You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ernie Howe MOD Sunday
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ernie Howe MOD Sunday


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Feb 21 1.00pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Howe should be assessed on his record as a manager rather than how he comes across on telly.

He did wonders for Bournemouth when they were skint at the foot of League One, and ended up getting them up into the Championship on a shoestring. Thereafter, however, I don't think his results were actually that impressive when you look at his spending.

In getting promoted to the premier league in 2014-15 Howe (or Bournemouth) spent so much money they didn't actually have that they got fined £4.75m for breaching Financial Fair Play rules. Bournemouth were happy to pay it as they originally expected to be fined £7.6m.

In their five premier league seasons Bournemouth / Howe spent (and keep in mind this figure is after player sales) £133 million. Howe was in charge for all of this spending, they were all his signings.

Bournemouth got relegated, with Howe looking devoid of ideas as to how to stop it.

Our net spend over the same period is £56 million, of which Hodgson has had the benefit of about £25m spent whilst £50m came in for AWB.

Not saying Howe couldn't do a good job for us, and perhaps he's learned a few hard lessons that he could put to good use at Palace, but frankly he'd have had to say something pretty fecking amazing on telly last night to make him a better bet than Hodgson based on a pounds to points ratio.


When you consider what budget Dyche has had at his disposal, Howes record is not that great. Then when it started to go belly up at Bournemouth he jumped ship. We are better off well out!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Feb 21 1.04pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews


When you consider what budget Dyche has had at his disposal, Howes record is not that great. Then when it started to go belly up at Bournemouth he jumped ship. We are better off well out!

[Link]

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Feb 21 1.20pm

Originally posted by Putitout


I don’t see either Howe , or Lampard , as an instant answer to who should get the job ,post Hodgson. What I do think is it will be very hard to move this club forward if it is not drastically reinvented. We can name a few possible safe hands , none of which will prevent us being competitive only in the lower end of the league. And that will always involve a percentage of plain and simple safety first football
As far as Lampard is concerned, I feel he could reinvent us but in the Championship, where he has already shown how with his Derby side ,built on one or two young players brought in . An unfinished project but a good indication of his ability. I don’t believe we can be reinvented easily whilst trying to survive the week in week out pressures of the realities of Premiership football. Our academy is not the whole answer, but we have the means to bring in quality youngsters. And in the Championship could be developed into certainly a classier outfit, with more potential for real progress. Thinking there is an instant answer to turning CP into a silk purse is nice, but going to be very hard to achieve,
By the way our academy is doing very well, maybe not as far adrift as you say.



We really don't want to be going down to the Championship if we can avoid it. A big part of our future development has to be a new stand so as to increase both capacity and revenue. That's never going to happen if we're down in the Championship.

If we go down, it is by no means certain we can either:
1. Get back quickly or
2. if we do get back that we will be able to stay up.
The record of promoted teams staying up makes sober reading.

Of the 27 completed PL seasons (excluding the first season)
- only on 3 occasions did all three promoted teams manage to survive their first season.
- on 1 occasion all 3 went straight back down
- on 9 occasions 2 of the 3 went straight back down and
- on the other 14, 1 of the 3 went straight back down.

Clubs that have had 2 or more promotions and relegations to/from the PL and are not currently in it comprise quite a list:
- Norwich
- Middlesbrough
- Nottingham Forest
- Sunderland
- Derby
- Bolton
- Charlton
- Watford
- QPR
- Birmingham
- Reading
- Hull
- Cardiff
IMO, it is vital that we don't rejoin this list if we can avoid it.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 01 Feb 21 1.31pm

Perhaps my memory is selective, but didn't Roy school Howe the last few times we played Bournemouth?

Dyche is a fit (apart from the fact he probably wouldn't come). Howe is not.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Feb 21 1.31pm


It should be remembered that up to now, Hodgson, is the only manager we have had that has not either become a sacking candidate, or a mysterious, sudden out the door and away job..
This surely has to reflect on just how hard it is to manage CP.
It will have to happen, Roy surely can not go on for ever. But whoever takes the reins , in our present condition, it will need to be someone that is completely in tune with the solid hard work needed to succeed even to gain mid table.
If available after this year I would go for Chris Wilder.If he could get the same application into our lot as he achieved with the squad he had at Sheffield last year. And with an ounce more quality in his side would have repeated this, and not been where his team is now..

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Feb 21 1.40pm

Originally posted by doombear


We really don't want to be going down to the Championship if we can avoid it. A big part of our future development has to be a new stand so as to increase both capacity and revenue. That's never going to happen if we're down in the Championship.

If we go down, it is by no means certain we can either:
1. Get back quickly or
2. if we do get back that we will be able to stay up.
The record of promoted teams staying up makes sober reading.

Of the 27 completed PL seasons (excluding the first season)
- only on 3 occasions did all three promoted teams manage to survive their first season.
- on 1 occasion all 3 went straight back down
- on 9 occasions 2 of the 3 went straight back down and
- on the other 14, 1 of the 3 went straight back down.

Clubs that have had 2 or more promotions and relegations to/from the PL and are not currently in it comprise quite a list:
- Norwich
- Middlesbrough
- Nottingham Forest
- Sunderland
- Derby
- Bolton
- Charlton
- Watford
- QPR
- Birmingham
- Reading
- Hull
- Cardiff
IMO, it is vital that we don't rejoin this list if we can avoid it.


Yer, I don’t really recommend it, other than in the terms of it allowing time for a complete reappraisal , with a young talented manager given scope to develop young talented players , and moulding a quality outfit really suited to get above half way in the Premier, when that came about.
What I m trying to say , is I don’t think that would be likely to be possible to do whilst trying not to get relegated. Anyway.
If it’s just a case of hoping we can do a bit better than as we do now, as I have said in another post , it’s Wilder, for me.

 

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 01 Feb 21 1.45pm

Steven Gerrard i think is a good fit for Palace, at some point he will want to manage in the Premier, unlikely the top six or so would go for him, other than Liverpool in a few years time, so a mid table club would be his best bet, i have a gut feeling that he will manage us,

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 Feb 21 1.55pm

Originally posted by Putitout


Yer, I don’t really recommend it, other than in the terms of it allowing time for a complete reappraisal , with a young talented manager given scope to develop young talented players , and moulding a quality outfit really suited to get above half way in the Premier, when that came about.
What I m trying to say , is I don’t think that would be likely to be possible to do whilst trying not to get relegated. Anyway.
If it’s just a case of hoping we can do a bit better than as we do now, as I have said in another post , it’s Wilder, for me.

Thing is, does it ever actually happen that way? Far more likely that we end up selling any good young players we happen to develop to premier league clubs, as happened last time with Clyne and Zaha.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 01 Feb 21 1.57pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

no, he was dating a widow known as Sue, she lived all alone in Lindley Lane at number 22, it was two ton from Teddington who drove the baker's van you're getting mixed up with: "Now Ernie dragged him from his van and beneath the blazing sun, They stood there face to face, and Ted went for his bun." And as for Ernie Howe maybe the OP meant this bloke:

[Link]

jury's out on Howe, wouldn't be surprised if it went either way. I'd prefer Pearson, Bilic (now unavailable)or Dyche (won't come) to either Ernie or Frank.

Show off

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Feb 21 2.21pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Thing is, does it ever actually happen that way? Far more likely that we end up selling any good young players we happen to develop to premier league clubs, as happened last time with Clyne and Zaha.


Not often, to answer the question. I do think we would be in a better position than the Club that sold Clyde, and Wilf, was. it would all depend on the resolve of the club. I wouldn’t pretend for a moment it is a fail safe option. Or one I would feel totally comfortable with.
But it’s as realistic as thinking the club can hire a manager that can get us top half Premier status, keep us there, without ,him getting pulled , and every budding talent , going the same way either before he goes or soon after. And that’s without it all going tits up before it even got off the ground. And the end product being ,what?
This in my opinion would probably sum up how things would go for Lampard, either way.

 

JohnB Flag 01 Feb 21 3.20pm

The one thing that always sticks out for me is the interview that Ian Holloway did a few years after he left us.

He said that he had come to the club with his own ideology on how football should be played and wanted to move us from the style which we were playing at the time, counter attacking, to a more possession based and attacking team.

He said it was the first time in his career that the players had just absolutely resisted this change. The players only had any real interest in playing as a counter attacking team, hence why we did so well under Pulis after him.

The team between then and now is vastly different and one that should be able to transition across to that style of play. However, with Home, his philosophy and style is at complete odds to have we have set up for the last decade. If we are to bring him in, then he will need time, to be backed to bring in players that suit his style of play. If we don't have the patience and backing, then he will just be another FDB.

FDB was too much too quickly, but Howe will still be a significant shift and will only work if we can get in 2 more midfielders that are both comfortable on the ball and have composure. The only CM I can see working under him is Jairo.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 01 Feb 21 3.55pm

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

Show off

should have put 'two ton TED' of course, and yes I am an appalling show off, no news there

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Feb 21 4.06pm

The old “mutual consent” which is well over used and can mean so many things....

 

Palacelinc Flag Lincoln 01 Feb 21 5.52pm

I’d prefer Thomas Frank at Brentford to Howe or Dych. Works on a budget, plays good football, Palace are a step up

 

jackosperoni Flag Penzance, Cornwall 01 Feb 21 6.15pm

Ernie Howe looks just right for the Palace and, as his last job was at Sutton, he may even still live in the area, so no moving costs to pick up if he accepts the job. He's still only 67 so a pup compared with Roy. Worth a punt if we can't get Eddie! Lol!!!

Ernie Howe is an English football manager and former player who is currently no longer managing a team after he mutually parted company with Sutton United on 30 March 2008, having failed to pull them out of the Conference South relegation zone. He was Basingstoke Town's manager for 13 years until 2006, winning the Hampshire Senior Cup and promotion during his tenure.

A defender in his playing career, Howe turned out for Fulham alongside the likes of George Best and Rodney Marsh. He was a member of the Fulham squad beaten 2–0 by West Ham United in the 1975 FA Cup Final but did not make the team. He was subsequently transferred to Queens Park Rangers and then Portsmouth. Although not known for his goal scoring Howe scored on his Pompey debut at home to Sheffield United in August 1982. He helped Portsmouth win the Division Three championship that season. The following season before leaving Pompey he also scored in his final home game.

After leaving Portsmouth he was appointed coach at Wokingham Town.

He married the sister of fellow footballer Andy McCulloch, whose father Adam McCulloch had also played.

 


55 years on the Palace rollercoaster!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Feb 21 6.22pm

Originally posted by jackosperoni

Ernie Howe looks just right for the Palace and, as his last job was at Sutton, he may even still live in the area, so no moving costs to pick up if he accepts the job. He's still only 67 so a pup compared with Roy. Worth a punt if we can't get Eddie! Lol!!!

Ernie Howe is an English football manager and former player who is currently no longer managing a team after he mutually parted company with Sutton United on 30 March 2008, having failed to pull them out of the Conference South relegation zone. He was Basingstoke Town's manager for 13 years until 2006, winning the Hampshire Senior Cup and promotion during his tenure.

A defender in his playing career, Howe turned out for Fulham alongside the likes of George Best and Rodney Marsh. He was a member of the Fulham squad beaten 2–0 by West Ham United in the 1975 FA Cup Final but did not make the team. He was subsequently transferred to Queens Park Rangers and then Portsmouth. Although not known for his goal scoring Howe scored on his Pompey debut at home to Sheffield United in August 1982. He helped Portsmouth win the Division Three championship that season. The following season before leaving Pompey he also scored in his final home game.

After leaving Portsmouth he was appointed coach at Wokingham Town.

He married the sister of fellow footballer Andy McCulloch, whose father Adam McCulloch had also played.

I recall Andy McCulloch playing for us in the 80s.


Edited by Willo (01 Feb 2021 6.22pm)

 

EddieMac Flag 01 Feb 21 6.42pm

Originally posted by Putitout


I don’t see either Howe , or Lampard , as an instant answer to who should get the job ,post Hodgson. What I do think is it will be very hard to move this club forward if it is not drastically reinvented. We can name a few possible safe hands , none of which will prevent us being competitive only in the lower end of the league. And that will always involve a percentage of plain and simple safety first football
As far as Lampard is concerned, I feel he could reinvent us but in the Championship, where he has already shown how with his Derby side ,built on one or two young players brought in . An unfinished project but a good indication of his ability. I don’t believe we can be reinvented easily whilst trying to survive the week in week out pressures of the realities of Premiership football. Our academy is not the whole answer, but we have the means to bring in quality youngsters. And in the Championship could be developed into certainly a classier outfit, with more potential for real progress. Thinking there is an instant answer to turning CP into a silk purse is nice, but going to be very hard to achieve,
By the way our academy is doing very well, maybe not as far adrift as you say.


How exactly would reinventing ourselves in the Championship work?

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Feb 21 7.32pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

How exactly would reinventing ourselves in the Championship work?


I have put one or two explanations in previous posts. It’s not a given, we should start again in the Championship, just a suggestion . It’s not a request to get relegated, it’s more to do with how best to use someone with Lampards talents. I have said I wouldn’t go for either ,Howe, or Lampard. But if I did it would be Lampard, And his best chance would be in having time to change our approach drastically to climbing the Premier.
For me the most likely route for the club is to consolidate what Hodgson , has started, with the emphasis on organisation and application. And for that my choice would be Chris Wilder.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 01 Feb 21 7.41pm

Originally posted by Palacelinc

I’d prefer Thomas Frank at Brentford to Howe or Dych. Works on a budget, plays good football, Palace are a step up

Me too. To me he’s the obvious candidate.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Feb 21 7.48pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Me too. To me he’s the obvious candidate.

I would give Frank ,a go if the club could back him in the same way as his predecessor is getting supported at Villa. He seems to have a very good support system behind what he does now at Brentford.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ernie Howe MOD Sunday