This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Obviously I being tongue in cheek there.....however, around about 30 percent of English or WASP DNA is germanic....with the rest being what I've mentioned previously. However, this is England.....and if the English aren't running it....then it is no longer England....and by proxy Scots running Scotland and so on. I speculate that your concern over 'anglo saxons' is probably part of the over arching problem. Which English? The Anglo Saxons displaced in a wholesale fashion by the Normans? I don't want any single ethnicity running the country, even if you could work out who is what. But if it were one ethnicity it would involve largely red headed people in my opinion. Depends how far back you choose to go. Wouldn't want those Jonny Come Lately Frenchies from post 1066.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Which English? The Anglo Saxons displaced in a wholesale fashion by the Normans? I don't want any single ethnicity running the country, even if you could work out who is what. But if it were one ethnicity it would involve largely red headed people in my opinion. Depends how far back you choose to go. Wouldn't want those Jonny Come Lately Frenchies from post 1066. No, the genetics have been done and tested for WASPs in England.....Germanic DNA is far higher at 30 percent than French DNA is....in fact it's the highest....so the term 'anglo saxon' is reasonable enough. You seem to be ignoring what I'm saying. The English are not a single genetic line. The English are those who subscribe to being English and have lived here for generations. I've made that plain. If you disagree with the notion that the English should be in control of England then we are at odds.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
He killed an estimated 600,000 out of a population of around 1.400,000......Most of them civilians, lots of women and children. Cromwell was well known for hating catholics. Now I agree that we need to be careful in judging past history by today's standards.....for example, Alexander is lauded by many but he also was known for butchering every inhabitant of a town or city if its leaders had opposed him.....But that doesn't mean that I have to regard Cromwell in a favourable light.....just a nuanced one. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Nov 2018 6.39am) For the actions of Cromwell in Ireland there is a book by Niall Ferguson and a TV series. Think it was called Cromwell: God's Executioner. Historian is Irish and he tries to put Cromwell's actions into context.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
My favourite Cromwell moment is his trial and execution after being dug up from his grave. I hope you all have a favourite Cromwell moment too. just like any real King, after he croaked Oliver Cromwell wanted his son to continue in the family business. Richard became the second Lord Protector. Richard Cromwell lasted 5 minutes in the job. Known as 'tumbledown dick or Queen dick' Edited by PalazioVecchio (26 Nov 2018 9.17pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No, the genetics have been done and tested for WASPs in England.....Germanic DNA is far higher at 30 percent than French DNA is....in fact it's the highest....so the term 'anglo saxon' is reasonable enough. You seem to be ignoring what I'm saying. The English are not a single genetic line. The English are those who subscribe to being English and have lived here for generations. I've made that plain. If you disagree with the notion that the English should be in control of England then we are at odds. My grandparents are Irish. Does that mean I’m not English?
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
My grandparents are Irish. Does that mean I’m not English? No. You're Welsh.
|
|
| steve1984 26 Nov 18 11.01pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Having a statue of Cromwell at Westminster is about as offensive to irish people as the Statue of Bomber Harris is to any people from Dresden. That might be a more worthwhile comparison if after bombing the place to bits we'd then annexed Saxony and moved in a load of Scottish people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No, the genetics have been done and tested for WASPs in England.....Germanic DNA is far higher at 30 percent than French DNA is....in fact it's the highest....so the term 'anglo saxon' is reasonable enough. You seem to be ignoring what I'm saying. The English are not a single genetic line. The English are those who subscribe to being English and have lived here for generations. I've made that plain. If you disagree with the notion that the English should be in control of England then we are at odds. You did remember to add in the Viking DNA for the Normans I suppose. The English are not Anglo Saxon so why do you say that term is reasonable enough. Some of the most English people I know have recent progenitors from overseas. No, I don’t subscribe to your lived here for generations point. In fact it makes me deeply uncomfortable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
You did remember to add in the Viking DNA for the Normans I suppose. The English are not Anglo Saxon so why do you say that term is reasonable enough. Some of the most English people I know have recent progenitors from overseas. No, I don’t subscribe to your lived here for generations point. In fact it makes me deeply uncomfortable. You'll get over it. What I won't tolerate is being told what I should think about being British by people who have been here for one or two generations.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
My grandparents are Irish. Does that mean I’m not English? You can get the EU passport...
We'll never die |
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
My grandparents are Irish. Does that mean I’m not English? No...You've read the comments and this is your level of understanding?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
You did remember to add in the Viking DNA for the Normans I suppose. I've already told you those genes are not anywhere near as high a percentage in WASPs as Germanic ones....Yet you type that. Look it up....I did. Originally posted by Mapletree
The English are not Anglo Saxon so why do you say that term is reasonable enough. Because it's a collective term.....for feck's sake!....haven't you heard of 'anglosphere'? Even the Americans recognise the 'anglo saxon' influence and they haven't had that for two centuries. Just like English is a group term for what makes up the English. Originally posted by Mapletree
Some of the most English people I know have recent progenitors from overseas. No, I don’t subscribe to your lived here for generations point. In fact it makes me deeply uncomfortable. Oh be very certain that your attitude does more than that for me. Your attitude is in the majority within a certain demographic in the country and has been screwing this country for decades. My attitude is no different to the attitude of many within countries around the world.....Japan, Poland, Hungary and others. Your attitude sees the English effectively being wiped out and replaced......and people like you will probably just shrug your shoulders....that's for you but no thanks. I'm a nationalist. I'm pro the English being the main culture within England. I believe that all nations have a right to define themselves. I completely reject the internationalist mindset.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
No...You've read the comments and this is your level of understanding? Yep. Any my family haven’t been here centuries, not even one in fact, so can we be considered English in your Blighty utopia? What about my best mate whose dad was born in St Lucia? It’s almost like your logic is deeply flawed.
|
|
|
F*cked it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Yep. Any my family haven’t been here centuries, not even one in fact, so can we be considered English in your Blighty utopia? What about my best mate whose dad was born in St Lucia? It’s almost like your logic is deeply flawed.
Do you have an allegiance, an attachment to England? Do you have an preference for English culture?....Not a dislike of other cultures and people but just a preference for the one you were brought up in. Do you have an appreciation and regard for most of its history. A love of its language and achievements? Some of its rituals perhaps. Do you see yourself as English?.....Not Irish (even though that would be fine) or some kind of global based culturally mixed rootless mongrel? Right the answer to that determines more than any other aspect whether I regard you as English or not.....If your answer is no....then fine....that doesn't make you a terrible person as such...it just makes you an internationalist. The point I made about generations being important is because without that it's less likely that you have enough 'English' skin in the game to feel that way.....but only less likely. I don't exclude someone coming from elsewhere and being genuine in wanting to be English...Definitely if they are second generation and brought up here...This is usually easier if those countries are culturally similar to this one but regardless.....If someone has a genuine allegiance to English culture....I'd probably regard them as English. Indeed most of us have family from within the British islands, Irish family or European family. This does not disclude someone from being English. The most important aspect is a genuine allegiance and that is much more often than not from how they were brought up. Do you understand now?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Do you have an allegiance, an attachment to England? Do you have an preference for English culture?....Not a dislike of other cultures and people but just a preference for the one you were brought up in. Do you have an appreciation and regard for most of its history. A love of its language and achievements? Some of its rituals perhaps. Do you see yourself as English?.....Not Irish (even though that would be fine) or some kind of global based culturally mixed rootless mongrel? Right the answer to that determines more than any other aspect whether I regard you as English or not.....If your answer is no....then fine....that doesn't make you a terrible person as such...it just makes you an internationalist. The point I made about generations being important is because without that it's less likely that you have enough 'English' skin in the game to feel that way.....but only less likely. I don't exclude someone coming from elsewhere and being genuine in wanting to be English...Definitely if they are second generation and brought up here...This is usually easier if those countries are culturally similar to this one but regardless.....If someone has a genuine allegiance to English culture....I'd probably regard them as English. Indeed most of us have family from within the British islands, Irish family or European family. This does not disclude someone from being English. The most important aspect is a genuine allegiance and that is much more often than not from how they were brought up. Do you understand now?
I think that’s all fair enough, just probably applies to a lot more people living in this country then you probably think.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Do you have an allegiance, an attachment to England? Do you have an preference for English culture?....Not a dislike of other cultures and people but just a preference for the one you were brought up in. Do you have an appreciation and regard for most of its history. A love of its language and achievements? Some of its rituals perhaps. Do you see yourself as English?.....Not Irish (even though that would be fine) or some kind of global based culturally mixed rootless mongrel? Right the answer to that determines more than any other aspect whether I regard you as English or not.....If your answer is no....then fine....that doesn't make you a terrible person as such...it just makes you an internationalist. The point I made about generations being important is because without that it's less likely that you have enough 'English' skin in the game to feel that way.....but only less likely. I don't exclude someone coming from elsewhere and being genuine in wanting to be English...Definitely if they are second generation and brought up here...This is usually easier if those countries are culturally similar to this one but regardless.....If someone has a genuine allegiance to English culture....I'd probably regard them as English. Indeed most of us have family from within the British islands, Irish family or European family. This does not disclude someone from being English. The most important aspect is a genuine allegiance and that is much more often than not from how they were brought up. Do you understand now?
'' The English are those who subscribe to being English and have lived here for generations.'' There seems to be a change in tone here You have completely missed the point about culture. Our culture is more influenced by the Normans, who largely were Viking, than by Anglo Saxons. It seems you struggled with my point. The mix isn't pure, it's a mix of a mix. But the main point is that the culture in England has little influence left from the Anglo Saxons, the main culture drivers from whom moved North and West to get away from the Normans. Following in the footsteps of a similar exodus by the Celts I believe. Presumably the majority didn't move, but the best educated tended to and the culture moved on with the incomers. So in reality our culture was historically dominated by the Normans who were heavily influenced, culturally and genetically, by the Vikings. So why don't you simply say it as it is and state we should all get back to being Scandinavian
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
my family haven’t been here centuries, not even one in fact, so can we be considered English in your Blighty utopia? What about my best mate whose dad was born in St Lucia? Norman Tebbit said back in 1990 that you could tell a person's allegiance by the cricket team they supported
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Norman Tebbit said back in 1990 that you could tell a person's allegiance by the cricket team they supported Still accurate today.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
'' The English are those who subscribe to being English and have lived here for generations.'' There seems to be a change in tone here No there isn't....you just went and ran with your own understanding based upon that one sentence. You needed clarification and I provided it. Originally posted by Mapletree
You have completely missed the point about culture. Our culture is more influenced by the Normans, who largely were Viking, than by Anglo Saxons. It seems you struggled with my point. The mix isn't pure, it's a mix of a mix. But the main point is that the culture in England has little influence left from the Anglo Saxons, the main culture drivers from whom moved North and West to get away from the Normans. Following in the footsteps of a similar exodus by the Celts I believe. Presumably the majority didn't move, but the best educated tended to and the culture moved on with the incomers. So in reality our culture was historically dominated by the Normans who were heavily influenced, culturally and genetically, by the Vikings. So why don't you simply say it as it is and state we should all get back to being Scandinavian So what you are saying here.....from what I understand is that the traditional British culture is heavily influenced by Normans. I agree there is influence but it's not as dominant as anglo saxon. Norman culture was restricted mostly to the aristocracy and the landed class because there wasn't an overwhelming influx from Normandy following 1066. That's why the genes on this island are majority anglo saxon and not Norman. The Normans themselves were actually originally Norsemen (or Vikings). Culture itself is influenced by genes....but that's another story and probably a little controversial for you. Edited by Stirlingsays (27 Nov 2018 11.45am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.