This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I guess that's because the deaths haven't yet happened. There is obviously a time lag between infection and death. What the impact of the greater understanding and more effective treatments will be on the number of deaths I don't think is known yet either. What is known is the infection rate increasing and that's enough. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (16 Oct 2020 10.28pm) But the virus has never gone away. Why not report the daily/monthly excess deaths. If it is that deadly, there will be excess deaths all the time the virus exists. Regardless of any measures. Where are they? If treatments are better or not, and there are no excess deaths, why have further lockdowns? If there are excess deaths, they would be broadcast loud to justify lockdowns.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
That's incorrect. I label people who claim the government wants to vaccinate us to "chip us" or to "ensure conformity" as conspiracy theorists. And from there inaccuracies branch out to an overly simplified idea that (flu) vaccines are 'useless and harmful' by supplying incomplete information on the topic, and being attacked for posting a far more comprehensive and balances view. My overriding take is that people are perfectly able to have a view on government approach, without adopting an unbelievably slanted take across the board that I can only assume they feel absolves them of any responsibility or impact of their own stance. Whatever decisions are made are going to be worse than the status quo and so there will be no there's destined to be no shortage of blame. It may well be that the eventual impact of lockdowns and measures causes more damage than harm of the virus itself and I've said absolutely nothing that criticises that take. We can of course factor in that initially we didn't know what we were dealing with, whereas now we know more and have better treatments, and so I have sympathy for the views of cities under measures now. Just as I do those concerned that the situation might get worse (though I did highlight that deaths might be less alarmist metric to get behind, rather than case count, which was likely vastly higher than it is now earlier in the year). But regardless of what people think of the government approach, it pays to have an outlook of the virus itself, treatments and of individual takes that offer a degree of balance and takes on board information from multiple perspectives rather than adopt a skewed conclusion and spends all day hunting for information that supports it. I'm not the one on here wagging my finger at people who shield if they need to or have a degree of social life if they don't. I'm criticising those who ignore anything that is contrary to their comfort blanket. When you start getting people with X-Files like takes on vaccines, or denying numbers only in ways that's convenient to their outlook while ignoring everything else, and mocking vulnerable people holding out hope for vaccines then yes I'll speak up about those things.
Just a thought here, not critisism. You talk a lot about "holding out hope for vaccines". How long do you think is reasonable to wait for one that might work? And if it is available next week, do you think it is reasonable for people to refuse it as it has had no real testing? Becky brought up this subject earlier, but I'm not sure that you understand the implications of untested "miracle drugs". Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (17 Oct 2020 9.23pm)
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It's not forever and that really is the point. I'm of the opinion that this is a novel virus. It is highly contagious, and will likely kill old and vulnerable people. There will be exceptions, as there always is in any situation, regardless of what is being discussed. People smoke 40 fags a day and live to 102. It proves nothing about lung cancer. What I take issue with is this desire to shut down normal life to save a minority. This will be looked back upon as a massive self destruction. The economy is effectively screwed. You harp on about the 80's, (I lost a business then by the way), and how it bounced back, but we still had a fair amount of industry back then. Not now. Globalisation was a glimmer in the eye of corporations then. It's reality now. Small business will not come back if it goes under now. The big guys just move in and corner off everything. So, I'm fine meeting Joe Public, and letting us all try and live individual lives, and have small businesses, not corporate, unfulfilling jobs for the wealthy.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
The death rate dropped so much over the summer that any excess would be lost in natural statistical variation and nothing of value could be learned. Now that the infection rate is rising again so quickly such a statistic will doubtless become useful again, but it's meaningless at the moment. What will be most valuable is to determine how effective the treatments now are and how much these modify the infection to death ratio. So excess deaths matter if they are high, but not if they are low. I get your thinking. Crikey! You are something special.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
That in itself is a simplification, but I'm happy to answer. I've said that I see little point in those in non at risk groups waiting for a vaccine to live as normal life as is possible, because they likely won't be impacted by covid-19 in any meaningful way anyway. For those in genuinely vulnerable groups though and seriously knocking on in years, I can well understand why they might have reasonably been extra careful. My point is, with stage 3 results for various vaccines being released within the next couple of months, if they are positive I can well understand why many would elect to be first in line. Yes, it's not risk free, but then for some neither is covid-19. It would of course be reasonable to refuse it, just as it would be reasonable and probably sensible for many to have it. For some it could potentially be their route back to a normal life. Edited by BlueJay (17 Oct 2020 9.37pm) So, if it kills them in a slow and painful manner, because it had a fatal flaw, is ok?
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Shall we all have a virtual hug? ‘In a socially distanced way?’
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
What insults? Questioning my numeracy skills. You do it to other posters too. And not just numeracy. It's a form of bullying. Behaving in a haughty, I know better than you manner. It really doesn't bother me as you clearly don't. I just think you should stop with the petty snipes. It's detracting from debate.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Sorry about your business and I lost my home. I’m not sure about that. If there’s still a virus, masks, unemployment, working from home, habit of eating at home or buying everything at the supermarket then I’m not as confident as you. In some areas some will survive. But the margins in eating out are small and the amount of covers (customers) needs to be high. Plus there’s more working and shopping from home. A big concern of mine is small businesses vanishing and big businesses making that race to the bottom in wages faster. We’ve seen acceleration in shopping online away from the high street and getting used to never leaving the house that would’ve taken decades.
COYP |
|
|
It looks like around a 1 in 40 chance of dying.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It looks like around a 1 in 40 chance of dying. Where have you got those stats? Are they just reported cases? Talk of actual cases being 10 times higher than reported in spring/summer.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Sorry about your business and I lost my home. Don't be sorry for my business crash, I'm still here, as you are after losing your house. The bit in bold is exactly why the problem is worse this time. All of that money "free loans", people on "furlough", "grants" etc., needs to be paid back. We didn't have that in the 80's. We had inflation rates going through the roof. 22% in 1980!!!! But it fell to 4 or 5 % by '83. That helped a load. But there was no debt to pay back. Which will impact every working person in the country (that isn't fiddling). And do you think we won't reach 12.5% of the population being unemployed if we persist with lockdowns? Now some conspiracy... People are being laid off every day as their bosses realise that their time in the office was pointless. Just let one person do 3 peoples work from home. Maybe not. But....maybe????
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
It looks like around a 1 in 40 chance of dying. That's rubbish. You have as much chance of being killed walking down the street as c-19. Who is giving you this nonsense? It's clearly working to scare the life out of you, so who are you listening to?
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.