You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag
November 22 2026 1.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Flag


Page 4 of 18 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 12 Jul 14 3.04pm

Quote grump at 12 Jul 2014 8.50am

Well I will continue to display the Southern Cross along with the St George Cross and Union Jack. If people interpret this as a sign I am a racist then I'm afraid that is their problem not mine. Unfortunately narrow minded people will always make stupid assumptions.


Grump, the connotations of the Confederate flag are not assumptions. If you assume it is just a pretty blue and red flag, then your assumption is wrong. If people then assume this flag flown at Selhurst means the club is OK with the attitudes this flag represents, then the loss is Palace's: are you happy? Being a person concerned with the wealth of our club I can't see how you can be.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 12 Jul 14 3.53pm

Anyone who thinks this has nothing to do with slavery should read the constitution of the Confederate States.

[Link]

See: Article 1 Section 9 clause 4; article 4 section 2 clause 1; article 4 section 3 clause 3.

These guarantee the right to own slaves. They also guarantee that a slaveowner can take his 'property' anywhere without risk of seizure, and they guarantee any new states joining the confederacy must allow slaveowners to travel without risk of the seizure of their slaves. Thus, this guaranteed a slave owning society even if the confederacy expanded. It's the one main theme separating this from the original US Constitution.

As for the argument that the average southerner was not a slave owner so the war wasn't about slavery, well neither was the average German a Nazi!

Edited by NickinOX (12 Jul 2014 3.53pm)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Jul 14 4.49pm

Quote Happiness Stan at 12 Jul 2014 9.43am

Bin it and get a Tibetan one innit. Red and blue and looks great. Tho doubtless some people would start s***ting the bed about affecting shirt sales in china

[Link]


Took one to Wemberly last year cos it looked cool (and was cheap)

 

c_block_shedevil Flag London 13 Jul 14 5.21pm

Isn't the confederate flag used in the 'rebel' context rather than racist slave owners like some here suggest?

The flag has been used on many singers album and promotional material. Does that mean they are racist?

 


I'm tough. I'm ambitious. I know exactly what I want. If that makes me a bitch, I'm OK with that.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 14 5.44pm

Quote grump at 12 Jul 2014 8.50am

Well I will continue to display the Southern Cross along with the St George Cross and Union Jack. If people interpret this as a sign I am a racist then I'm afraid that is their problem not mine. Unfortunately narrow minded people will always make stupid assumptions.

Interesting combination, the Southern Cross mostly appears on Australian and New Zealand flags.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 14 5.51pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 13 Jul 2014 5.21pm

Isn't the confederate flag used in the 'rebel' context rather than racist slave owners like some here suggest?

The flag has been used on many singers album and promotional material. Does that mean they are racist?

It's often used as a rebel symbol in the US, as well as an unofficial southern states flag. Problem is its association not just with slavery in the civil war, but it was used by groups like the KKK and as part of the anti-desegregation campaign in the US, and still has a very strong relationship with US hate groups, such as Neo-Nazism.

Its kind of like a Swastika it generally doesn't mean what most people think, but its not going to go down very well with people.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 5.52pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 13 Jul 2014 5.21pm

Isn't the confederate flag used in the 'rebel' context rather than racist slave owners like some here suggest?

The flag has been used on many singers album and promotional material. Does that mean they are racist?


Nope.

The confederate flag on its own is no proof of that. It carries other meanings as well.....It's how the person uses it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 5.53pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 13 Jul 14 6.06pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 5.52pm

Quote c_block_shedevil at 13 Jul 2014 5.21pm

Isn't the confederate flag used in the 'rebel' context rather than racist slave owners like some here suggest?

The flag has been used on many singers album and promotional material. Does that mean they are racist?


Nope.

The confederate flag on its own is no proof of that. It carries other meanings as well.....It's how the person uses it.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 5.53pm)

The problem for the flag is similar to that of the swastika. For example, Finland used it during WW2 and it had nothing to do with them fighting alongside Nazi Germany. They just happened to use the same symbol. There are some hippies who wear a swastika "to reclaim it" from it's evil past. I doubt their ideology calls for the mass extermination of Jews, Slavs, and Gypsies, etc. But the swastika on their t-shirt screams Nazi.

The average person is probably ignorant of the direct link the Confederate flag has to slavery and racism. Mind you, I've met quite a few who are aware of the link but think it's cool. Sort of like rich people and pictures of Stalin or Che. How rad!


 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 6.15pm

Quote NickinOX at 13 Jul 2014 6.06pm

The problem for the flag is similar to that of the swastika. For example, Finland used it during WW2 and it had nothing to do with them fighting alongside Nazi Germany. They just happened to use the same symbol. There are some hippies who wear a swastika "to reclaim it" from it's evil past. I doubt their ideology calls for the mass extermination of Jews, Slavs, and Gypsies, etc. But the swastika on their t-shirt screams Nazi.

The average person is probably ignorant of the direct link the Confederate flag has to slavery and racism. Mind you, I've met quite a few who are aware of the link but think it's cool. Sort of like rich people and pictures of Stalin or Che. How rad!



What the average person thinks matters little really. None of us can control what others think. If people want to make the wrong assumptions about others based upon symbols that they are partly ignorant about then that's their problem and less the issue for the individual.

All they need do is ask.

It's like someone getting a tatto and others thinking they are a thug. It's an assumption....It needs more input until you know.

As an aside I saw something on telly last year about a black southerner who walks around his state on weekends with the Confederate flag for exactly the reason that he wants to alter perceptions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 6.15pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 13 Jul 14 6.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 6.15pm

Quote NickinOX at 13 Jul 2014 6.06pm

The problem for the flag is similar to that of the swastika. For example, Finland used it during WW2 and it had nothing to do with them fighting alongside Nazi Germany. They just happened to use the same symbol. There are some hippies who wear a swastika "to reclaim it" from it's evil past. I doubt their ideology calls for the mass extermination of Jews, Slavs, and Gypsies, etc. But the swastika on their t-shirt screams Nazi.

The average person is probably ignorant of the direct link the Confederate flag has to slavery and racism. Mind you, I've met quite a few who are aware of the link but think it's cool. Sort of like rich people and pictures of Stalin or Che. How rad!



What the average person thinks matters little really. None of us can control what others think. If people want to make the wrong assumptions about others based upon symbols that they are partly ignorant about then that's their problem and less the issue for the individual.

All they need do is ask.

It's like someone getting a tatto and others thinking they are a thug. It's an assumption....It needs more input until you know.

As an aside I saw something on telly last year about a black southerner who walks around his state on weekends with the Confederate flag for exactly the reason that he wants to alter perceptions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 6.15pm)

Let me be clear. I'm not offended by it. But, in the US it's become a hot potato issue largely due to its association with Jim Crow southern states. I certainly wouldn't want it flying above the state house because of this. But if an individual wants to display it, good luck to them.

These days, we seem far too quick to take offense.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 6.44pm

Quote NickinOX at 13 Jul 2014 6.33pm

Let me be clear. I'm not offended by it. But, in the US it's become a hot potato issue largely due to its association with Jim Crow southern states. I certainly wouldn't want it flying above the state house because of this. But if an individual wants to display it, good luck to them.

These days, we seem far too quick to take offense.

I agree.

Some people who use it will be racists of course and/or just want the 'shock' value.......But it also has other contexts, anti establishment/state independence/personal independence and so on.

I didn't like the period we are just coming out of in this country where if you waved the St George some ignorants thought you were a racist or member of a far right organization.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 14 6.54pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 6.15pm

Quote NickinOX at 13 Jul 2014 6.06pm

The problem for the flag is similar to that of the swastika. For example, Finland used it during WW2 and it had nothing to do with them fighting alongside Nazi Germany. They just happened to use the same symbol. There are some hippies who wear a swastika "to reclaim it" from it's evil past. I doubt their ideology calls for the mass extermination of Jews, Slavs, and Gypsies, etc. But the swastika on their t-shirt screams Nazi.

The average person is probably ignorant of the direct link the Confederate flag has to slavery and racism. Mind you, I've met quite a few who are aware of the link but think it's cool. Sort of like rich people and pictures of Stalin or Che. How rad!



What the average person thinks matters little really. None of us can control what others think. If people want to make the wrong assumptions about others based upon symbols that they are partly ignorant about then that's their problem and less the issue for the individual.

All they need do is ask.

It's like someone getting a tatto and others thinking they are a thug. It's an assumption....It needs more input until you know.

As an aside I saw something on telly last year about a black southerner who walks around his state on weekends with the Confederate flag for exactly the reason that he wants to alter perceptions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 6.15pm)

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Jul 14 7.30pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

So should the flag waver at Selhurst also embroider a caveat for using the flag on a separate flag so that those watching the mighty Palace on the telly don't think we are pro slavery?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 7.36pm

Quote nickgusset at 13 Jul 2014 7.30pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

So should the flag waver at Selhurst also embroider a caveat for using the flag on a separate flag so that those watching the mighty Palace on the telly don't think we are pro slavery?

That would be pants.

Na.....He should just make it clear when he's asked.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Jul 14 7.41pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.36pm

Quote nickgusset at 13 Jul 2014 7.30pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

So should the flag waver at Selhurst also embroider a caveat for using the flag on a separate flag so that those watching the mighty Palace on the telly don't think we are pro slavery?

That would be pants.

Na.....He should just make it clear when he's asked.

Difficult to do if you are in say, Detroit!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 7.46pm

Quote nickgusset at 13 Jul 2014 7.41pm

Difficult to do if you are in say, Detroit!

Personal choice.....Though it would seem a silly one.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Lombardos barber Flag 13 Jul 14 8.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

What a ridiculous comment from someone with no knowledge of history.

Im not a fan of liberals and generally am far from PC but that flag has such appalling conotations that it shouldnt be glossed over as a "personal choice" issue.

Is it a fair one to wave a Swastika if, along the lines of what you said, someone believed in a Austria German union but wasnt really a fan of the Holocaust?

As someone who has served alongside many Americans, there is a lot of denial over how bad the lot of Black people was in the US, especially during the time of slavery.

We should not welcome that kind of symbolism at Selhurst. Millwall, Chelsea, Leeds, Rangers etc can have it.

Edited by Lombardos barber (13 Jul 2014 8.34pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jul 14 10.47pm

Quote Lombardos barber at 13 Jul 2014 8.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

What a ridiculous comment from someone with no knowledge of history.

Im not a fan of liberals and generally am far from PC but that flag has such appalling conotations that it shouldnt be glossed over as a "personal choice" issue.

Is it a fair one to wave a Swastika if, along the lines of what you said, someone believed in a Austria German union but wasnt really a fan of the Holocaust?

As someone who has served alongside many Americans, there is a lot of denial over how bad the lot of Black people was in the US, especially during the time of slavery.

We should not welcome that kind of symbolism at Selhurst. Millwall, Chelsea, Leeds, Rangers etc can have it.

Edited by Lombardos barber (13 Jul 2014 8.34pm)

Oh dear.

Yeah, no knowledge of history mate. Strange how I've taught the subject in schools isn't it.

Did you read the series of posts? Or is your knee jerking?

The Swastika doesn't represent a German/Austria union by the way. It represents either the Nazis, modern far right groups by chosen association or as an ancient symbol sometimes used by several different cultures. The WW2 union between German and Austria is not its purpose.

That is an action the Nazis took, not the purpose of the flag.

The confederate flag does represent a union of southern states.....That's its original meaning and purpose. As that union was defeated in the civil war its usage by people now falls under several different guises.

So your analogy is wrong.....In fact it's quite annoying.

The confederate flag has been used by people who aren't racists and by those that are....It is down to context. The fact that some people can't move away from its association with slavery is their problem.

Britain practiced slavery under the union jack flag.....Should we associate that? Oh and the Dutch flag and so on.

It's a sodding flag....And people use it to mean what they want it to mean......A lot of Americans in the south use it to distance themselves from the US government.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 10.53pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 13 Jul 14 10.53pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 10.47pm

Quote Lombardos barber at 13 Jul 2014 8.33pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Jul 2014 7.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jul 2014 6.54pm

Yeah but you also shouldn't be surprised if people get really f**ked off either - Its a symbol, and symbols have profound effects on people. Its a shame because its one of the most beautiful flags ever produced.


People have the right to be offended but not the right to deny a person to express (within reason).....Whatever it is they are expressing.

If someone believes in a southern state independence for example the confederate flag could be a good symbol for that.

It would of course help if those using a 'controversial' flag also made it clear what they stand for.

What a ridiculous comment from someone with no knowledge of history.

Im not a fan of liberals and generally am far from PC but that flag has such appalling conotations that it shouldnt be glossed over as a "personal choice" issue.

Is it a fair one to wave a Swastika if, along the lines of what you said, someone believed in a Austria German union but wasnt really a fan of the Holocaust?

As someone who has served alongside many Americans, there is a lot of denial over how bad the lot of Black people was in the US, especially during the time of slavery.

We should not welcome that kind of symbolism at Selhurst. Millwall, Chelsea, Leeds, Rangers etc can have it.

Edited by Lombardos barber (13 Jul 2014 8.34pm)

Oh dear.

Yeah, no knowledge of history mate. Strange how I've taught the subject in schools isn't it.

Did you read the series of posts? Or is your knee jerking?

The Swastika doesn't represent a German/Austria union by the way. It represents either the Nazis, modern far right groups by chosen association or as an ancient symbol sometimes used by several different cultures. The WW2 union between German and Austria is not its purpose.

That is an action the Nazis took, not the purpose of the flag.

The confederate flag does represent a union of southern states.....That's its original meaning and purpose. As that union was defeated in the civil war its usage by people now falls under several different guises.

So your analogy is wrong.....In fact it's quite annoying.

The confederate flag has been used by people who aren't racists and by those that are....It is down to context. The fact that some people can't move away from its association with slavery is their problem.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jul 2014 10.48pm)


Which will unfortunately mean some viewers may draw the negative connotations if they see it.

Having said that, I'm sure that the flag, which if I remember rightly was part of a patchwork of other flags had been removed. Or I might have dreamt it.

 

Page 4 of 18 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Flag