You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Workers to pay for social care
November 21 2026 9.57pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Workers to pay for social care


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 08 Sep 21 9.28am

1.3m young people take out a student loan each year in the UK. That results in what effectively is an increase in their tax rate of 9%.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Sep 21 9.32am

The pledge that people in care won’t spend any more than £86,000 on their care starting from October 2023 is just the care part of the costs. It doesn’t include the accommodation and food etc. As nursing home care is £1,350 per week minus maybe £150-£180 government subsidies, just how much of the rest is kept score until it reaches the £86,000? As homes that aren’t nursing homes are around £1,000, I doubt it’s very much at all. I expect many will die before they reach the £86,000 or have blown all their house sale money on nearly £1,000 per week.

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 08 Sep 21 9.43am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The pledge that people in care won’t spend any more than £86,000 on their care starting from October 2023 is just the care part of the costs. It doesn’t include the accommodation and food etc. As nursing home care is £1,350 per week minus maybe £150-£180 government subsidies, just how much of the rest is kept score until it reaches the £86,000? As homes that aren’t nursing homes are around £1,000, I doubt it’s very much at all. I expect many will die before they reach the £86,000 or have blown all their house sale money on nearly £1,000 per week.

It takes roughly 3.5 years to reach the cap at current rates, following which only the care element is funded. Few people live in Care Homes for that length of time.

The average life expectancy in UK care homes is 24 months for care homes without nursing and 12 months for care homes with nursing.


Edited by Mapletree (08 Sep 2021 9.44am)

 

fromtherope Flag In the woods of deepest Surrey 08 Sep 21 9.54am

Tax the rich, tax the rich. Came the plaintiff cry for the benefit scroungers, left wing luvvies and all sorts of talking heads on the news last night.

I am not rich, I am not poor. I have worked all my life and now run my own business and employ a couple of people.

I have a nice house, three kids settled and in their own properties because I worked hard to be able to fund them.

I pay my taxes and then some and I will happily bear the revised taxes that are due to hit.

And yet the feckless want me to throw even more money in the pot so they don't have to work, so we can give houses et al to the current flood of migrants and pour money to to oversea aid to feed the fat cats in those countries.

And where is the so call Opposition in all of this. No ideas, no alternatives just a bunch of hindsight time wasters whinging away.

Right, enough said time to work on my business, revise my investments to make more money and fund the things I care about... My Family

 


I am enjoying being back at Selhurst and having a beer with my mates just like we have done for the past 40 years. Through Thick and thin we stick with our club. Not chairman, players or managers, OUR CLUB!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Sep 21 10.04am

Originally posted by Mapletree

It takes roughly 3.5 years to reach the cap at current rates, following which only the care element is funded. Few people live in Care Homes for that length of time.

The average life expectancy in UK care homes is 24 months for care homes without nursing and 12 months for care homes with nursing.


Edited by Mapletree (08 Sep 2021 9.44am)

Could you break this down please?

How much of the costs incurred by someone in either type of care are counted towards the £86,000 that then become ‘free’ (to them)?

What are the amounts you’re using?

Full costs for both types of care?

Amount that goes towards the £86,000 in both types of care?

The rest that doesn’t go towards and they’ll be paying for however long they live in both types of care?

I’ve sort of assumed it’s £1,000 or £1,200 (after govt aid) per week at full cost.

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 08 Sep 21 10.05am

Originally posted by DanH

Have you seen the average wage to house price ratio over the last 50 years?

There are about 25m homes in the UK and during those 50 years the UK population has increased by 13m. Regardless of the reasons for that increase there aren’t enough dwellings available and selling off council properties and the attraction of buy to let haven’t helped.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Sep 21 10.07am

Originally posted by Orange1290


Yep, the usual denial from the blinkered. Often looking in from the outside the real situation can be seen, it's called perspective of which you seem to have very little.

You don't even live in Britain.

Who cares what you think.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Sep 21 10.13am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

There are about 25m homes in the UK and during those 50 years the UK population has increased by 13m. Regardless of the reasons for that increase there aren’t enough dwellings available and selling off council properties and the attraction of buy to let haven’t helped.

Yes, these are part of the reasons why home ownership is beyond reach of more than ever before, and it’s getting worse. And these reasons aren’t their fault, so just saying ‘’we had it hard too’’ when it’s much harder now, addresses nothing. In the ‘60s a couple in their 20’s could get on the property ladder, even if it was in need of repair. Absolutely no chance of that now until a decade later or more, sometimes never.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2021 10.15am)

 


COYP

Teddy Eagle Flag 08 Sep 21 10.21am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yes, these are part of the reasons why home ownership is beyond reach of more than ever before, and it’s getting worse. And these reasons aren’t their fault, so just saying ‘’we had it hard too’’ when it’s much harder now, addresses nothing. In the ‘60s a couple in their 20’s could get on the property ladder, even if it was in need of repair. Absolutely no chance of that now until a decade later or more, sometimes never.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2021 10.15am)

Rudi, I appreciate that sounded more unsympathetic than intended. My only excuse is a skinful of Staropramen.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Sep 21 11.12am

Funny how we now live in a country where we have to increase tax, where the young have no chance of buying a property and where wages have been stagnant for a decade. And yet we were told that mass immigration was the answer to our problems.

Wake up everyone. We are being screwed so the rich man can get richer.

A lack of housing is forcing up prices while wages are suppressed, and now we have to pay more to house all those new immigrants beaching on the shingle of Kent and the others who legitimately bring their huge families here and are housed at our expense. Let's not even get into the added expense for the health service on treating these people, many of whom you see filling up our appallingly run hospitals.

This is the Britain that Tony Blair gave us and that no government since has reversed.

Do you ever feel like you have been had?

 

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 11.25am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Funny how we now live in a country where we have to increase tax, where the young have no chance of buying a property and where wages have been stagnant for a decade. And yet we were told that mass immigration was the answer to our problems.

Wake up everyone. We are being screwed so the rich man can get richer.

A lack of housing is forcing up prices while wages are suppressed, and now we have to pay more to house all those new immigrants beaching on the shingle of Kent and the others who legitimately bring their huge families here and are housed at our expense. Let's not even get into the added expense for the health service on treating these people, many of whom you see filling up our appallingly run hospitals.

This is the Britain that Tony Blair gave us and that no government since has reversed.

Do you ever feel like you have been had?

It's really not that simple.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 08 Sep 21 12.21pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3660682]

Whilst I agree with you about workers over the age of 65 and unearned income needing to be properly looked at in regard to tax/NIC, I take issue with the youth of today feeling hard done by on this issue. Every one of "the demographic on here" have had to pay for the last 30 years (and more) to wipe the arses of the older generation so what's the issue?

Also, it would be nice to feel a little appreciated for the 19 years of free health care and dentistry you were offered that we paid into for you.

There's some truth to that, thought clearly reality has to factor in to the point where we acknowledge that 'making your own way' for younger people now is much more difficult than generations prior. For various reasons owning their own home and the likes are unreachable dreams for many compared to past generations, and so expecting them to dish out more to people who already effectively lucked out into a more advantageous position is a bit rich.

I'm not sure expecting a virtual pat on the back for paying for someone braces to be fitted quite covers the vast challenges a 20 or 30 something has ahead of them compared to past generations. With that said, as with anything, it depends how this money actually ends up being used. If it genuinely does benefit society, then that's one thing. It it just ends up being another government cash grab with funds not even finding their way to the places they're needed then that's another.

Edited by BlueJay (08 Sep 2021 12.26pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Sep 21 12.23pm

Originally posted by DanH

It's really not that simple.

Isn't it?

So you think wage freezes, house prices and the cost of housing immigrants has nothing to do with mass immigration?
There is an issue with an ageing population, but immigrants get old too.

If you don't see the connection, then you are living in cloud cuckoo land.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Sep 21 12.58pm

I’ve read that the actual ‘care’ part of care home costs is about £400 per week. So as I think Maple says, 4 years and £86,000 in payments and you get care free. You will however have been spending another £600-£800 per week or £120,000-£160,000 in that time on accommodation etc and will continue to do so. Most in the south won’t notice the difference, that is if relative in care lasts more than 4 years. Oh and they don’t start to keep a score of these £400 payments until October 2023 so everything before is ignored.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2021 1.02pm)

 


COYP

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Sep 21 1.08pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Funny how we now live in a country where we have to increase tax, where the young have no chance of buying a property and where wages have been stagnant for a decade. And yet we were told that mass immigration was the answer to our problems.

Wake up everyone. We are being screwed so the rich man can get richer.

A lack of housing is forcing up prices while wages are suppressed, and now we have to pay more to house all those new immigrants beaching on the shingle of Kent and the others who legitimately bring their huge families here and are housed at our expense. Let's not even get into the added expense for the health service on treating these people, many of whom you see filling up our appallingly run hospitals.

This is the Britain that Tony Blair gave us and that no government since has reversed.

Do you ever feel like you have been had?

Excellent points.

A whole generation screwed without even getting the taxi cab fare home.

The 'I'm alright Jacks' are the same as they ever was....until it comes for them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mapletree Flag Croydon 08 Sep 21 7.33pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Could you break this down please?

How much of the costs incurred by someone in either type of care are counted towards the £86,000 that then become ‘free’ (to them)?

What are the amounts you’re using?

Full costs for both types of care?

Amount that goes towards the £86,000 in both types of care?

The rest that doesn’t go towards and they’ll be paying for however long they live in both types of care?

I’ve sort of assumed it’s £1,000 or £1,200 (after govt aid) per week at full cost.

Example of Care Home with nursing and medium care needs.

£3,500 per month for Care, £3,000 for accommodation. Purley.

You get some back for Funding for Nursing Care (around £740) and Attendance Allowance (around £390)

Edited by Mapletree (08 Sep 2021 7.37pm)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Sep 21 8.39pm

Originally posted by DanH

Newly qualified graduates with student debt who earn over the £28k threshold now have a marginal tax rate of 42.25% with repayments taken into account. How is that generation ever meant to save to get on the housing ladder?

You can get a longer mortgage to suit your earnings. If getting on the housing ladder is really important then a longer mortgage will be suitable. Lower monthly payments which reduces the pressure. As earnings rise overpayments could be made which will being the term down.
Can you put the sum up which shows your figures. I don't think NI can be included tbh as all earning over 10k pay this.

 

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 8.53pm

Originally posted by cryrst

You can get a longer mortgage to suit your earnings. If getting on the housing ladder is really important then a longer mortgage will be suitable. Lower monthly payments which reduces the pressure. As earnings rise overpayments could be made which will being the term down.
Can you put the sum up which shows your figures. I don't think NI can be included tbh as all earning over 10k pay this.

It’s not so much mortgage repayments that are the problem - it’s having the deposit. Quite often rent payments eclipse what a mortgage repayment would be on the same property.

A graduate on £28k annually would be paying tax @ 20%, NI @ 13.25% and student loan repayments @ 9%. Naturally there are allowances and thresholds before you start paying but that monthly net home barely leaves anything left after you have paid rent, bills and the cost of living meaning it’s nigh on impossible for young people to save anywhere near enough to get to the amount required to put down a deposit on a house.

 

DanH Flag SW2 08 Sep 21 8.58pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Excellent points.

A whole generation screwed without even getting the taxi cab fare home.

The 'I'm alright Jacks' are the same as they ever was....until it comes for them.

But they’re not excellent points are they? They’re a huge oversimplification of a hugely complex issue suited to his and your prejudices.

Blaming immigration solely is so, so lazy and all it does is highlight the kind of person you are rather than a rational, sensible grown up.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Sep 21 8.59pm

Originally posted by DanH

It’s not so much mortgage repayments that are the problem - it’s having the deposit. Quite often rent payments eclipse what a mortgage repayment would be on the same property.

A graduate on £28k annually would be paying tax @ 20%, NI @ 13.25% and student loan repayments @ 9%. Naturally there are allowances and thresholds before you start paying but that monthly net home barely leaves anything left after you have paid rent, bills and the cost of living meaning it’s nigh on impossible for young people to save anywhere near enough to get to the amount required to put down a deposit on a house.

But we are led to beleive that the fees payable for the education will allow you to earn at least 10% higher wages. That 9% is like a free hit. And I don't think the NI should be included as we all pay it. Basically it's 20 % tax like anyone under 50k. How much deposit is needed for a mortgage?

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Workers to pay for social care