You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better without cabaye?
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we better without cabaye?


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 12 Sep 16 9.19pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I agree his form has dipped, but he's still a far better footballer than Ledley.

I think he's judged very harshly by some because he was our first 'international' signing - if you compare his performances to most of the team, he's usually one of the better players, but because it's Cabaye, it's not considered so.

This is the major problem when judging this position that people get wrong. It doesn't matter about who is a better a footballer in the DM role imo. It's nice if you find one that can play a bit as well of course. What really counts is effectiveness in this position. Something that Jedi had in spades was effectiveness. Do I feel that Cabaye is as effect as a DM? Not really.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 12 Sep 16 10.43pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

This is the major problem when judging this position that people get wrong. It doesn't matter about who is a better a footballer in the DM role imo. It's nice if you find one that can play a bit as well of course. What really counts is effectiveness in this position. Something that Jedi had in spades was effectiveness. Do I feel that Cabaye is as effect as a DM? Not really.


You can defend by keeping the ball. Jedi was less ideal at that and our terrible run did coincide almost precisely with when we turned to s*** having been great. Before that point, we'd managed without Jedi.

As well as tackles and interceptionsee he gave the ball away.

Cabaye is a good player. Better than Ledley although I do feel Ledley is very under rated.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Username Flag Horsham 12 Sep 16 11.18pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

This is the major problem when judging this position that people get wrong. It doesn't matter about who is a better a footballer in the DM role imo. It's nice if you find one that can play a bit as well of course. What really counts is effectiveness in this position. Something that Jedi had in spades was effectiveness. Do I feel that Cabaye is as effect as a DM? Not really.

He was pretty effective this time last year.

Being a good DM isn't about flying into challenges or winning headers like Jedinak. It's about reading the game, intercepting the ball, squeezing the space, covering your full backs and not giving the ball away. Cabaye is excellent at every one of those.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

phillanth Flag London 12 Sep 16 11.55pm

Originally posted by Username

He was pretty effective this time last year.

Being a good DM isn't about flying into challenges or winning headers like Jedinak. It's about reading the game, intercepting the ball, squeezing the space, covering your full backs and not giving the ball away. Cabaye is excellent at every one of those.

Quite right. I thought he made a big difference when he came on at half time at White Hart Lane enabling us get keep possession more and take the game to Tottenham. He also played well in the second half against Bournemouth. I would definitely pick him over Ledley against Stoke because we will need all the creativity we can get. I agree that his set plays have been disappointing though and Benteke should take the next penalty.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 13 Sep 16 1.04am

Originally posted by Username

He was pretty effective this time last year.

Being a good DM isn't about flying into challenges or winning headers like Jedinak. It's about reading the game, intercepting the ball, squeezing the space, covering your full backs and not giving the ball away. Cabaye is excellent at every one of those.

I disagree, he lets opponents run through unchallenged on many occasions, (Bournemouth, Spurs, Everton, Norwich), dwells on the ball too long passing the ball ten metres here and there and putting our own players under pressure by keep passing the ball back to them in the same spot they have passed the ball to him so they are still under as much pressure as when they gave the ball to him.
It is no coincidence we looked more fluent and positive in the last league game we won against Stoke when he went off at half time , and again against 'Boro on Saturday, the last two league games we have won. In fact in you look at important stats the last 4 league games we have won , Cabaye only played 90 mins in one v Norwich, and it was not much down to him.
Anyway , just how I see it watching the games.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 13 Sep 16 4.13am

I would have Mcarthur and Flamini in there
Forget Cabaye and Ledley

Yes we are better without him
His legs have gone

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 13 Sep 16 7.01am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

This is the major problem when judging this position that people get wrong. It doesn't matter about who is a better a footballer in the DM role imo. It's nice if you find one that can play a bit as well of course. What really counts is effectiveness in this position. Something that Jedi had in spades was effectiveness. Do I feel that Cabaye is as effect as a DM? Not really.

Of course it matters who's a better footballer.

Cabaye was amongst the top 10 in the division for tackles and interceptions last season, so I'd argue he's very effective as a DM.

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 13 Sep 16 8.49am

I think Lesley should keep his place for Stoke , don't change a winning team and all that! Cabaye will have to bench it until one of the midfield has a poor game. Will just be nice to have some quality off the bench.

 

IMpalace Flag London 13 Sep 16 9.27am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

This is the major problem when judging this position that people get wrong. It doesn't matter about who is a better a footballer in the DM role imo. It's nice if you find one that can play a bit as well of course. What really counts is effectiveness in this position. Something that Jedi had in spades was effectiveness. Do I feel that Cabaye is as effect as a DM? Not really.

Rather than go with feeling probably best to go with stats: 5th most interceptions in the league last year (3rd highest for a midfielder).

I think his biggest issue is people expect him to do everything including score goals and get assists, which isn't his job. Everyday I see someone on this forum say we should play him behind the striker which is absolutely not his position.

He's class, and we are a trillion times better keeping the ball when he's on the pitch. Add that to the stat above and is a no brainer as to whether we are better with or without him.

Edited by IMpalace (13 Sep 2016 9.30am)

 

DivingIsNotGood Flag se25 13 Sep 16 10.39am

Originally posted by IMpalace

Rather than go with feeling probably best to go with stats: 5th most interceptions in the league last year (3rd highest for a midfielder).

I think his biggest issue is people expect him to do everything including score goals and get assists, which isn't his job. Everyday I see someone on this forum say we should play him behind the striker which is absolutely not his position.

He's class, and we are a trillion times better keeping the ball when he's on the pitch. Add that to the stat above and is a no brainer as to whether we are better with or without him.

Edited by IMpalace (13 Sep 2016 9.30am)

can you find a stat on how many dead ball, free kicks, corners and so on he's flunked?

 


VOTING OUT - Brexit will allow Britain to embrace the Commonwealth and be GREAT again

npn Flag Crowborough 13 Sep 16 10.43am

Originally posted by DivingIsNotGood

can you find a stat on how many dead ball, free kicks, corners and so on he's flunked?

Surely the answer to that one is to relieve him of dead ball duty if, indeed, there is anyone better?

I'd say he should certainly be in the side, but let's leave him doing what he's best at.

 

IMpalace Flag London 13 Sep 16 10.46am

Originally posted by DivingIsNotGood

can you find a stat on how many dead ball, free kicks, corners and so on he's flunked?

If there is anyone better at set pieces then Pardew should have them take them e.g. penalties, where Benteke has missed 2 in 9, Cabaye has missed 2 in 6 (in the league, don't have cup stats)

Edited by IMpalace (13 Sep 2016 10.49am)

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 15 Sep 16 11.08am

On set pieces definitely

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Holmesdale 1989 Flag 15 Sep 16 11.18pm

Originally posted by CPFC/SCCC

After watching the highlights of our game against Boro. I feel our midfield is more balanced with mcarthur and Ledley with puncheon in the advanced role. Cabaye form has certainly drop since the turn of the year. I just feel he doesn't deserve his place back until he proves it.

Your thoughts

I agree with the OP

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 Sep 16 3.03am

Whatever, very happy we have a player like Joe Ledley in our squad. Give his all, rarely lets us down and can play with the best (i.e Euro 2016 - Bale & Ramsey). More than good enough for our team...

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 16 Sep 16 4.10am

Pro football is a bit like a computer. Most people undestand and use about 5% of what a computer offers.
It's the same with pro footie. reading all thes posts, anyone would think we've got some pretty good cover should AP take a hike.
The truth is probably no posters here have anything like the knowledge of the pro game to make any sort of objective criticism of players or management.
Pro football has got so much depth to it a bit like the computer that very few fans can grasp the in depth position.
OK I hear it, you are all just having fun on here which is cool. But appreciate we have a top level manager, and chairman and we suddenly have a whole load of quality players at our disposal in our much improved squad.
Let AP work his magic in bringing out the players strongest assets and watch the results. even with our on going set backs re injuries and accident I remain very optimistic for our on going advance and development.
Things here at the Palace are looking better than ever in my view.

 

PhuketEagle Flag Phuket 16 Sep 16 6.21am

Good that we have some options at last. Would like to see McArthur, Flamini & Ledley together in midfield. While I like Cabaye he's not spurred us on & didn't get the captaincy when it became available - when perhaps he would've been in consideration if his performances had merited it.
Let's find a good midfield solution & stick with the players as they learn to understand each other (barring injuries.)

 

The Dolphin Flag 16 Sep 16 7.11am

We should be better with him - no doubt at all.
I wonder if the system we use doesn't work for him?
Also is Jimmy Mac too similar perhaps?
I would always rather he played even though he hasn't generally been as good as I thought he would be

 

srh Flag london 16 Sep 16 8.09am

Anyone who has ever been coached properly and played football and has half a brain can see that Cabye is by far our best central midfield player.

 

Griffish Flag Croydon 16 Sep 16 8.11am

Cabaye and Mcarthur together is our best centre mid partnership without doubt (although we've not seen Flamini yet).

Our success for the first half of the season was hugely down to this partnership in the middle where both were comfortable on the ball in tight areas and we're always looking for short passes from our defenders. I think Cabaye was 2nd in for tackles and interceptions for a midfielder at Christmas behind only Kante (I might be slightly off with that stat) but a lot of his defensive work goes unnoticed because some of us (me included at the start of the season) expected him to be scoring all sorts of goals from all over the place.

When Mcarthur got injured, the Cabaye/Jedi partnership simply didn't work, and injuries to other key players certainly didn't help with results. As much of a warrior as Jedi is, he doesn't have the pace or agility to receive the balls in those tight areas which forced us to bypass the midfield more often and go direct. Although it must have been frustrating for Cabaye he certainly deserves some criticism for what seemed a lack of interest in a lot of games after Christmas when we needed him most.

I can't wait to see Cabaye/Mcarthur link up in the middle again but it would be harsh on Ledley to be dropped for the Stoke game after his solid performance last week.

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better without cabaye?