You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 4.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 329 of 753 < 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 20 10.36am

Originally posted by Badger11

Public Health England a complete disaster but blame Matt Hancock not the people who run it and advise the government.

Exam results a complete disaster but its the Minster's fault not the people who advised we should use an algorithm that doesn't work.

When are Civil Servants going to be accountable? In the real world they would be sacked.

It doesn't mater which party is in power Ministers rely on the Civil Servants and yet they seem immune from criticism.

Of course Ministers have to take political responsibility but does anyone believe that Gavin Williamson came up with the algorithm? Ofqual have a lot to answer for.


I have been trying to get the point across that SCS are to blame for a lot that goes on and indeed are, in general, not held accountable. Please note I did say SENIOR Civil Servants. You are correct it does not matter which party are in power, they all rely on SCS

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 21 Aug 20 10.59am

Scientists and Civil Servants are advisors. The political decisions are made by the government, and it is those in power who should be accountable.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 20 11.24am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Scientists and Civil Servants are advisors. The political decisions are made by the government, and it is those in power who should be accountable.

Yep the only one I can remember from the HO that was held accountable was Jackie Smith, who fell on her sword, after the Romanian/Bulgarian visa fiasco. Policies written by and implemented by SCS, who she presumably trusted, policies that were ridiculous and unworkable. TBF she took the wrap

 

becky Flag over the moon 21 Aug 20 12.39pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Public Health England a complete disaster but blame Matt Hancock not the people who run it and advise the government.

Exam results a complete disaster but its the Minster's fault not the people who advised we should use an algorithm that doesn't work.

When are Civil Servants going to be accountable? In the real world they would be sacked.

It doesn't mater which party is in power Ministers rely on the Civil Servants and yet they seem immune from criticism.

Of course Ministers have to take political responsibility but does anyone believe that Gavin Williamson came up with the algorithm? Ofqual have a lot to answer for.


In the Civil Service they are covered up for until they can retire with their gold plated pensions, lump sums and a knighthood to say 'thank you'

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 20 1.03pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Yep the only one I can remember from the HO that was held accountable was Jackie Smith, who fell on her sword, after the Romanian/Bulgarian visa fiasco. Policies written by and implemented by SCS, who she presumably trusted, policies that were ridiculous and unworkable. TBF she took the wrap

To repeat

Ministers are accountable. They have to make the decisions in the end otherwise what is the point in Governments. To do that they use special advisers as well as Civil Servants.

For information they spend at least £10m per year on that.

[Link]

The most expensive appears to be Lee Cain, a British former journalist who currently serves as Downing Street Director of Communications under Boris Johnson. I don't think anyone can claim the recent communications have worked well and I also don't think you can blame - or at least not exclusively - senior civil servants.

They also use a plethora of management consultants at vast cost. I know because I was involved in the restructuring of the MoD on more than one occasion. For example the Department of Health spent £12.4m in 2017/18. Preparing for Brexit has cost £97m in consultancy fees.

Forgive me, therefore, if I don't buy Mr Cummings' line that it's not the Government's fault when things go wrong but an endemic problem with the Civil Service. Or with SAGE. Or PHE. Or Ofqual.

[Link]

We have a bunch of little boys and one or two girls trying hard to do a grown-up job, but failing.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Aug 20 1.06pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

Scientists and Civil Servants are advisors. The political decisions are made by the government, and it is those in power who should be accountable.

SCS "Minister I suggest the government uses this algorithm to resolve the A level results issues."

Minister "Has this been thoroughly tested, what if it doesn't work they'll be hell to pay"

SCS "No problem we have crunched the numbers it will work"

Of course politicians are responsible for making decisions but they can only act on the advice they are given if it is bad advice shouldn't the advisor be accountable.

 


One more point

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 20 1.22pm

Originally posted by Badger11

SCS "Minister I suggest the government uses this algorithm to resolve the A level results issues."

Minister "Has this been thoroughly tested, what if it doesn't work they'll be hell to pay"

SCS "No problem we have crunched the numbers it will work"

Of course politicians are responsible for making decisions but they can only act on the advice they are given if it is bad advice shouldn't the advisor be accountable.

Nope

The Minister is accountable. A civil servant may be responsible. And almost certainly other advisers as well.

Looking at A levels, this has been made far worse by the removal of AS levels. Concerns were raised at the time:

[Link]

That was Michael Gove, who freely admitted he had taken advice from many sources. So not primarily civil servants.

If you take on a job as a leader you show leadership and it is your judgement that is key. End of.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 21 Aug 20 1.24pm


Judgment on this will have to wait, at least until the numbers have been confirmed. Let’s be honest, some places haven’t been entirely open about the number of deaths.
There aren’t many countries who’ve handled this particularly well. Germany’s figures are on the rise and Argentina, who were being praised for their response, experienced a record increase in cases on day 145 of a strict lockdown.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Aug 20 3.08pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Nope

The Minister is accountable. A civil servant may be responsible. And almost certainly other advisers as well.

Looking at A levels, this has been made far worse by the removal of AS levels. Concerns were raised at the time:

[Link]

That was Michael Gove, who freely admitted he had taken advice from many sources. So not primarily civil servants.

If you take on a job as a leader you show leadership and it is your judgement that is key. End of.

I don't accept that. Any decision can only be made on the evidence or advice that is available. If the person providing that is wrong then they have to accept some responsibility as well.

 


One more point

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Aug 20 3.24pm

Georgia State QB Mikele Colasurdo diagnosed with heart condition linked to COVID-19 - [Link]

More and more of these covid related heart issues coming up of late in otherwise fit and healthy individuals.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Aug 20 3.24pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


Judgment on this will have to wait, at least until the numbers have been confirmed. Let’s be honest, some places haven’t been entirely open about the number of deaths.
There aren’t many countries who’ve handled this particularly well. Germany’s figures are on the rise and Argentina, who were being praised for their response, experienced a record increase in cases on day 145 of a strict lockdown.

True, for all of the sometimes fair criticism, our numbers have remained pretty steady since opening back up and people appear to have achieved a sensible balance for now.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 20 3.33pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I don't accept that. Any decision can only be made on the evidence or advice that is available. If the person providing that is wrong then they have to accept some responsibility as well.

Yes, if they are wrong they should face the consequences. A good leader will deal with that. But not throw an underling under the bus. That is very bad leadership. THE BUCK STOPS HERE! Including dealing with underperformance of those that report in to the leader.

Or maybe you are one of those people that goes bleating to the CEO if you make a wrong decision due to poor performance from your direct reports. I do not, I take the hit for my team every time. But then, I am ruthless at moving on anyone that doesn't live up to my very high expectations.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 20 3.45pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

True, for all of the sometimes fair criticism, our numbers have remained pretty steady since opening back up and people appear to have achieved a sensible balance for now.

We are notifying at 13.1 per 100,000 in the UK for 14 day incidence reports. That is higher than 15 of the other EU and EEA countries but lower than 15. So bang in the middle. Luxembourg, Romania and Spain are way the worst. Sweden is at 30.7 by the way.

I am struggling to understand why we now appear to be performing at an average level when it was so poor early on. Maybe the policy really was one of herd immunity and we achieved some element of it. If so, at a pretty huge cost in lives up front. Had we really flattened the curve and now be having higher incident levels, at least we would have have learned much about how to cope with the disease and have a credible drug to help. Taking a big hit early on gave the medics little chance.

[Link]

Edited by Mapletree (21 Aug 2020 3.47pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Aug 20 3.51pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Yes, if they are wrong they should face the consequences. A good leader will deal with that. But not throw an underling under the bus. That is very bad leadership. THE BUCK STOPS HERE! Including dealing with underperformance of those that report in to the leader.

Or maybe you are one of those people that goes bleating to the CEO if you make a wrong decision due to poor performance from your direct reports. I do not, I take the hit for my team every time. But then, I am ruthless at moving on anyone that doesn't live up to my very high expectations.

I think we are arguing the same point I agree with that statement.

To labour my point SCS seem to be bullet proof they are rarely sacked for performance related issues unlike the private sector. I fully expect Gavin Williamson to be sacked at some point soon however I suspect that the SCS will still be there long after he is gone. SCS are like teachers they are rarely sacked for incompetence.

And for the record I was a senior manager and did take the heat for my own failings and my staff.

 


One more point

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 20 4.09pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think we are arguing the same point I agree with that statement.

To labour my point SCS seem to be bullet proof they are rarely sacked for performance related issues unlike the private sector. I fully expect Gavin Williamson to be sacked at some point soon however I suspect that the SCS will still be there long after he is gone. SCS are like teachers they are rarely sacked for incompetence.

And for the record I was a senior manager and did take the heat for my own failings and my staff.

Spot on about SCS

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 20 4.12pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

To repeat

Ministers are accountable. They have to make the decisions in the end otherwise what is the point in Governments. To do that they use special advisers as well as Civil Servants.

For information they spend at least £10m per year on that.

[Link]

The most expensive appears to be Lee Cain, a British former journalist who currently serves as Downing Street Director of Communications under Boris Johnson. I don't think anyone can claim the recent communications have worked well and I also don't think you can blame - or at least not exclusively - senior civil servants.

They also use a plethora of management consultants at vast cost. I know because I was involved in the restructuring of the MoD on more than one occasion. For example the Department of Health spent £12.4m in 2017/18. Preparing for Brexit has cost £97m in consultancy fees.

Forgive me, therefore, if I don't buy Mr Cummings' line that it's not the Government's fault when things go wrong but an endemic problem with the Civil Service. Or with SAGE. Or PHE. Or Ofqual.

[Link]

We have a bunch of little boys and one or two girls trying hard to do a grown-up job, but failing.

To repeat the only one I can remember being held accountable in my Department was Jackie Smith, didn’t say they shouldn’t be held accountable.
Boys and Girls! Bit of a patronising description of adults, still no surprise there.

Edited by Spiderman (21 Aug 2020 4.14pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Aug 20 4.49pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

To repeat the only one I can remember being held accountable in my Department was Jackie Smith, didn’t say they shouldn’t be held accountable.
Boys and Girls! Bit of a patronising description of adults, still no surprise there.

Edited by Spiderman (21 Aug 2020 4.14pm)

So which of the following would you term as a fully experienced and capable leader?

Boris Johnson
Rishi Sunak
Dominic Raab
Priti Patel
Matt Hancock
Liz Truss
Gavin Williamson
George Eustice
Robert Jenrick
Grant Shapps

I have left out Gove who is a weird Peter Pan figure and a bunch of people who don't have enough profile to know much about them.

To me, the Cabinet is just stuffed full of work experience people.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 21 Aug 20 5.30pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

So which of the following would you term as a fully experienced and capable leader?

Boris Johnson
Rishi Sunak
Dominic Raab
Priti Patel
Matt Hancock
Liz Truss
Gavin Williamson
George Eustice
Robert Jenrick
Grant Shapps

I have left out Gove who is a weird Peter Pan figure and a bunch of people who don't have enough profile to know much about them.

To me, the Cabinet is just stuffed full of work experience people.

They are so incompetent they fit the voters exactly.

After another two years of them, those of us left after covid will turn our taps on and find there is no water.

Ridiculous, no it is likely......

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 20 5.46pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

So which of the following would you term as a fully experienced and capable leader?

Boris Johnson
Rishi Sunak
Dominic Raab
Priti Patel
Matt Hancock
Liz Truss
Gavin Williamson
George Eustice
Robert Jenrick
Grant Shapps

I have left out Gove who is a weird Peter Pan figure and a bunch of people who don't have enough profile to know much about them.

To me, the Cabinet is just stuffed full of work experience people.

I cannot see the relevance of that question in reply to my post,

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Aug 20 5.46pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

They are so incompetent they fit the voters exactly.

After another two years of them, those of us left after covid will turn our taps on and find there is no water.

Ridiculous, no it is likely......

Ffs there are some very bitter posters on here

Edited by Spiderman (21 Aug 2020 5.47pm)

 

Page 329 of 753 < 325 326 327 328 329 330 331 332 333 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic