You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Grenfell - who's to blame
November 21 2026 9.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Grenfell - who's to blame


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Stirlingsays Flag 05 Nov 19 3.27pm

Anyone who works in the public sector is always on a hiding to nothing.

What I detest is that proportion of the middle and higher classes who would never let their kids work in these jobs yet are full of contempt for these services.....I'm thinking especially of those in the media and political classes.

While I have huge problems with how politicised our Police is now....largely that's a politicised management problem and if you work in the public sector you are a force for good in society....response teams are obviously very important people.

But when things go wrong we know that there are plenty of awful people who will hang you out to dry as fast as they can.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Nov 2019 3.50pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

W12 05 Nov 19 3.39pm

Originally posted by DanH

So you shouldn't try to get to the bottom of why things happen?

I didn't say you shouldn't work out how to avoid this happening in the future. That is almost the exact opposite of just finding someone to blame.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 05 Nov 19 9.11pm

Originally posted by W12

We used to call these things tragic accidents because that's what they were.

Now it's just an exercise in apportioning blame depending on whose side you are on.

That cultural shift is what happens when you consistently tell people that they part of a victim hierarchy perpetuated by evil white men.

it was a tragic accident that happened because of the cladding, you are bringing race into it, isn't the issue the rich crapping on the poor ... 'evil white men?!' … what has the racial (and sexual) demographic of the culprits or victims got to do with this? there is a clear undertone to your comment which betrays some fantasy idea that the complaint is based in the inability of a coloured underclass who can't afford a better place to live - maybe they should be grateful they had any cladding at all, maybe if there's a similar fire that kills a load of plumbers from Essex you'll be able to see more clearly.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 05 Nov 19 9.30pm

Simple answer is Eric Pickles and our very own Gavin Barwell.

The Lakanal House coroner's report was largely ignored.

The fire spread in a way it should not have done.

[Link]

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Nov 19 9.43pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

it was a tragic accident that happened because of the cladding, you are bringing race into it, isn't the issue the rich crapping on the poor ... 'evil white men?!' … what has the racial (and sexual) demographic of the culprits or victims got to do with this? there is a clear undertone to your comment which betrays some fantasy idea that the complaint is based in the inability of a coloured underclass who can't afford a better place to live - maybe they should be grateful they had any cladding at all, maybe if there's a similar fire that kills a load of plumbers from Essex you'll be able to see more clearly.

From what I've seen most of the commentary about race with this tragedy has been from leftist commentators.

Who on the left complained about that connection and only focused upon the regulations and cladding?

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Nov 2019 9.45pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 05 Nov 19 10.30pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

it was a tragic accident that happened because of the cladding, you are bringing race into it, isn't the issue the rich crapping on the poor ... 'evil white men?!' … what has the racial (and sexual) demographic of the culprits or victims got to do with this? there is a clear undertone to your comment which betrays some fantasy idea that the complaint is based in the inability of a coloured underclass who can't afford a better place to live - maybe they should be grateful they had any cladding at all, maybe if there's a similar fire that kills a load of plumbers from Essex you'll be able to see more clearly.

Grenfell was multi coloured.
Afford a better place to live!
Reports I've read say how much they loved living there, not forgetting a lot dont want to leave the area.
The cladding passed the relevant standards required at the time.
It takes disasters for changes.
That's a sad fact.
Look at history and most changes for our safety are because of this fact.
Unfortunatly grenfell was a very freak and extremely rare event.
A perfect storm involving all the factors.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 05 Nov 19 10.51pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Grenfell was multi coloured.
Afford a better place to live!
Reports I've read say how much they loved living there, not forgetting a lot dont want to leave the area.
The cladding passed the relevant standards required at the time.
It takes disasters for changes.
That's a sad fact.
Look at history and most changes for our safety are because of this fact.
Unfortunatly grenfell was a very freak and extremely rare event.
A perfect storm involving all the factors.

But not unexpected or unpredictable. See my earlier post. A Coroner had already warned us that this could happen. It wasn’t just about cladding, there were many factors.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 06 Nov 19 1.59am

Originally posted by cryrst

Grenfell was multi coloured.
Afford a better place to live!
Reports I've read say how much they loved living there, not forgetting a lot dont want to leave the area.
The cladding passed the relevant standards required at the time.
It takes disasters for changes.
That's a sad fact.
Look at history and most changes for our safety are because of this fact.
Unfortunatly grenfell was a very freak and extremely rare event.
A perfect storm involving all the factors.

In retrospect it's clear that the cladding was entirely inadequate (along with regulations) and essentially turned a block of flats into a potential tomb. I agree though, that until something terrible happens it's all theoretical and 'nothing to see'.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 06 Nov 19 2.08am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I want to know if it turns out that someone had about 15 plugs from one socket and the fire was caused by a short - will it still be everyone else's fault? Particularly if it was then delayed in being reported?
Lack of any type of personal responsibility rife these days. No doubt though, even if something like that caused the fire - we won't be told.
Obviously the cladding spread the fire but it had to start somewhere. Just a thought.

[Link]

Possibly the above.


Edited by dollardays (06 Nov 2019 2.10am)

 

Matov Flag 06 Nov 19 9.55am

How or why that fire started in the flat is not the issue. Fires happen. Faulty wiring happens. Just a fact of life. The only issue is why that building was clad in that material. That is why all those poor people died.

And what is being pushed to one side. Brushed under the carpet. All this froth around the fire-brigade and the prosecutions of the people trying to scrounge in the aftermath is pure BS. Classic political distraction techniques and I suspect one that our entire political class is embracing.

Playing up to ALL of our collective worse sensibilities. We need to acknowledge that. Our venal, self-aggrandizing political elite at its very worst.

No cladding, no deaths. It is as simple as that. The fire-brigade response was perfectly in line with the known 'facts' prior to the incident getting underway. Certainly worthy of retrospection but still a matter of internal LFB consideration. Not a public enquiry and certainly not before the main question with regards to how that cladding came to be in place to start with.

Cladding. Cladding. Cladding. That is it. That is why that tower block was turned into a torch. Why was it up there? Who passed it as being safe? What were the process? The policy?

I am firmly of the Right. Make no bones about that. But my political antennae are twitching away like anything because this stinks and goes well beyond the usual slings and arrows of the 'game'. With politicians from all sides of the divide playing their part in ensuring that the cladding question is not being given the absolute prominence it deserves. That is the rot in all of this.

Forget everything else. All merely window dressing. The key lays in the process as to why that cladding went up on that building.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 06 Nov 19 11.08am

Originally posted by Matov

How or why that fire started in the flat is not the issue. Fires happen. Faulty wiring happens. Just a fact of life. The only issue is why that building was clad in that material. That is why all those poor people died.

And what is being pushed to one side. Brushed under the carpet. All this froth around the fire-brigade and the prosecutions of the people trying to scrounge in the aftermath is pure BS. Classic political distraction techniques and I suspect one that our entire political class is embracing.

Playing up to ALL of our collective worse sensibilities. We need to acknowledge that. Our venal, self-aggrandizing political elite at its very worst.

No cladding, no deaths. It is as simple as that. The fire-brigade response was perfectly in line with the known 'facts' prior to the incident getting underway. Certainly worthy of retrospection but still a matter of internal LFB consideration. Not a public enquiry and certainly not before the main question with regards to how that cladding came to be in place to start with.

Cladding. Cladding. Cladding. That is it. That is why that tower block was turned into a torch. Why was it up there? Who passed it as being safe? What were the process? The policy?

I am firmly of the Right. Make no bones about that. But my political antennae are twitching away like anything because this stinks and goes well beyond the usual slings and arrows of the 'game'. With politicians from all sides of the divide playing their part in ensuring that the cladding question is not being given the absolute prominence it deserves. That is the rot in all of this.

Forget everything else. All merely window dressing. The key lays in the process as to why that cladding went up on that building.

The enquiry is going to get to the building side of it.
There is a process which will get to investigating causes effects and prevention.

 

W12 06 Nov 19 2.10pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

it was a tragic accident that happened because of the cladding, you are bringing race into it, isn't the issue the rich crapping on the poor ... 'evil white men?!' … what has the racial (and sexual) demographic of the culprits or victims got to do with this? there is a clear undertone to your comment which betrays some fantasy idea that the complaint is based in the inability of a coloured underclass who can't afford a better place to live - maybe they should be grateful they had any cladding at all, maybe if there's a similar fire that kills a load of plumbers from Essex you'll be able to see more clearly.

Doreen Lawrence brought race into it along with many other talking heads from various "communities"......and the media ran with it.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Nov 19 7.15pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The enquiry is going to get to the building side of it.
There is a process which will get to investigating causes effects and prevention.

… and that process involves smearing the LFB first before a possible two year delay until the decision makers are scrutinised - and well done Matov - abs spot on.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 06 Nov 19 7.55pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

… and that process involves smearing the LFB first before a possible two year delay until the decision makers are scrutinised - and well done Matov - abs spot on.

The LFB made mistakes.
Should everyone apart from the emergency services be implicated.
The fact they have been pulled up will save many lives going forwards.
It takes disasters to get change.
100 years ago at ypres it took one day and 20k dead for the army to realise a mistake and make changes.
History shows this.
I dont think its personal.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Nov 19 8.13pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The LFB made mistakes.
Should everyone apart from the emergency services be implicated.
The fact they have been pulled up will save many lives going forwards.
It takes disasters to get change.
100 years ago at ypres it took one day and 20k dead for the army to realise a mistake and make changes.
History shows this.
I dont think its personal.

Do tower blocks without cladding have to have the stay put advice rescinded?
LFB were not responsible for the tower burning down.
Easy target to pick on and any suggestion of racism is disgusting.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 06 Nov 19 8.20pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Do tower blocks without cladding have to have the stay put advice rescinded?
LFB were not responsible for the tower burning down.
Easy target to pick on and any suggestion of racism is disgusting.

No they didnt clad the building or set it on fire.
The truth is they made mistakes on the night.
Whether through a building being not properly fire rated or lack of training in certain situations I dont know.
It's as if like climate change they and it are beyond criticism.
Also not once have I thought that woman was correct.
I still dont believe the report about the police after Lawrence was killed.
That's a reason we are where we are now with racism and accusations every two minutes.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Nov 19 8.21pm

All emergency services do their best in situations most of the public would s*** themselves in.
You are given protocols to follow, but you can step outside them if you feel it is in the public/patients best interest.
To have anyone comment or judge them on that, unless they have been in that position is laughable.
Someones life is the biggest responsibility you can have in your hands.
I know. I did it over the course of 3 decades.
Race,colour,creed never came into it.
Just did your best for each patient you dealt with.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 06 Nov 19 8.33pm

Originally posted by cryrst

No they didnt clad the building or set it on fire.
The truth is they made mistakes on the night.
Whether through a building being not properly fire rated or lack of training in certain situations I dont know.
It's as if like climate change they and it are beyond criticism.
Also not once have I thought that woman was correct.
I still dont believe the report about the police after Lawrence was killed.
That's a reason we are where we are now with racism and accusations every two minutes.

Easy to say they made mistakes on the night.
They followed the set protocols and risked their lives to save people.
Cop out to pick apart those protocols from a set of circumstances not faced before (the cladding) and try and blame them.
999 services are not perfect, but how many people do their job whilst being threatened verbally or physically?
In my career i had a knife held at me, a shotgun pointed at me and lost count of the physical threats let alone the verbal.
All while trying to help someone.
Easy targets.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 06 Nov 19 8.38pm

Originally posted by sickboy

All emergency services do their best in situations most of the public would s*** themselves in.
You are given protocols to follow, but you can step outside them if you feel it is in the public/patients best interest.
To have anyone comment or judge them on that, unless they have been in that position is laughable.
Someones life is the biggest responsibility you can have in your hands.
I know. I did it over the course of 3 decades.
Race,colour,creed never came into it.
Just did your best for each patient you dealt with.

I've got nothing but respect and admiration for all of these people.
Doctors nurses fire police ambulance etc etc.
That though isnt being questioned in this case.
We are just about to see millions taken out of the police budget if this ER mob sue for damages over wrongful arrest.
Some will find this correct but personally it sucks.
Point is the police have been found to have made a mistake and been pulled up.
LFB rightly or wrongly being pulled up made mistakes on that night.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Nov 19 8.43pm

Originally posted by sickboy

Easy to say they made mistakes on the night.
They followed the set protocols and risked their lives to save people.
Cop out to pick apart those protocols from a set of circumstances not faced before (the cladding) and try and blame them.
999 services are not perfect, but how many people do their job whilst being threatened verbally or physically?
In my career i had a knife held at me, a shotgun pointed at me and lost count of the physical threats let alone the verbal.
All while trying to help someone.
Easy targets.

Yep all spot on.

Look, uncomfortable truth is that when you are in a situation like that you need to use your common sense.

What Mogg said was accurate but obviously the disingenuous are suggesting that this is him criticising victims when it isn't.

It's recognising that when the sh1t hits the fan that it's you....the sh1t and the fan and you need to make the decisions....It's not fair, it's horrible but it's reality. Often people don't want to hear it.

Never forget that for many different reasons 'experts' are often wrong.


Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Nov 2019 9.23pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Grenfell - who's to blame