You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf
November 21 2026 1.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilf


Page 3 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
PatrickA Flag London 27 Dec 21 9.42am

It seems to me that he has a lot a bit of his pace which was a key factor in getting away from defenders and enabled Wilf to on occasions just run past them rather than trying to beat them through footwork.
If he’s conscious that he has lost a pit of pace it may be why he seems to have adapted his game and seems far easier to mark out of the game.
This could contribute to the frustration he continually exhibits on the field.
You can never predict when players ‘go ever the edge.’
Puncheon’s form seemed to drop off a cliff over a relatively short period.
He went from being touted to be an England candidate to a shambling, lethargic midfield presence in a couple of seasons.
Alex Ferguson was renowned for observing the tipping point for players and would discard and replace them at the tipping point.
Obviously I’m not suggesting we are in a position to discard Wilf and he remains a fine athlete.
I doubt we’ll see him at his electrifying best again though.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 27 Dec 21 9.52am

I think the only thing I would change on the below is -
he still has the ability to be an integral part of "a" team ( whether thats going to be "this" team or another remains to be seen)


Originally posted by NEILLO

I had come to terms with Wilfs petulance. I accepted it as part of his make up, his DNA. Take that side away and who knows what would be left...

However yesterday does concern me.

His overall performance was unbelievably poor. When he got the first Yellow I said to my son, he's heading for a Red. I just didn't think it would happen so quickly.

I think he's at a career crossroads. He's lost a bit of pace but he still has the ability to be an integral part of the team. Whether he wants to be is another question. He had his house up for sale recently and I don't know what to read into that - doesn't necessarily mean he's leaving Palace.

On balance, I would like him to stay. But it's fair to say that I would be nowhere near as disappointed if he left as I would have been a couple of years ago

 

BlueJay Flag UK 27 Dec 21 11.02am

Clearly an asset but also a liability at times. he certainly screwed this game up for us anyway.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Dec 21 11.07am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He seemed Ok to me today, he was fouled constantly along with Ayew and the officials seemed to have much fun ignoring their plight as usual, he has always had issues with the abuse he receives and today was no worse, both bookings were completely over the top and unnecessary from a ref clearly out of his depth, red cards do nothing but destroy a competitive game for everyone watching and I feel the rules need to change by introducing the sin bin, why should the other ten players, management, staff and thousands of fans suffer from the actions of one individual who needs to be dealt with by an independent body who decide after watching the game again the proper punishment for them, this also includes players like Kane who get away with a red on the pitch only to find themselves being dealt with off it.

Can't agree that he was even OK today. Every pass went astray, easily dispossessed, no pace, no enthusiasm. Awful.

Hasn't he been involved in some housing scam...might be playing on his mind.....just trying to come up with some reason he's bee so poor lately...

Edited by spartakev2 (27 Dec 2021 12.59pm)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Dec 21 11.12am

I had come round to the opinion that we might as well keep him now because he has the occasional flash of something special and who on earth is going to pay top dollar for him now he’s lost his pace, is almost 30 and is on circa £130K per week.

However, having been utter toilet for most of the season and after yesterday’s appalling show I would sooner be rid of this petulant ‘has been’ who is currently stealing a wage from us and who is actually now just a distraction and holding us back.

Get him gone to Newcastle for £20M and reinvest the wages in some decent younger players.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (27 Dec 2021 11.14am)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 27 Dec 21 11.14am

I think the suggestion that we cut our losses (whatever those are) are a bit premature.

Nobody knows how long Eze will take to get back to full fitness. Aside from Gallagher he remains our only serious goal threat not forgetting the chances he recently put on a plate for Edouard and Benteke.

A few weeks ago he got the goals that gave us back to back wins against City and Wolves.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (27 Dec 2021 11.16am)

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 27 Dec 21 11.21am


attacking players who try to dribble and keep the ball will always draw a lot of fouls.

the problem is that referees know that Wilf sulks and frowns. So they reward him very few fouls & punishments to the opposition.

the red card yesterday ? its been in the post for quite a while. There could be many more red cards. In which case, Wilf is a liability.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 27 Dec 21 11.26am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

He seemed Ok to me today, he was fouled constantly along with Ayew and the officials seemed to have much fun ignoring their plight as usual, he has always had issues with the abuse he receives and today was no worse, both bookings were completely over the top and unnecessary from a ref clearly out of his depth, red cards do nothing but destroy a competitive game for everyone watching and I feel the rules need to change by introducing the sin bin, why should the other ten players, management, staff and thousands of fans suffer from the actions of one individual who needs to be dealt with by an independent body who decide after watching the game again the proper punishment for them, this also includes players like Kane who get away with a red on the pitch only to find themselves being dealt with off it.


Before VAR, this is what the FA did, i believe they called it 'Retrospective Punishment' or trial by TV, of which Sky & the bbc took great delight in highlighting who they wanted punished after the match(es) had finished.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Dec 21 11.32am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I think the suggestion that we cut our losses (whatever those are) are a bit premature.

Nobody knows how long Eze will take to get back to full fitness. Aside from Gallagher he remains our only serious goal threat not forgetting the chances he recently put on a plate for Edouard and Benteke.

A few weeks ago he got the goals that gave us back to back wins against City and Wolves.

Fair enough but countless people on here said that we just HAD to retain Roy Hodgson as he was the only person who could keep us in the Premier League.

I genuinely believe he is now doing us more harm than good and persisting with him is holding us back in terms of finding an out and out replacement.

His best position for us currently probably is up front, all the while we persist with him on the left we are going to see more and more performances like yesterday.

Something is very wrong with him and I like so many others are just sick to death of it. Enough is enough…his pathetic attitude, awful performance and actions yesterday whilst on a yellow was almost as if he was totally disinterested and trying to get himself sent off. The bloke is the top earner at our club by a country mile and he is literally worth a third of what he is currently being paid.

As somebody else said earlier, Ferguson had this fantastic knack of knowing when to try something new with someone and when to simply move them on. I’d actually be relieved if someone took him off us in January.

 

hythemaceagle Flag Hythe Kent 27 Dec 21 12.19pm

Football is a team game, but I’m afraid to say that WZ is no longer a team player. The show of petulance yesterday was just mind boggling, and the Red Card was totally predictable. He gives little or nothing to CPFC anymore. He’s over the hill in my opinion, and deep down he knows it.
So, I think he should man up for once, grow a pair, buy himself out of his contract, and go find a club that will tolerate his moronic antics and pay him the crazy amount of wages that he’s on now. This player has completely gone down in my estimations and I would be delighted to see him walk. I would imagine that PV was disgusted with him yesterday.
Rant over!

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Dec 21 12.23pm

Originally posted by MR100%

Last few games Wilf has looked totally unsettled, hasn't beaten anyone or really tried to take anyone on,and, whilst the first incident today didn't warrant a booking, he must realise that he can't behave as he did, particularly, as Moss clearly doesn't like him

Going off to the African Nations Cup may help him ,but also help Viera understand what our best team is without him

Trouble is our best team without him is currently isolating!

 

A89M Flag Streatham 27 Dec 21 12.23pm

There's no loyalty in football eh..

May I remind everyone that Wilf is still our second top goalscorer this season behind the phenomenon that is Conor Gallagher. Wilf may not be the winger who takes players on anymore but he is still the most impactful player that is under contract by Crystal Palace. Take CG away next season and Wilf is back to being our best.

Rewind back to the home game against Spurs and you'll see Wilf do the very same thing he did yesterday, he stayed on the pitch and he went on to play a huge part in winning us the game.

His theatrics are what makes him the player he is, he gets worked up and seems to play better, we've all seen this work in our favour in many games, unfortunately it did not yesterday, that's football. That's 2 reds in 262 PL games, where he's been kicked from pillar to post.. Get a grip guys..

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 27 Dec 21 12.28pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Fair enough but countless people on here said that we just HAD to retain Roy Hodgson as he was the only person who could keep us in the Premier League.

I genuinely believe he is now doing us more harm than good and persisting with him is holding us back in terms of finding an out and out replacement.

His best position for us currently probably is up front, all the while we persist with him on the left we are going to see more and more performances like yesterday.

Something is very wrong with him and I like so many others are just sick to death of it. Enough is enough…his pathetic attitude, awful performance and actions yesterday whilst on a yellow was almost as if he was totally disinterested and trying to get himself sent off. The bloke is the top earner at our club by a country mile and he is literally worth a third of what he is currently being paid.

As somebody else said earlier, Ferguson had this fantastic knack of knowing when to try something new with someone and when to simply move them on. I’d actually be relieved if someone took him off us in January.

One for the club psychologist. All I know is that a narcissist likes to be the centre of attention, and at one stage in Zaha's Palace career he was just that, so much so that he got ahead of himself and erroneously thought he was Champions League material.
The end line is he requested a transfer and we should have let him go then while the going was good.
As a contrast watch Saka's performance for Arsenal - team player, scores goals, got a few tricks in his locker, good alround attitude.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 27 Dec 21 12.33pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

One for the club psychologist. All I know is that a narcissist likes to be the centre of attention, and at one stage in Zaha's Palace career he was just that, so much so that he got ahead of himself and erroneously thought he was Champions League material.
The end line is he requested a transfer and we should have let him go then while the going was good.
As a contrast watch Saka's performance for Arsenal - team player, scores goals, got a few tricks in his locker, good alround attitude.

Raised through Arsenal's and England's youth system that NOW breeds grounding. No prima donnas. Zaha, on the other hand, was a child with posters of him all over South London saying "he's just to good for you".

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Dec 21 2.04pm

Originally posted by A89M

There's no loyalty in football eh..

May I remind everyone that Wilf is still our second top goalscorer this season behind the phenomenon that is Conor Gallagher. Wilf may not be the winger who takes players on anymore but he is still the most impactful player that is under contract by Crystal Palace. Take CG away next season and Wilf is back to being our best.

Rewind back to the home game against Spurs and you'll see Wilf do the very same thing he did yesterday, he stayed on the pitch and he went on to play a huge part in winning us the game.

His theatrics are what makes him the player he is, he gets worked up and seems to play better, we've all seen this work in our favour in many games, unfortunately it did not yesterday, that's football. That's 2 reds in 262 PL games, where he's been kicked from pillar to post.. Get a grip guys..

You are in a small crowd of cheerleaders here. Sorry, but his theatrics are a benefit to neither himself or his team. He needs to sort himself out or go.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 27 Dec 21 2.09pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Fair enough but countless people on here said that we just HAD to retain Roy Hodgson as he was the only person who could keep us in the Premier League.

I genuinely believe he is now doing us more harm than good and persisting with him is holding us back in terms of finding an out and out replacement.

His best position for us currently probably is up front, all the while we persist with him on the left we are going to see more and more performances like yesterday.

Something is very wrong with him and I like so many others are just sick to death of it. Enough is enough…his pathetic attitude, awful performance and actions yesterday whilst on a yellow was almost as if he was totally disinterested and trying to get himself sent off. The bloke is the top earner at our club by a country mile and he is literally worth a third of what he is currently being paid.

As somebody else said earlier, Ferguson had this fantastic knack of knowing when to try something new with someone and when to simply move them on. I’d actually be relieved if someone took him off us in January.

I don't intend to re-ignite the Roy debate but I don't recall anyone saying we had to keep him to stay in the division.

Anyway Zaha has been on the way down for a while IMO but the bar was high and that doesn't stop him from being an asset to the team. I suspect this and his failure to have got the big move move may be at the root of his frustration.

I agree that he looks more effective as an inside forward and his performances this season have been inconsistent but comparisons with Ferguson and Man Utds ability to source replacements are nonsense to be honest.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Dec 21 2.44pm

No comparison whatsoever with Ferguson’s / United ability to source replacements. If you re-read my post it was about his uncanny knack to spot when someone needed moving on, that’s all.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 27 Dec 21 2.47pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I don't intend to re-ignite the Roy debate but I don't recall anyone saying we had to keep him to stay in the division.

Anyway Zaha has been on the way down for a while IMO but the bar was high and that doesn't stop him from being an asset to the team. I suspect this and his failure to have got the big move move may be at the root of his frustration.

I agree that he looks more effective as an inside forward and his performances this season have been inconsistent but comparisons with Ferguson and Man Utds ability to source replacements are nonsense to be honest.

He got his big move, he went to Man Utd for heavens sake!

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 27 Dec 21 3.09pm

Earlier in the season I thought we were seeing a new Wilf as for a few games he gave off a positive attitude and looked really up for it. He now seems to have reverted to type, and, temperament wise, it is hard to see him changing his ways at this stage of his career.

A couple of other points ... we often talk as if there was some heyday when Wilf was constantly on top of his game. In truth I don't think he has ever been reliably consistent. If one was to plough back through the history of Wilf threads, in amongst the eulogies, I suspect you'd also find plenty of debate about his temperament, application and lack of contribution in certain games.

I definitely recall a time when a lot of posters were of the opinion that Yannick Bolasie was the better player.

There have of course been plenty of magic moments from Wilf and this makes it easy to forget his downtime. And, statistics do suggest that we have struggled to win games without him in the side. So, I am not damning the fella, but just trying to keep hold of reality and remember that some of the criticisms we are throwing in his direction now are anything but new.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 28 Dec 21 1.20am


in the recent past, our statistics for wins were starkly different a) with zaha and b) without.


football is constantly putting theories to the test. We will beat Norwich...... but lets keep an open mind for games thereafter.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 3 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf