What's in it for Israel is peace. At the moment they spend huge amounts on weapons (although the US gives them 90% of them) and much of what could be there labour force is in the Army. If they are not actually at war they are getting ready for it, as well as the distortion of their society caused by oppressing millions of other people. A country which occupies others cannot itself be truly free.
At the moment they are like white South Africa, shunned by most of the rest of the world.
If they want to be a respected country like any other, they must stop their oppression.
Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Jul 2014 1.11pm
Quote davidpercival at 25 Jul 2014 12.53pm
Stirling (Correctly spelt I trust) - As you have raised a new topic, I think that breaches our ceasefire agreement and I can comment.
Let me get this right. You admit the Israeli settlements are illegal yet you say they can only be expected to give them up as part of a legal process?
Yes.....The realistic alternative being?
Quote davidpercival at 25 Jul 2014 12.53pm
It is rather as if you got mugged in the street and the thief said you can only get your property back if you take it through the Courts and you will have to make concessions to do it?
If someone mugs you in the street then unless you can win that property back there and then yes.....The only way you get it back is through the courts.
Whether or not there will be concessions on the illegal settlements is a matter for negotiations on the two state solution.
A two state solution would involve transitional wars within both states to implement it......The moderates within both states would have to fight and beat their own to implement it.
It is the only way.
Quote davidpercival at 25 Jul 2014 12.53pm
I think all this defending Israel is causing you to lose contact with rational thinking. Surely the starting point is Israel saying they will give up the stolen land and that they are prepared to negotiate ordinary relations between states with whatever government the Palestinian people chose to elect.
And the motivation for Israel to do that is?
There is no point giving land and a state back to an enemy which is dedicated to wiping you out....Has a constitution that says it is at war and continually fires rockets....Any break being only an opportunity to grow stronger.
Sorry.....tell me what's in it for Israel?
If someone declares permanent war on you do you treat them fairly and enable them to grow stronger then?
Any peace with the Palestinians cannot involve Hamas.....The right in Israel only have power from the ballot box....Israel's constitution means peace is possible.....Hamas's doesn't.
Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Jul 2014 1.13pm)