over the whole season it has to be Speroni or Ward. Jedi has had some amazing games and was back to his best against Chelsea but he has had a couple of stinkers in recent weeks too.
Puncheon is another one who is in great form at the moment but hasn't always been.
Chamakh deserves a mention but has been in/out of the team a couple of times.
Bolasie has also proved me wrong. I did not believe he could make the step up to the Premiership but he has at times been outstanding. But his goal scoring rate is appalling. While it is not his job to score the goals he has had plenty of opportunities, especially recently. You'd expect him to weigh in with at least one or two.

For me Jules, although Ward runs him very close.

 

jpegnall Flag Surrey 14 Apr 14 5.51pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 4.16pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 3.00pm

Quote Plane at 14 Apr 2014 2.07pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 1.58pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 11.21am

Quote Leicestershireeagle at 14 Apr 2014 10.51am

Ward, Speroni and Jedinak.

Don't know who though. Jedinak is so instrumental in our game; he had the week or the week before, and may still do now, the most interceptions in EUROPE. Speroni has saved us so many times, and Ward' step up to this level has been brilliant.

Don't think I'd grumble if it was any of them.

Ive been very underwhelmed by Jedi this year.


33 Starts suggests you know very little about Football.

That's apparent just by reading any of his posts.


So he has been amazing all season has he. His stats are very high because on a good day he is an absolute beast and wins the ball so much, but some games this year have been appalling and he has gifted the opposition goals on many occasion.

Name those Games.?
We have only let in 39.!!
We have the 5th best defence in the League.
My previous comment stacks up.

Edited by Bill Glazier (14 Apr 2014 4.16pm)


I cant name the games tbf most were Holloway matches. Stoke, Man UTD (Mistake led to pen), Swansea, Fulham, Newcastle and Norwich. I think are the games. Don't get me wrong on a whole he has been fine but no way player of the year. Jules, Ward, Delaney or Puncheon for me.


Early part of the season under IH he did give away the ball a lot with lazy passes some of which led to goals, but under TP there have been none that I can remember...

 

doublesuited77 Flag London (Camden) 14 Apr 14 5.59pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 5.29pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Apr 2014 5.08pm

my votes

1. Speroni
2. Dann, this the defence really solidified when he got here

3. Jedinak, always great consistent effort

Doing very well but only 9 games.

and look at our results in those games.

I honestly see the point and i will be shocked if anyone but Jules wins.

However, I interpreted this question in a slightly different way -- which player has the most to do with us staying safe?

In my mind, after Jules, Its Scott Dann. If we didnt acquire him, I honestly think we are in the drop zone right now. Though only 9 games, I would take him against almost any centre back in the PL


 


Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace

Mstrobez Flag 14 Apr 14 6.00pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Apr 2014 5.59pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 5.29pm

Quote doublesuited77 at 14 Apr 2014 5.08pm

my votes

1. Speroni
2. Dann, this the defence really solidified when he got here

3. Jedinak, always great consistent effort

Doing very well but only 9 games.

and look at our results in those games.

I honestly see the point and i will be shocked if anyone but Jules wins.

However, I interpreted this question in a slightly different way -- which player has the most to do with us staying safe?

In my mind, after Jules, Its Scott Dann. If we didnt acquire him, I honestly think we are in the drop zone right now. Though only 9 games, I would take him against almost any centre back in the PL



I dunno about that...

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 14 Apr 14 6.17pm

Speroni or Ward, both deserve the prize. Jedinak a beast in defending, but half of the game is to pass the ball to a teammate. In this section MJ is nothing but awful.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 14 Apr 14 6.22pm

Quote jpegnall at 14 Apr 2014 5.51pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 4.16pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 3.00pm

Quote Plane at 14 Apr 2014 2.07pm

Quote Bill Glazier at 14 Apr 2014 1.58pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 14 Apr 2014 11.21am

Quote Leicestershireeagle at 14 Apr 2014 10.51am

Ward, Speroni and Jedinak.

Don't know who though. Jedinak is so instrumental in our game; he had the week or the week before, and may still do now, the most interceptions in EUROPE. Speroni has saved us so many times, and Ward' step up to this level has been brilliant.

Don't think I'd grumble if it was any of them.

Ive been very underwhelmed by Jedi this year.


33 Starts suggests you know very little about Football.

That's apparent just by reading any of his posts.


So he has been amazing all season has he. His stats are very high because on a good day he is an absolute beast and wins the ball so much, but some games this year have been appalling and he has gifted the opposition goals on many occasion.

Name those Games.?
We have only let in 39.!!
We have the 5th best defence in the League.
My previous comment stacks up.

Edited by Bill Glazier (14 Apr 2014 4.16pm)


I cant name the games tbf most were Holloway matches. Stoke, Man UTD (Mistake led to pen), Swansea, Fulham, Newcastle and Norwich. I think are the games. Don't get me wrong on a whole he has been fine but no way player of the year. Jules, Ward, Delaney or Puncheon for me.


Early part of the season under IH he did give away the ball a lot with lazy passes some of which led to goals, but under TP there have been none that I can remember...


Which is why I cant award him player of the year, Damo and Ward were great even under the clown that is Ian Holloway. Although under Pulis Jedi has been good, but he still has had bad games.

 

Lawrie Flag Brooks Green (near Horsham) 14 Apr 14 7.01pm

Slightly different slant on this subject.....
Considering that we've shipped fewer goals than a lot of teams (including Liverpool), then the obvious answer is that the player of the season should be a defender.
Then you should consider the defensive contributions of some of our forwards. Chamakh is a classic example, although he's not the only attacker who's tracked back & defended well. (didn't Jerome clear one off the line recently?)
We should also not ignore the attacking abilities of defenders. Guys like Moxey, Parr and Ward skipping up the wing to set up attacks.
No........this season has been a team effort. I'm bloody proud of everyone who's put on the shirt this year (perhaps apart from Campana, who promised so much, but delivered so little).
So.....the player of the year should be shared by everyone.
Everyone who's put on the Red & Blue.
Stupid idea.....yeah probably, but worth a shout....hopefully.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 14 Apr 14 7.55pm

Joel Ward has been consistently great throughout the whole season. The only game where he's been slightly weaker was at the Emirates, but he's allowed one off day and he should get Player of the Year and be on the plane to Brazil.

Speroni struggled slightly in the early part of the season (under Holloway I know, but still), although his form since Holloway left has been superb, and he seems to dominate his box a lot more. I thought he'd be exposed on that front, but he hasn't at all. 2nd

But, as people have mentioned, it truly has been a team effort. Delaney, Chamakh, Jedinak, Puncheon and Dann have all been great too.

 

jpegnall Flag Surrey 14 Apr 14 8.35pm

Quote TomThePalaceFanatic at 14 Apr 2014 7.55pm

Joel Ward has been consistently great throughout the whole season. The only game where he's been slightly weaker was at the Emirates, but he's allowed one off day and he should get Player of the Year and be on the plane to Brazil.

Speroni struggled slightly in the early part of the season (under Holloway I know, but still), although his form since Holloway left has been superb, and he seems to dominate his box a lot more. I thought he'd be exposed on that front, but he hasn't at all. 2nd

But, as people have mentioned, it truly has been a team effort. Delaney, Chamakh, Jedinak, Puncheon and Dann have all been great too.

I don't think you can say he struggled... the goals we conceded were no reflection on him, he still was playing well, not making mistakes and making good saves - he couldn't make up for our lack of defence true, but no keeper in the world would have made a difference to the outcome of our games under IH this season.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 14 Apr 14 8.37pm

Quote jpegnall at 14 Apr 2014 8.35pm

Quote TomThePalaceFanatic at 14 Apr 2014 7.55pm

Joel Ward has been consistently great throughout the whole season. The only game where he's been slightly weaker was at the Emirates, but he's allowed one off day and he should get Player of the Year and be on the plane to Brazil.

Speroni struggled slightly in the early part of the season (under Holloway I know, but still), although his form since Holloway left has been superb, and he seems to dominate his box a lot more. I thought he'd be exposed on that front, but he hasn't at all. 2nd

But, as people have mentioned, it truly has been a team effort. Delaney, Chamakh, Jedinak, Puncheon and Dann have all been great too.

I don't think you can say he struggled... the goals we conceded were no reflection on him, he still was playing well, not making mistakes and making good saves - he couldn't make up for our lack of defence true, but no keeper in the world would have made a difference to the outcome of our games under IH this season.

He let in soft goals at United away and Swansea at home, just from memory

 

dg1937 Flag 14 Apr 14 9.16pm

I agree with those who've said it has to be a defender this year.

I think the candidates are: Jules; Delaney; Ward; and Jedinak.

Ward has played in three different positions and been outstanding in all three (well, maybe not quite 'outstanding' as a defensive midfielder but still very good). He oozes class even when playing on his 'wrong' side.

Jedinak has been a real leader and his stats on interceptions and headers speak for themselves. I agree his passing is not great but the man is an absolute beast and I'm convinced we would have lost many more games without him protecting the back four.

Jules has had a fantastic season. It isn't often a keeper gets a standing ovation for a single save but I can remember at least three times this season when the ground has risen to applaud an outstanding save, most recently in the dying minutes last Saturday. Absolute legend but runner up for me this year.

My vote goes to Delaney. Like quite a few on here I didn't think he'd be up to it in the Prem but he's proved the doubters wrong. How many times has he put his body on the line this season to make crucial blocks? The consumate professional. Not the most talented footballer but someone who squeezes every last drop out the ability he has got. I'm very much looking forward to seeing how he does against Suarez and Co in a few weeks time.

But, as others have said, it's been a team effort and just about everyone who has pulled on the shirt this season has been a hero.

 

shaness2 Flag 14 Apr 14 9.27pm

John Terry! :-D

Those unexpected 3 points from his well taken goal have made our battle for survival a whole lot less stressful.

 

xGeorgex Flag Oh South London 14 Apr 14 10.06pm

Julian Speroni

1. One of the most clean sheets in the league.
2. Has come up with some of the best saves I have ever seen (Hazard).
3. Has not reacted badly to Hennessy coming in. In fact he has thrived.
4. Played every game League game I believe.
5. Could be his last season so it pays great respect.

image.jpg Attachment: image.jpg (144.59Kb)

 


E Block - Win, Lose or Draw it’s about having a good day out

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 14 Apr 14 10.22pm

Quote TomThePalaceFanatic at 14 Apr 2014 8.37pm

Quote jpegnall at 14 Apr 2014 8.35pm

Quote TomThePalaceFanatic at 14 Apr 2014 7.55pm

Joel Ward has been consistently great throughout the whole season. The only game where he's been slightly weaker was at the Emirates, but he's allowed one off day and he should get Player of the Year and be on the plane to Brazil.

Speroni struggled slightly in the early part of the season (under Holloway I know, but still), although his form since Holloway left has been superb, and he seems to dominate his box a lot more. I thought he'd be exposed on that front, but he hasn't at all. 2nd

But, as people have mentioned, it truly has been a team effort. Delaney, Chamakh, Jedinak, Puncheon and Dann have all been great too.

I don't think you can say he struggled... the goals we conceded were no reflection on him, he still was playing well, not making mistakes and making good saves - he couldn't make up for our lack of defence true, but no keeper in the world would have made a difference to the outcome of our games under IH this season.

He let in soft goals at United away and Swansea at home, just from memory


UTD away was a penalty and a great free kick. Swansea on both goals Swansea were through one on one. Arsenal away he conceded a soft goal but what keeper doesn't.

Edited by EastEndPalace (14 Apr 2014 10.23pm)

 

Fareham Kev Flag Fareham,Hampshire 14 Apr 14 10.50pm

It Really is Hard to nominate somebody for the Player of the Season and I think just for once as this has been an outstanding Season back in the Premier League for Palace, I would like the whole Team Squad to be recognised for their tremendous efforts on and off the field.

This would be a Presentation to the TEAM of The Season - CRYSTAL PALACE F.C for their historical achievement of being the FIRST CRYSTAL PALACE TEAM to stay up in the PREMIER LEAGUE.

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 15 Apr 14 8.30am

Who started this complete myth about Jedi's awful passing? I have seen stats that say his pass accuracy is 71% - which I suggest is pretty damn good.

We expect everything from him because he offers and delivers and adds so much to the team. He was superb in early season performance (Spurs, Stoke & Sunderland) and was our only stand out player in those days under IH along with Ward.

Yes I know he has made a few poor passes but who the hell has not done that in this league if they have managed to play every single game?

I actually think SPERONI deserves the award this year if it has to be given to just one man but to constantly keep on about Jedi's passing is now becoming boring.

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the season