You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What if Allardyce hadn't left?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What if Allardyce hadn't left?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Jun 19 7.56am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


do you complain to all the national newspapers after they write complete garbage like AWB wants to leave Palace or Zaha is unhappy at Palace even though there is not a jot of truth in what is said? No I didn’t think so.

I don't read the transfer speculation in the media but unfortunately I have to read the posts on here, even the defamatory garbage

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Jun 19 9.28am

Originally posted by Painter

Did Allardyce lie about why he wanted to leave or not, it’s quite simple without made up theories.

Who cares? Did he stitch us up in any way whatsoever? No.

Has the budget since been minuscule? Yes.

Have you ever lied about leaving a job for career progression when it was really more cash or an easier job? You’re a painter so self employed probably and either don’t have an employer or me be agency all the time.

 


COYP

est1905 Flag 15 Jun 19 5.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Who cares? Did he stitch us up in any way whatsoever? No.

Has the budget since been minuscule? Yes.

Have you ever lied about leaving a job for career progression when it was really more cash or an easier job? You’re a painter so self employed probably and either don’t have an employer or me be agency all the time.

I would say the budget on incoming players has been miniscule since Allardyce left simply because he spent more than we could afford to get out of trouble and up the table. The club have had to cut cloth accordingly ever since.
Saying that, if we could just get our wage bill under more control we could probably now push on with a quality signing or two. The last few meagre windows must surely mean now that the books are balanced.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 15 Jun 19 6.18pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Who cares? Did he stitch us up in any way whatsoever? No.

Has the budget since been minuscule? Yes.

Have you ever lied about leaving a job for career progression when it was really more cash or an easier job? You’re a painter so self employed probably and either don’t have an employer or me be agency all the time.

If he didn't lie about why he was leaving, then Everton wouldn't have paid us compensation as he was under contract to us. The budget has been minuscule as he overspent the budget. Roy has done a far better job, with hardly any money.
Why do you assume my name signifies my employment, I don't assume your a washed up ex footballer? He was your favourite player for some bizarre reason.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Jun 19 7.34pm

Originally posted by Painter

The budget has been minuscule as he overspent the budget. Roy has done a far better job, with hardly any money.

The three players that Sam bought still form part of our team with one of them being the captain and highest scorer last season.

In contrast the players bought or loaned under Roy's watch have included many of poor quality which have been a waste of money.

We must have wasted £12m or £13m on Sorloth and Jach neither of whom are good enough to play for us

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Jun 19 7.46pm

Originally posted by Painter

If he didn't lie about why he was leaving, then Everton wouldn't have paid us compensation as he was under contract to us. The budget has been minuscule as he overspent the budget. Roy has done a far better job, with hardly any money.
Why do you assume my name signifies my employment, I don't assume your a washed up ex footballer? He was your favourite player for some bizarre reason.

I said who cares if he did lie. He left amicably and didn’t stitch us up with ageing one trick pony players or cloggers.

Rudi Hedman was a cult hero whose ‘Rudi’ chant could be heard a long distance from the Arfur enclosure.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Jun 19 8.01pm

Originally posted by est1905

I would say the budget on incoming players has been miniscule since Allardyce left simply because he spent more than we could afford to get out of trouble and up the table. The club have had to cut cloth accordingly ever since.
Saying that, if we could just get our wage bill under more control we could probably now push on with a quality signing or two. The last few meagre windows must surely mean now that the books are balanced.

The books are certainly not balanced and without selling anyone you’re looking at not much more spent than we did on kouyate.

If you look at the sam signings, first of all they had to cost because it was January and our obvious needs to anyone with 2 working eyes watching us ship 5 goals in games. They also included 2 proven Prem left backs. If we bl00dy had a proper backup to Souare then we may not have needed both in January, but then again Pardew might’ve survived and caused more long term damage. We blatantly needed a CB and because our scouting is p1ss poor we loaned in Sakho and then Parish bought him when FDB was stealing a living. Luka, as midlands says, ended up being our captain and I even heard Freedman had said that def mid was our weakest link after a live game loss, whereas we were obsessing about no left back.

Parish knew we were in trouble. The document sam wrote that he and the US 2 saw was obviously taken rightly seriously.

Roy did a tremendous job because I thought we’d run out of time. But it should also be pointed out that he didn’t have fewer players than sam had. Roy had RLC, but he had no striker after Benteke got injured at Man City. That in itself was verging on miraculous to deal with. With cabaye and RLC we grew into an immense force. Sadly now we’re a bit timid until teams wind down for their summer holidays.

 


COYP

silvertop Flag Portishead 15 Jun 19 8.20pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The three players that Sam bought still form part of our team with one of them being the captain and highest scorer last season.

In contrast the players bought or loaned under Roy's watch have included many of poor quality which have been a waste of money.

We must have wasted £12m or £13m on Sorloth and Jach neither of whom are good enough to play for us

Please provide evidence to support the suggestion that allardyce has anything to do with those players.

Due diligence and informal discussions take months answer I bet they predated fatty

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Jun 19 8.30pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Please provide evidence to support the suggestion that allardyce has anything to do with those players.

Due diligence and informal discussions take months answer I bet they predated fatty

Well pva definitely involved sam. What do you think sam had written in this ‘document’ in what it would take he sent to the club then?

I thought Luka was a sam target but it sounded like he wasn’t. Sakho I think came as a surprise, possibly by Parish, which again proves how serious Parish knew things were.

This whole thing of sam being the devil incarnate is so ridiculous I can imagine many giving him grief in a holiday resort and then sh1tting it in their hotel room or avoiding him after he goes ‘boo’ and makes you freeze in fear.

He did the job he presented, left us with good players rather than garbage but wasn’t interested in working miracles or these cycles of over and underspending with little in the way of scouting or expertise at the training ground. Look at what happened with FDB. Shambles.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Jun 19 10.02am

Originally posted by silvertop


Please provide evidence to support the suggestion that allardyce has anything to do with those players.

Don't be ridiculous. Do you think this is a court of law?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Jun 19 10.10am

Originally posted by silvertop


Please provide evidence to support the suggestion that allardyce has anything to do with those players.

BBC website 30/01/2017

Crystal Palace have signed Sunderland defender Patrick van Aanholt for a transfer fee that could rise to £14m

<snip>

Allardyce added: "You like to bring players you've worked with before and hopefully his impact is instant.

You can research the others yourself as I'm not your research assistant

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 16 Jun 19 10.39am

if i remember correctly we went almost 4 games without a shot in target under [ defamatory comment removed by moderator ].

in response to the original question...we would have almost certainly wasted a lot of money on tosun.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (16 Jun 2019 10.57am)

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Jun 19 11.37am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

if i remember correctly we went almost 4 games without a shot in target under [ defamatory comment removed by moderator ].

in response to the original question...we would have almost certainly wasted a lot of money on tosun.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (16 Jun 2019 10.57am)

I think you need to rethink your accusations.

We (Parish?) tried to sign Tosun in the summer of 2017 under FDB with a week left of the window for £12 mil.

Sam signed him at Everton for £27 mil about 5 months later in January 2018.

We tried to loan or buy him off Everton but they wanted £20 mil.

Everton are likely to be charged more and going by his performances in the champions league after we gave his club no time to find a replacement it’s hardly surprising his price rose.

The same fault keeps cropping up here. (No left back cover 5 months before sam, no professional attempt for a striker 5 months after sam) Not getting the deal done when it was needed, and therefore you can see why sam left before this kind of thing was going to happen again.

There is no proof he wouldn’t have succeeded in a team including Luka, cabaye and RLC with Zaha and Townsend. He looked better with games stretched, which is how we’ve succeeded on the counter attack. He wouldn’t have been thrown in either until Benteke got injured at Man City and sam probably looked and expected it to happen.

Roy has done really well under pressure. It’s just when more is possible under much less pressure he stays cautious. Sam could probably foresee this stuff. No issue from me.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (16 Jun 2019 11.42am)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Jun 19 11.39am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

if i remember correctly we went almost 4 games without a shot in target under [ defamatory comment removed by moderator ].

in response to the original question...we would have almost certainly wasted a lot of money on tosun.

Edited by Midlands Eagle (16 Jun 2019 10.57am)


You seem to have forgotten the old sayings ‘start from the back’ and ‘respect the point’ that Pardew ignored and preferred his gung ho 5-4 losses after being ahead, twice was it?

 


COYP

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 16 Jun 19 1.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I think you need to rethink your accusations.

We (Parish?) tried to sign Tosun in the summer of 2017 under FDB with a week left of the window for £12 mil.

Sam signed him at Everton for £27 mil about 5 months later in January 2018.

We tried to loan or buy him off Everton but they wanted £20 mil.

Everton are likely to be charged more and going by his performances in the champions league after we gave his club no time to find a replacement it’s hardly surprising his price rose.

The same fault keeps cropping up here. (No left back cover 5 months before sam, no professional attempt for a striker 5 months after sam) Not getting the deal done when it was needed, and therefore you can see why sam left before this kind of thing was going to happen again.

There is no proof he wouldn’t have succeeded in a team including Luka, cabaye and RLC with Zaha and Townsend. He looked better with games stretched, which is how we’ve succeeded on the counter attack. He wouldn’t have been thrown in either until Benteke got injured at Man City and sam probably looked and expected it to happen.

Roy has done really well under pressure. It’s just when more is possible under much less pressure he stays cautious. Sam could probably foresee this stuff. No issue from me.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (16 Jun 2019 11.42am)

spin it however you like, he fooked off after a few months after spending a small fortune, because he knew he wouldn't have the same thrown at him again in the summer.

in truth we actually dodged a bullet him him packing his bags.

and your memory seems a bit hazy...you seem to forget that pape souare was a very good full back for us before his freak injury.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


ChrisGC Flag Wantage 16 Jun 19 1.34pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

spin it however you like, he fooked off after a few months after spending a small fortune, because he knew he wouldn't have the same thrown at him again in the summer.

in truth we actually dodged a bullet him him packing his bags.

and your memory seems a bit hazy...you seem to forget that pape souare was a very good full back for us before his freak injury.

Souare was bang average imo. Did a job.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Jun 19 11.58pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

spin it however you like, he fooked off after a few months after spending a small fortune, because he knew he wouldn't have the same thrown at him again in the summer.

in truth we actually dodged a bullet him him packing his bags.

and your memory seems a bit hazy...you seem to forget that pape souare was a very good full back for us before his freak injury.

My memory isn’t hazy. We went into the season with 6 defenders in including one full back - Souare. Criminal. We also had the excuse called Zeki Fryers added to that grand total of 6. That is shambolic.

The car crash is not an excuse. He could’ve broken his leg on the pitch. You don’t go into the season with one player in a specialised position like left back plus Zeki Fryers.

Allardyce left and what did we do? Started the next season with one forward after offering besiktas the minimum for Tosun without enough time to find a replacement. I forget when niasse had a similar late approach and failed for different reasons but proves why Allardyce didn’t want or need it. We’re lucky a local boy wants it maybe. Otherwise maybe nobody respectable then and now would. I just wish it wasn’t so dull.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 17 Jun 19 8.47am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

My memory isn’t hazy. We went into the season with 6 defenders in including one full back - Souare. Criminal. We also had the excuse called Zeki Fryers added to that grand total of 6. That is shambolic.

The car crash is not an excuse. He could’ve broken his leg on the pitch. You don’t go into the season with one player in a specialised position like left back plus Zeki Fryers.

Allardyce left and what did we do? Started the next season with one forward after offering besiktas the minimum for Tosun without enough time to find a replacement. I forget when niasse had a similar late approach and failed for different reasons but proves why Allardyce didn’t want or need it. We’re lucky a local boy wants it maybe. Otherwise maybe nobody respectable then and now would. I just wish it wasn’t so dull.

Whatever way you wish to look at it, Allardyce is a cheque book manager with limited ability. Perhaps you are correct and he didn’t want his limitations exposed. Roy seems to have coped very well without buying, showing a good manager that can work with the players he has.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Jun 19 9.13am

Originally posted by Painter

If he didn't lie about why he was leaving, then Everton wouldn't have paid us compensation as he was under contract to us. The budget has been minuscule as he overspent the budget. Roy has done a far better job, with hardly any money.
Why do you assume my name signifies my employment, I don't assume your a washed up ex footballer? He was your favourite player for some bizarre reason.


There wasn't a contract as such, the fee was a clause that Palace made that if he took another job within a certain time frame ( two years i think) then compensation would be paid.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 17 Jun 19 10.28am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


There wasn't a contract as such, the fee was a clause that Palace made that if he took another job within a certain time frame ( two years i think) then compensation would be paid.

You think Everton paid without Allardyce being under a contract, where would this clause be?

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What if Allardyce hadn't left?