You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > ok enlighten me
November 16 2026 12.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ok enlighten me


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
eaglesmad Flag Tonbridge with all the other mad c... 13 May 14 12.23am

How can TP win premier manager of the year but rodgers wins manager of the year, WTF is there a scouse division we dont know about I thought the prem was the top division I must be wrong is it a gift to Hansen coz he left MOTD, Prem manager of the year is top manager of the year end of.

 


and now Fred Davis will try for the pink, for those watching in black n white its just behind the green..........

Alex55 Flag SM1 13 May 14 12.27am

Just seen this on the BBC; The LMA manager of the year is voted for by all 92 managers in the Premier League and Football League. The Premier League one is voted by a panel. Seems that's the difference.

 


'- Really? Honestly? Back in the USSR,,,you don't know how lucky you are.

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 13 May 14 12.34am

It's bollocks but who gives a sh*t, we never get the recognition we deserve, we should know that by now.

We know what the score is and who's been the best manager this year. And it ain't Brenda "Choker" Rodgers.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

eaglesmad Flag Tonbridge with all the other mad c... 13 May 14 12.36am

Well it sucks how can minor bods vote for top manager might as well put a ad in tv choice for a public vote.

 


and now Fred Davis will try for the pink, for those watching in black n white its just behind the green..........

Alex55 Flag SM1 13 May 14 12.41am

Scousers a bit put out when they thought TP had won it.

[Link]

 


'- Really? Honestly? Back in the USSR,,,you don't know how lucky you are.

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 13 May 14 12.49am

Quote Alex55 at 13 May 2014 12.41am

Scousers a bit put out when they thought TP had won it.

[Link]


Some people really have an ingrained stereotypical view of Pulis don't they?

Well, we don't mind. We've been sticking it to the big teams and their fancy passing ways for years now. We will carry on defying the bookies and the pundits by kicking a bit of arse and winning quite a few football matches, thank you very much.

Bring it on

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 13 May 14 12.52am

Looks like nine minutes of football have made Liverpool fans hate anything to do with us for good!

How am I going to get over this?

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

Dan Theolmesdaleroad Flag Up north 13 May 14 1.05am

Maybe Rodgers does deserve it, but not for taking Liverpool from 7th place to 2nd in only a year. The remarkable way in which he skilfully guided them from 1st place to 2nd in only a couple of weeks was truly a joy to behold. Well done, Brendan.

 

lambsandwich Flag Gillingham 13 May 14 8.34am

Brendan Rogers really doesn't deserve any awards. So Liverpoo were challenging for the title for the whole season, so what? So were Chelsea, shouldn't they be challenging every year? OK he took Liverpool from 7th last season to 2nd this season. Tony took Palace from 19th to 11th in half a season that's an 8 place improvement against Brendans 5 place inmprovement in half the time. Not to mention we played a big part in helping to decide the title race and we had a shoestring budget.

It's not even a contest for me, maybe I'm wearing my red and blue tinted glasses but presiding over a team that choked with 3 games to go after celebrating in the streets like they'd already won the league is not an award winning acheivement for me.

 


I don't mean to sound bitter, cold or cruel, but I am so that's how it comes out

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 13 May 14 8.39am

Quote Seth at 13 May 2014 12.49am

Some people really have an ingrained stereotypical view of Pulis don't they?

Yep. Many "football fans" don't actually watch the game for the sport itself. So they are unable to form a proper opinion without the help of pundits who often just regurgitate tired old cliches.

 

ADW1988 Flag Bromley 13 May 14 8.49am

Pellegrini should have been Prem Manager of Year and Pulis LMA overall.

It's crazy Rogers got anywhere near? Won nothing and took a side with Gerrard, Suarez etc up 5 places.. Sorry it just seems the whole world owe Liverpool something!!

1st year in Prem and Pellegrini wins 2 domestic cups is an achievement but overlooked...
Pulis, if we'd have finished 17th still should have won it, but 11th and 12 points clear is an achievement.
Bottling it like Roger's team isn't an achievement. End of.

Vile club for me

Edited by ADW1988 (13 May 2014 8.50am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 13 May 14 8.54am

We won't care about this at all when we are challenging for European Competition qualification next season.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Proper_Gander Flag Anerley 13 May 14 8.58am

Quote ADW1988 at 13 May 2014 8.49am

Pellegrini should have been Prem Manager of Year and Pulis LMA overall.

It's crazy Rogers got anywhere near? Won nothing and took a side with Gerrard, Suarez etc up 5 places.. Sorry it just seems the whole world owe Liverpool something!!

1st year in Prem and Pellegrini wins 2 domestic cups is an achievement but overlooked...
Pulis, if we'd have finished 17th still should have won it, but 11th and 12 points clear is an achievement.
Bottling it like Roger's team isn't an achievement. End of.

Vile club for me

Edited by ADW1988 (13 May 2014 8.50am)


You could say he deserves it for delivering some of the most entertaining games all season. In that respect, he's the premier league manager of the season.

Even if he did throw away the title by not taking the draw against Mourinho, and keeping a 0-3 lead for 10 minutes against a team who were relegation favourites by a mile at the beginning of the season.

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 13 May 14 9.00am

Quote Seth at 13 May 2014 12.49am

Quote Alex55 at 13 May 2014 12.41am

Scousers a bit put out when they thought TP had won it.

[Link]


Some people really have an ingrained stereotypical view of Pulis don't they?

Well, we don't mind. We've been sticking it to the big teams and their fancy passing ways for years now. We will carry on defying the bookies and the pundits by kicking a bit of arse and winning quite a few football matches, thank you very much.

Bring it on

This tweet made me laugh: "Taking no credit away from Pulis but Rodgers deserves it. Challenged for the title all year with a tiny squad and finished 2nd. Mad."

Some of them really are deluded. Liverpool spent around £300m in transfers & wages compared to our measly (not even)£60m.

Brenda took them from 7th to 2nd, TP took us from bottom to 11th. A feat never previously achieved by any manager. Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them. TP took us up 9 places!

However, as Dan Theolmesdaleroad said: "The remarkable way in which he skilfully guided them from 1st place to 2nd in only a couple of weeks was truly a joy to behold." - Maybe it was this that won Brenda his award.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 14 9.21am

Quote Eagle_SA at 13 May 2014 9.00am

Brenda took them from 7th to 2nd, TP took us from bottom to 11th. A feat never previously achieved by any manager. Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them. TP took us up 9 places!

There may well have been far fewer points dividing the teams in the bottom half of the table until the last couple of weeks as I seem to recall that the points difference between the team in 10th place and the relegation zone was only a few points at one stage.

Whilst it may well be true that "Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them" let's not forget that Pulis wasn't the only manager to break that record as Gus Poyet did it too

 

Plane Flag Bromley 13 May 14 9.34am

Quote Ian J at 13 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Eagle_SA at 13 May 2014 9.00am

Brenda took them from 7th to 2nd, TP took us from bottom to 11th. A feat never previously achieved by any manager. Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them. TP took us up 9 places!

There may well have been far fewer points dividing the teams in the bottom half of the table until the last couple of weeks as I seem to recall that the points difference between the team in 10th place and the relegation zone was only a few points at one stage.

Whilst it may well be true that "Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them" let's not forget that Pulis wasn't the only manager to break that record as Gus Poyet did it too


Why don't you sign up to a Sunderland site and you can be amongst your own.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 13 May 14 9.56am

Well, I think it was either one or the other; and Liverpool have played the most exciting football in this division. Very easy on the eye. To get 2nd by playing lovely flamboyant football [other than e.g. the score once and then park the bus Chelsea way] deserved the big prize.

Pulis was the Prems MOTY - also deserved for reasons given by others.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 13 May 14 10.23am

Rogers deserves it on what basis? He took a club with some very good players and not remotely afraid of spending big money into the top four from an underachieving seventh place the previous season, against a group of teams who all had the major distraction of Europe while Rogers' team had no distractions at all. Furthermore, with that free run Rogers failed to fully capitalise by winning the Premiership entirely due to his own shortcomings as a manager, through both the failure to recruit adequate central defenders in the transfer market or to play tactically intelligent football in the two crunch games at the end of the season, a result in either of which likely would have given them the title. Basically, Rogers put out a team that was pleasing on the eye and did well, but hardly reflected managerial brilliance. Bottom line: Pellegrini, Pulis, and Poyet all had better claims than Rodgers to the award and Mourinho and Martinez arguably did.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Bangell Flag Oxford 13 May 14 10.33am

We've been witnesses to the sickly media Liverpool love-in all season, and it's no surprise that Rodgers wasn't allowed to get away without being fawned upon one last time.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 May 14 10.33am

Rogers has done well, but I think his success is much more a reflection of how poorly preceeding managers had done with Liverpool, and he did have several years to achieve this. Liverpools achievements aren't quite as phenominal as they appear at first sight, the success of Sturridge and Suraz up front distract from the fact that the team were incompetant in defence. For every two goals they scored, Liverpool conceeded 1.

Liverpool are a club that should be competing for champions league and title season on season. That they weren't was down to p*ss poor managers before Rodgers came in. He steadied the ship, rebuilt it and got Liverpool back to the position they should have been in.

Personally, Pulis deserved the LMA Manager of the Year and Poyet the Premier League Manager of the year, simply because both have achieved not only against expectation, but achieved almost miraculous transformations of teams.

Managers of the season for me, in order.

Pulis
Poyet
Martinez (His achievements at Everton eclipse those of Liverpool).
Rogers / Pelligrini

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > ok enlighten me