You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Missing Jedinak?
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Missing Jedinak?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 09 Nov 16 3.04pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

“You speak to guys inside the camp, you ask about Mile, I understand where a lot of supporters are coming from, but they want him on that pitch.

“He might misplace a pass or two here or there but they want him on that pitch.

“It’s the intangibles that he provides – presence, toughness, leadership, coolness from the penalty spot".


I've previously posted this, but it seems worth doing again.

Over the 2014-15 season our record with Jedi in the team:
W6, D7, L11 (or 1.04 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D2, L5 (or 1.64 ppg)

Over the 2015-16 season with Jedi in the team:
W4, D9, L14 (or 0.78 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D0, L4 (or 1.91 ppg)

So, yes, let's talk about the intangibles.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Mad4palace Flag 09 Nov 16 5.55pm

Originally posted by NickinOX


I've previously posted this, but it seems worth doing again.

Over the 2014-15 season our record with Jedi in the team:
W6, D7, L11 (or 1.04 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D2, L5 (or 1.64 ppg)

Over the 2015-16 season with Jedi in the team:
W4, D9, L14 (or 0.78 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D0, L4 (or 1.91 ppg)

So, yes, let's talk about the intangibles.

Jedinak almost notoriously seems to take quite a few games to settle back into things, being in and out of the side didn't help him under Pardew. I believe he was getting back to his best at the tail end of last season where I thought he was MOTM in the semi and final in the FA Cup, AND I thought he was our best player in the defeat to West Brom this season.

I think Pardew simply just didn't understand Jedinak's game, last year he was trying to fit Jedinak into the same role as the injured McArthur, which was bizarre.

Edited by Mad4palace (09 Nov 2016 5.55pm)

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 09 Nov 16 6.34pm

I think Jedi is not better than our starting XI midfielders - no way. However, as others have pointed out, he IS better than our back-up/bench midfielders. I wonder what the point averages are when Ledley (I rate Ledley btw) or Mutch are in the team?

 


[Link]

cpj Flag Kent 09 Nov 16 6.36pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

So we're not free to point out the huge problem in the DM position? Ledley and Cabaye are not doing the job. Pardew deserves criticism for making that position a problem.

During our great run in the first half of last season, Cabaye and McArthur were the DMs. Jedinak wasn't in the side at all.

 

Mad4palace Flag 09 Nov 16 10.17pm

Originally posted by cpj

During our great run in the first half of last season, Cabaye and McArthur were the DMs. Jedinak wasn't in the side at all.

I think the trio of McArthur, Cabaye and Puncheon was wonderful for that period, whether we're doing something fundamentally different to that or teams have learned to counter it, something is not right. Also we do need more of a plan b and Jedinak could have been part of that plan.

The thing I can see that's different is that this season McArthur has been really pushed forward to support Benteke. Cabaye's stats indicate he's doing ok but for whatever reason teams still seem to walk right through our midfield. Pushing McArthur so far forward might be giving Benteke more support up front and also making us into a better pressing team but it comes at the expense of not having McArthur back alongside Cabaye.

 

The Dolphin Flag 10 Nov 16 9.17am

Originally posted by NickinOX


I've previously posted this, but it seems worth doing again.

Over the 2014-15 season our record with Jedi in the team:
W6, D7, L11 (or 1.04 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D2, L5 (or 1.64 ppg)

Over the 2015-16 season with Jedi in the team:
W4, D9, L14 (or 0.78 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D0, L4 (or 1.91 ppg)

So, yes, let's talk about the intangibles.

I can't argue with you because I have not done the sums.
I will check though as it seems a little odd to me.
He rarely played in the first half of last season when we did well but when it all went wrong he came in and steadied the ship.
Stats cannot be argued with but they don't always tell the true story.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 10 Nov 16 2.44pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I can't argue with you because I have not done the sums.
I will check though as it seems a little odd to me.
He rarely played in the first half of last season when we did well but when it all went wrong he came in and steadied the ship.
Stats cannot be argued with but they don't always tell the true story.

When I looked it up, it was far worse than I expected. But you are free to check for yourself.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 10 Nov 16 2.46pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Jedinak almost notoriously seems to take quite a few games to settle back into things, being in and out of the side didn't help him under Pardew. I believe he was getting back to his best at the tail end of last season where I thought he was MOTM in the semi and final in the FA Cup, AND I thought he was our best player in the defeat to West Brom this season.

I think Pardew simply just didn't understand Jedinak's game, last year he was trying to fit Jedinak into the same role as the injured McArthur, which was bizarre.

Edited by Mad4palace (09 Nov 2016 5.55pm)

Look up the games for yourself. He had a decent run of games but it made little difference.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

james03 Flag Bangkok 11 Nov 16 1.37am

Jedinak ,moving on was the correct decision and four million pounds, or whatever it was, certainly made it even more sensible to say farewell.

We had Cabaye, Mutch, Lee, Puncheon, McArthur and Ledley for three midfield positions so imagined, wrongly, that we had decent cover already for a player who was not an automatic starter.

Jedinak read the game so well and was often aware of where the defensive gaps were that needed plugging. However, his passing was often his Achilles heel and we needed better in that DM position if we are to progress.

Unfortunately we have seen McArthur moved further forward, Cabaye following up behind the attack and Ledley more a liability than asset. Puncheon is truly dreadful at any defensive duties and Mutch has done nothing to merit a place in the team. Lee, whilst he has his moments, is another of the Guedioura, Bannon etc. type midfielders who are not quite Premier league quality.

In my opinion we need a high quality defensive midfielder and have been linked with one in Morgan Schneiderlin. Another option may be Kirchhoff who was fantastic in that role for Sunderland last season and due to return to fitness next month.

Other possibles include Jon Obi Mikel who is out of favour at Chelsea, Bastian Schweinsteiger set to leave Man United, Lucas of Liverpool, Delph from Manchester City and McCarthy from Everton.

Such a player then allows the likes of Puncheon, Cabaye, McArthur to play further forward without overly exposing the defence.

So no we do not miss Jedinak but we DO miss a player of his ilk.

Edited by james03 (11 Nov 2016 1.39am)

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

OldFella Flag London 11 Nov 16 2.32am

Originally posted by NickinOX


I've previously posted this, but it seems worth doing again.

Over the 2014-15 season our record with Jedi in the team:
W6, D7, L11 (or 1.04 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D2, L5 (or 1.64 ppg)

Over the 2015-16 season with Jedi in the team:
W4, D9, L14 (or 0.78 ppg)

Jedi out of the team:
W7, D0, L4 (or 1.91 ppg)

So, yes, let's talk about the intangibles.

Your stats are wrong, btw...sorry to p on your firework

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

The Dolphin Flag 11 Nov 16 5.34am

Originally posted by james03

Jedinak ,moving on was the correct decision and four million pounds, or whatever it was, certainly made it even more sensible to say farewell.

We had Cabaye, Mutch, Lee, Puncheon, McArthur and Ledley for three midfield positions so imagined, wrongly, that we had decent cover already for a player who was not an automatic starter.

Jedinak read the game so well and was often aware of where the defensive gaps were that needed plugging. However, his passing was often his Achilles heel and we needed better in that DM position if we are to progress.

Unfortunately we have seen McArthur moved further forward, Cabaye following up behind the attack and Ledley more a liability than asset. Puncheon is truly dreadful at any defensive duties and Mutch has done nothing to merit a place in the team. Lee, whilst he has his moments, is another of the Guedioura, Bannon etc. type midfielders who are not quite Premier league quality.

In my opinion we need a high quality defensive midfielder and have been linked with one in Morgan Schneiderlin. Another option may be Kirchhoff who was fantastic in that role for Sunderland last season and due to return to fitness next month.

Other possibles include Jon Obi Mikel who is out of favour at Chelsea, Bastian Schweinsteiger set to leave Man United, Lucas of Liverpool, Delph from Manchester City and McCarthy from Everton.

Such a player then allows the likes of Puncheon, Cabaye, McArthur to play further forward without overly exposing the defence.

So no we do not miss Jedinak but we DO miss a player of his ilk.

Edited by james03 (11 Nov 2016 1.39am)

I do so hate common sense!!

We certainly should not have got rid of him without first having cover in the same position.

My way of saying I concur!

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 11 Nov 16 2.08pm

Originally posted by OldFella

Your stats are wrong, btw...sorry to p on your firework

And your evidence is?

Anyone is free to look up our league record themselves. But clearly, you couldn't be arsed as the facts might not fit. Easier instead to just denounce without checking for yourself.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Nov 16 3.56pm

Jedi is a f**king great defensive midfielder, but unfortunately that's about it. He's also getting on a bit, and his legs were going.

Now he's better than Ledley, McArthur and Cabaye as a DM, but they also have much more capacity to their game in midfield than Jedi.

Odd as it seems, defensively, we were probably at our best with Jedi and KG playing in that holding role. They were, defensively, an immense pairing, but they never really had more to contribute beyond that.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Nov 16 4.09pm

I miss him (strokes beard).

 


Red and Blue Army!

elgrande Flag bedford 11 Nov 16 4.28pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I miss him (strokes beard).

What his or yours..!!

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 11 Nov 16 4.29pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Jedi is a f**king great defensive midfielder, but unfortunately that's about it. He's also getting on a bit, and his legs were going.

Now he's better than Ledley, McArthur and Cabaye as a DM, but they also have much more capacity to their game in midfield than Jedi.

Odd as it seems, defensively, we were probably at our best with Jedi and KG playing in that holding role. They were, defensively, an immense pairing, but they never really had more to contribute beyond that.

Agreed. Jedi was immense for us through our first year in the PL. But as he became less mobile his impact waned. That's when his inability to pass and create much became a real problem.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Nov 16 4.38pm

Originally posted by elgrande

What his or yours..!!

Mine - but a bit of a tribute. Still have Ledley so not at all lost.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Username Flag Horsham 11 Nov 16 4.52pm

Originally posted by james03

Jedinak ,moving on was the correct decision and four million pounds, or whatever it was, certainly made it even more sensible to say farewell.

We had Cabaye, Mutch, Lee, Puncheon, McArthur and Ledley for three midfield positions so imagined, wrongly, that we had decent cover already for a player who was not an automatic starter.

Jedinak read the game so well and was often aware of where the defensive gaps were that needed plugging. However, his passing was often his Achilles heel and we needed better in that DM position if we are to progress.

Unfortunately we have seen McArthur moved further forward, Cabaye following up behind the attack and Ledley more a liability than asset. Puncheon is truly dreadful at any defensive duties and Mutch has done nothing to merit a place in the team. Lee, whilst he has his moments, is another of the Guedioura, Bannon etc. type midfielders who are not quite Premier league quality.

In my opinion we need a high quality defensive midfielder and have been linked with one in Morgan Schneiderlin. Another option may be Kirchhoff who was fantastic in that role for Sunderland last season and due to return to fitness next month.

Other possibles include Jon Obi Mikel who is out of favour at Chelsea, Bastian Schweinsteiger set to leave Man United, Lucas of Liverpool, Delph from Manchester City and McCarthy from Everton.

Such a player then allows the likes of Puncheon, Cabaye, McArthur to play further forward without overly exposing the defence.

So no we do not miss Jedinak but we DO miss a player of his ilk.

Edited by james03 (11 Nov 2016 1.39am)

I'd argue that is where the problem is. To address the lack of a proper attacking midfielder we've now compromised our midfield two that were so good this time a year ago.

If we had an attacking midfielder who could play closer to Benteke, then McArthur can go back to patrolling the midfield, playing closer to Cabaye and protecting the full backs.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

tonymikejoe Flag UK 11 Nov 16 5.53pm

Some great quotes here on Jedi from Villa fans :


sirdennis

Massive disappointment. I really thought he would help sort our midfield problems , but he is nowhere near the player I saw playing for Palace.

Whether the travelling has taken its toll I don't know , but Gana looked pants last season and is now starring for Everton , so I think it's a mix of Jedinaks decline and the fact that our midfield as a unit is dysfunctional.


fat loser

Have to say I thought this would prove to be a very good signing ( unfortunately I appear at this stage to be wrong)

Legs seem to have gone, leadership qualities questionable .... Disappointing


glensider

The only positive that I can see so far regarding our signing of Mile Jedinak, is that the guy cannot be as bad as he looks?

Hence, surely things can only get better?

Oh yes, he's renowned for his pointing. He's different class.

Every time he points I jump out of my seat in expectation.


Martin, we've both been watching Aston Villa home and away for many, many years.

I personally struggle to bring up the name of any other individual wearing the claret and blue, who offered so little, contributed so little, yet played so many games.

It completely baffles me.


david-avfc

I can't believe how poor this guys passing is. It's embarrassing that this guy is apparently a good player and he plays like that


holtelower

I am absolutely stunned on what we have actually got.

No pace, no skill, no hunger.

I dont know why he is like that, is it travelling, is it age, is it hunger - I have no idea.

The only thing I do know is that he does not deserve a place in our team at the moment, and if that means playing Ashley Westwood, then so be it.

Read more: [Link]


They don't seem too happy do they?


 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Nov 16 6.11pm

Seems like we did a good bit of business, £4m for a worn out player.

Doubtless many on here, still want him back, god knows why.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Missing Jedinak?