You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > "The Trouble With Socialism ..... Other people's m
November 21 2026 9.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

"The Trouble With Socialism ..... Other people's m


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Glazier#1 Flag 11 Sep 23 11.17pm

Phew! Lol

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 11 Sep 23 11.25pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

True, Ted, but there is another, crucial 'but'.

But the Tories took all the money they got from council house sales and put not a penny of it into building new ones. Why? Because they knew that many of the less well-off workers lived in council houses.

It was part of the plan to emasculate the unions: if strikers were council renters, they could strike and get behind on the rent without being evicted. If they had mortgages, their house would be repossessed. So,- get rid of council houses, make this country a 'property owning democracy' and cut the workers' ability to strike. Neat. Until we look at the property market today. Ray! Another of Maggie's crowning achievements is shown to be just wrong.

Sorry, is this me talking the usual Wicked -Tory leftish crap?

Seems a convoluted solution.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 11 Sep 23 11.35pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Seems a convoluted solution.

Haha, I know what you mean.

Not a solution in itself but part of a design to change the way the country was run and to change people's attitudes. "No such thing as society" is another famous catchphrase that encapsulates the idea that the state shouldn't provide everything and we should be more self-reliant, doesn't it?

So selling off council houses adhered to that philosophy too, crucially. It also offered, at the same stroke, a chance to help castrate the unions. Nice and tidy.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Sep 23 11.47pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Well, I was hoping to draw out a response where we might be a little more nuanced about the subject. The question was rhetorical, really.

Since the days of the workhouse there's been a tension between aid for the needy and accusations of feckless laziness.

Anyway, I wasn't really wanting the thread to veer off the original point about that old, famous saying.

Trouble is, no-one's actually written what they think about how the video refutes the 'truism'.

The video seems to show that all these years that old truism about the Labour party being the party of tax, tax, tax is not a fair conclusion. Not only do the Tories tax more, they spend less at the same time. Blimey!

Edited by Glazier#1 (11 Sep 2023 10.27pm)

There is a difference between need and want. Got no problem with those that need help getting that help. Got a massive issue with those who want and know how to get what they want. Ironically it’s the wants who help reduce what the needs get. Unfortunately any changes to try to get the wants out of the system will inadvertently capture a small amount of the needs. Then the media and other t***s get involved so the issue will never be solved as the change is reversed because innocents are caught up in the net. I don’t claim any, not that I might need to one day so not sure how welfare rolls tbh. Also it was a safety net; now it’s a way of life for maybe millions.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 11 Sep 23 11.57pm

Originally posted by cryrst

There is a difference between need and want. Got no problem with those that need help getting that help. Got a massive issue with those who want and know how to get what they want. Ironically it’s the wants who help reduce what the needs get. Unfortunately any changes to try to get the wants out of the system will inadvertently capture a small amount of the needs. Then the media and other t***s get involved so the issue will never be solved as the change is reversed because innocents are caught up in the net. I don’t claim any, not that I might need to one day so not sure how welfare rolls tbh. Also it was a safety net; now it’s a way of life for maybe millions.

Yes, I know what you mean and the balance is difficult to manage effectively.

The answer will come when we learn to balance need and incentive.

Anyway, did you watch the link? I thought I'd put it up to get some rock-hard responses to the point being made in the vid. So far, I have to say, I've had no joy. An enjoyable ride but not really what I had hoped for.

Thanks for the response: a good read.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 12 Sep 23 12.31am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Haha, I know what you mean.

Not a solution in itself but part of a design to change the way the country was run and to change people's attitudes. "No such thing as society" is another famous catchphrase that encapsulates the idea that the state shouldn't provide everything and we should be more self-reliant, doesn't it?

So selling off council houses adhered to that philosophy too, crucially. It also offered, at the same stroke, a chance to help castrate the unions. Nice and tidy.

You could be right but our governments have generally been more likely to **** up a two car funeral than see such a Machiavellian plan through to successful completion.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 12 Sep 23 6.56am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

What?!

Well, I never.

Perhaps we should float them all on a barge off the Dorset coast?

good idea !

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 12 Sep 23 7.27am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

** That looks like you're angry with me. ** I didn't mean to offend, Mr Norman.

I posted the video in order to discuss whether that age old saying about the left spending other's money was valid.

At least we are shown his opinion, supported by evidence, that the old saying appears not only to be false but, in fact, the opposite applies.

If you call that 'crap', it's up to you, of course but I should add that merely throwing insults at something/someone doesn't make them wrong.

I'm not angry with you or offended, Mr Glazier. It's like when Jehovah's Witnesses present their solutions, you just wonder how people can be so deluded.

Edited by georgenorman (12 Sep 2023 7.33am)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 12 Sep 23 7.54am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Yes, I know what you mean and the balance is difficult to manage effectively.

The answer will come when we learn to balance need and incentive.

Anyway, did you watch the link? I thought I'd put it up to get some rock-hard responses to the point being made in the vid. So far, I have to say, I've had no joy. An enjoyable ride but not really what I had hoped for.

Thanks for the response: a good read.

I didn’t watch the link. I have my opinions on how it is and my eyes don’t fib. Collateral damage for the better good does happen and a huge majority of the time it works, or worked. Nowadays perfection is sought as a resolution to a problem. The social as it was, is abused and abused but cannot be changed because of the above. Like the NHS the welfare state is too big to fail and too big to succeed. Although my recent NHS experience has been brilliant and I’m nearly better. And I’m sure the good stories about both of the above outweigh the bad by a massive margin; but that’s not news is it ?

 

Glazier#1 Flag 12 Sep 23 9.54am

Originally posted by cryrst

I didn’t watch the link. I have my opinions on how it is and my eyes don’t fib. Collateral damage for the better good does happen and a huge majority of the time it works, or worked. Nowadays perfection is sought as a resolution to a problem. The social as it was, is abused and abused but cannot be changed because of the above. Like the NHS the welfare state is too big to fail and too big to succeed. Although my recent NHS experience has been brilliant and I’m nearly better. And I’m sure the good stories about both of the above outweigh the bad by a massive margin; but that’s not news is it ?

What a shame. I know you think you 'know' but what harm to watch a 10 minute clip, eh?

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 12 Sep 23 10.05am

Socialism is driven by envy and hatred. It's like a fella going nuts cos another fella has a prettier wife. Which is, of course, simply the way of the World. One can hate it or one can accept it. A Champions League striker will have a nicer car & wife than everybody else.

Socialism is also driven by people rights.....but with no regard to their duties. 'i am entitled to a roof over my head'.....regardless of whether i behave like a t0sser in all the rest of my life. Refusing to work, choosing to party and generally behave like a loser.

the net result : Socialism makes everybody poorer and eradicates the work-ethic.

When you mix all this into Lefties insistence on opening up the Borders to legions of military-age men....the final outcome is anarchy.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Glazier#1 Flag 12 Sep 23 10.16am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Socialism is driven by envy and hatred. It's like a fella going nuts cos another fella has a prettier wife. Which is, of course, simply the way of the World. One can hate it or one can accept it. A Champions League striker will have a nicer car & wife than everybody else.

Socialism is also driven by people rights.....but with no regard to their duties. 'i am entitled to a roof over my head'.....regardless of whether i behave like a t0sser in all the rest of my life. Refusing to work, choosing to party and generally behave like a loser.

the net result : Socialism makes everybody poorer and eradicates the work-ethic.

When you mix all this into Lefties insistence on opening up the Borders to legions of military-age men....the final outcome is anarchy.


All this thread was meant to be about was to watch the video and discuss the presenter's claim. People can't even be bothered to do that which, I think, tells me enough.

Now look what's happened.


Sorry, can't be doing with EDL talk, Cristallo.

I'm out.

Edited by Glazier#1 (12 Sep 2023 10.20am)

Edited by Glazier#1 (12 Sep 2023 10.21am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 12 Sep 23 10.21am

Originally posted by Glazier#1


All this thread was meant to be about was to watch the video and discuss the presenter's claim. People can't even be bothered to do that which, I think, tells me enough.

Now look what's happened.


Sorry, can't be doing with EDL talk.

I'm out.

Edited by Glazier#1 (12 Sep 2023 10.20am)

Pleae don't feel obliged to come back in.

 

ouzo Flag Rafina 12 Sep 23 10.34am

I had a view of the link Glazier posted and it is, in my opinion, garbage.

To not take into consideration the dollar/GBP exchange rate in each year means you are never going to get anywhere near a close comparison. From my quick search I found that in 1974 the average rate of exchange was around 2.3, whereas 2022 was around 1.2. This vastly alters the results presented. Generally, form my calculations, all years were vey close from 29 - 33%.

there is no other factors taken into account, like government borrowing or selling off assets (e.g. gold reserves) to pay for any government spending.

As I said, garbage.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 12 Sep 23 10.47am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Pleae don't feel obliged to come back in.

Haha, I might have known you'd turn up, eventually, to contribute your usual, helpful and open-minded pen'orth. Your response is the only thing you've contributed: that's about right haha.

Of course, the sentiment just about sums up the temperature here with some people.

Thanks for taking the trouble to respond, Ouzo; you are the only person who's taken the trouble to watch, consider and respond to the clip.

I did wonder about the exchange rate question but wondered whether he'd done his sums and taken that into consideration.

I have absolutely no problem with you making your comments. I see them as healthy and part and parcel of proper discussion.

You see, Hrolf, old boy: it's not difficult.

 

ouzo Flag Rafina 12 Sep 23 11.02am

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Haha, I might have known you'd turn up, eventually, to contribute your usual, helpful and open-minded pen'orth. Your response is the only thing you've contributed: that's about right haha.

Of course, the sentiment just about sums up the temperature here with some people.

Thanks for taking the trouble to respond, Ouzo; you are the only person who's taken the trouble to watch, consider and respond to the clip.

I did wonder about the exchange rate question but wondered whether he'd done his sums and taken that into consideration.

I have absolutely no problem with you making your comments. I see them as healthy and part and parcel of proper discussion.

You see, Hrolf, old boy: it's not difficult.

I believe he says that he ignored them as couldn't find accurate data, or some such remark. I say he ignored them as it didn't fit his agenda.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 12 Sep 23 11.08am

Government spending and taxation vary at different times and situations, there are all sorts of factors at play - for example, if the country is at war or there is a pandemic or other major events.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 12 Sep 23 11.37am

Originally posted by ouzo

I had a view of the link Glazier posted and it is, in my opinion, garbage.

To not take into consideration the dollar/GBP exchange rate in each year means you are never going to get anywhere near a close comparison. From my quick search I found that in 1974 the average rate of exchange was around 2.3, whereas 2022 was around 1.2. This vastly alters the results presented. Generally, form my calculations, all years were vey close from 29 - 33%.

there is no other factors taken into account, like government borrowing or selling off assets (e.g. gold reserves) to pay for any government spending.

As I said, garbage.

Are you saying that, from your calculations, there's hardly any difference between the parties?

 

ouzo Flag Rafina 12 Sep 23 12.04pm

Originally posted by Glazier#1

Are you saying that, from your calculations, there's hardly any difference between the parties?

I am not a mathematician so my quick calculation could well be wrong, but, without checking who was in government, the range was as stated. I don't think you could say a 4% difference was significant.
To have a comprehensive overview you'd also need to take into account every year as only looking at years where there was a change in government will always skew the results, as there are quite often taxation changes designed to stay in power.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 12 Sep 23 12.20pm

Cheers, Ouzo.

Good luck

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > "The Trouble With Socialism ..... Other people's m