You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson to stay
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson to stay


Page 3 of 41 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 16 May 23 1.55pm

Assuming it happens, and you would have to assume he is planning for it, at some Parish will have to push the button on the stadium build. That will then commit the club & owners to a risky period of high capital spend & disruption. He must be thinking he would love the club to be stable going into & through that period until the build is finished. He’s probably take that stability over any European involvement during that time. Appointing Roy feels like the first stage in achieving that. If it works out I wouldn’t be surprised to see Roy given even longer. If it doesn’t work out he can get someone else in at any time.

 

PatrickA Flag London 16 May 23 2.41pm

The reasons I’ve seen for Roy not staying are,

1) his age
2) not forward thinking in terms of planning for the future
3) the stodgy football played at the end of his last tenure

To these reasons I would counter,

1) he enjoys robust health, is mentally alert, retains his enthusiasm and is still more involved in day to day coaching than many other younger managers.

2) what constitutes planning in modern football?
At the beginning of this season Vieira was seen as the future for us but come February that looked more of a forlorn hope than a reality.
Brighton had Potter and all his staff which was all part of their long term plan at the beginning of the season, but then Chelsea came and poached not only Potter but most of his staff. Now fortunately for them that seems to have worked out with the new manager, but if he continues on his current trajectory he won’t be there long with higher teams beckoning.
The point I’m making is that upheaval is part of the modern game with a revolving door for managers.
You can make longer terms plan around e.g the academy, transfer strategy, ground development but not on the certain duration of a manager’s tenure.
With the above in mind Roy seems a highly credible candidate for at least the next season.

3) I was a big critic of Roy at the end of his last spell with the stagnant football.
However, in fairness once he’s had the talent (Cabaye, RLC, Eze, Olise) he has demonstrated that he does not stifle talent but positively encourages it.
Under Vieira the assumption was that the squad wasn’t good enough or didn’t run enough as the games without efforts on goals or getting players in the box mounted up.
The same squad is giving a lie to this assumption as Roy and the coaching team have transformed our play with a far more positive approach and no more possession for possession’s sake in our own half which was frequently the case under Vieira.

In summary it’s less of a risk to stay with Hodgson than take a punt on an unknown overseas manager unfamiliar with our players or the Premier League.
Moreover, there could even be an upside if the current players continue to flourish under Roy and we strengthen in a couple of areas.

 

PJEagle Flag London 16 May 23 2.50pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I don't think that Wilf will stay unless he can't get decent money elsewhere.
If he stays I think it would be a massive benefit to the club and the younger players in my opinion.
I would prefer we went down the slightly untested route as long as they have sound coaching skills - let Roy stay and be the man manager.

He's beginning to look injury prone. Other clubs might be less interested?

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 May 23 2.53pm

Originally posted by PJEagle

He's beginning to look injury prone. Other clubs might be less interested?

Almost seems as though the deal with his maker was 'You'll be absolutely fine and extremely resilient in your best years however will fall apart quite quickly and dramatically after 30'.

Unfortunately he may not have factored this into his career pathway.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 May 23 3.07pm

Parish thinking, we'll employ Roy and not buy anyone.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 16 May 23 4.11pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I would have mixed feelings if Roy were to stay on. He has done a fantastic job in digging us out of a hole, but I would worry that he may not be able to keep this momentum going. Two years ago he rightly considered it was time to move on, and I wonder if he really has the stomach for a another full season with all its trials and tribulations.

I just feel that keeping Roy for another year would be treading water and putting off the search for someone new, something that will inevitably have to happen sooner or later.

But of course there would have to be some suitable candidates available for the role. I wonder how willing Parish is to again risk appointing a manager with little or no PL experience. Previous out-of-the-box punts have given us DeBoer (a disaster) and Viera (ultimately falling short).

So I wouldn't be at all surprised if caution wins over and Roy was offered another year.

I completely agree. I'm in the 'I want a new manager camp' for the main reason that another season of Roy is just kicking the can down the road.

In Rogers and Potter there are a couple of good managers out of work and then add to that list a few of the good ones in Holland and Germany linked. That 'feel' more ambitious.

But hey, Roy has an infinitely better team than he did before, and the players seam to be responding to him. So there is no reason to think that the form wont continue into next season

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 May 23 4.27pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I completely agree. I'm in the 'I want a new manager camp' for the main reason that another season of Roy is just kicking the can down the road.

In Rogers and Potter there are a couple of good managers out of work and then add to that list a few of the good ones in Holland and Germany linked. That 'feel' more ambitious.

But hey, Roy has an infinitely better team than he did before, and the players seam to be responding to him. So there is no reason to think that the form wont continue into next season

I think in some sort of way I agree Robbo.

Hodgson for me represents something I instinctively view as quite static - we are all braced for that we have seen before and whilst perhaps not wildly ambitious is far less likely to spell disaster. He therefore represents safety for me but nothing glamorous.

With this squad and God forbid some ambition reflected through investment you never know. So the dream is for a inspired new manager to come in, revolutionise and take us forward however Roy may bring some progression but definitely insurance against worse case scenario.

I'm therefore content with Roy unless a well researched and concocted plan is in place for something else.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

TheBigToePunt Flag 16 May 23 4.45pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

The reasons I’ve seen for Roy not staying are,

1) his age
2) not forward thinking in terms of planning for the future
3) the stodgy football played at the end of his last tenure

To these reasons I would counter,

1) he enjoys robust health, is mentally alert, retains his enthusiasm and is still more involved in day to day coaching than many other younger managers.

2) what constitutes planning in modern football?
At the beginning of this season Vieira was seen as the future for us but come February that looked more of a forlorn hope than a reality.
Brighton had Potter and all his staff which was all part of their long term plan at the beginning of the season, but then Chelsea came and poached not only Potter but most of his staff. Now fortunately for them that seems to have worked out with the new manager, but if he continues on his current trajectory he won’t be there long with higher teams beckoning.
The point I’m making is that upheaval is part of the modern game with a revolving door for managers.
You can make longer terms plan around e.g the academy, transfer strategy, ground development but not on the certain duration of a manager’s tenure.
With the above in mind Roy seems a highly credible candidate for at least the next season.

3) I was a big critic of Roy at the end of his last spell with the stagnant football.
However, in fairness once he’s had the talent (Cabaye, RLC, Eze, Olise) he has demonstrated that he does not stifle talent but positively encourages it.
Under Vieira the assumption was that the squad wasn’t good enough or didn’t run enough as the games without efforts on goals or getting players in the box mounted up.
The same squad is giving a lie to this assumption as Roy and the coaching team have transformed our play with a far more positive approach and no more possession for possession’s sake in our own half which was frequently the case under Vieira.

In summary it’s less of a risk to stay with Hodgson than take a punt on an unknown overseas manager unfamiliar with our players or the Premier League.
Moreover, there could even be an upside if the current players continue to flourish under Roy and we strengthen in a couple of areas.

I think you are spot on regarding the fools gold of long-term planning built around 'The One'; a manager that will, all by themselves, take the club to the fabled 'next level'.

Our long-term planning as a club is done by the Chairman who, lest we forget, stabilized the club financially (more than many have managed), reunited the club and ground, bought and developed the training ground, then the academy, and will doubtless build the new stand in the end. These are all things he explained to be pillars of his long-term plan at the outset.

Our medium-term planning as a team is done by the DoF. Our 'managers' are just coaches. They do not sign or sell players, they do not offer or withhold contracts, and they do not shape direction. They pick the team and the tactics from the set of players the club provides.

I don't see any reason why Roy can't do a decent job for another year, or why we need to get, or should even be hoping for, a three or four year-long stewardship from our next manager. That's not how the club is set up nowadays.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (16 May 2023 4.51pm)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 16 May 23 5.12pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Frank, De Zerbi? Two of the best in the league and untried until they arrived. A good manager is a good manager, simple as that.

Both had proper CVs, McCarthy does not have anything serious to recommend him as a PL manager. Doesn't mean it's beyond him, but it's wild to suggest it's not a crazy punt.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 May 23 5.20pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Our medium-term planning as a team is done by the DoF. Our 'managers' are just coaches. They do not sign or sell players, they do not offer or withhold contracts, and they do not shape direction. They pick the team and the tactics from the set of players the club provides.

If that is how the job is being sold to prospective managers I doubt whether any half decent manager would join us

 

beak Flag croydon 16 May 23 5.45pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I think that this would be a mistake.
We will be back into survival mode and without Wilf - it will be dull and not pretty because I cannot see him unleashing this lot again over the period of a season.
Also - an old man on a one year contract will not attract and new players to the club - I wouldn't have thought anyway.
He should leave at the end of this season with his head held very high.

Roy is highly regarded by most people in the game,he has worked miracles over the last few weeks with what was a goal shy team ,remember? Age is NOT a disqualifier for office Joe Biden is running the World's biggest country.New young players such as Eze will flock to come and tap in to Roy's outstanding knowledge of football.You post was well wide of the mark!

 

eaglesdare Flag 16 May 23 5.47pm

Originally posted by beak

Roy is highly regarded by most people in the game,he has worked miracles over the last few weeks with what was a goal shy team ,remember? Age is NOT a disqualifier for office Joe Biden is running the World's biggest country.New young players such as Eze will flock to come and tap in to Roy's outstanding knowledge of football.You post was well wide of the mark!

Using sleepy joe as an example does not fill me with any confidence.

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 16 May 23 6.24pm

Fine

So Steve / Doug don’t f him around this time

Get him the players !

If he is extended build a squad not a reason to sack him by Jan ok

 


Forever Palace Proud

samprior Flag Hamburg 16 May 23 7.12pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Both had proper CVs, McCarthy does not have anything serious to recommend him as a PL manager. Doesn't mean it's beyond him, but it's wild to suggest it's not a crazy punt.

De Zerbi had a reasonable CV but wasn't Frank just the assistant before he got the full time gig when Dean Smith left brentford for villa?

 

beak Flag croydon 16 May 23 7.12pm

Originally posted by eaglesdare

Using sleepy joe as an example does not fill me with any confidence.

The American electorate voted him in as they thought more of him than Trump,Good enough for me.

 

SarfNorwoodAl Flag South Norwood 16 May 23 7.18pm

What a wonderful chairman Mr Parish is. Brings back the same bloke as permanent manager who he got rid of 2 years ago. This will end in tears and he will have to sack him sometime next year you watch. It worked this time as it was for 10 games. Having Roy back for a whole pre season and 38 games next season the players will get bored of his tactics by Xmas you mark my words.

Parish will do another u turn and have to sack him in 2024 you watch it will happen 100%.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 May 23 7.20pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops



Frank, De Zerbi? Two of the best in the league and untried until
they arrived. A good manager is a good manager, simple as that.

Before Thomas Frank arrived at Brentford as Asst Head Coach to Dean Smith he had been manager of Brondby and Brentford were not in the PL at that time.He was Assistant for some 2 years before he was appointed manager.

De Zerbi has managed clubs in Serie A and was manager of Shakhtar Donetsk before he was appointed Brighton manager.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 16 May 23 7.26pm

Originally posted by SarfNorwoodAl

What a wonderful chairman Mr Parish is. Brings back the same bloke as permanent manager who he got rid of 2 years ago. This will end in tears and he will have to sack him sometime next year you watch. It worked this time as it was for 10 games. Having Roy back for a whole pre season and 38 games next season the players will get bored of his tactics by Xmas you mark my words.

Parish will do another u turn and have to sack him in 2024 you watch it will happen 100%.

Steve Parish did not show Mr Hodgson the door.
Mr Hodgson himself decided that after several years of managing and coaching the time was right for him to step away from the rigours of top-flight Premier League and the football responsibilities of being a full-time manager.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 16 May 23 7.35pm

Originally posted by SarfNorwoodAl

What a wonderful chairman Mr Parish is. Brings back the same bloke as permanent manager who he got rid of 2 years ago. This will end in tears and he will have to sack him sometime next year you watch. It worked this time as it was for 10 games. Having Roy back for a whole pre season and 38 games next season the players will get bored of his tactics by Xmas you mark my words.

Parish will do another u turn and have to sack him in 2024 you watch it will happen 100%.

Complete Hogwash

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 16 May 23 7.35pm

Originally posted by beak

Roy is highly regarded by most people in the game,he has worked miracles over the last few weeks with what was a goal shy team ,remember? Age is NOT a disqualifier for office Joe Biden is running the World's biggest country.New young players such as Eze will flock to come and tap in to Roy's outstanding knowledge of football.You post was well wide of the mark!

Excellent post.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Page 3 of 41 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson to stay