This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Even as a Marxist, I'd be one to put the idea that Marxism has an element of the conspiracy theorist about it. That said, I quite like the idea of a Labour leader who doesn't sound like he's one of the more liberal members of the Conservative party. Then again, I think being right is more important than winning.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich. Quite right - Systems of public transport should be under the provision of the state, not run for profit organizations. Transport infrastructure locally should ideally be free to use for the public and supported by taxation revenue, allowing the majority to avoid having to pay to go to work. Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliché I like this, we need this. Politics shouldn't be the lesser of two or three evils, but actually based around ideology and belief, rather than popularism and mass appeal. Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche. Labour was always better when the Unions were directly involved, the distancing between the Unions and Labour Party resulted in the New Labour Party, a movement of Conservativism lite and corporate appeasement. Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off. Everyone should. The middle classes are pitifully dull, and largely boring people, driven by the insecurities and self loathing. They're the only class that actively hates their own class members. Also most people who think they're middle classed, aren't, they're upper working class. A symptom of which is the belief they are middle class. Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" - its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way. He probably less left wing as Ted Heath, who was more left wing than the last labour government. Plus what is wrong with being a Marxist - Has it become a thing now that Politicians who have established ideals and beliefs are somehow unfit for politics. Knee jerk right wingers tend to have settled into an American political rhetoric, where anything that's not the right wing party is by default left wing, and if its more left wing then it must be Socialism or Communism. Sadly, even very intelligent reasonable right wingers fall into this trap of assuming anything to the left of New Labour is far left. Its not, its the Liberal democrats, then the 70s and traditional conservatives, then the old SDLP and Liberals, then the old labour party, and then you getting towards the socialism and communist groups. I swear people would s**t themselves if they actually heard someone who was actually left wing and socialist. Also, its worth noting that Marxist theory, dialectical analysis and discourse theory are practiced by non-Marxists. Its like saying any psychiatrist who talks to their patient is a Freudian.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.