You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR at its worst
November 22 2026 7.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR at its worst


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 09 Jul 20 9.09pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Apart from the other night in the Leicster game.

I put my trust in Collina rather than FIFA.

Me too. How did Tarkowski not get a red card?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Jul 20 8.22am

Something needs to be done about VAR

[Link]

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Jul 20 9.34am

Originally posted by Badger11

Something needs to be done about VAR

[Link]

I believe I mentioned on HOL, before VAR was introduced to our game, that it was not a panacea and there would still be debate because of the subjective decisions which would be made.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Jul 20 10.11am

Originally posted by Willo

I believe I mentioned on HOL, before VAR was introduced to our game, that it was not a panacea and there would still be debate because of the subjective decisions which would be made.

I'm sure you did.

However overall I think it has been a good thing because those blatant errors have largely been irradiated as has the perception of big team bias.

It's true that mistakes are still made and some decisions will always be subjective, but it was ever thus.

Hopefully Collina will now set some standards across Europe.

Edited by Badger11 (10 Jul 2020 10.12am)

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Jul 20 10.21am

Originally posted by Badger11

I'm sure you did.

However overall I think it has been a good thing because those blatant errors have largely been irradiated as has the perception of big team bias.

It's true that mistakes are still made and some decisions will always be subjective, but it was ever thus.

Hopefully Collina will now set some standards across Europe.

Edited by Badger11 (10 Jul 2020 10.12am)

There has been mention of a standardisation of on-field referees referring to pitchside monitors.
Currently in the PL, referees only do so in respect of potential red-card incidents.

Whether referees refer to monitors or the VAR gets involved, at the end of the day they will be making subjective decisions and of course these trigger conflicting opinions.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 10 Jul 20 10.49am

The Premier League admit three VAR decisions wrong last night, that's quite an admission.

I have only seen the referees consulting pitch-side monitors during the last World Cup, it was long-winded and seemed to take over.

The match is already held-up so I think enough is enough, the English fan wants an instant correct decision and that has to come at a price.

The VAR gave an instant decision against Kane's demand for a penalty and it was unanimous in the media that they were wrong.

I don't think so, the defenders eyes were on the ball not Kane and Kane was kidding the ref, I think that's what the ref thought too.

So there we go!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 10 Jul 20 11.22am

Originally posted by steeleye20

The Premier League admit three VAR decisions wrong last night, that's quite an admission.

I have only seen the referees consulting pitch-side monitors during the last World Cup, it was long-winded and seemed to take over.

The match is already held-up so I think enough is enough, the English fan wants an instant correct decision and that has to come at a price.

The VAR gave an instant decision against Kane's demand for a penalty and it was unanimous in the media that they were wrong.

I don't think so, the defenders eyes were on the ball not Kane and Kane was kidding the ref, I think that's what the ref thought too.

So there we go!

Wasn’t it used at Selhurst against Derby when Luka was sent off? And at Leicester the other night?

Edited by Spiderman (10 Jul 2020 11.22am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Jul 20 11.25am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Wasn’t it used at Selhurst against Derby when Luka was sent off? And at Leicester the other night?

Edited by Spiderman (10 Jul 2020 11.22am)

You are absolutely correct.
This was the first time that a referee referred to the pitchside monitor in England. Michael Oliver was the referee and he sent of Milivojevic.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Jul 20 5.52pm

Don't know why we need to bring someone in. We have the ultimate expert in VAR in the Premier League already. All VAR decisions should be taken by Mourinho ultimately, as he always gets it right.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 12 Jul 20 9.24am

We got 2 penalties yesterday for less than some of the shirt pulling wrestling type fouls on our players that have been missed in previous games .

Not complaining though..

Does show the inconsistency which is the main problem.

They won't win over the screen business - people will complain it takes too long to make a decision and as we saw with Arteta managers will still put pressure on the ref looking at the screen.

Everyone felt the Man U penalty wasn't one apart from their manager who thought it was clear cut!

It's the subjective views of the officials that creates problems- not the VAR itself .

Edited by Superhorns3 (12 Jul 2020 9.30am)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 15 Jul 20 8.02pm

After having just having seen Mike Dean give Burnley a penalty v Wolves when very very very clearly it is dangerous play by Wood I am convinced: the friends will be friends culture among referees in the PL makes the system, which is in principle great if you judge critically , practically horribly wrong and I hope it will be scrapped. I would almost go as ar as question the integrity of the referees. The penalties of the last fortnight (Grealish kicking himself and getting a penalty standing out), our goal last Sunday, goals clearly over the line and no correction we can go on and on....

It beggars belief.

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 16 Jul 20 12.46pm

I too thought it was a potential high foot but most pundits seem to agree it was handball and a penalty so guess that goes down as a subjective decision.

I suppose they will say Wood was going for a genuine over head kick and the defender tried to stop him getting the ball with his arm.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 16 Jul 20 1.05pm

VAR is not being used as intended.

The VAR man should ask the referee to check for himself on the pitch side monitor if he thinks an error has been made.
That way the match referee's decision is final, as it always should be.

How often has this happened - a half dozen times at most.

Hopefully as the PL now has to conform with the rest of the world next season we will get sensible outcomes.

At present many decisions have been laughably wrong.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 16 Jul 20 1.28pm

We really must dump VAR at the earliest opportunity.

Can VAR actually get a decision right? Recently new levels of incompetence have emerged suggesting it is just totally wrong.

It's nothing like the respected cricket DRS where very rarely, if ever, a mistake is made.

You may as well flip a coin and not play the game at all.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Jul 20 1.36pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

We really must dump VAR at the earliest opportunity.

Can VAR actually get a decision right? Recently new levels of incompetence have emerged suggesting it is just totally wrong.

It's nothing like the respected cricket DRS where very rarely, if ever, a mistake is made.

You may as well flip a coin and not play the game at all.

Gives Sky something to talk about though. That's basically what seems to matter. It is becoming increasingly evident that the fans don't matter a jot.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 16 Jul 20 2.05pm

True instead of spending hours on decisions made by the on pitch ref they just talk about the VAR officials .

Least you can understand why mistake are made by the former but excuse does the bloke watching a screen have ?!

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 17 Jul 20 11.43am

VAR is ruining the game and the enjoyment of the game and is still getting loads of decisions wrong!

I would scrap it in a heart beat and just use the GLT that we had previously. I’d take the occasional mistake from the referee / linesman that we had before over this absolute sh*t show that we’ve got with VAR.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 18 Jul 20 11.15am

Originally posted by Uphill

VAR is not being used as intended.

The VAR man should ask the referee to check for himself on the pitch side monitor if he thinks an error has been made.
That way the match referee's decision is final, as it always should be.

How often has this happened - a half dozen times at most.

Hopefully as the PL now has to conform with the rest of the world next season we will get sensible outcomes.

At present many decisions have been laughably wrong.

The only time at Selhurst I can recall this happening was in the match (I cant remember which one) when the ref. sent Ward off for a dangerous tackle. On reviewing it he rescinded red and just gave Joel yellow.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 18 Jul 20 11.35pm

If anyone watched the Stoke/Brentford game today, there was the most blatant foul in the area which was not given. Right in front of the linesman, how he missed it beggars belief and could well have cost Brentford promotion.
Brentford player running into area to meet a cross, was grabbed by his shirt collar and thrown to the ground, unbelievable. I am as fed up with VAR as everyone else but I bet Brentford would have given anything for it today

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 21 Jul 20 8.19am

I’m obviously missing something. Why wasn’t VAR even consulted when the Wolves player clearly contacted the ball with his arm yesterday? Why didn’t the commentators highlight it a bit more instead of simply brushing it off?

Confused...

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR at its worst