You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why Can't We Score?
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why Can't We Score?


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
trapperjohn Flag Horsham 11 Feb 19 8.16am

I feel sorry for anyone playing centre forward in the current regime because so often the ball just doesn’t come, or when it does the entire defence is back and settled.

The big difference between first and second half Saturday was that in the first the build up was so pedestrian. Endless triangles between Sakho, Schlupp and PVA (when he wasn’t just giving the ball away), or Wilf getting the ball and immediately slowing down to allow second defender to close him down. Alternatively AWB to Andros; to AWM to MacArthur (when he wasn’t giving the ball away).

All this time Benteke is trying to get into position for something. From the upper tier you can see him getting on the defender’s shoulder (same with Ayew in previous games) for a ball into the channel which never comes. Well twice it did earlier in the season when Luka seriously over hit one and MacArthur knocked the other one at least ten metres wide of where it was needed.

That along with our dreadful corners and the crosses which bounce first on the far 18 yard line and second bounce out of play sum up that the delivery to the forwards is shocking. I have great hopes for Batshuayi but I fear that he too won’t get the service.

Oh and it would probably help if someone, anyone could get into the box and give some support so the defence cannot all concentrate on the one guy who is in there. During the pedestrian buildup they have plenty of time to get in there

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

Johng Flag 11 Feb 19 8.42am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

We do seem poor on decision making. Yesterday there were several examples:

Macca shot should go across keeper.

Benteke didn’t need to take a touch before his shot - all that did was narrow the angle & give the keeper time to set himself.

Macca’s ‘big miss’ should’ve been a simple pass to PVA or Benteke.

There were several times where the ball came in low with Benteke the only target or up high when he wasn’t there. A quick look up could solve this though.

We rarely hit first time crosses either which allows defenders to sort themselves out rather than be heading towards their own goal when it comes in. Pape used to supply a few & even Ward too - perhaps AWB could swing em in rather than looking for Andros?

It’s frustrating that we can be so clinical against City, Spurs or Liverpool yet profligate against those teams around us.

Edited by Nobbybm (10 Feb 2019 11.23pm)

This.

It's a real shame Pape needed another op recently 'cos he'd be banging on the door to start instead of PVA.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Feb 19 9.04am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Where have you got this interpretation from? Read the post again and engage your brain.

Of course they're training, my question is whether the training is appropriate and working.

As you've identified that we have strikers who are proven goalscorers, who aren't scoring despite the amount of chances created it seems incredible that you haven't drawn the same conclusion as the logic necessarily follows.

You did not question the training. You made a statement.

Your words were '' The players lack confidence in front of goal because their training isn't up to scratch ''.

Perhaps you should read your own post again - with brain engaged of course.

I have to assume that you are privy to their training methods and are quite rightly calling Hodgson and Lewington out for their lack of attention to detail when it comes to finishing the many chances our play creates.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

gbox82 Flag Meols, Wirral 11 Feb 19 9.31am

Originally posted by Mwncisee

Here's another way to look at it.

How many past seasons have we seen us have quite a lot of deficiencies and we hope we can graft enough or be lucky enough to get away with it and stay up?

Now we play good decent football, exciting to see us on the attack and the only deficiency is putting it in the back of the net.

For so long we couldn't create chances and now we tend to create a lot especially against those teams around us.

I believe it will come and will be the final piece clicking into place. Maybe Michy will be that piece and when it does click think how prolific we could be!

Totally agree with this. If we think back to when we stayed up under Pulis (and Allardyce) we did it by being dead tight at the back, not losing much and winning by the odd goal here and there - creating very few chances in the process.

Personally I think it's only a matter of time before it all clicks, we have a relatively settled team. Just needs the right formula/tactics in the final third (and maybe a tiny bit of luck!)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Feb 19 9.41am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

McArthur used to score some vital goals. Now he narrowly misses. What is he doing wrong? It’s happening every game.

It's the footballing equivalent of writer's block.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Feb 19 9.49am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You did not question the training. You made a statement.

Your words were '' The players lack confidence in front of goal because their training isn't up to scratch ''.

Perhaps you should read your own post again - with brain engaged of course.

I have to assume that you are privy to their training methods and are quite rightly calling Hodgson and Lewington out for their lack of attention to detail when it comes to finishing the many chances our play creates.

I agree there is nothing wrong with the training, we are playing some of the best football, since being in the Premier. We are not a push over for any team. The defence is sound apart from the occasional aberration from PVA, midfield covers a lot of ground, but could be a bit more creative. We are creating loads of chances up front, it’s only a matter of time before it clicks, people can complain when we are creating chances. Benteke is a good striker with ability, as his over head kick against Fulham showed, just not getting the rub of the green.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 11 Feb 19 10.45am

We sure create chances and are not that shot shy. I am sure the attacker pratcice scoring goals it is their trade. You saw how much it mean't to tekers when he missed he smashed his fist in to the pitch in utter fruastrtion as to the lad wickham look how much it mean't to him. Bats we shall see but I would expect the same reaction to scoring/missing it is their trade. Now Roy knows to win matches you have to make chances, which his team/our team are doing. If he could fathom why strikers miss he would surly fix it. But football isn't like that is it. Its chaos and its the chaos we love. look on the bright side we're still in it and fighting what more can expect.

Any insults regarding my opinion'engadging brian etc please reffer to bin

Edited by johnmcormick8 (11 Feb 2019 10.47am)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 11 Feb 19 11.04am

how many xtg for Sakho at corners this season. anybody know?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 11 Feb 19 11.59am

Originally posted by NEILLO

You did not question the training. You made a statement.

Your words were '' The players lack confidence in front of goal because their training isn't up to scratch ''.

Perhaps you should read your own post again - with brain engaged of course.

I have to assume that you are privy to their training methods and are quite rightly calling Hodgson and Lewington out for their lack of attention to detail when it comes to finishing the many chances our play creates.


Top white knighting.

Well done for repeating exactly what I said, what's your point fella?

 

Dman Palace Flag Brixton 11 Feb 19 12.09pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Boils down to training methods, variety, frequency and duration.

In any trade the more you practice and the more engaged you are with the training the better you are at your job.

The players lack confidence in front of goal because their training isn't up to scratch.


You don't half spurt some twaddle and make bold statements instead of an opinion. What do you know about the training? Are you privy to the training sessions? Do you go down there and spy like a Leeds scout?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 19 12.12pm

Originally posted by Painter

I agree there is nothing wrong with the training, we are playing some of the best football, since being in the Premier. We are not a push over for any team. The defence is sound apart from the occasional aberration from PVA, midfield covers a lot of ground, but could be a bit more creative. We are creating loads of chances up front, it’s only a matter of time before it clicks, people can complain when we are creating chances. Benteke is a good striker with ability, as his over head kick against Fulham showed, just not getting the rub of the green.

Hitting the bar in a once in a lifetime overhead kick is great, but it won’t happen again. What happens over and over again is his poor control, taking the ball away from goal rather than keeping it under control and rolling towards goal. That is why he misses, as he did again. He ruins the angle he could’ve had.

He isn’t a good player at this level. A lot of the important stuff he did for us in his first season was with his head. Sunderland away and Everton away are perfect examples. Fact is we’re carrying him. He’s a waste of a selection. It’s better to have him on the pitch than not have him but that’s not a great endorsement.

 


COYP

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Feb 19 12.17pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Hitting the bar in a once in a lifetime overhead kick is great, but it won’t happen again. What happens over and over again is his poor control, taking the ball away from goal rather than keeping it under control and rolling towards goal. That is why he misses, as he did again. He ruins the angle he could’ve had.

He isn’t a good player at this level. A lot of the important stuff he did for us in his first season was with his head. Sunderland away and Everton away are perfect examples. Fact is we’re carrying him. He’s a waste of a selection. It’s better to have him on the pitch than not have him but that’s not a great endorsement.

There was a clip on Facebook's Palace page from a season or two ago that showed him and Wilf knocking the ball to each other in training. The amount of times it bounced off his shin or he couldn't direct it back accurately was shocking. If he can't do it in a simple knockabout he'll never do it on match day.

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 11 Feb 19 12.36pm

I guess that if you want to score, you need a striker that scores.
But ours (Benteke) doesn't anymore, why I don't know, the point is that he's so low in confidence, clumsy, slow that he seems a different person than the one we once knew.
So, if you play with him, as a target man with shoulders to the goal, then you need your wingers to score the goals he does not.
But we have Zaha, whose record season tally is 9 and it only happened once. The other is Townsend, and his best record is 6.
So, if wingers score little then you need central mids to score running in, the problem is that Luka scores, but almost all penalties, maybe he can score 3 per season from open play, McArthur's record is 4, and before anyone mention it, Mayer is 6 (in Bundesliga).

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 11 Feb 19 12.48pm

Majority of the posts here already highlight the root causes. But on top of them, i also think we don`t bite when opponent has the ball. This significantly reduce the chance to have the ball when opponent is somehow unsettled / non-ready and leave us with attacking when opponent is ready to face with us.

IMHO, worst game we had this year at home was against Chelsea that we even didn`t attempt to bite / put pressure at anytime and we nearly had no chances until we start putting pressure in last 10 min.

This will definitely provide more agility on attackers as they will be facing a defense who is confused or who tries to settle.

 

cpj Flag Kent 11 Feb 19 1.08pm

In 12 home games we've had 211 shots and scored just 6 goals in open play!

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 11 Feb 19 1.33pm

Originally posted by trapperjohn

I feel sorry for anyone playing centre forward in the current regime because so often the ball just doesn’t come, or when it does the entire defence is back and settled.

The big difference between first and second half Saturday was that in the first the build up was so pedestrian. Endless triangles between Sakho, Schlupp and PVA (when he wasn’t just giving the ball away), or Wilf getting the ball and immediately slowing down to allow second defender to close him down. Alternatively AWB to Andros; to AWM to MacArthur (when he wasn’t giving the ball away).

All this time Benteke is trying to get into position for something. From the upper tier you can see him getting on the defender’s shoulder (same with Ayew in previous games) for a ball into the channel which never comes. Well twice it did earlier in the season when Luka seriously over hit one and MacArthur knocked the other one at least ten metres wide of where it was needed.

That along with our dreadful corners and the crosses which bounce first on the far 18 yard line and second bounce out of play sum up that the delivery to the forwards is shocking. I have great hopes for Batshuayi but I fear that he too won’t get the service.

Oh and it would probably help if someone, anyone could get into the box and give some support so the defence cannot all concentrate on the one guy who is in there. During the pedestrian buildup they have plenty of time to get in there

We've had 211 shots in 12 home games scoring 6 goals. Creating is not our problem, finishing is. If we're not putting the ball on bentekes head on the 6 yard box, maybe he shoukd use his feet a bit more, or is that asking too much for a £30m pound player. Oh and he had a great ball in the chanel saturday and completely f****d it up...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Feb 19 1.49pm

Originally posted by blackheatheagle

Majority of the posts here already highlight the root causes. But on top of them, i also think we don`t bite when opponent has the ball. This significantly reduce the chance to have the ball when opponent is somehow unsettled / non-ready and leave us with attacking when opponent is ready to face with us.

IMHO, worst game we had this year at home was against Chelsea that we even didn`t attempt to bite / put pressure at anytime and we nearly had no chances until we start putting pressure in last 10 min.

This will definitely provide more agility on attackers as they will be facing a defense who is confused or who tries to settle.

Very good post. Villa were a counter attacking team that were excellent away from home and his goals came when the opposition defence were in disarray. Maybe why he was better with Pardew. Play was so open and end to end. Everyone spread around rather than the congested nature of our games now.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 11 Feb 19 2.00pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Very good post. Villa were a counter attacking team that were excellent away from home and his goals came when the opposition defence were in disarray. Maybe why he was better with Pardew. Play was so open and end to end. Everyone spread around rather than the congested nature of our games now.

So our £30m player will only score if our wingers cross early and put the ball right on his head. Or our oponents defenders are in 'disarray'. The guy has totally lost confidence and IMHO will never get it back while playing for palace. Needs to go to a new club in the summer.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 11 Feb 19 2.43pm

Originally posted by cpj

In 12 home games we've had 211 shots and scored just 6 goals in open play!

Ugh. Good grief.

Let that sink in.

We need players in the final third who are not afraid to take a shot and can get some joy.

Schlupp actually shows some of these qualities ironically.

Sadly most of the team look like rabbits in the headlights when they have a goal chance.

You wont see a worse miss than what you say yesterday from one of our midfielders.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

davidpercival Flag Croydon 11 Feb 19 3.19pm

What no one seems to have mentioned is that we have scored more away goals than any other team outside the top 6, so it is not that we can't score in general, just that we can't score at home. This could be just a statistical freak which should correct itself soon.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why Can't We Score?