You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > EU Renegotiation
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

EU Renegotiation


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 03 Feb 16 9.56pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Read it back:... "Hmm..business leaders generally think we are better off in the EU than we would be if we left. Do you have any info to genuinely undermine their position? Why exactly would be be better off economically if we left. Facts only please."

If you would - Make the case against. Ta. Not long to go. The referendum might be brought forward to June.

Also, if you could inform me as to why they are being 'cunds' also in this particular instance then I will bow to your greater knowledge.

Not sure where in this thread anyone has stated that the UK would be better off economically if we left the EU.
The probability is that UK trade would be largely unaffected as the EU need to sell into the UK market as much - or maybe even more - than we need theirs.
Are you able to provide any other distinct advantage - other than your dubious economic one - in remaining in the EU ?

Edited by rob1969 (03 Feb 2016 9.57pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Feb 16 12.40pm

Radio 4 Today Programme had a section about the planned referendum and Cameron's attempts to change the benefits payments situation for the UK by negotiating with our EU partners.

They went to Portsmouth and interviewed loads of migrants from Poland and the rest of Eastern European migrants.

To a man, all of them said they would still come here if there were no benefits ever as life in general is better and pay is much higher.

It seems that if Cameron hopes his negotiations will create a major reduction in migrants beating a path to the UK to live and work he is sadly mistaken.

Vote OUT

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Feb 16 12.45pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Radio 4 Today Programme had a section about the planned referendum and Cameron's attempts to change the benefits payments situation for the UK by negotiating with our EU partners.

They went to Portsmouth and interviewed loads of migrants from Poland and the rest of Eastern European migrants.

To a man, all of them said they would still come here if there were no benefits ever as life in general is better and pay is much higher.

It seems that if Cameron hopes his negotiations will create a major reduction in migrants beating a path to the UK to live and work he is sadly mistaken.

Vote OUT

Hoof Hearted

You and I are "Singing from the same hymn sheet" on this one.

See you at the "Vote Leave" stall in Lancing on Saturday ! I suspect that the referendum will be 23rd June.

VOTE LEAVE

 

elgrande Flag bedford 04 Feb 16 2.41pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Radio 4 Today Programme had a section about the planned referendum and Cameron's attempts to change the benefits payments situation for the UK by negotiating with our EU partners.

They went to Portsmouth and interviewed loads of migrants from Poland and the rest of Eastern European migrants.

To a man, all of them said they would still come here if there were no benefits ever as life in general is better and pay is much higher.

It seems that if Cameron hopes his negotiations will create a major reduction in migrants beating a path to the UK to live and work he is sadly mistaken.

Vote OUT

Totally agree Hoof,we need vote out to control the numbers of people coming here.
When are people going to realise that mass immigration does the indeginas people no good at all.
In fact it does the exact opposite that the left want it to.
Eastern Europeans,or any migrants will work for less,they live in houses that they all pay for....if you have ten migrants all living in one house it doesn't matter if they are under cutting the local guy/girl because the whole house is paying the bills.
What chance has a couple with a couple of kids got....answer none

Vote out.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Feb 16 2.46pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

They went to Portsmouth and interviewed loads of migrants from Poland and the rest of Eastern European migrants.

To a man, all of them said they would still come here if there were no benefits ever as life in general is better and pay is much higher.

It seems that if Cameron hopes his negotiations will create a major reduction in migrants beating a path to the UK to live and work he is sadly mistaken.

Vote OUT

Exacerbated of course by the new "Living wage".

The only way to control our borders is for us to leave the EU.

VOTE LEAVE

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 04 Feb 16 3.41pm

If there is a vote and if the vote is to get out, do we know if this will automatically mean that EU residents wont be able to work here without a visa?

Could the Tories decide that they will let EU residents work but without being able to claim benefits?

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

DanH Flag SW2 04 Feb 16 3.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

Exacerbated of course by the new "Living wage".

The only way to control our borders is for us to leave the EU.

VOTE LEAVE


Well you've made my mind up for me.

I'M VOTING STAY

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 16 3.53pm

Originally posted by Willo

Exacerbated of course by the new "Living wage".

The only way to control our borders is for us to leave the EU.

VOTE LEAVE

I disagree with that, fixing a decent living wage should in theory at least, making it more viable for UK unemployed to seek these jobs out. I don't have a problem with migration, what I've seen though over the last decade is the government surrender to corporate interests over the interests of UK nationals who are out of work, or in low income jobs.

In the periods of boom, they utilised cheap migrant labour rather than unemployed UK nationals - This, for me, was a betrayal by Labour of the working classes. During that period of economic boom was an opportunity to relocate unemployed individuals and families into areas of employment, towards a plan for longer term growth of social interest, rather than shipping in temporary migrant labour.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Feb 16 3.53pm

Originally posted by topcat

If there is a vote and if the vote is to get out, do we know if this will automatically mean that EU residents wont be able to work here without a visa?

Could the Tories decide that they will let EU residents work but without being able to claim benefits?

Anyone already here will be allowed to stay forever, as far as I'm aware.

If the majority did vote to leave you can bet it will somehow take years to actually implement it, and they'll be flooding in right up to the cut off date.

After the cut off they'd need to apply for working visas presumably. If the government then waived visa requirements I think they'd get heavily punished at a GE by those who voted to leave the EU, so I doubt they'd do that.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Feb 16 3.53pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Totally agree Hoof,we need vote out to control the numbers of people coming here.
When are people going to realise that mass immigration does the indeginas people no good at all.
In fact it does the exact opposite that the left want it to.
Eastern Europeans,or any migrants will work for less,they live in houses that they all pay for....if you have ten migrants all living in one house it doesn't matter if they are under cutting the local guy/girl because the whole house is paying the bills.
What chance has a couple with a couple of kids got....answer none

Vote out.

How would you define the indigenous people of the U.K?


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 16 3.55pm

Originally posted by topcat

If there is a vote and if the vote is to get out, do we know if this will automatically mean that EU residents wont be able to work here without a visa?

Could the Tories decide that they will let EU residents work but without being able to claim benefits?

EU Migrants have to work for around three years to be eligible for benefits. The only non-nationals who are automatically entitled to claim benefits are asylum seekers prior to being granted status. The reason for this, is that UK law forbids them from working.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Feb 16 3.55pm

Originally posted by topcat

If there is a vote and if the vote is to get out, do we know if this will automatically mean that EU residents wont be able to work here without a visa?

Could the Tories decide that they will let EU residents work but without being able to claim benefits?

Those already here will be allowed to stay. I don't know about length of residency but we won't turn into the BNP.

If we vote out the Tories can stop all benefits to non British citizens. As it is there's no stop to in-work benefits unless this brake comes in on a Brexit and there's a strain on public services. "How long is a piece of string?" Things are already straining. Maybe not compared to other countries but they are for what we're used to/have been in for.

They could also make all foreign citizens prove they can speak English, something the Marbella set may be concerned about as English is a problem before Spanish.

However, I doubt things will get too Alf Garnett like because if we go for a Swiss type trade agreement for goods (big & small business) and services (our reliance on financial) we'll need to be able to negotiate workable terms.

 


COYP

elgrande Flag bedford 04 Feb 16 4.09pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

How would you define the indigenous people of the U.K?


The ones who have family or have grown up here(regardless of where they originated from before you start)...and maybe before the left decided that mass immigration was good for us.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Feb 16 4.16pm

Originally posted by elgrande

The ones who have family or have grown up here(regardless of where they originated from before you start)...and maybe before the left decided that mass immigration was good for us.

I think you'll find that mass immigration isn't a 'leftie' ideal, after all aren't left wing ideologies tied in with betterment for workers?

Nope, mass immigration serves a right wing agenda.

Uncontrolled immigration drives down wages and increases the competition for jobs (especially low-skilled jobs), making the prospect of unemployment, low pay or the horrors of zero hours contracts much more likely for millions of ordinary workers.

Another way in which ordinary workers lose out through mass immigration is the increased pressure on local services such as health and education, on which they, and their children rely.


Corporations and rich employers benefit from the large labour surpluses created by mass uncontrolled immigration, because the increased competition for jobs allows them to drive down the wages they pay, therefore increasing their profit margins.

The profitability of the labour surplus is hardly a new concept. Karl Marx explained how capitalism benefits from surplus labour way back in the mid-19th Century. A large standing army of unemployed, provided with just enough welfare to keep them alive is absolutely fundamental to the modern neoliberalised capitalist system.

The wealthy minority are almost completely insulated from the negative effects of mass uncontrolled immigration. They don't even notice the extra pressure on services, because the majority of the executive class generally have private health plans and privately educate their kids.

What is more, they are much more likely to be dodging their taxes, so many amongst them don't even contribute towards the costs of providing these extra services, despite the fact that they are the ones benefiting most from mass uncontrolled immigration.

You've fallen for the spin of the press again I'm afraid.

Edited by nickgusset (04 Feb 2016 4.18pm)

12670115_10207074524553977_8428254540054138954_n.jpg Attachment: 12670115_10207074524553977_8428254540054138954_n.jpg (37.29Kb)

 

elgrande Flag bedford 04 Feb 16 4.32pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I think you'll find that mass immigration isn't a 'leftie' ideal, after all aren't left wing ideologies tied in with betterment for workers?

Nope, mass immigration serves a right wing agenda.

Uncontrolled immigration drives down wages and increases the competition for jobs (especially low-skilled jobs), making the prospect of unemployment, low pay or the horrors of zero hours contracts much more likely for millions of ordinary workers.

Another way in which ordinary workers lose out through mass immigration is the increased pressure on local services such as health and education, on which they, and their children rely.


Corporations and rich employers benefit from the large labour surpluses created by mass uncontrolled immigration, because the increased competition for jobs allows them to drive down the wages they pay, therefore increasing their profit margins.

The profitability of the labour surplus is hardly a new concept. Karl Marx explained how capitalism benefits from surplus labour way back in the mid-19th Century. A large standing army of unemployed, provided with just enough welfare to keep them alive is absolutely fundamental to the modern neoliberalised capitalist system.

The wealthy minority are almost completely insulated from the negative effects of mass uncontrolled immigration. They don't even notice the extra pressure on services, because the majority of the executive class generally have private health plans and privately educate their kids.

What is more, they are much more likely to be dodging their taxes, so many amongst them don't even contribute towards the costs of providing these extra services, despite the fact that they are the ones benefiting most from mass uncontrolled immigration.

You've fallen for the spin of the press again I'm afraid.

Edited by nickgusset (04 Feb 2016 4.18pm)


While intake in what you are saying.....with the greatest respect. That's bollocks....the left are the ones calling for mass immigration... Hence Corbyn and his cronies visiting the camps in France.
And yes if you read my post,that his just what I am saying mass immigration affects the very people the left are supposed to protect.
In fact I was talking to someone today who owns a cleaning company.
He has had to lay off half a dozen cleaners recently, because of just that,the offices are employing people ( eastern Europeans) for half the price he was paying his workforce.
Which yes the company who are employing them for less are totally wrong.....but if they were not here they foul not do it.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 16 4.34pm

Originally posted by elgrande

The ones who have family or have grown up here(regardless of where they originated from before you start)...and maybe before the left decided that mass immigration was good for us.

By left, you mean the right of centre government of Tony Blair, who are more or less indistinguishable politically from the current Conservative party?

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

elgrande Flag bedford 04 Feb 16 4.36pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

By left, you mean the right of centre government of Tony Blair, who are more or less indistinguishable politically from the current Conservative party?

Maybe Jamie...but Corbyn has it on his agenda

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Feb 16 4.39pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Maybe Jamie...but Corbyn has it on his agenda

Corbyn's agenda is to help those fleeing war and persecution.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 16 4.40pm

Originally posted by elgrande


While intake in what you are saying.....with the greatest respect. That's bollocks....the left are the ones calling for mass immigration... Hence Corbyn and his cronies visiting the camps in France.
And yes if you read my post,that his just what I am saying mass immigration affects the very people the left are supposed to protect.
In fact I was talking to someone today who owns a cleaning company.
He has had to lay off half a dozen cleaners recently, because of just that,the offices are employing people ( eastern Europeans) for half the price he was paying his workforce.
Which yes the company who are employing them for less are totally wrong.....but if they were not here they foul not do it.

That sounds like capitalism, rather than leftist economics to me, using cheap labour to under cut the market.

Its corporate interests that drive the EU and this policy, which no one except the left wing were complaining about prior to the credit crunch. For as long as I can remember I've been banging on that EU migrant labour has been used to undercut the bargaining position of the UK working classes.

Don't mistake Tony Blair and Gordon Brown for left wing. Pro-Market, Pro-Capitalist corporate shills that's what New Labour was. That said, Blair did do a good smoke screen.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

elgrande Flag bedford 04 Feb 16 4.44pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

That sounds like capitalism, rather than leftist economics to me, using cheap labour to under cut the market.

Its corporate interests that drive the EU and this policy, which no one except the left wing were complaining about prior to the credit crunch. For as long as I can remember I've been banging on that EU migrant labour has been used to undercut the bargaining position of the UK working classes.

Don't mistake Tony Blair and Gordon Brown for left wing. Pro-Market, Pro-Capitalist corporate shills that's what New Labour was. That said, Blair did do a good smoke screen.

Well I agree with you on the EU labour point...which is the point I was making in the first place.

But I'm afraid we will have to agree to disagree on the Calais point.
Because I do not believe that many there are fleeing persecution, economic migrants.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > EU Renegotiation