You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Keep Roy
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Keep Roy


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Mar 21 7.24pm

Originally posted by m/k mick

if Roy is going to stay, i am personally fine with that, but it must be sorted out very soon,

Just because we don't know what is happening doesn't mean that it hasn't been sorted. Perhaps there is a new manager in the background and perhaps he is advising on squad changes but we just don't know about it

 

EddieMac Flag 18 Mar 21 7.26pm

We are now basically safe and Roy has said there will be no contract discussions till he has kept his end of the bargain and kept us safe. So with that in mind, it looks like Roy will be staying on a little longer.

It makes perfect sense in my book. Lots of fans won't be happy but the future of the club is at stake and Roy is the perfect manager to keep things steady.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 18 Mar 21 11.54pm

Originally posted by The Heath Eagle

I am not afraid to change the manager but fans such as yourself lack perspective. You want to see a change no matter what, when Roy is keeping us safely in the league while the board are selling players for £50m and not reinvesting the money in the squad. How is Roy responsible for such lack of ambition at board level?

I want there to be a clear idea and philosophy from board level downwards. Some punt on an ex player or some foreign coach while the fundamentals at board level are missing is a recipe for relegation.

I do hope you will be there back in the champo if you get your way. Somehow I doubt it.

100% Ambition comes from the top and there is none, apart from stay in the league. Unless there is significant investment, why change the manager.

 

Therealeaglestilidie Flag 19 Mar 21 6.19am

Man City
Man Utd
Leicester
Chelsea
West Ham
Liverpool
Everton
Tottenham
Aston Villa
Arsenal
Crystal Palace

11th in the premier league is probably the highest position realistically that we could have achieved.

At the start of the season would you have said we would have finished above any of the teams currently above us, probably not apart from West Ham and Villa who are having great seasons but have also spent money.

I think that Roy has done the job he was bought in to do which was to stabilise and retain our premier league status.

Unless we are bought by an Arab Sheik or Russian oligarch we are where we are with the recourses at our disposal.

This has been mentioned before but Charlton fans got bored of finishing mid table under Alan Curbishley and look where they ended up.

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Mar 21 7.21am

Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie

This has been mentioned before but Charlton fans got bored of finishing mid table under Alan Curbishley and look where they ended up.

I always think that this argument is brought up by people who don't have a more sensible response as they omit to mention all of the other clubs who changed manager and did really well and there are loads of them.

Presumably you also believe that if we spend more than tuppence ha'penny we'll go into Administration again

 

BelfastEagle Flag 19 Mar 21 7.31am

Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie

Man City
Man Utd
Leicester
Chelsea
West Ham
Liverpool
Everton
Tottenham
Aston Villa
Arsenal
Crystal Palace

11th in the premier league is probably the highest position realistically that we could have achieved.

At the start of the season would you have said we would have finished above any of the teams currently above us, probably not apart from West Ham and Villa who are having great seasons but have also spent money.

I think that Roy has done the job he was bought in to do which was to stabilise and retain our premier league status.

Unless we are bought by an Arab Sheik or Russian oligarch we are where we are with the recourses at our disposal.

This has been mentioned before but Charlton fans got bored of finishing mid table under Alan Curbishley and look where they ended up.

I think we are getting a little carried away here....this is not the final league table ! We have just come off a run of arguably more winnable games, let’s look at it again when the season is complete and then judge how we have performed.

Although some people will probably want Roy to manage for ever he is fast approaching the end of his management career due to his age. To make a comparison with Alan Curbishley is not sensible.

Edited by BelfastEagle (19 Mar 2021 7.34am)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Mar 21 8.23am

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

I think we are getting a little carried away here....this is not the final league table ! We have just come off a run of arguably more winnable games, let’s look at it again when the season is complete and then judge how we have performed.

Although some people will probably want Roy to manage for ever he is fast approaching the end of his management career due to his age. To make a comparison with Alan Curbishley is not sensible.

Edited by BelfastEagle (19 Mar 2021 7.34am)

Although correct, it is the fact though that this manager has achieved this for every season with us so far and is on course for another with a squad which is now deteriorating in front of our eyes let alone his, he should be awarded with a statue not all this horrible crap, he needs new blood on the pitch he definitely doesn't want his blood pressure to go through the roof next season.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 19 Mar 21 9.39am

Originally posted by Therealeaglestilidie

Man City
Man Utd
Leicester
Chelsea
West Ham
Liverpool
Everton
Tottenham
Aston Villa
Arsenal
Crystal Palace

11th in the premier league is probably the highest position realistically that we could have achieved.

At the start of the season would you have said we would have finished above any of the teams currently above us, probably not apart from West Ham and Villa who are having great seasons but have also spent money.

I think that Roy has done the job he was bought in to do which was to stabilise and retain our premier league status.

Unless we are bought by an Arab Sheik or Russian oligarch we are where we are with the recourses at our disposal.

This has been mentioned before but Charlton fans got bored of finishing mid table under Alan Curbishley and look where they ended up.


The table highlights the status quo. It’s not a managerial thing in total by any means. It is in fact in most cases a matter of financial means.
Roy has done the job he was hired to do. The table shows that.
The only reason to change the manager is to hope to change the style of play, probably on the same budget . In other words an entertainment issue in the main.
For some it goes beyond that. They seem to suggest we could be a top half side , merely by sacking Roy.
The Curbishley, Charlton, story is ,whether it’s liked or not , a prime example of clubs hitting the buffers, approximately where we are now. Another recent example is Stoke.
If you add to these a succession of clubs that have flirted with the Premier league changing management regularly making little or no improvement to that clubs prospects. Then any reason to want Roy gone, are limited
unless the club has a genuine well financed plan to take the club to another level. Even the age argument , is not completely sound, because the record shows Roy, does the job. Any manager has to be followed one day, but it’s usually best when the occupant is no longer performing on the budget , or not thought to be able to handle a better financed situation. In this case he does well on the budget , and a better financed situation has a huge question mark over it.


 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Mar 21 9.46am

Simplify this a bit. Same team minus Zaha, same manager, equals probable relegation next season.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Mar 21 9.55am

I get the feeling that an announcement of Mr Hodgson staying for a further season and some contracts for the "Old guard" being extended will not be well received many of our supporters.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 19 Mar 21 10.29am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Simplify this a bit. Same team minus Zaha, same manager, equals probable relegation next season.

Yes good point re Wilf. That’s a good question. If you could keep Roy or keep Wilf next season who would you pick? Would Wilf be more likely to stay if we had a more attack - minded manager?

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 19 Mar 21 10.44am

There is is the need for teams like ourselves to stay in this league, for the money, and the kudos of playing the mega outfits that regularly take on the might of Europe.
The problem being , that is all we are, clubs with bigger support and history now find they are little better off than us, if better at all in this respect.
If we are to be more concerned with style over substance then we have to accept we could have to practise it at a lower level.
Dreams of entering fully into the big time in a prolonged and financially sustained way is just that. Newcastle , are an example of how difficult it would be,. One team town. Huge gates, one hell of a good ground, a hot bed of basic talent on the doorstep., reasonable finance. Presently scrambling to stay in the league.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 19 Mar 21 11.07am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Simplify this a bit. Same team minus Zaha, same manager, equals probable relegation next season.

Surely it’s more a question of . What the hell is this board going to do if they lose Wilf.?The result of losing Roy, remains guess work, the effects of no Wilf, would be fatal if the team wasn’t completely reinvented.


Edited by Putitout (19 Mar 2021 11.08am)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 19 Mar 21 2.00pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Yes good point re Wilf. That’s a good question. If you could keep Roy or keep Wilf next season who would you pick? Would Wilf be more likely to stay if we had a more attack - minded manager?


Wilf wants to move to a club that will be playing European club football. I suggest the type of manager at Palace is unlikely to be a factor in his reasoning/desires.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Mar 21 2.09pm

Originally posted by doombear


Wilf wants to move to a club that will be playing European club football. I suggest the type of manager at Palace is unlikely to be a factor in his reasoning/desires.

Indeed.

I don't think there are vast swathes of our support base expecting to see Zaha at our club next season.
Zaha will be 29 later this year and one suspects his sale will provide the majority of funds for our transfer activity.

Edited by Willo (19 Mar 2021 2.10pm)

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 19 Mar 21 4.44pm

We are in the strange position of having experienced some truly awful performances this season, yet find ourselves on 37 points and close to securing another season in the PL.

Consequently, I really don't know what to feel about the season, and Roy. Surviving another season is I suppose mission accomplished.

The reality is that if Roy doesn't go this summer he will surely do so next year. So at some point sooner or later Parish has to find a replacement, and whoever we choose, will bring a degree of risk with them. But then there is also a risk that Roy's fortunes will finally desert him if he stays. Better the devil you know, or fortune favours the brave - take your pick!

Personally the thought of another season of the turgid mind numbing stuff we have seen of late horrifies me
( and I have just renewed my season ticket).

I don't entirely hold with the view that Roy is doing the best with what he has available. I know we haven't been playing like Real Madrid in the last couple of seasons, but, with very much the same personnel, we did sometimes come out of our shell and attack the opposition goal. Now though, Roy seems to have engendered a kind of paralysis in the team where there appears to be a fear and antipathy of moving into the attacking half of the field.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Mar 21 4.53pm

Originally posted by Pete53

We are in the strange position of having experienced some truly awful performances this season, yet find ourselves on 37 points and close to securing another season in the PL.

Consequently, I really don't know what to feel about the season, and Roy. Surviving another season is I suppose mission accomplished.

The reality is that if Roy doesn't go this summer he will surely do so next year. So at some point sooner or later Parish has to find a replacement, and whoever we choose, will bring a degree of risk with them. But then there is also a risk that Roy's fortunes will finally desert him if he stays. Better the devil you know, or fortune favours the brave - take your pick!

Personally the thought of another season of the turgid mind numbing stuff we have seen of late horrifies me
( and I have just renewed my season ticket).

I don't entirely hold with the view that Roy is doing the best with what he has available. I know we haven't been playing like Real Madrid in the last couple of seasons, but, with very much the same personnel, we did sometimes come out of our shell and attack the opposition goal. Now though, Roy seems to have engendered a kind of paralysis in the team where there appears to be a fear and antipathy of moving into the attacking half of the field.

Perhaps you would be advised to spend Saturday's watching your local team Hassocks at the 'Beacon'. !!
I have been there a few times!

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 19 Mar 21 5.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

Perhaps you would be advised to spend Saturday's watching your local team Hassocks at the 'Beacon'. !!
I have been there a few times!

I don't doubt it would provide more entertainment than Palace do at present. And it would be certainly be a lot cheaper! I could even cycle to the to the "stadium" in 10 minutes.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 19 Mar 21 5.21pm

The point is if you play good exciting football you get headlines. Albeit the UK has its fanbase, it is the whole 7 billion of the world which brings in finance. Manure have their fanbase because of that. Winning things and getting headlines. I would imagine billions are made outside the UK in their name. Im not putting us in that bracket but if this goes PPV then who is going to pay to watch us.
20k season ticket holders and a few day tickets.
Thats about it. When we did crytstanbul I think the headlines for that may have got us fans willing to pay to watch us. Now they're probably wondering why they bought the shirt. I get you need to crawl, walk,run but 8 years and we still don't appear ambitious. Why?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Mar 21 6.16pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The point is if you play good exciting football you get headlines. Albeit the UK has its fanbase, it is the whole 7 billion of the world which brings in finance. Manure have their fanbase because of that. Winning things and getting headlines. I would imagine billions are made outside the UK in their name. Im not putting us in that bracket but if this goes PPV then who is going to pay to watch us.
20k season ticket holders and a few day tickets.
Thats about it. When we did crytstanbul I think the headlines for that may have got us fans willing to pay to watch us. Now they're probably wondering why they bought the shirt. I get you need to crawl, walk,run but 8 years and we still don't appear ambitious. Why?

I noticed we picked up some international fans, mostly Americans. I do wonder how they feel about our play. I find myself less interested but that could be Covid as much as the rubbish football.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Keep Roy