You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Jeremy Corbyn
November 20 2026 2.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jeremy Corbyn


Page 3 of 279 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 28 Jul 15 4.00pm

I have first hand experience of Corbyn from way back - at the time I was a bit of a leftie, Labour party member, trade unionist and all that jazz and we (BT)went on a national strike - prob about 1991-ish

Anyhoo the POEU got JC and The Beast of Bolsover down to give us a pep talk in London - utter dogmatic. polemic gibberish without any foundation in the real world from start to finish from the pair of them...

Edited by The Sash (28 Jul 2015 4.01pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

ghosteagle Flag 28 Jul 15 6.37pm

Quote The Sash at 28 Jul 2015 4.00pm

I have first hand experience of Corbyn from way back - at the time I was a bit of a leftie, Labour party member, trade unionist and all that jazz and we (BT)went on a national strike - prob about 1991-ish

Anyhoo the POEU got JC and The Beast of Bolsover down to give us a pep talk in London - utter dogmatic. polemic gibberish without any foundation in the real world from start to finish from the pair of them...

Edited by The Sash (28 Jul 2015 4.01pm)

Looks like he's got much better in the last 24 years.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Jul 15 6.48pm

Does anyone think he will get over 50% of the votes and as a result there won't be any need for the lowest candidate to drop-out and the voters re-distributed etc etc ? And what will be his chances if indeed the latter situation occurs ?

I must say I haven't given this much thought hence interested to know what people think. Perhaps I should join #ToriesForCorbyn !!!!

Edited by Willo (28 Jul 2015 6.48pm)

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 28 Jul 15 10.31pm

Why do the lefties think the future is to go backwards?

Corbyn is the measure of the dearth of credible candidates in the labour party, Just like that wet blanket Millibland was their best man last time, their would be chancellor didn't even win his seat.

He just has a load of student Union policies and suddenly he's their best man, he just needs the Che Guevera T Shirt and a pint of snakebite. hardly re-inventing the wheel.

It's the beginning of the end for Labour, it's just a slow painful death and many years in the political wilderness.

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 28 Jul 15 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.


 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 29 Jul 15 3.55am

Interesting article:

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 29 Jul 15 8.22am

Quote ghosteagle at 28 Jul 2015 6.37pm

Quote The Sash at 28 Jul 2015 4.00pm

I have first hand experience of Corbyn from way back - at the time I was a bit of a leftie, Labour party member, trade unionist and all that jazz and we (BT)went on a national strike - prob about 1991-ish

Anyhoo the POEU got JC and The Beast of Bolsover down to give us a pep talk in London - utter dogmatic. polemic gibberish without any foundation in the real world from start to finish from the pair of them...

Edited by The Sash (28 Jul 2015 4.01pm)

Looks like he's got much better in the last 24 years.

Maybe / maybe not....you are hardly going to see Comrade Jeremey stand in the light.


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 29 Jul 15 9.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Why is it with you always down to the newspapers people read?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 29 Jul 15 9.33am

Bert has access to a secret library full of books which contain the truth. The rest of us are stuck being drip-fed lies from the media which we swallow without questioning.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 29 Jul 15 9.55am

Quote Cucking Funt at 29 Jul 2015 9.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Why is it with you always down to the newspapers people read?

Are you disagreeing with what Bert says other than the fed s***e by newspaper osmosis?

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 29 Jul 15 10.06am

Quote nickgusset at 29 Jul 2015 9.55am

Quote Cucking Funt at 29 Jul 2015 9.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Why is it with you always down to the newspapers people read?

Are you disagreeing with what Bert says other than the fed s***e by newspaper osmosis?


Let me put it this way: I'm more in fed up eagle's camp than Bert's.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 29 Jul 15 10.10am

Quote nickgusset at 29 Jul 2015 9.55am

Quote Cucking Funt at 29 Jul 2015 9.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Why is it with you always down to the newspapers people read?

Are you disagreeing with what Bert says other than the fed s***e by newspaper osmosis?

What is the Morning Star's line Nick? Let me guess, "General Strike now!"?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 29 Jul 15 10.15am

Quote leggedstruggle at 29 Jul 2015 10.10am

Quote nickgusset at 29 Jul 2015 9.55am

Quote Cucking Funt at 29 Jul 2015 9.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Why is it with you always down to the newspapers people read?

Are you disagreeing with what Bert says other than the fed s***e by newspaper osmosis?

What is the Morning Star's line Nick? Let me guess, "General Strike now!"?

Answer my question please.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Jul 15 10.20am

Quote leggedstruggle at 29 Jul 2015 10.10am

Quote nickgusset at 29 Jul 2015 9.55am

Quote Cucking Funt at 29 Jul 2015 9.20am

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Why is it with you always down to the newspapers people read?

Are you disagreeing with what Bert says other than the fed s***e by newspaper osmosis?

What is the Morning Star's line Nick? Let me guess, "General Strike now!"?


 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 30 Jul 15 4.24pm

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Let's be honest, you think he's a credible candidate because of what you've read in some left wing rag like the Guardian. I know what Corbyn's policies are and they'll take us back to the dark ages. Perhaps that's what you lefties want is it?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jul 15 4.30pm

Even as a Marxist, I'd be one to put the idea that Marxism has an element of the conspiracy theorist about it.

That said, I quite like the idea of a Labour leader who doesn't sound like he's one of the more liberal members of the Conservative party.

Then again, I think being right is more important than winning.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jul 15 4.45pm

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

Quite right - Systems of public transport should be under the provision of the state, not run for profit organizations. Transport infrastructure locally should ideally be free to use for the public and supported by taxation revenue, allowing the majority to avoid having to pay to go to work.

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliché

I like this, we need this. Politics shouldn't be the lesser of two or three evils, but actually based around ideology and belief, rather than popularism and mass appeal.

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

Labour was always better when the Unions were directly involved, the distancing between the Unions and Labour Party resulted in the New Labour Party, a movement of Conservativism lite and corporate appeasement.

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

Everyone should. The middle classes are pitifully dull, and largely boring people, driven by the insecurities and self loathing. They're the only class that actively hates their own class members.

Also most people who think they're middle classed, aren't, they're upper working class. A symptom of which is the belief they are middle class.

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm
5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

He probably less left wing as Ted Heath, who was more left wing than the last labour government. Plus what is wrong with being a Marxist - Has it become a thing now that Politicians who have established ideals and beliefs are somehow unfit for politics.

Knee jerk right wingers tend to have settled into an American political rhetoric, where anything that's not the right wing party is by default left wing, and if its more left wing then it must be Socialism or Communism. Sadly, even very intelligent reasonable right wingers fall into this trap of assuming anything to the left of New Labour is far left. Its not, its the Liberal democrats, then the 70s and traditional conservatives, then the old SDLP and Liberals, then the old labour party, and then you getting towards the socialism and communist groups.

I swear people would s**t themselves if they actually heard someone who was actually left wing and socialist.

Also, its worth noting that Marxist theory, dialectical analysis and discourse theory are practiced by non-Marxists. Its like saying any psychiatrist who talks to their patient is a Freudian.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

ghosteagle Flag 30 Jul 15 4.50pm

Quote fed up eagle at 30 Jul 2015 4.24pm

Quote Bert the Head at 28 Jul 2015 11.51pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 27 Jul 2015 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 27 Jul 2015 4.58pm

Well where to start! The guys as marxist as they come. Anyone see him on the Andrew Marr show on Sunday? I was listening to BBC Radio 5live this morning on the way to work and apparently even Tories are signing upto the Labour party and putting in a vote for him in the leadership race, along with hard line crazy leftists. Would be hilarious if he won the leadership contest. Labour would be even more unelectable, which serves them right after what they've done to this country.


So which part of his proposed policies do you not agree with and why?

How will he make labour more unelectable?

I'm genuinely interested in what you think about 70% of the public agreeing with rail nationalisation.

What are your concerns about Corbyn's plans for a national bank?

Do you not agree with investment for growth?

1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work

2) He wants to return to the politics of the eighties

3) He's another union stooge

4) Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population.

5) He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more.

Edited by fed up eagle (27 Jul 2015 5.33pm)


1) Nationalising the railways? That didn't work - privatization isn't working. We are paying more to subsidize a railway that gives out a dividend to share holders for investing in something that doesn't work. Not really Hayek more of even more welfare for the rich.

2) "He wants to return to the politics of the eighties" - this is just a very tired old cliche

3) "He's another union stooge" - another tired old cliche.

4) "Has utter contempt for the middle class, which makes up a big swave of the population" - this is not based on anything he actually says. He does want to tax the very wealthy in a more equitable way to redistribute wealth. But they will still be well off.

5) "He won't deny that he's a marxist and has the support of extreme left factions, need I say more" -
its not illegal to be a Marxist but I wouldn't say he is a Marxist, for example he doesn't believe in a revolution of the proletariat. Maybe he has some sympathy with the Marxist diagnoses but not the prescription. Marx was brilliant at the diagnosis. But you are just applying "Marxist" and "extreme left factions" in the tired bogeyman cliche way.

The Telegraph article is an embarrassment for anyone who questions what they read or isn't a full on Tory just waiting to grab hold of any bunch of tired old cliches.

Neo-libralism was new and shiny in the 80s but it doesn't work for enough people. It works for a few people amazingly well and they are getting richer and richer and richer, but the wealth is being sucked up and not trickling down. Its time there was a political party to properly challenge it.

Why not look at his policies. If you don't like them argue against them. That's fair enough. But why just regurgitate tired old cliches that solidified in your head as a result of reading a bias newspaper over an over again? Its as if you repeat them without even thinking anymore.



Let's be honest, you think he's a credible candidate because of what you've read in some left wing rag like the Guardian. I know what Corbyn's policies are and they'll take us back to the dark ages. Perhaps that's what you lefties want is it?

A rather obvious lie as if you had looked at the Guardian then you would know that they are doing their hardest to convince people not to vote for Corbyn. Funnily enough, the more the mainstream media comes out against him the more popular he gets. The papers are really starting to get scared that he will win...

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 30 Jul 15 4.57pm

In all honesty all the candidates for the Labour leadership are shyte. Labour, the party of mass immigration and out of control spending, not forgetting they're in hoc to the unions. But I guess they're all lies as well. Whatever, my opinions shall not change no matter what propaganda you type.

 

ghosteagle Flag 30 Jul 15 5.02pm

Quote fed up eagle at 30 Jul 2015 4.57pm

In all honesty all the candidates for the Labour leadership are shyte. Labour, the party of mass immigration and out of control spending, not forgetting they're in hoc to the unions. But I guess they're all lies as well. Whatever, my opinions shall not change no matter what propaganda you type.

Well, the out of control spending is a lie and the thing about them being in 'hoc' to the unions is a falsehood. The party of 'mass immigration' is simply an overexageration so 2/3 i'm afraid. I'm sure that no amount of evidence or reasoned arguments could change your narrow-minded, ignorant, nationalistic views. I salute you sir.


Edited by ghosteagle (30 Jul 2015 5.03pm)

 

Page 3 of 279 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Jeremy Corbyn