You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We can't progress because we won't let it happen
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We can't progress because we won't let it happen


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Mstrobez Flag 15 Aug 17 12.59am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Trouble is the 2 wide forwards high up the pitch so you less players defending overall. 3-5-2 is an alternative. You can have Zaha in a free role, Luka shielding and 2 midfielders doing their stuff from box to box with freedom they didn't have v Huddersfield.

I agree, that system with Luka holding and Cabaye/RLC would actually give us an excellent looking and solid midfield. I worry about Luka under Frank, great at the dirty work but does he really have the vision and passing ability required for his type of style.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 15 Aug 17 8.29am

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

I appreciate the thoroughness of your message however would like to offer you an alternative point of view. Perhaps even a bit of a qualified alternative point of view as I was a season ticket holder at the great Ajax mid nineties and a regular visitor of Ajax also under the Boer.

The main reason why the money floods in the English game is the attitude you seem to think rather derogatory about. Directness, attacking in principle, lots of things happening in the box. I think that is what brings worldwide TV money in the game. Now I will not say we were brilliant to watch under Allerdyce but in principle there is nothing wrong or not entertaining with a direct style.

You mention Guardiola and van Gaal. The first is indeed a prime example of system over everything. he now has to spent a s***load of money to try and repeat what he did at Barcelona and Bayern but any comparison with us is non existent as they are in a different league altogether. Van Gaal I would rate as tactically very very strong, he almost got us in the World cup final with a very average squad and to be honest very defensive football. Yet at Man Utd he made exactly the mistake that I am worried FdB is also making right now: putting system over squad and reality not taking into consideration what the crowd wants and be arrogant and know it all about it.

And you may think its appropriate to call a groaning crowd pathetic but sorry to say that I may well have been one of the groaners. Maybe you should allow people to have there own preference of style and not by default assume a new system will bring superior football and entertainment. I come across to England not to see a possession based style of football that leads to no treat, no action in the box and defenders playing it to each other. I have seen so much of this in the Amsterdam Arena that it may just be too much effort to travel across for. And yes, I feel strongly about it and will ask the question: do we really get more entertainment from a different style? And would we really think, at the moment we are a club that can move up the table into European positions? Tweak things yes, try things out fine, but the attitude of "a new system is there to be implied, whatever" is not something I will buy.

Also I would think it is rather odd you call the Chelsea style of football of last season s***ty, yet this is exactly the style FdB wants to introduce. What furthermore, strangely so, has gone completely under the radar is that FdB never ever played this system at Ajax. That was simply a 4 man defense, with 3 in midfield and yes, 2 wingers and central attacking player upfront. Something I would hope he would soon settle for with us.

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.45pm)

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.46pm)


That's a great well reasoned post. Johan well done


Edited by Lyons550 (15 Aug 2017 8.30am)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 15 Aug 17 8.32am

Originally posted by Lyons550


That's a great well reasoned post. Johan well done


Edited by Lyons550 (15 Aug 2017 8.30am)

Agree with this , A Great Post by Johan.

 

beer man Flag Kent 15 Aug 17 8.36am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Agree with this , A Great Post by Johan.


Also agree, excellent post.

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 15 Aug 17 3.02pm

O.k I understand some of the frustration and also agree that there is no point installing FdB as manager and not giving him the opportunity to do what he has been put in place to do. What I don’t understand is why everyone is so sure that we have to ‘progress’ to possession game in order to be successful, Leicester played a counter attacking game and won the league, Chelsea do enjoy more possession then the opposition in most matches but that’s because most team do what Allardyce did and defend, when Chelsea play a top team they sit back and counter attack. Athletico Madrid rank 10th for possession last year in la Liga , Juventus beat Barcelona in the champions league quarter final 3-0 with just 32% possession and pass success rate of 74% compared to 88%.
Arguable Palace are actual quite good in possession in certain circumstance mainly when we win the ball in our half with the other team attacking, when is Zaha at his best ? When he can attack a full back at speed with 30-40 yards to run in to. I appreciate that is not going to come as a shock but we are poor is when teams come to defend we can’t break them down. What we need is a good number 10, to break down set defences and link up the play in the final third not a radically over haul of the team ,system or style. I’m not arguing that we should ‘hoof it’ but there is nothing wrong in moving the ball quickly into an attacking position and not allowing the opposition defence to get set, possession for possession sake or slowing the game and playing out from the back doesn’t really suit us.


Edited by Ketteridge (15 Aug 2017 4.53pm)

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

Mr Fenandes Flag 15 Aug 17 3.18pm

uMAXit have just written a pretty good article that sums up the change in philosophy:

[Link]

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Aug 17 4.02pm

Originally posted by Mr Fenandes

uMAXit have just written a pretty good article that sums up the change in philosophy:

[Link]

Good article and emphasises the need for time that Guardiola and Pochettino got. But it doesn't mention formation changes here. Is it imperative we play with 3 at the back and 3 high up the pitch? Can it not be done with 4 at the back the players understand? Or 3-5-2 without 3 players so far from the ball when we're under pressure and actually 3 central midfielders to actually 'dominate' rather than 2 getting dominated?

I feel this 3-4-3 has been decided regardless of the squad he arrived with and the players he could sign, and boy did it show. 3 new players vs Huddersfield and still 3 players short.

Good luck Frank.

 


COYP

Aray Flag South London 15 Aug 17 4.29pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

This style of football only works if you have top players. So yes when Barcelona, Bayern etc play it they win. But take any mid table team from any other league and put them in the premier league and they will be just as s*** as we were today.

Bournemouth play possession football.

 

Aray Flag South London 15 Aug 17 4.40pm

great post by Johan. I also liked that website link. I am torn. Rome wasn't built in a day but I do fear we're in a dog fight and i'm not sure there's sufficient fight in our team.

i'm not writing FdB off yet.

 

johnno42000 Flag 15 Aug 17 8.18pm

I'm watching the Hoffenheim - Liverpool match and Hoffenheim seem to be playing the 3 at the back. They move the ball so much quicker than we did and their players are constantly moving to make space, all the way from their back 3 to the forward. We didn't. At present they are doing very well.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Part Time James Flag 15 Aug 17 8.20pm

Hamburger

 




Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 15 Aug 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by Ketteridge

O.k I understand some of the frustration and also agree that there is no point installing FdB as manager and not giving him the opportunity to do what he has been put in place to do. What I don’t understand is why everyone is so sure that we have to ‘progress’ to possession game in order to be successful, Leicester played a counter attacking game and won the league, Chelsea do enjoy more possession then the opposition in most matches but that’s because most team do what Allardyce did and defend, when Chelsea play a top team they sit back and counter attack. Athletico Madrid rank 10th for possession last year in la Liga , Juventus beat Barcelona in the champions league quarter final 3-0 with just 32% possession and pass success rate of 74% compared to 88%.
Arguable Palace are actual quite good in possession in certain circumstance mainly when we win the ball in our half with the other team attacking, when is Zaha at his best ? When he can attack a full back at speed with 30-40 yards to run in to. I appreciate that is not going to come as a shock but we are poor is when teams come to defend we can’t break them down. What we need is a good number 10, to break down set defences and link up the play in the final third not a radically over haul of the team ,system or style. I’m not arguing that we should ‘hoof it’ but there is nothing wrong in moving the ball quickly into an attacking position and not allowing the opposition defence to get set, possession for possession sake or slowing the game and playing out from the back doesn’t really suit us.


Edited by Ketteridge (15 Aug 2017 4.53pm)

Agree with this completely. This "next level" is a myth and nobody has actually managed it. Pursuing it ended up killing Charlton.

We still have the rich six and Everton. Most of the stuff you read and hear about tactics etc is self prophesising nonsense from people trying to bluff that they're smarter than they really are.


 

You What Flag se25 15 Aug 17 8.37pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

After an extremely poor result and performance I'm gonna put an opinion out that I know will prove unpopular but here goes.

In England, we delude ourselves senseless that we have the best league in the world. We go on about how much harder it is in england in comparison to Spain and Germany but our top teams never compete in Europe. We constantly talk down a possession based style of play, despite the fact that the best teams in the world play with this style and produce some of the most entertaining and successful teams and players in the world.

A new manager comes to the premier league, say a Pep or Van Gaal and instantly everyone calls them out to fail because "it doesn't work in the premier league". And the minute there is a bad result, the media and the fans are on progressive type managers like a pack of wolves with the "I told you so's" "you ain't in Spain/Holland/Germany/Italy anymore pal" etc etc.

No one ever stops to see the bigger picture, everyone wants instant results and success, regardless of longevity. Regardless of building anything in the long term. Regardless of whether or not overall they could build a more successful team that actually wins consistently or continentally. It's all now now now. The consequence of this is teams like Chelsea, playing a s***ty brand of football, winning the league and then the next season not even coming close to doing anything, getting knocked out by a European giant in the champions league and sacking Conte.

This is the epitome of what I saw at Selhurst today. There has been negativity around trying a new approach from the minute it was brought up. Every time we tried to play out from the back, the crowd groaned. Every time Hennessey or Dann or Riedewald didn't hoof the ball out, the crowd groaned. Ironically, when they did then hoof it out, the crowd also groaned. I think as fans we massively underestimate the amount it undermines the team and quite frankly one game in to the season, I think it was utterly pathetic.

The reason we won't progress is because of this attitude, we cannot improve without giving it a chance. Its funny how we bang on about "OH NOT A FAN OF THIS TIPPY TAPPY NONSENSE" yet completely ignore the fact that the newly promoted side who tanked us today are a team who've worked on a progressive type system for the past year. They're no hoof ball merchants, they're patient in possession, tactically sound and they play as a team.

There were many negatives in today's performance, that goes without saying. I have my own reservations about De Boer. We looked defensively all over the place and god forbid we sustain any injuries because barring Cabaye that would've been pretty much a fully fit team we put out today. But unless we try and get better, unless we adapt to the modern game, we will stagnate and it will inevitably lead to relegation because there are only so many Big Sams and Pulises knocking about and we've used up those 2 life lines already.

I predict the media will inevitably already have De Boer as a target and it would seem the fans have already passed judgement and deemed this a failed experiment. This will probably lead to a half hearted approach to our new style at the fear of being ruined by the press and booed every time we evade Hennessey hitting and hoping for the best. I've got my tin hat firmly on for this one and I will make a speedy exit before I undoubtedly get destroyed by many on here but this is my opinion about the Premier league in general. And it's one I've had for years, I don't buy the media nonsense pushed down our throat in this country about how amazingly excellent our league is.
Watch how one of the European giants play on a big champions league night, that's the best football in the world in my opinion, not this counter attacking "let's be avin ya" 80s type s*** that is common in the premier league.

B*llocks

 

You What Flag se25 15 Aug 17 9.04pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

I appreciate the thoroughness of your message however would like to offer you an alternative point of view. Perhaps even a bit of a qualified alternative point of view as I was a season ticket holder at the great Ajax mid nineties and a regular visitor of Ajax also under the Boer.

The main reason why the money floods in the English game is the attitude you seem to think rather derogatory about. Directness, attacking in principle, lots of things happening in the box. I think that is what brings worldwide TV money in the game. Now I will not say we were brilliant to watch under Allerdyce but in principle there is nothing wrong or not entertaining with a direct style.

You mention Guardiola and van Gaal. The first is indeed a prime example of system over everything. he now has to spent a s***load of money to try and repeat what he did at Barcelona and Bayern but any comparison with us is non existent as they are in a different league altogether. Van Gaal I would rate as tactically very very strong, he almost got us in the World cup final with a very average squad and to be honest very defensive football. Yet at Man Utd he made exactly the mistake that I am worried FdB is also making right now: putting system over squad and reality not taking into consideration what the crowd wants and be arrogant and know it all about it.

And you may think its appropriate to call a groaning crowd pathetic but sorry to say that I may well have been one of the groaners. Maybe you should allow people to have there own preference of style and not by default assume a new system will bring superior football and entertainment. I come across to England not to see a possession based style of football that leads to no treat, no action in the box and defenders playing it to each other. I have seen so much of this in the Amsterdam Arena that it may just be too much effort to travel across for. And yes, I feel strongly about it and will ask the question: do we really get more entertainment from a different style? And would we really think, at the moment we are a club that can move up the table into European positions? Tweak things yes, try things out fine, but the attitude of "a new system is there to be implied, whatever" is not something I will buy.

Also I would think it is rather odd you call the Chelsea style of football of last season s***ty, yet this is exactly the style FdB wants to introduce. What furthermore, strangely so, has gone completely under the radar is that FdB never ever played this system at Ajax. That was simply a 4 man defense, with 3 in midfield and yes, 2 wingers and central attacking player upfront. Something I would hope he would soon settle for with us.

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.45pm)

Edited by DutchEagleJohan (14 Aug 2017 5.46pm)


Excellent post. Best so far this season.


Edited by You What (15 Aug 2017 9.05pm)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 15 Aug 17 9.09pm

Originally posted by Aray

Bournemouth play possession football.

So do Swansea and Huddersfield.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 15 Aug 17 9.36pm

Our last season in the Championship, Freedman introduced a new style with us. We looked uncomfortable and started off with a pre-season defeat at Welling United, before losing our first 3 games included a 4-1 drubbing at Bristol City, plus a 4-1 at Preston in the cup. We were bottom of the league by the end of August.

We signed a couple of players who suited the system (Delaney, Bolasie, Moritz), went 14 games unbeaten and ended up promoted.

Let's wait until the end of the window and see who we get in. This time last year, we still had Bolasie and didn't have Benteke.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Mstrobez Flag 15 Aug 17 10.46pm

Originally posted by You What

B*llocks

Great contribution.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

majorkaios Flag Trowbridge, Wilts 15 Aug 17 11.25pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

3:4:3 = relegation
4:3:3 = survival

Your choice.

Edited by Sansbup (12 Aug 2017 6.45pm)

Let's AGREE TO DISAGREE

3:4:3 = survival, WITH A GROWING AND DESIREABLE ACADEMY

4:3:3 = possible survival, but eventual Bankcrupsy as we won't afford much more than hoof ball players.

COYP

 


School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. ))

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Aug 17 11.43pm

Originally posted by majorkaios

Let's AGREE TO DISAGREE

3:4:3 = survival, WITH A GROWING AND DESIREABLE ACADEMY

4:3:3 = possible survival, but eventual Bankcrupsy as we won't afford much more than hoof ball players.

COYP

So you can only grow an academy and do things prudently with 3-4-3? Are you absolutely sure?

Have you actually looked at the squad? Have you not noticed we have 3 excellent central midfielders in Luka, Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek and 3-4-3 only uses 2? Have you also not noticed we do not have a right wing back?

There is also 4-2-3-1. 4-1-4-1. 3-5-2.

 


COYP

batcountry Flag Melbourne 15 Aug 17 11.43pm

The big problem with "hoofball" is it doesn't commit opposition to making decisions they're uncomfortable with. If they know what's coming it gives defenders time to double team on the obvious target men. That's why Wilf usually has three defenders around him because they have nothing else to do. Also the distance of the passer from the target man means our cavalry arrives too late to support our more gifted players who become isolated.

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We can't progress because we won't let it happen