You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Press Conference Re-Scheduled (is that a bad sign?
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Press Conference Re-Scheduled (is that a bad sign?


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
EagleEssex Flag Essex 07 Sep 17 1.20pm

Originally posted by miles18

Parish didn't give a s*** when Pardew couldn't win a football match.

Why is FDB not being given the same amount of time?

Completely different.
Pardew saved us from relegation in his first season and guided us to an 10th place finish.
In his second season we got off to a great start and were well in the top half of the table at Christmas. The wheels fell off in the second half of the season and we went on a bad run, but he still got us to the FA Cup Final. The bad run continued until his 3rd season but at his time of sacking, we still had points on the board and were NOT in the relegation zone.
For that reason Parish was justified not to wield the axe because of past success under Pardew.
FDB is unproved in the premier league and was a flop in Italy so its a completely difference scenario.
That said I think he ought to be given more time, at least another 3 games.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 07 Sep 17 2.06pm

The way I see it, the Crux of the matter is The 'Evolution/Revolution' Comment. one of FdBs more famous comments was 'Evolution not Revolution' and it's easy to see how SP would have bought into that idea.

It was obvious Parish fell for FdB and his promise of more expansive, Totalfootball. If this is the way FdB sold himself and the plan for the club, then Parish has a right to be aggrieved with the way things have started.
Plunging the Players at his disposal into a 3-4-3 that they were not ready for. That's not evolving a squad, that's deep-end sink or swim stuff.

If SP has indeed agreed with FdB to return to a 4-3-3, then to me that is a sensible thing he has done. Force an Evolution over the Revolution whilst keeping FdB's desire to change things as the end goal. It's in FdB's court now to Prove he has the acumen to implement a slower change.

I'm not going to comment on The Transfer dealings other than to say that we have no idea who we were/were not in for(except Niasse, who could have been 3rd/4th/5th choice for all we know) . It seemed that we wanted a lot of players that went elsewhere for reasons unknown. I'm not about to speculate any further.

Overall, Hopefully this is SP reigning in his manager after a rather brash opening, If they work together and keep pushing each other, then we could end up exactly where we want to be.
fight as they are(if you beleive the rumours and media - I do not), then getting rid is the only way to avoid relegation.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Sep 17 2.10pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

The way I see it, the Crux of the matter is The 'Evolution/Revolution' Comment. one of FdBs more famous comments was 'Evolution not Revolution' and it's easy to see how SP would have bought into that idea.

It was obvious Parish fell for FdB and his promise of more expansive, Totalfootball. If this is the way FdB sold himself and the plan for the club, then Parish has a right to be aggrieved with the way things have started.
Plunging the Players at his disposal into a 3-4-3 that they were not ready for. That's not evolving a squad, that's deep-end sink or swim stuff.

If SP has indeed agreed with FdB to return to a 4-3-3, then to me that is a sensible thing he has done. Force an Evolution over the Revolution whilst keeping FdB's desire to change things as the end goal. It's in FdB's court now to Prove he has the acumen to implement a slower change.

I'm not going to comment on The Transfer dealings other than to say that we have no idea who we were/were not in for(except Niasse, who could have been 3rd/4th/5th choice for all we know) . It seemed that we wanted a lot of players that went elsewhere for reasons unknown. I'm not about to speculate any further.

Overall, Hopefully this is SP reigning in his manager after a rather brash opening, If they work together and keep pushing each other, then we could end up exactly where we want to be.
fight as they are(if you beleive the rumours and media - I do not), then getting rid is the only way to avoid relegation.

Do you firmly believe that Steve goes into detail about formations with FDB and tells him to play 4-3-3, 4-5-1, etc etc ?

Interestingly Burnley have been known to play a 2 man strike force and it has been said that 3 at the back is well-equipped to deal with such a formation.Someone has just sent me this :

A great example of the dilemma for managers who want to play a three-man defence. That system can work well, but generally only against a two-man strikeforce.

Edited by Willo (07 Sep 2017 2.15pm)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 07 Sep 17 2.21pm

Originally posted by Willo

Do you firmly believe that Steve goes into detail about formations with FDB and tells him to play 4-3-3, 4-5-1, etc etc ?

Interestingly Burnley have been known to play a 2 man strike force and it has been said that 3 at the back is well-equipped to deal with such a formation.Someone has just sent me this :

A great example of the dilemma for managers who want to play a three-man defence. That system can work well, but generally only against a two-man strikeforce.

Edited by Willo (07 Sep 2017 2.15pm)

I was just commenting on what others have said/reported. I do not believe that they have talked formations.
I guess my point was that If Parish is trying to slow the Revolution it can only be a good thing - and exactly what he should be doing at this stage.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by Willo

Do you firmly believe that Steve goes into detail about formations with FDB and tells him to play 4-3-3, 4-5-1, etc etc ?

Interestingly Burnley have been known to play a 2 man strike force and it has been said that 3 at the back is well-equipped to deal with such a formation.Someone has just sent me this :

A great example of the dilemma for managers who want to play a three-man defence. That system can work well, but generally only against a two-man strikeforce.

Edited by Willo (07 Sep 2017 2.15pm)

It's a good point but rarely do teams have both strikers pushing so high. One usually drops off or there's a gaping hole for Luka to pick the ball up all day long, instead of the 2nd striker, which is probably what he'll do.

 


COYP

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 07 Sep 17 2.27pm

What baffles me at the moment is that if FdB reverts to a 4-3-3...its exactly the system that he was successful with at Ajax...so why did he want to move straight to a 3-4-3? Or was he being influenced on what 'trendy' formation to play by others?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 17 2.33pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

What baffles me at the moment is that if FdB reverts to a 4-3-3...its exactly the system that he was successful with at Ajax...so why did he want to move straight to a 3-4-3? Or was he being influenced on what 'trendy' formation to play by others?

Yes. To not assess his own squad properly or at all before making the decision it looks so.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (07 Sep 2017 3.16pm)

 


COYP

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 07 Sep 17 2.42pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yes. To not assess his own squad properly or at all before doing the decision it looks so.

But it was stated I think by De Boer himself that he had evaluated the squad and decide 3-4-3 was the best formation.........The dude's a gonna it's only a matter of when.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 07 Sep 17 2.45pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yes. To not assess his own squad properly or at all before doing the decision it looks so.

I think that's a little harsh - Prospective/New Managers don;t have too long to make this call accurately.
I think he did looked at The players we had, then did believe they suited 3-4-3. I think he overestimated the ability of some of our players to play in the manner he wanted.

His mistake was not recognising that and not updating his plan. but then - maybe he recognised that it takes more time to Change, and soon they will adapt.

Edited by CrazyBadger (07 Sep 2017 2.46pm)

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 07 Sep 17 2.47pm

Originally posted by Andy_G

But it was stated I think by De Boer himself that he had evaluated the squad and decide 3-4-3 was the best formation.........The dude's a gonna it's only a matter of when.

Spot on. FDB knew the squad when appointed. Much as we might have wished for more, we still signed 4 players this window. Unless he thought he'd be able to get 7 or 8 in, which might have made 3-4-3 viable, FDB is still to blame for persisting in an unsuitable formation.

Could have stuck with 4-3-3 variant, but just impressed on players positivity of passing. Then switched formation when players a bit more comfortable for way of playing

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 17 3.25pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I think that's a little harsh - Prospective/New Managers don;t have too long to make this call accurately.
I think he did looked at The players we had, then did believe they suited 3-4-3. I think he overestimated the ability of some of our players to play in the manner he wanted.

His mistake was not recognising that and not updating his plan. but then - maybe he recognised that it takes more time to Change, and soon they will adapt.

Edited by CrazyBadger (07 Sep 2017 2.46pm)

I think he made the call before even assessing the squad and was (in secret) hell bent on 3-4-3 wherever he managed in the prem.

If we knew (actually me and Bexleydave and a few others) it'd be more likely to fall on its & rse then Sammy Lee certainly knew.

Whether the mistake is not updating his plan or what not, it's Frank's responsibility and shoulders it falls on.

That doesn't mean to say I want him out. I'd rather he played to our strengths, gets 6 in the next 2 and a result or 2 out of ManC, Manu and Chelsea, then when we're at full strength get some pass and move going a bit more, with 3 at the back on the back burner for a while, ready to unleash without 3 months of notice like West Ham did to us last season.

 


COYP

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 07 Sep 17 4.33pm

I do not think that is harsh at all! Is it too much to ask from a new manager to properly look the games of last season(s) back? That should have told him a few things about amongst other Puncheon, Milo, Tekkers and Ward as a potential wing back, should it not?
And yes, finally it now seems picked up that he was never a 3-4-3 man with wing backs. The Ajax system is 4 at the back, and wingers UPFRONT. So why change not only the manner of your new team, but also the manner you are use to yourself? Copy the current champions? Try something new? Be different? A vanity project as understandably some have called it seems the most accurate description to me. You can perfectly ask players to play less direct and more controlled without changing the whole system for the sake of it. It simply can not be based on the quality of the squad as we may not be professional specialists as fans, we still have eyes in our head and can see what happens on the pitch.

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I think that's a little harsh - Prospective/New Managers don;t have too long to make this call accurately.
I think he did looked at The players we had, then did believe they suited 3-4-3. I think he overestimated the ability of some of our players to play in the manner he wanted.

His mistake was not recognising that and not updating his plan. but then - maybe he recognised that it takes more time to Change, and soon they will adapt.

Edited by CrazyBadger (07 Sep 2017 2.46pm)


Edited by DutchEagleJohan (07 Sep 2017 4.33pm)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 07 Sep 17 5.06pm

Our players are more than capable of playing a short pass and move style, its just the tactic that was wrong.

Look at our players, a PVA grew up in the culture of pass and move, milo would've played that game in Greece no doubt, Cabaye, of course, Zaha one of the best wingers in British football should be able to, Townsend certainly did at spurs, Benteke does whenever he comes on for Belgium and did at Liverpool, Dann did for Blackburn, they weren't that direct, schlupp played a quick direct game admittedly at Leicester but even they play it on the ground because Vardy and Okosaki, whatever his name is, are short asses.

Most of our side have played pass and move or are capable. The issue has been the formation and not utilizing the only striker we have in the best way possible, Benteke is a target man predominantly.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 07 Sep 17 5.10pm

Going back to topic title, perhaps the conference was delayed as the game is sunday not Saturday?

Saying that I always thought these conferences of ours were held on a Friday anyway, no?

 

est1905 Flag 07 Sep 17 5.20pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I think that's a little harsh - Prospective/New Managers don;t have too long to make this call accurately.
I think he did looked at The players we had, then did believe they suited 3-4-3. I think he overestimated the ability of some of our players to play in the manner he wanted.

His mistake was not recognising that and not updating his plan. but then - maybe he recognised that it takes more time to Change, and soon they will adapt.

Edited by CrazyBadger (07 Sep 2017 2.46pm)

Or just maybe he thought Palace might be a touch more patient than the idiots now running Inter Milan and give him more than 3 league games before hes under pressure to keep his job.
Its reasonable to assume he believed he could make it work with hard work and patience. Something (if he is sacked within the next 5 games) he has not been afforded.

 

est1905 Flag 07 Sep 17 5.24pm

Originally posted by matthau

Our players are more than capable of playing a short pass and move style, its just the tactic that was wrong.

Look at our players, a PVA grew up in the culture of pass and move, milo would've played that game in Greece no doubt, Cabaye, of course, Zaha one of the best wingers in British football should be able to, Townsend certainly did at spurs, Benteke does whenever he comes on for Belgium and did at Liverpool, Dann did for Blackburn, they weren't that direct, schlupp played a quick direct game admittedly at Leicester but even they play it on the ground because Vardy and Okosaki, whatever his name is, are short asses.

Most of our side have played pass and move or are capable. The issue has been the formation and not utilizing the only striker we have in the best way possible, Benteke is a target man predominantly.

The issue is as Sam Allardyce said yesterday. Almost word for word: 'It has nothing to do with systems and formations, they are creating enough chances but not putting them away. But the real issue is individually and collectively they are not defending correctly'

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 07 Sep 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

We saw it at the end of Pardew's reign and the beginning on Sam's. Remember the 0-4 drubbing to a truly awful Sunderland team?

The Delaney moment pretending to be asleep on the bench at Swansea wasn't great but for the most part we were being beaten narrowly, often late in the game, due to poor fitness /subs/concentration. Last four games beat Soton, drew Hull lost narrowly at home to United and Chelsea.

The Sunderland game was a bit freakish really on the back of a good win at Bournemouth and hinged on some weak goalkeeping for the first goal and two mental minutes at the end of the first half. Always had a bit of hope that Sam would make us hard to beat although after the game at West Ham I looked at players leaving the pitch and thought we were gone then to be honest.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 07 Sep 17 8.50pm

Originally posted by matthau

Going back to topic title, perhaps the conference was delayed as the game is sunday not Saturday?

Saying that I always thought these conferences of ours were held on a Friday anyway, no?

We delayed a few last season too but nobody gave a toss because the FdB feeding frenzy didn't exist.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Sep 17 9.08pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

We delayed a few last season too but nobody gave a toss because the FdB feeding frenzy didn't exist.

Yes it's gone insane and a lot of it is entertaining the bored. I'm a big critic but I appreciate there are more games needed (1 or 2 perhaps or game by game for a bit) for various reasons, analysis and decisions.

Part of the audience now. Demand constant entertainment, enjoyment, fulfilment, drama, where they can't create their own.

The other demand is a statement from parish. To say what? 'It's been sh1t but I'm putting full faith in Frank unless it's shyte and then he'll be sacked.' He's said the obvious already.

 


COYP

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 07 Sep 17 9.37pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yes it's gone insane and a lot of it is entertaining the bored. I'm a big critic but I appreciate there are more games needed (1 or 2 perhaps or game by game for a bit) for various reasons, analysis and decisions.

Part of the audience now. Demand constant entertainment, enjoyment, fulfilment, drama, where they can't create their own.

The other demand is a statement from parish. To say what? 'It's been sh1t but I'm putting full faith in Frank unless it's shyte and then he'll be sacked.' He's said the obvious already.

I know what you mean. Problem is I can imagine a (very unlikely) situation where things turn around & we go on a run beating everyone & by the time we've beaten the entire top 6 at theirs the crowd are still booing. FdB stands in the middle of the emirates pitch & shouts "are you not entertained?!" Full on Gladiator style

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Press Conference Re-Scheduled (is that a bad sign?