You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Mandanda
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Mandanda


Page 3 of 19 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 03 Nov 16 7.06am

Originally posted by victor43

Come on, if you're going to criticise our players, at least try and spell them right!

And it would be 3 home wins in a year actually, excluding cup games.

Oh, that's much better! Nothing to be concerned about then?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

cpj Flag Kent 03 Nov 16 10.14am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

This is nonsense.

First of hall Hennessey's command of the area was very poor despite his height.

He was also, on a number of occasions, slow to go for the ball or completely flat footed.

While we're being picky it was also a poor kick from him that indirectly led to United's winner the cup final.

Some serious amnesia in this thread

Extremely picky! The kick went some 30 yards out of the goal where Puncheon lost the ball. Can't blame WH for that.

Also, at least WH came off his line to try and get the ball and he tried to dive and save shots. SM looks like he's not especially bothered at times.

 

MARKY Flag coulsdon 03 Nov 16 11.15am

Its more imperative than ever this season for the keeper to dominate his area as grappling with strikers is being clamped down on, with Mandanda doing statue impressions at corners our centre half's are being hung out to dry, come 2.00pm Saturday I will be a lot more confident of a result if Hennesy is back on the team sheet, He appears to be similar to Speroni but our Argentinian was a hell of a lot better at shot stopping, personally I think Speroni would of saved both headers as they were straight at the keeper, one through his legs, 2nd straight through his hands. English footie is all about getting crosses into the box I suspect his weakness wasn't highlighted so much in France due to the different style of play

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Nov 16 11.24am

If Mandanda plays at Burnley, has the sort of game Heaton had last week at Man Utd and we draw 0-0, he will be a hero and the "Pardew must stay" brigade will be out in force !!!!! How things can change in a week !

 

cpj Flag Kent 03 Nov 16 11.46am

Originally posted by Willo

If Mandanda plays at Burnley, has the sort of game Heaton had last week at Man Utd and we draw 0-0, he will be a hero and the "Pardew must stay" brigade will be out in force !!!!! How things can change in a week !

I suspect he won't! Can't see us keeping a clean sheet. Nor will people be happy with a 0-0 at a newly-promoted team.

 

MARKY Flag coulsdon 03 Nov 16 11.53am

Its ironic, Pulis bought WH as Speroni didn't command his penalty box so Super Alan Pardew dumps WH and buys a poor man's Speroni!

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 03 Nov 16 1.22pm

So for all of his appearances for us Mandanda watches Dann, Delaney or Tomkins clear crosses, free kicks and corners at will away from anywhere in the area but on Saturday suddenly he is faced with 2 virtually unstoppable headers one after half a challenge from Dann the other totally unchallenged.

Sorry I have to pick you up on this.

Not having a go at Steveee, as I said earlier the jury is still out IMHO, but neither header was unstoppable last Sat. One went under his legs and the other above his head.

If he had stayed 'big and tall' he might have saved the first and better reactions could have saved the second. Not saying he was at fault but that's the small difference between a good and an outstanding goalie.

His style is definitely more of the Speroni - only come and claim if it's a few yards from the goal line and that is inviting pressure. I think this is a fact and not really open for debate.

 

OldFella Flag London 03 Nov 16 3.07pm

Originally posted by palace99

So for all of his appearances for us Mandanda watches Dann, Delaney or Tomkins clear crosses, free kicks and corners at will away from anywhere in the area but on Saturday suddenly he is faced with 2 virtually unstoppable headers one after half a challenge from Dann the other totally unchallenged.

Sorry I have to pick you up on this.

Not having a go at Steveee, as I said earlier the jury is still out IMHO, but neither header was unstoppable last Sat. One went under his legs and the other above his head.

If he had stayed 'big and tall' he might have saved the first and better reactions could have saved the second. Not saying he was at fault but that's the small difference between a good and an outstanding goalie.

His style is definitely more of the Speroni - only come and claim if it's a few yards from the goal line and that is inviting pressure. I think this is a fact and not really open for debate.

Some thoughts

1. We have lost a number of players who helped considerably with aerial defending of corners in earlier seasons - including e.g. Jedi, Chamakh, Murray.

2. The "no holding" rule enforcement has hit Scott Dann's effectiveness in particular.

3. Mandanda, frankly, is way off the mark in terms of dominating/collecting crosses.

4. Tomkins needs to improve/put his body on the line in the same way that Damo has always tried to.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 03 Nov 16 3.08pm

Originally posted by OldFella

Some thoughts

1. We have lost a number of players who helped considerably with aerial defending of corners in earlier seasons - including e.g. Jedi, Chamakh, Murray.

2. The "no holding" rule enforcement has hit Scott Dann's effectiveness in particular.

3. Mandanda, frankly, is way off the mark in terms of dominating/collecting crosses.

4. Tomkins needs to improve/put his body on the line in the same way that Damo has always tried to.

Well said.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 16 3.42pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Well said.

1. Ca you tell me when the three of them played in the same team in the premiership. We now have benteke who ain't bad in the air.
2.doesnt stop him jumping for the ball?
3.and hennessey and speroni were?
4. This one I do agree with.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 03 Nov 16 3.45pm

Originally posted by MARKY

I am amazed Mandanda hasn't come in for more criticism. His shot stopping has been poor (apart from 1 great save). The modern identikit of a premier league goalie is being 6ft 5 and coming out and dominating your area from set pieces, we are now conceding goals from corner etc. because he doesn't come off his line. Analysts from other clubs are looking at him and dropping corners, free kicks on our 6yd line and putting our centre half’s under huge pressure. I think we should put Hennessy in for the Burnley game, I think he was better than Palace fans gave him credit for and had a really good Euro's. While I am ranting he is another Pardew buy that isn't shaping up
Saoure - jury still out whether he is a good premiership full back
Kebaye - has not lived up to price tag/wages, not guaranteed starter
Tompkins - looks average
Townsend - been disappointing
Sakho - championship player
Chongy - too inconsistent
Wickham - injury prone, has looked uninterested this season
Benteke - no brainer

Don't think we will win another home match before Pardew's 2 year anniversary, that could be 2 home wins in a year, as much as I want Pardew to be a success too many cracks are appearing, you judge a manager on buys, tactics and improving players he is looking average on all counts

The point at which I stopped reading is in bold.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 16 3.52pm

I just don't get the critism of him. He's pulled off some stunning saves for us, especially a number of one of ones and really can't see how he was to blame for any of the recejt goals we've let in. The fact is our captain and best defender, plus our regular left back have been out if the team and our squad hasn't been able to cope. We all knew in the summer if anything happened to soare wed be in trouble....

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 03 Nov 16 5.39pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

1. Ca you tell me when the three of them played in the same team in the premiership. We now have benteke who ain't bad in the air.
2.doesnt stop him jumping for the ball?
3.and hennessey and speroni were?
4. This one I do agree with.

First off why you picking on me i only agreed. Next we are definitely missing jedi in the aerial dept but not much else imo. Dann has suffered this season from the clampdown, much as Leicesters pair of Morgan and Huth, whose shirt was ripped from his back at a corner at ours last season. Speroni i agree was poor at coming for crosses and vastly over rated purely by having been at the club a long time, cue the hysteria surrounding Hennessey replacing him , but was better than both at crosses imo.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 16 5.53pm

Originally posted by sickboy

First off why you picking on me i only agreed. Next we are definitely missing jedi in the aerial dept but not much else imo. Dann has suffered this season from the clampdown, much as Leicesters pair of Morgan and Huth, whose shirt was ripped from his back at a corner at ours last season. Speroni i agree was poor at coming for crosses and vastly over rated purely by having been at the club a long time, cue the hysteria surrounding Hennessey replacing him , but was better than both at crosses imo.

What makes you think im picking on you, you agreed with him I disagreed ...can't agree dann suffering under the new rules, been ok apart from Saturday. If he can't beat a player to a header without fouling him we are in troube.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 03 Nov 16 5.56pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

What makes you think im picking on you, you agreed with him I disagreed ...can't agree dann suffering under the new rules, been ok apart from Saturday. If he can't beat a player to a header without fouling him we are in troube.

I will agree that saturday was probably more ring rust with SD.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 03 Nov 16 6.02pm

Originally posted by sickboy

I will agree that saturday was probably more ring rust with SD.

I think so too, he definitely was off the pace most if the game. Probably the wrong game to bring him back. Personally I'd have kept him for burnley. Easy yo say in hindsight but not sure delaney would have given their player a free header for the first goal.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 03 Nov 16 6.28pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I think so too, he definitely was off the pace most if the game. Probably the wrong game to bring him back. Personally I'd have kept him for burnley. Easy yo say in hindsight but not sure delaney would have given their player a free header for the first goal.

Damo, is a defender first and foremost, i just wish he was 5 years younger.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 03 Nov 16 6.59pm

Mandanda is stronger, braver, more agile and has greater reflexes than Hennessey. I've noticed that in the handful of games I've seen him in this season so far. He hasn't had a settled first team defence in front of him yet and is getting used to the PL. Think a few who were saying to give WH a season last year, need to have the same ethos for Steeeeeve. Or s*** off.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Nov 16 7.25pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Mandanda is stronger, braver, more agile and has greater reflexes than Hennessey. I've noticed that in the handful of games I've seen him in this season so far. He hasn't had a settled first team defence in front of him yet and is getting used to the PL. Think a few who were saying to give WH a season last year, need to have the same ethos for Steeeeeve. Or s*** off.

We must be watching a different keeper, agile and greater reflexs isn't a description I would use for him. I don't particularly think WH is better or worse, but Mandanda hasn't impressed, just seemed to unsettle the defence.
I think we will be in trouble when it gets wet and cold, as he doesn't like diving and getting his kit dirty.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 03 Nov 16 7.40pm

Originally posted by Painter

We must be watching a different keeper, agile and greater reflexs isn't a description I would use for him. I don't particularly think WH is better or worse, but Mandanda hasn't impressed, just seemed to unsettle the defence.
I think we will be in trouble when it gets wet and cold, as he doesn't like diving and getting his kit dirty.

Really? The way he collects the ball by throwing his body out behind him and taking the ball into his chest into the ground is pretty impressive considering the speed the ball travels now days. This seems to be a trademark of his and takes great agility to pull off.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Page 3 of 19 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Mandanda