|
Curbing free speech has been part of good old English law for many centuries..the very embodiment of "traditional values".We have never had total "freedom of speech".That's why we have defamation laws.What might be curbed "ie defamatory or not"changes over time.We have much more "freedom of speech" than historically.
Over the past 50 years we have I think largely moved as a society overall to regard racial abuse as inappropriate. We've moved a long way generally from the attitudes towards immigrants from the W. Indies,Africa and Asia in the 50's/60's/70's .We see in our own team some of the the fruits of this immigration and attitudes to whom is regarded as "one of our own". Would Derben move out if Puncheon,Zaha.Bolasie,Campbell etc moved into his village small/town? If he did,what would most HOL members think about it?Would he regard Punch as "one of our own?"
But I Digress,
Anyone can find examples of situations where the application of virtually any law in a few cases might be carried out in an inappropriate way.In the case of the old lady,she yelled it at random muslims quietly going about their business leaving a mosque.Perhaps the police might have just asked her to stop.They could have arrested her simply for conduct likely to cause a breach of the peace,another centuries old law.So,that would have "curbed her free speech" anyway.
The inappropriateness might be said to relate more to how the police dealt with her on the spot than the fact of there being a law against racially aggravated conduct.The merits of football fan violence being unlawful are not the same as the police going in "over the top" on some occasions if things kick off.
That doesn't mean having a law against aggravated racial abuse is a bad idea per se.
HOL has a rule against posts that are racially offensive .Should the Mods drop it?
Is it a good thing in principle to be able to give people racial abuse or a bad thing?
Edited by legaleagle (12 Jun 2015 10.22pm)
|