You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better without cabaye?
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we better without cabaye?


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 16 Sep 16 8.17am

Originally posted by srh

Anyone who has ever been coached properly and played football and has half a brain can see that Cabye is by far our best central midfield player.

Anyone who watches the games can see he isn't.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Sep 16 8.36am

Originally posted by PhuketEagle

Good that we have some options at last. Would like to see McArthur, Flamini & Ledley together in midfield. While I like Cabaye he's not spurred us on & didn't get the captaincy when it became available - when perhaps he would've been in consideration if his performances had merited it.
Let's find a good midfield solution & stick with the players as they learn to understand each other (barring injuries.)

Thought we had a solution first half of last season with cabaye and macarthur, they were superb. But then macarthur got injured ( which I think was our biggest problem) and I'm not sure cabaye was really fit second half if season, for one reason or another. If they are both 100% I think they are by far our best combination.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 16 Sep 16 8.39am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Anyone who watches the games can see he isn't.

It is his impact on the team which is far more important than whether he is our best midfielder or not

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 16 Sep 16 8.39am

Sorry griffish, wrote my post before reading yours. Said the same, but yours was much better put...

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 16 Sep 16 8.54am

Originally posted by slubglurge

It is his impact on the team which is far more important than whether he is our best midfielder or not

I suppose that is what I am missing. I can see Dann's impact , I can see McArthur's impact , I could see Jedi's impact, but I cannot see what Cabaye is doing that wins us games, I cannot recall a game when I thought Cabaye carried us through that and won it for us.
His best game for us was probably the semi-final against Watford , but Jedi was even better in that game.
I also do not understand how Cabaye's loss of form is excused with McArthur's abscence , can he not be effective on his own? McArthur can play without him, why not vice-versa?
Anyway I shall keep watching , I really want him to show some international form for Palace.


 

Griffish Flag Croydon 16 Sep 16 8.58am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Sorry griffish, wrote my post before reading yours. Said the same, but yours was much better put...

No need to apologise kev. I'm just sad enough to write a life story on here haha!

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 16 Sep 16 9.10am

I think we're better off knowing that he isn't indispensable. I think Pards needs to told that as well. I don't think that it's good for any team or player, knowing that there is a player in the team who will be selected no matter how they are playing or what effectulness they have on the team at the time.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 16 Sep 16 10.14am

Originally posted by Petereagle

I think he may well be on the bench for a good while, not only because Ledley, but there is also now Flamini to compete against, so I dont think he's just going to automatically jump back into the starting 11

For me Flamini ranks up there with Benteke as top signing of the summer.

Absolute quality and quoted by none other than Cesc Fabregas as the best midfielder he has ever played with. Doesn't need the Money as he is a paper billionaire so is playing for the love of the game. I think when he is fully match fit, despite his age he will show cabaye how to run the tempo of a game, and if Cabaye is smart he will learn.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 16 Sep 16 4.41pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

I suppose that is what I am missing. I can see Dann's impact , I can see McArthur's impact , I could see Jedi's impact, but I cannot see what Cabaye is doing that wins us games, I cannot recall a game when I thought Cabaye carried us through that and won it for us.
His best game for us was probably the semi-final against Watford , but Jedi was even better in that game.
I also do not understand how Cabaye's loss of form is excused with McArthur's abscence , can he not be effective on his own? McArthur can play without him, why not vice-versa?
Anyway I shall keep watching , I really want him to show some international form for Palace.


Cabaye is excellent at squeezing the play wide and getting the ball back. Also very good at chasing back without (always) fouling. If Jedi got beat you knew the only way he was getting back into the play was by fouling. Cabaye is also good at providing outlet support.

For me the big difference I notice is that when we have Cabaye we are much better protected from the break. When he's not, (if we had Jedi or Ledley as holding Mids) the other team has a free run to our box.

He was less visible in the build up, because we were lumping it forward from the back --rather than building play from the back.

This is where I see a big difference. Mandanda wants to build the play, and Benteke is looking great at hold up play and bringing the mids into the game.

Maybe Flamini can bring something similar, I hope so, but I have no idea what his game was like --I just remember a lot of fouls, which is probably what other teams remember about Cabaye.


Edited by ThatPetrolRelation (16 Sep 2016 4.42pm)

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Sep 16 11.24pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Cabaye is excellent at squeezing the play wide and getting the ball back. Also very good at chasing back without (always) fouling. If Jedi got beat you knew the only way he was getting back into the play was by fouling. Cabaye is also good at providing outlet support.

For me the big difference I notice is that when we have Cabaye we are much better protected from the break. When he's not, (if we had Jedi or Ledley as holding Mids) the other team has a free run to our box.

He was less visible in the build up, because we were lumping it forward from the back --rather than building play from the back.

This is where I see a big difference. Mandanda wants to build the play, and Benteke is looking great at hold up play and bringing the mids into the game.

Maybe Flamini can bring something similar, I hope so, but I have no idea what his game was like --I just remember a lot of fouls, which is probably what other teams remember about Cabaye.


Edited by ThatPetrolRelation (16 Sep 2016 4.42pm)

Well I do not know what Excellent at squeezing the play wide really means , or how it, s done or how it wins us games, so I asked some football people who have been coached at a higher level than I , and they are none the wiser.
So please tell me what you mean / see and tell us how it would have made us better today.

 

Thegamesafoot Flag Somewhere but Nowhere 19 Sep 16 12.22am

If I had to guess what it means, I'd say that Cabaye is very good when having the ball at his feet outside our area in a central position and under pressure, he is very good at picking a short pass to left or right (not wide) and making himself immediately available for a return ball so as to try and progress play. Of course he could just pass to Damo to play the outball and have to do it all over again one minute later.

 


It's good to keep an opened mind, but not so open that your brains fall out.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 1.01am

Pardew has luckily stumbled upon a central midfield partnership with Ledley and Jimmac that works. Let's see how good it is versus

Sunderland away
Everton away
West Ham home
Liverpool away

before we write about off a world class player who may well know he needs to up his game.

However, I do see and get that she Cabaye plays Punch doesn't perform.

 


COYP

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 1.24am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Pardew has luckily stumbled upon a central midfield partnership with Ledley and Jimmac that works. Let's see how good it is versus

Sunderland away
Everton away
West Ham home
Liverpool away

before we write about off a world class player who may well know he needs to up his game.

However, I do see and get that she Cabaye plays Punch doesn't perform.

-.-' -.-' -.-'

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 9.15am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

-.-' -.-' -.-'

Who else was there to pick? Jedi was selected before and Ledley has come in since Jedi's departure with only 2 options: Jimmac and Ledley.

So tell me who the options were?

 


COYP

taylors lovechild Flag 19 Sep 16 9.23am

I think Cabaye will fit in well with our new style. I don't think the last three games are as a result of him being out of the team, more that the team has started firing. I like Ledley, but I think Cabaye is a better player.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Sep 16 9.48am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Pardew has luckily stumbled upon a central midfield partnership with Ledley and Jimmac that works. Let's see how good it is versus

Sunderland away
Everton away
West Ham home
Liverpool away

before we write about off a world class player who may well know he needs to up his game.

However, I do see and get that she Cabaye plays Punch doesn't perform.

Possibly luck, equally recognising that it has worked before?

Was he lucky when Chamakh got injured and Punch had to cover the No 10 role? maybe. However in both cases he recognised that we had certain personnel who could perform a particular role. That's a good thing surely?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 9.57am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Possibly luck, equally recognising that it has worked before?

Was he lucky when Chamakh got injured and Punch had to cover the No 10 role? maybe. However in both cases he recognised that we had certain personnel who could perform a particular role. That's a good thing surely?

I agree but pretending it's genius when Ledley has only come in again since Jedi was sold is overdoing it. And you could also say that Puncheon is required at number 10 so even more need for Ledley there and less options.

Of course you have to be flexible and adapt but pretending Pardew sat there this summer and planned Jimmac and Ledley to be the answer is nonsense. We held on vs Mboro and dominated a very strange situation of a struggling Stoke team.

Cabaye will up his game now there's 2 better options in Townsend and Benteke showing themselves properly to pass to.

 


COYP

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 10.09am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Who else was there to pick? Jedi was selected before and Ledley has come in since Jedi's departure with only 2 options: Jimmac and Ledley.

So tell me who the options were?

You talk such crap sometimes Rudi, AP is not picking numbers for the Euro -Millions hes picking a team from a squad of players he works with every day.In the case of JMac and Ledley they were both at the club when he arrived so f@ck knows how many hours hes spent watching them train and play.He rates them both which is why he got rid of Jedi therefore its not luckily stumbled upon its who he chose to keep in the squad. I would of said Ledley and JMac would work well even before the season started FFS

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 16 10.17am

Originally posted by citizensmudge

You talk such crap sometimes Rudi, AP is not picking numbers for the Euro -Millions hes picking a team from a squad of players he works with every day.In the case of JMac and Ledley they were both at the club when he arrived so f@ck knows how many hours hes spent watching them train and play.He rates them both which is why he got rid of Jedi therefore its not luckily stumbled upon its who he chose to keep in the squad. I would of said Ledley and JMac would work well even before the season started FFS

You talk sh1t pal. He always played Jedi before Ledley. Last season, this season. Now Jedi's gone, in comes Ledley. If we were offered £4 mil for Ledley and not Jedi it would be Ledley gone and Jedi winning balls but not able to link up with those around as effectively. Ledley would've been sold for less than £4 mil and I suppose the panic after selling Jedi and not getting another midfielder in and bringing the higher class Flamini never really happened because we had that McLedley partnership Pardew kept secret during 24 games with 2 wins. Yeah right.

 


COYP

citizensmudge Flag midlands 19 Sep 16 10.34am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You talk sh1t pal. He always played Jedi before Ledley. Last season, this season. Now Jedi's gone, in comes Ledley. If we were offered £4 mil for Ledley and not Jedi it would be Ledley gone and Jedi winning balls but not able to link up with those around as effectively. Ledley would've been sold for less than £4 mil and I suppose the panic after selling Jedi and not getting another midfielder in and bringing the higher class Flamini never really happened because we had that McLedley partnership Pardew kept secret during 24 games with 2 wins. Yeah right.

Over the two previous seasons Ledley played 4 more games than Jedi and he picked up his fair share of injuries over that period.Once again,he sold Jedi because his distribution was awful and he didn't fit his plans for this season.Ledley was a big part of Wales success in the Euros which was based on keeping possession of the ball between the 3 at the back and the 5 in midfield.He would never have sold Ledley that is just you spouting more b0ll0x because you have an issue with the midfield be it selling Jedi or not signing Rincon.Do your homework.

 

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we better without cabaye?