This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The abuse possibilities of what you are suggesting here are Orwellian. Surely you see that. Look at what YouTube and Twitter are doing to conservative commentators.....We are going to end up with competing outlets based upon politics and that ramps up polarization and division another level. I, for example have already drastically reduced my Google footprint after Demore.....I see this splitting happening everywhere eventually.....things have become overly political in entertainment and news and divisive consequences are inevitable. Sure, I agree...we have problems....But who gets to decide on 'fake news'? A Sanders supporter shot at Republicans....All that hyperbolic 'end of the world' nonsense spoken about Trump...when checks and balances are built into the American system for this very thing....Was that 'fake news'?.....That has consequences too....who gets to decide on what's is reasonable....How do you keep bias away from this? There is a definite problem....I agree with you...But when it comes to politics action worries me. However, I agree....The Internet promotes both the qualified person and the charlatan equally. Trump would never have been elected without the Internet and soundbite headline obsessed news outlets....People good at polarization and s*** talking are rewarded...moderates and peoeple who compromise to actually get things done are not. How to sort this...without essentially censoring people who don't agree with the accepted 'group-think'.....that's the problem.....I've grown very suspicious of the move towards censorship....it seems to be politically motivated. America probably have the best system on free speech in the world.....But freedom has its price.
Not really what I was trying to get at. My issue isn't with the troll, but with the 'alt-right news media' that picked up the story and ran with it. Its them I hold responsible, for publicising an obviously fake story as true, without doing any fact checking. They're the ones who essentially 'shouted fire' in a theatre, and could very well have ended up getting people killed. If my car manufacturer lies about my car, then its not free speech, its a class action law suit and possible criminal charges. And let be honest - This story was so obviously fake and ridiculously easy to fact check. Those carrying the story didn't verify it - and as a result several hundred criminal acts were commited culminating in a man turning up and firing three shots from an assault rifle in a restaurant. These are so called news outlets, they should be held accountable for their content. Not just them, but other news media. They have a responsibility to the public. Edited by jamiemartin721 (19 Sep 2017 10.09am)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Not really what I was trying to get at. My issue isn't with the troll, but with the 'alt-right news media' that picked up the story and ran with it. Its them I hold responsible, for publicising an obviously fake story as true, without doing any fact checking. They're the ones who essentially 'shouted fire' in a theatre, and could very well have ended up getting people killed. If my car manufacturer lies about my car, then its not free speech, its a class action law suit and possible criminal charges. And let be honest - This story was so obviously fake and ridiculously easy to fact check. Those carrying the story didn't verify it - and as a result several hundred criminal acts were commited culminating in a man turning up and firing three shots from an assault rifle in a restaurant. These are so called news outlets, they should be held accountable for their content. Not just them, but other news media. They have a responsibility to the public. Edited by jamiemartin721 (19 Sep 2017 10.09am) Car manufacturing where your car has to fit factual statistics is an ill fitting comparison to news and interpretation......0 to 60 in so and so seconds isn't 'this is how you should think' is it. You aren't really addressing the problems inherent in tackling this stuff though are you? .....the problems of bias and who watches the watcher. It's all very well complaining about what you don't like about the alt-right media with its distortions and bias I could easily say about the Emmys last night.....I get annoyed by Newsnight and loads of political commentary.....Your fake news is someone's else's worldview.....Facts form one part of reality...how you interpret those facts is another part. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Sep 2017 10.59am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
America probably have the best system on free speech in the world.....But freedom has its price. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Sep 2017 7.24am) Ideologically, I'd agree, but in practicality its a system that has effectively led to the idea that opinion and belief have the same merit as factually demonstrated and evidenced arguments - and provided a forum by which law abiding Americans are demonised and the idea of value of being right and debate is undermined - and the power of speech belongs to those who have the financial capacity to broadcast. I totally believe in the idea of the free speech of individuals - I'm not sure that we should extend that to media outlets and similar businesses - where there should be a responsibility to the consumer relating to the value and integrity of the product. Problem of free speech, like any other ideal, is people - both sides - who effectively want to just shout out the otherside, rather than engage in debate. Tragic really. All its served is to lend value to opinions, and undermine reasoned debate.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You aren't really addressing the problems inherent in tackling this stuff though are you .....the problems of bias and who watches the watcher. Car manufacturing where your car has to fit factual statistics is an ill fitting comparison to news and interpretation......0 to 60 in so and so seconds isn't 'this is how you should think' is it. What you don't like about the alt-right media with its distortions and bias I could easily say about the Emmys last night. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Sep 2017 10.53am) If you're broadcasting lies and deceit, as truth, you are telling people what to think. That's the danger of 'fake news'; its removing from the individual the capacity to make a choice based on the evidence. I don't think the news can ever be free of some bias. But there is a difference between bias, and deceit; and that's journalistic integrity. But there is a difference between The Times (right wing bias) and Fake News. And you can enforce that, by making outlets accountable for researching their stories and fact checking them. This isn't a new idea, its a cornerstone of journalism. You can't slander someone or libel them, so why should you be able to demonise them as pedophile death cult without being accountable for the consequences
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Ideologically, I'd agree, but in practicality its a system that has effectively led to the idea that opinion and belief have the same merit as factually demonstrated and evidenced arguments - and provided a forum by which law abiding Americans are demonised and the idea of value of being right and debate is undermined - and the power of speech belongs to those who have the financial capacity to broadcast. I totally believe in the idea of the free speech of individuals - I'm not sure that we should extend that to media outlets and similar businesses - where there should be a responsibility to the consumer relating to the value and integrity of the product. Problem of free speech, like any other ideal, is people - both sides - who effectively want to just shout out the otherside, rather than engage in debate. Tragic really. All its served is to lend value to opinions, and undermine reasoned debate. Sure, you highlight real problems here....I'm just not sure how much this concerned you before Trump. This has been going on....especially in the US for decades. This is what happens when news loses objectivity and becomes politically biased. There are only two solutions....remove bias from reporting....which is nearly impossible or have a competing news outlet with the same level of funding. The US has this, we do not.....I use to think we were in the better position.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
You can't slander someone or libel them, so why should you be able to demonise them as pedophile death cult without being accountable for the consequences Pizza gate was there certainly....the law courts are open if so desired. There were plenty of fake news stories about Trump as well of course. Click bait is the new unethical money spinner......If action is to be taken on this stuff.....then I think it has to be very carefully done. However, what I've seen, in terms of censorship, from Google, Twitter and Facebook is not good at all. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Sep 2017 11.14am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Sure, you highlight real problems here....I'm just not sure how much this concerned you before Trump. This has been going on....especially in the US for decades. This is what happens when news loses objectivity and becomes politically biased. There are only two solutions....remove bias from reporting....which is nearly impossible or have a competing news outlet with the same level of funding. The US has this, we do not.....I use to think we were in the better position. This is what happens when you have self regulation in industries, rather than an independent regulatory body; you end up with systems that serve agendas. If the news is a commodity, then its covered by trading standards (and selling something that's not fit for purpose breaks that standard) and if its the fourth estate, who are a body that effectively named in the constitution as being necessary for a free democracy, then it has to be regulated. We do that here, better than the states, through a regulatory body, and when the press crosses lines, its held accountable for doing so (admittedly not well). I'm not sure the US has better news media, as a result of competition either. Competition creates choice of outlet, but it doesn't ensure the quality of the product is better, only that its tailored to demographics of consumers. I might not agree with the slant of the Times or the Telegraph, but I can't fault them for their journalism - They separate their political bias from political parties. Left wing bias and right wing bias in the UK hasn't stopped news outlets going after political parties either. Bias isn't the problem - Its the degree of bias that's the problem - Fox News, CNN etc have an agenda, not a bias.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
This is what happens when you have self regulation in industries, rather than an independent regulatory body; you end up with systems that serve agendas. If the news is a commodity, then its covered by trading standards (and selling something that's not fit for purpose breaks that standard) and if its the fourth estate, who are a body that effectively named in the constitution as being necessary for a free democracy, then it has to be regulated. We do that here, better than the states, through a regulatory body, and when the press crosses lines, its held accountable for doing so (admittedly not well). I'm not sure the US has better news media, as a result of competition either. Competition creates choice of outlet, but it doesn't ensure the quality of the product is better, only that its tailored to demographics of consumers. I might not agree with the slant of the Times or the Telegraph, but I can't fault them for their journalism - They separate their political bias from political parties. Left wing bias and right wing bias in the UK hasn't stopped news outlets going after political parties either. Bias isn't the problem - Its the degree of bias that's the problem - Fox News, CNN etc have an agenda, not a bias.
And before we get dragged down a rabbit hole about suppressing free speech, this has nothing to do with that. The US - like everyone else - regulates the use of the public airways, and it was deemed a good idea not to allow people to use such to air agenda-fueled content. The deal was that you can say what you want in the pub, but you don't get to signal-boost it all over the country without being at least responsibly accurate.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Pizza gate was there certainly....the law courts are open if so desired. There were plenty of fake news stories about Trump as well of course. Click bait is the new unethical money spinner......If action is to be taken on this stuff.....then I think it has to be very carefully done. However, what I've seen, in terms of censorship, from Google, Twitter and Facebook is not good at all. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Sep 2017 11.14am) I don't think banning click bait is actually suppression of free speech, more like reasonable regulation of advertising and advertising standards. Its either news, or not. Sites like Infowars are not about 'free speech', they're the opposite of free speech. As I said earlier, if your lying, you're not contributing to free speech, you're telling people what to think. That is the real Orwellian nightmare. Not that you can't speak freely, but that your being indoctrinated into accepting lies and truth. Also, whilst we're at it, we should also regulate Social Media accordingly, and how free speech is applied and protected there.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Word is that Milo's "s***show" (the co-organiser's description, not mine) of an event at Berkeley is going to be cancelled. [Link] A number of the announced speakers had no idea they were being proposed for the event, others (like Bannon and Coulter) had never confirmed their appearance, and the organisers failed to provide the university with the necessary paperwork for it to block out space and provide security. Milo has been drip-feeding comments all week leading up to cancellation, which he is expected to announce tomorrow - blaming UC Berkeley for the whole mess in the process.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I don't think banning click bait is actually suppression of free speech, more like reasonable regulation of advertising and advertising standards. Its either news, or not. Sites like Infowars are not about 'free speech', they're the opposite of free speech. As I said earlier, if your lying, you're not contributing to free speech, you're telling people what to think. That is the real Orwellian nightmare. Not that you can't speak freely, but that your being indoctrinated into accepting lies and truth. Also, whilst we're at it, we should also regulate Social Media accordingly, and how free speech is applied and protected there. Click bait is bad.....click bait journalism is mostly lying it's true....I suppose I just suspicious of this reality being used as cover for censoring 'views we don't like'. I think an example of this is found in your attitude to 'info wars'. I don't agree that it's quite the same thing. Some of the things Alex Jones has said are awful....like saying Sandy Hook wasn't what it so clearly was. However, much of what he spins does come under right wing republicanism. And that the danger of the recent moves in my view. While I don't watch Jones, I quite like some of Paul Joseph Watson's stuff and he comes under 'info wars' so this also troubles me. I don't agree with you saying that their speech isn't free speech or indeed that Watson is a liar if you imply that. What he does is push a confrontational conservative worldview. I am concerned about who decides who is lying? You still haven't dealt with this problem in your replies. Who watches the watcher? Who decides what is a worldview and what are lies. This is why America's position in relation to free speech is so much more superior to ours.....But I would support some careful action on click bait. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2017 6.25pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Word is that Milo's "s***show" (the co-organiser's description, not mine) of an event at Berkeley is going to be cancelled. [Link] A number of the announced speakers had no idea they were being proposed for the event, others (like Bannon and Coulter) had never confirmed their appearance, and the organisers failed to provide the university with the necessary paperwork for it to block out space and provide security. Milo has been drip-feeding comments all week leading up to cancellation, which he is expected to announce tomorrow - blaming UC Berkeley for the whole mess in the process. What an amazingly one eyed way of viewing the suppression of free speech as a positive. Berkeley are totally responsible for the political mess they have created within their university. Their reputation for free speech is in tatters and they had to spend 600, 000 dollars on security the other week just to stop their own students from stopping Shapiro's speech. If Berkeley cancel this speech they will deserve the continued hits to their reputation as little more than a 'progressive' institution that's partly funded by tax payers......The majority of whom don't agree with their student's politics of rioting and shutting down free speech. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2017 6.32pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What an amazingly one eyed way of viewing the suppression of free speech as a positive. Berkeley are totally responsible for the political mess they have created within their university. Their reputation for free speech is in tatters and they had to spend 600, 000 dollars on security the other week just to stop their own students from stopping Shapiro's speech. If Berkeley cancel this speech they will deserve the continued hits to their reputation as little more than a 'progressive' institution that's partly funded by tax payers......The majority of whom don't agree with their student's politics of rioting and shutting down free speech. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2017 6.32pm) The organisers didn't have the necessary paperwork. Doesn't sound like Berkeley's fault. Still if those right wing nutnobs can't get the paperwork right at least it doesn't give them the chance to spread their quasi racist devisive shock jock drivel to those that think others are less superior.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What an amazingly one eyed way of viewing the suppression of free speech as a positive. Berkeley are totally responsible for the political mess they have created within their university. Their reputation for free speech is in tatters and they had to spend 600, 000 dollars on security the other week just to stop their own students from stopping Shapiro's speech. If Berkeley cancel this speech they will deserve the continued hits to their reputation as little more than a 'progressive' institution that's partly funded by tax payers......The majority of whom don't agree with their student's politics of rioting and shutting down free speech. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2017 6.32pm) Just out of curiosity how did you feel back in the 80's, or now even looking back, the Thatcher's administration's decision to gag Sein Fein in public and make it illegal for their voices to be heard?
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
What an amazingly one eyed way of viewing the suppression of free speech as a positive. Berkeley are totally responsible for the political mess they have created within their university. Their reputation for free speech is in tatters and they had to spend 600, 000 dollars on security the other week just to stop their own students from stopping Shapiro's speech. If Berkeley cancel this speech they will deserve the continued hits to their reputation as little more than a 'progressive' institution that's partly funded by tax payers......The majority of whom don't agree with their student's politics of rioting and shutting down free speech.
How is all of that s*** the fault of the venue?
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
How is all of that s*** the fault of the venue? It's the fault of the venue because it's their responsibility.....as a partly publicly funded body to be able to stage free speech events. The trouble makers are their students. It's their politically minded tuition that has created this and as far as I see it's an example of the 'revolution eating itself'. If they cancel this event....It would be one of many they have cancelled and they again will be fully deserving of the huge amount of criticism they have received and personally I look forward to them losing their public funding.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
Just out of curiosity how did you feel back in the 80's, or now even looking back, the Thatcher's administration's decision to gag Sein Fein in public and make it illegal for their voices to be heard? If someone is supporting the murder of your own country's soldiers it probably is reasonable to censor their propaganda on nationally broadcast TV stations. What that has to do with a free speech rally organized by the republican body at Berkeley....You may not like Milo but he isn't supporting the murder of anybody......This rally is not being broadcast nationally and with only those present who have paid to be there I don't know.....Put your crowbar comparisons back in the shed Kermy. Sein Fein were supporting the murder of British soldiers. I have never supported terrorist organisations....the difference between Sinn Fein and the IRA was purely in the title....This only changed a little late on. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2017 7.23pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's the fault of the venue because it's their responsibility.....as a partly publicly funded body to be able to stage free speech events. The trouble makers are their students. It's their politically minded tuition that has created this and as far as I see it's an example of the 'revolution eating itself'. If they cancel this event....It would be one of many they have cancelled and they again will be fully deserving of the huge amount of criticism they have received and personally I look forward to them losing their public funding. Berkeley isn't cancelling the event, Milo is. I'm sure the 4 - four, total - speakers he had confirmed will be disappointed. You seem to have a giant bee in your bonnet about education establishments oppressing free speech - I believe this is the 4th or 5th thread you've started on the subject in the space of about a week. To a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Berkeley isn't cancelling the event, Milo is. I'm sure the 4 - four, total - speakers he had confirmed will be disappointed. You seem to have a giant bee in your bonnet about education establishments oppressing free speech - I believe this is the 4th or 5th thread you've started on the subject in the space of about a week. To a hammer, everything looks like a nail. Well, Berkeley shut down Milo in February. Where do you get your information that Milo has cancelled this event?....I'm not sure what the significance of the number of speakers is. Posters currently up on Berkeley campus. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Sep 2017 8.18pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.