You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bang on article
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bang on article


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
kev64 Flag Cambs 14 Sep 17 2.55pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

So there's a rumour he alienated 3 players, weirdly all 3 who are not deemed good enough by the majority of Palace fans. Throwing their toys out of the pram because 3 PL players can't adapt to a system that actually requires a bit of thought and technical skill. Funny how 3 defenders of their ability seem to know so much more than a defender with the career of Franks. "Weirdo" was the word quoted, how completely and utterly pathetic does that sound? Poor millionaire players "awienated", bless em. Maybe the players need to man up a bit. Absolutely amazing times we live in when Martin Kelly can get Frank de Boer the sack.

Rumours are also Parish is a control freak and an ego maniac who went above his head in transfer dealings, refused to back him with his targets because he was assigning the majority of the budget to Sakho and then ironically telling him what tactics he should be implementing.

The above just goes to show the value of basing assumptions on rumours. All we can do is go by facts - and the fact is unless Frank de Boer tried to shag all of the players wives, Parish really has no excuse for getting rid of him in the period of time that he did, especially after the performance vs Burnley.

The fact as I understand he made JW sit out if pre season to watch how RWB was supposed to be played by AT who has never played in that position and was not happy with it.

Told JW he was up for sale Friday before the game then played him as RWB !!! Ffs that's an inspirational piece of management, put him in the shop window to fail to show SP how bad he is.

JW and other senior players are a reason the team stayed in the PL regardless of not being world beaters, football is a team game and if you alienate the team for your own ego the you shouldn't be in the job.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 14 Sep 17 3.07pm

The amount of people bemoaning Parish for sacking FDB is ridonkulous, the same people moaned at SP for not venting AP sooner than he did. Maybe he saw certain similarities, realised he made a mistake and thought "not this time".

I would like to point out, before you get all frothy at the mouth, that I to think the clubs management of transfers is beyond pathetic and reeks of panick buying, 28 million for Benteke ? and even worse 28 million for a defender that's not even fit enough to play. My point is a combined fee of nearly 60 million for Sakho and Benteke is very much Panick buying, and the only reason can be a piss poor scouting network and an utterly unfit for purpose transfer policy, and the buck for that stops with Parish, and in my book we have learnt nothing since the Hollaway debacle and that is the Boards fault.

However FDB was not the one. Everyone keeps going on about how well we played against Burnley....So fckin what it was Burnley not a team we should be losing to, as were Huddersfield, and Swansea.

Yes we were better, but we could hardly be any worse than against Huddersfield and Swansea. You can't seriously tell me that in all honesty, if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley and it is feasible that we could have walked away from Anfield with a point, instead we have sweet f*** all points and the same amount of goals. First team since 1926 to not score in the top flight in their first 4 league games.

So in summary then:

Parish made a mistake, then rectified it. FDB poor man management and even poorer results.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Sep 17 3.30pm

Originally posted by dannyh

You can't seriously tell me that in all honesty, if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley

I seem to recall that when we had Sam Allardyce as manager we did lose to Swansea and Burnley

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 17 4.12pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I seem to recall that when we had Sam Allardyce as manager we did lose to Swansea and Burnley

After 10 weeks+ planning he wouldn't have.

Instead Frank invited his opponents to watch and plan for his irresponsible shambles he couldn't deliver.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Sep 17 4.27pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

After 10 weeks+ planning he wouldn't have.

I think that you just argue for the sake of it.

Sam became manager on 23rd December and we got beaten by Burnley on 29th April which according to my calculator is more than 10 weeks planning time

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 17 4.37pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I think that you just argue for the sake of it.

Sam became manager on 23rd December and we got beaten by Burnley on 29th April which according to my calculator is more than 10 weeks planning time

I'm talking about not losing 4 in a row, to nil. We had similar arguments with some members saying under Pardew we had no right to beat Burnley, hull, Swansea, any others. Well we shouldn't be losing to all of them and others. Anyway, situation was this:

Sam had to undo the squad that was Pardewed. When Frank took over he had pre season to prepare and a couple of holes to fill, and no pressure of prem results at the time to get it done. What Frank decided to do was create 6-7 holes to fill and play a handful of them in positions they wouldn't play in the league, thus damaging their performance, links in the team along with others who can't deliver in it anyway.

You must know all this. Maybe you don't see it or want to.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Sep 17 4.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I'm talking about not losing 4 in a row, to nil.

You must know all this. Maybe you don't see it or want to.

You weren't talking about losing four in a row at all but you seem to think that if you chuck in a mild insult people won't notice.

dannyh stated "You can't seriously tell me that in all honesty, if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley"

I responded "I seem to recall that when we had Sam Allardyce as manager we did lose to Swansea and Burnley"

You butted in to say "After 10 weeks+ planning he wouldn't have."

I responded "Sam became manager on 23rd December and we got beaten by Burnley on 29th April which according to my calculator is more than 10 weeks planning time"

You then tried to move the goalposts by pretending that you were arguing about something else.

As I said, I think that you just argue for the sake of it


 

Mstrobez Flag 14 Sep 17 6.45pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You weren't talking about losing four in a row at all but you seem to think that if you chuck in a mild insult people won't notice.

dannyh stated "You can't seriously tell me that in all honesty, if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley"

I responded "I seem to recall that when we had Sam Allardyce as manager we did lose to Swansea and Burnley"

You butted in to say "After 10 weeks+ planning he wouldn't have."

I responded "Sam became manager on 23rd December and we got beaten by Burnley on 29th April which according to my calculator is more than 10 weeks planning time"

You then tried to move the goalposts by pretending that you were arguing about something else.

As I said, I think that you just argue for the sake of it


Allardyces first 7 games in charge;

Watford 1-1 Palace

Palace 1-2 Swansea

Bolton 0-0 Palace (league cup)

West Ham 3-0 Palace

Palace 2-1 Bolton (league cup)

Palace 0-1 Everton

Palace 0-3 City

But that's okay becsuse he's English and "knows the premier league init!" Although I remember some seriously suggesting at the start of his reign that he had taken the club to lower than Pardew depths.

In my opinion it's a lot more to do with being opposed to a different culture of football than many would like to admit. All this nonsense that foreign managers don't work but that theory has been obliterated too many times now for it to really be taken seriously.


Edited by Mstrobez (14 Sep 2017 6.47pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 17 6.59pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You weren't talking about losing four in a row at all but you seem to think that if you chuck in a mild insult people won't notice.

dannyh stated "You can't seriously tell me that in all honesty, if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley"

I responded "I seem to recall that when we had Sam Allardyce as manager we did lose to Swansea and Burnley"

You butted in to say "After 10 weeks+ planning he wouldn't have."

I responded "Sam became manager on 23rd December and we got beaten by Burnley on 29th April which according to my calculator is more than 10 weeks planning time"

You then tried to move the goalposts by pretending that you were arguing about something else.

As I said, I think that you just argue for the sake of it


Crossed wires then. I'm arguing with you and rattus because neither of you can see what is front of you. The bloke lied about 'gradual and results', got the job, lied again about 'gradual and results', lied some more we suit 3-4-3, kept lying, lost 4 league games to nil and is out on his &Arsenal and £2 mil richer.

That's it. You can't see it. God knows why. Don't want to probably.

 


COYP

rattus2002 Flag 14 Sep 17 7.11pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You weren't talking about losing four in a row at all but you seem to think that if you chuck in a mild insult people won't notice.

dannyh stated "You can't seriously tell me that in all honesty, if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley"

I responded "I seem to recall that when we had Sam Allardyce as manager we did lose to Swansea and Burnley"

You butted in to say "After 10 weeks+ planning he wouldn't have."

I responded "Sam became manager on 23rd December and we got beaten by Burnley on 29th April which according to my calculator is more than 10 weeks planning time"

You then tried to move the goalposts by pretending that you were arguing about something else.

As I said, I think that you just argue for the sake of it


Rudi has called me an odd character and a crackpot on another thread so don't take it personally. Seems he doesn't like you questioning his point of view.

Edited by rattus2002 (14 Sep 2017 7.12pm)

 

Username Flag Horsham 14 Sep 17 7.15pm

There's no way anyone can really judge the situation, because none of us were involved and we don't know what will happen now. There were obviously problems from both sides. Even after nearly a week I still don't really know how to feel about it.

You can argue Parish made a mistake with the appointment, but at the same time FdB changed his tune almost immediately after he was appointed which was strange.

Does Parish meddle? Maybe, but at the same time weren't we all grateful when we changed to a back four? In which case maybe it was actually necessary for him to get involved?

The timing was weird yes, but it's so hard to judge. If we criticise Parish for the appointment, should we credit him for rectifying it? If he gave Pardew too long is it good he cut it short? Who knows, time will tell with our finishing position this season. If FDB couldn't work with these players, then maybe it is the right call to put the 'evolution' on hold, bring in some more 'expansive' players and then try again.

Frank talked about a long term plan, but their was little evidence of that. We spent it playing Luka and Ward in the back three and then changed it for the first game, and threw in a new player who'd barely met his team mates. Dann started the game next to two young players making their debut, one who had never played in England and one who had only just joined the club. In front of him we had Ward and Luka playing in completely different positions to those they had practiced. That woes a worrying sign, but then again after the Huddersfield game what really killed us was stupid individual errors, not bad tactics necessarily?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Midlands Eagle Flag 14 Sep 17 7.43pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Crossed wires then. I'm arguing with you and rattus because neither of you can see what is front of you. The bloke lied about 'gradual and results', got the job, lied again about 'gradual and results', lied some more we suit 3-4-3, kept lying, lost 4 league games to nil and is out on his &Arsenal and £2 mil richer.

That's it. You can't see it. God knows why. Don't want to probably.

What has that got to do with "if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley" which was what I was responding to.

It was you that decided to twist my response into something that we weren't discussing and if anyone "can't see it", it's you

 

Kramer15 Flag Brooklyn 14 Sep 17 8.00pm

Originally posted by Username

but then again after the Huddersfield game what really killed us was stupid individual errors, not bad tactics necessarily?

Individual errors come from poor preparation. In anything. You can point the finger at individuals for making them but when it is a common occurrence then you have to start looking the training and drills leading up to it.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 17 8.12pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

What has that got to do with "if we still had BFS as manager that we would have lost to Huddersfield, Swansea, or Burnley" which was what I was responding to.

It was you that decided to twist my response into something that we weren't discussing and if anyone "can't see it", it's you

Oh look who cares about that cr&p anyway. Frank bullsh1tted his way in, his real intentions were bollox and ultimately lost him his job on top of his bullsh1t. If you're gutted so be it. I'd rather not have that in our club putting us at risk. You would, fair enough.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 17 8.15pm

Originally posted by Kramer15

Individual errors come from poor preparation. In anything. You can point the finger at individuals for making them but when it is a common occurrence then you have to start looking the training and drills leading up to it.

Like

Ward being discarded one day and selected the next.

Luka playing his 2nd game as a def mid v Liverpool since mid May.

Kelly being sent to the youngsters and then being called back in need for Swansea, only to fvck up.

That type of inspirational man management you mean? I reckon by the time November came he would've played every player on the back of the programme. All 40 odd of them.

 


COYP

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 14 Sep 17 8.22pm

I can't believe that we still have the Parish love in going on despite all the fcuk-ups he has made over the past few years with his appointments and transfer dealings. He is a total w***er, full of himself, We are in the process of seeing his lack of responsibility for anything coming across again, All the rumours (and remember they are just rumours) probably have a vein of truth but thats all. I am sure at some point the other side of the argument will come out.

I ask myself why is a businessman interfering in football affairs, Why is he on a big jolly on all the tours, He is not a footballing genius. I really hope he gets help in running the club before he puts it back where he picked it up from. I don't think he is good for the club, He is out of his depth big time

Edited by Medway Eagle (14 Sep 2017 8.25pm)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 14 Sep 17 8.29pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Oh look who cares about that cr&p anyway. Frank bullsh1tted his way in, his real intentions were bollox and ultimately lost him his job on top of his bullsh1t. If you're gutted so be it. I'd rather not have that in our club putting us at risk. You would, fair enough.

Rudi you have no idea what Frank said during the ridiculously long recruitment process. He is Frank De Boer - he has been around the block a bit and has worked with some top managers, and got the Inter Job on the back of a very good reputation as a player and coach alike. Parish got stars in his eyes thinking about Swansea and Southampton, and went out and hired a manager who made his name of playing patient possession style football, with strong technical players - perfect fit for Palace dont you think? What do you mean by his "real intentions"? Dont you think he wanted to be successful at this club and win games? On the flip side we can only guess at what Parish told FdB in the interview process, but I doubt it was - we wont sign a backup striker or keeper in the transfer window, and will fart around on Sakho until the last minute clouding and disrupting our ability to do other deals. I would rather look at the architect of this situation, Mr Parish. Its one thing to make a bit of a mistake after spending 33 days hiring a manager, but this is an absolute howler of epic proportions. If after all of this time, he can make a clanger like that, I dont really trust him to run the club tbh. What would I propose I hear you cry - I propose he finds a suitable buyer and sells up. I know De Boer didnt help himself but there is something rotten at the club and the way things are being done at the minute.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 14 Sep 17 8.38pm

What a crock of sh*t.

Hiring De Boer was a big mistake but not because of just footballing reasons. He was a knob who alienated coaches players and the clubs hierarchy. He was tactically unprepared for the PL season and played two 20 year old CBs with a handful of PL minutes between them on the opening day after ruining the confidence of loads of other players by insulting them and switching around their position every 5 minutes in preaseason.

Honestly Parish probably should have got rid in the Summer before the season started when he realised it was only a matter of time before their relationship deteriorated further. At least then these so called 'football experts' would be able to see that this didn't happen purely on footballing grounds.

SP made the mistake in hiring him, firing him certainly wasn't a mistake.

As for the other managers.

Allardyce wanted out of football for a while, if it was really a problem with SP, he was hardly likely to have had a cal asking him back.

Pardew did a great job for us and faded and was fired 6 months too late.

Pulls, I fear we will never know the true details with us but what's clear was that we won the court case and he was a money grabbing knobhead who took money in good faith then tried to do a runner.

Holloway, walked because he couldn't hack it, deserved his shot after getting us up.

Warnock, probably the best choice around at the time and didn't manage to harken back to the manager he once was.

That's our PL manager history. 5 years in the top flight with a cup final. We have some unbelievable players. Sakho, Zaha, Tekkers, Yohan. These are huge players. Our club is in the best position it's been in my lifetime after being minutes away from extinction. So excuse me for having a little faith in our chairman and ignoring the nonsense from those who were not there at Lloyds bank, who don't remember Sheffield Wednesday, or who were not at the play off final.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (14 Sep 2017 8.51pm)

 

Kramer15 Flag Brooklyn 14 Sep 17 8.47pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Like

Ward being discarded one day and selected the next.

Luka playing his 2nd game as a def mid v Liverpool since mid May.

Kelly being sent to the youngsters and then being called back in need for Swansea, only to fvck up.

That type of inspirational man management you mean? I reckon by the time November came he would've played every player on the back of the programme. All 40 odd of them.

yes that's exactly what i mean. Somewhere along the line the team weren't being prepared for matches properly. Where the responsibility lies for that? Normally the manager.

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 14 Sep 17 8.52pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

What a crock of sh*t.

Hiring De Boer was a big mistake but not because of just footballing reasons. He was a knob who alienated coaches players and the clubs hierarchy. He was tactically unprepared for the PL season and played two 20 year old CBs with a handful of PL minutes between them on the opening day after ruining the confidence of loads of other players by insulting them and switching around their position every 5 minutes in preaseason.

Honestly Parish probably should have got rid in the Summer before the season started when he realised it was only a matter of time before their relationship deteriorated further. At least then these so called 'football experts' would be able to see that this didn't happen purely on footballing grounds.

SP made the mistake in hiring him, firing him certainly wasn't a mistake.

As for the other managers.

Allardyce wanted out of football for a while, if it was really a problem with SP, he was hardly likely to have had a cal asking him back.

Pardew did a great job for us and faded and was fired 6 months too late.

Pulls, I fear we will never know the true details with us but what's clear was that we won the court case and he was a money grabbing knobhead who took money in good faith then tried to do a runner.

Warnock, probably the best choice around at the time and didn't manage to harken back to the manager he once was.

Holloway, walked because he couldn't hack it, deserved his shot after getting us up.

That's our PL manager history. 5 years in the top flight with a cup final. We have some unbelievable players. Sakho, Zaha, Tekkers, Yohan. These are huge players. Our club is in the best position it's been in my lifetime after being minutes away from extinction. So excuse me for having a little faith in our chairman and ignoring the nonsense from those who were not there at Lloyds bank, who don't remember Sheffield Wednesday, or who were not at the play off final.

Which play off final? Leicester? Sheffield United? Watford? Blackburn Rovers in the old two leg home and away format? Dont tell me what i can or cannot have a view on.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bang on article