This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
A thread to itself - that challenge on De Bruyne
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
jeeagles 01 Jan 18 12.34pm |
|
|
It wasn't that bad of a challenge and after city's disgusting behaviour before the penalty who cares if we injured them.
|
Glazier#1 01 Jan 18 12.35pm |
|
|
|
Glazier#1 01 Jan 18 12.39pm |
|
|
Oh. Ok.
By deploring what you deplore when it's done to one of ours, I'm a Citeh supporter?
Couldn't make it up.
One-eyed. Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Zaha is fouled like that in almost every match. The commentators often refer to it as necessary or taking one for the team. I don't like cynical tackles and that's what Punch's tackle was. However, the OP sounds more like a Man City supporter with their massive over reaction. Save your breath for when our players (regularly) receive the rough treatment. Man City have enough support.
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 01 Jan 18 12.42pm |
|
Originally posted by boo909
There was no real violent intent in it, it was just an awful tackle made in a panic, by a player who's u nfortunately really off his game these days, probably deserved a red even though the ref didn't think so.
And it doesn't help your case coming across as patronising and superior either, have a little respect for posters who have a differing viewpoint to your own.
Edited by boo909 (01 Jan 2018 11.06am)
Have to say I agree with the comments ive put in bold Could easily have got a straight red, and the silly thwat injured himself too [Link]
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
Aray South London 01 Jan 18 12.44pm |
|
|
We've found a new Willo
|
Mapletree Croydon 01 Jan 18 12.56pm |
|
|
Originally posted by Glazier#1 Not miss=timed. Perfectly - timed.
And knee - high.
Agree with this, no doubt
He wanted to stop De Bruyne and succeeded. As De Bruyne was the most dangerous person on that break it made sense. Went high so he wouldn't get jumped over.
I don't think he aimed to hurt De Bruyne and it turned out he didn't hurt him badly. But did deserve a Red Card and I reckon Punch probably expected that.
So it was the right thing to do but maybe not carried out quite clinically enough to avoid danger to both parties.
|
Glazier#1 01 Jan 18 1.02pm |
|
|
Yes.
Originally posted by Mapletree
Originally posted by Glazier#1 Not miss=timed. Perfectly - timed.
And knee - high.
Agree with this, no doubt
He wanted to stop De Bruyne and succeeded. As De Bruyne was the most dangerous person on that break it made sense. Went high so he wouldn't get jumped over.
I don't think he aimed to hurt De Bruyne and it turned out he didn't hurt him badly. But did deserve a Red Card and I reckon Punch probably expected that.
So it was the right thing to do but maybe not carried out quite clinically enough to avoid danger to both parties.
|
YT Oxford 01 Jan 18 1.03pm |
|
|
Good grief; what a to-do! It was a foul. It got punished. It happens. Get over it.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
Glazier#1 01 Jan 18 1.04pm |
|
|
Oh. have 'we'?
And who might 'We' be?
|
boo909 Figeac 01 Jan 18 1.08pm |
|
|
I think we are in danger of letting this small incident overshadow the fact that it was a fantastic game of football, the most thrilling 0-0 draw I can remember seeing and all our players, including JP should be extremely proud of themselves.
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|
Glazier#1 01 Jan 18 1.09pm |
|
|
Ok, ok. I've expressed my point of view and so have many others Originally posted by YT
To conclude, all I'll say is that it was more than just 'a foul' and should have been 'punished' with a red card and long ban.
I accept that some on here have made some points that they've backed up but, as usual, there are others who are alright living with double standards. If others do it to us, it's the biggest crime in history, bodily assault. If we dish it out? Part of the game - stop whingeing.
That'll be football for you.
Happy new year.
Good grief; what a to-do! It was a foul. It got punished. It happens. Get over it.
|
Charlie Croker Hampshire 01 Jan 18 1.12pm |
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Have to say I agree with the comments ive put in bold Could easily have got a straight red, and the silly thwat injured himself too [Link]
Didn't see it in real time as I was still griping about the penalty miss. Saw it on Sky Sports later and agree that it could easily have been a red.
There's a lot of decisions that have been made recently that show the lack of consistency in refereeing - the Pogba, Kane and Alli challenges are the ones that spring to mind that got dealt with differently.
Also agree with the OP that there would be a massive reaction on here had it been KDB or someone else on WZ or Andros.
Edited by Charlie Croker (01 Jan 2018 1.13pm)
“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."
|
chateauferret 01 Jan 18 1.15pm |
|
|
Physioroom says de Bruyne has a "knee injury" with no return date but "major doubt" rather than "No" availability. Puncheon has a "knock". Dann has a "knee injury" with a prognosis of "f*** knows".
============ The Ferret ============
|
matthau South Croydon 01 Jan 18 1.19pm |
|
Originally posted by Glazier#1
What? a knee-high scythe with violent intent. No worse than we see are used to seeing?
If that is what we are accepting as run-of-the-mill violence then things have arrived at a bad state for the game.
No, the tackle was extraordinary in it's execution and intent.
Bet you hated football twenty years back when the tackles were flying everywhere
|
bicycle repair man 01 Jan 18 1.26pm |
|
|
We've recently seen Kane and Ali commit potentially career ending fouls but that was swiftly brushed under the carpet. But now people want Punch hung,drawn & quartered for what at worst was a reckless forwards challenge.
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 01 Jan 18 1.34pm |
|
Originally posted by bicycle repair man
We've recently seen Kane and Ali commit potentially career ending fouls but that was swiftly brushed under the carpet. But now people want Punch hung,drawn & quartered for what at worst was a reckless forwards challenge.
All should of received red cards for those challenges.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
westquay 58 miles from se25 01 Jan 18 1.45pm |
|
|
Yeh Deffo a pwaper nawty tackle from JP but lets be honest, when football was football then Billy Gilbert at Palace, Norman Hunter at Leeds and Ron Harris at some other little club would have only played two games a season in this day and age........ On another level... Punch just doesn't look right in his face (if you get what I mean)... Just looks like a troubled man in my opinion.... Maybe some counselling or help may sort his issues ..... A once (again my opinion) a pretty fair player who basically has just lost the plot...... I still rate the guy but he seems to have some serious issues that need sorting..... Its the premier league where bodily injuries are sorted by top proffesionals but mental health seems to be neglected...... Message to PUNCH....Happy New Year .... Hope you sort things and thanks for giving me something to cheer about at Wembley...... People have short memories...
"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel." "Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer" Martin Scorcese, Film director.
|
crystal-purley Purley 01 Jan 18 1.46pm |
|
|
I only saw it in real time but to that I would add the many "challenges" made by Walker on Wilf and the assault on Benteke which saw him hit the hoardings. There were many fouls not given by Moss such as the shove on Wilf and despite all of this it was a good game, if Punch is punished for this other than the yellow card then football continues it's dive into total corruption.
Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 01 Jan 18 1.51pm |
|
|
It was a s*** challenge, but if there was any malice, Punch would have taken his belt off.
I thought we'd get thumped yesterday so consoled myself with the fact I'd be watching some of the best players in the world. De Bruyne is one of them. A sublime footballer and one of my favourite non palace players.
Am I not allowed to appreciate players from other teams.
|
Qwijibo Bournemouth 01 Jan 18 1.51pm |
|
|
I'm not sure the ref saw it properly, hence the yellow. Conveniently means he won't get further punishment. It was so late I didn't see it until the replay as the play had moved on so much. I suspect the ref may have also been looking elsewhere.
At best the tackle can possibly be attributed to a lack of match-sharpness, but having just seen he was facing the wrong way during the penalty, the whole incident does seem bizarre. He'll escape a ban but that's irrelevant as he's confirmed he's not up to a first team place at present.
Secretly I do love a filthy tackle
|