You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Statues
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Confederate Statues


Page 4 of 30 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 16 Aug 17 5.42pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol


[Link]

Not all, but some.

Good to see they are renaming it

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 16 Aug 17 5.44pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

Why not put a statue of a famous black person by the side of the ones from the Confederacy? Also every Founding Father (bunch of traitors, all of them) owned slaves.

Yes, they did. Later, their successors decided that owning people was wrong and changed the law; Robert E. Lee and his ilk took up arms in opposition to that and nearly a million people died.

Also, giving a historical black figure equal prominence with a Confederate general is a Bolasian missing of the point.

Edited by Ray in Houston (16 Aug 2017 5.47pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

elgrande Flag bedford 16 Aug 17 5.49pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Yes, they did. Later, their successors decided that owning people was wrong and changed the law; Robert E. Lee and his ilk took up arms in opposition to that and nearly a million people died.

Also, giving a historical black figure equal prominence with a Confederate general is a Bolasian missing of the point.

Edited by Ray in Houston (16 Aug 2017 5.47pm)

Not sure it does to be honest.
If say you put a statue of Obama next to or near Lee,would that not send the right message out.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 16 Aug 17 5.50pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Not in the slightest. Read it again.

What you should be inferring is that ugly history should remain as something visible to challenge, learn from and serve as a clear reminder of what can happen when the rule of reason and ethics is sacrificed to the will of the rich and powerful.

I am not as relaxed about the airbrushing of history by lessening the visibility of its darker side as some people obviously are.


You appear quite relaxed about the airbrushing performed by erecting these statues in the first place.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 16 Aug 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Not sure it does to be honest.
If say you put a statue of Obama next to or near Lee,would that not send the right message out.

I'd say that message would be one of confusion.

It also wouldn't erase the reason why those statues were put up in the first place.

 

wordup Flag 16 Aug 17 5.56pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Different times, racism was a part of life....It's wrong and terrible but we also have to remember that these people and people now had relatives from these times. Sure some demonise and some understand and know it was wrong and a product of the times.

I think most of us agree that slavery and racism is wrong but as soon as you start screwing around with people's histories people get upset...whatever side they are on.

Hot-heads create more hot-heads. This said, people are responsible for their own actions but rhetoric doesn't help. Life has taught me that a closed fist meets a closed fist. If someone spat on a statue for the leader of an army that I had a relative in....well I'm going to be pissed off.

Other people don't get to tell them how they should feel about that. I know the resentment that causes. Essentially I can tell that more violence is on the way from both sides.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Aug 2017 2.41pm)

If spitting at a monument makes you want to punch someone in the face, consider what the political placement of this monument during a time of lynchings and heavy KKK activity decades after the civil war does to a person of colour and their families. Or don't their relatives count?

That's what I mean about this one sided emotional connection. These movements on the left and right take advantage of the most emotionally numb to one side of an argument. You called Richard Spencer a 'jerk' in the other thread. Maybe you should ask yourself why you need to water down the fact that he's a white supremacist who wants 'peaceful ethnic cleaning' and has denounced Jews but not Adolf Hitler.. why don't you appear to particularly care about that but someone spitting gets you filled with rage.

Still, violence on all sides is wrong in my book, whether aimed at an angry white supremacist, someone spitting at a monument, a ranting raving university student. They're going to need heavier police presence at these events.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Aug 17 5.58pm

Putting up a statue of anyone is questionable. People are just people. Giving them a statue suggests they are something more.
If you remove statues of everyone who had done bad things then there would be no statues.

My concern is not who's statue is being removed but why.
If this is another case of people running scared of offending particular minority groups then where will it all end?

What ridiculous demands will we cave into next?

I'm getting a little irritated by the Colosseum. Some of my ancestors probably died in there. And Nelson's column?
All those people he killed in sea battles. Bang out of order

 

elgrande Flag bedford 16 Aug 17 6.00pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

I'd say that message would be one of confusion.

It also wouldn't erase the reason why those statues were put up in the first place.

Why,surely it would say that the country has come a long way since black people were owned by white people..
I would say it sends out a positive message.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

wordup Flag 16 Aug 17 6.09pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Putting up a statue of anyone is questionable. People are just people. Giving them a statue suggests they are something more.
If you remove statues of everyone who had done bad things then there would be no statues.

My concern is not who's statue is being removed but why.
If this is another case of people running scared of offending particular minority groups then where will it all end?

What ridiculous demands will we cave into next?

I'm getting a little irritated by the Colosseum. Some of my ancestors probably died in there. And Nelson's column?
All those people he killed in sea battles. Bang out of order

I think we can ask the very same questions about when and why it was put up as we can the timing of when and why it was taken down.

We should find a way to democratically move all of these decisions to those in the areas involved. The alternative it to care what those outraged about a monument they hadn't even heard of the previous week think. And those on the left and right bused in to show outrage whenever something hits the headlines should be given short thrift.

Edited by wordup (16 Aug 2017 6.10pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Aug 17 6.59pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

This is such nonsense as a rationale to defend the south in the civil war. Many Germans died fighting for the Nazis too so, by your reckoning, it'd be ok - in 1990 - to erect a statue of Hitler in Berlin to honour those reluctant German soldiers who died in WW2?

You are so full of nonsense. Jefferson Davis was the leader of the confederacy. Hitler led the Nazi party and Germany.

I'd have no problem with a statue of Rommel. There are statues of him in Germany. Like Lee he was a general under whom many died.

The statue of Lee was in the south. Having a statue of Rommel in the UK would be like having a statue of Lee in the north.

I'm getting fed up with your nonsense now.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Aug 2017 7.12pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Aug 17 7.27pm

Originally posted by wordup

I think we can ask the very same questions about when and why it was put up as we can the timing of when and why it was taken down.

We should find a way to democratically move all of these decisions to those in the areas involved. The alternative it to care what those outraged about a monument they hadn't even heard of the previous week think. And those on the left and right bused in to show outrage whenever something hits the headlines should be given short thrift.

Edited by wordup (16 Aug 2017 6.10pm)

That is a fair point.

I'd need to be convinced that they were erected purely to celebrate 'racism' and slavery before I took a sledgehammer to them.

 

johnno42000 Flag 16 Aug 17 8.00pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Yes, they did. Later, their successors decided that owning people was wrong and changed the law; Robert E. Lee and his ilk took up arms in opposition to that and nearly a million people died.

Also, giving a historical black figure equal prominence with a Confederate general is a Bolasian missing of the point.

Edited by Ray in Houston (16 Aug 2017 5.47pm)

But not those traitors so any monuments to them should be ripped down. Are you certain none of their descendants let out a good old rebel yell? Also Washington must appear nowhere, vile traitor and slave owner.

What's Yannick got to do with it? My idea would sort out everyones problems, a confederate soldier alongside perhaps a black soldier who fought on the Union or Confederate side (not many I grant you but there were some).

Edited by johnno42000 (16 Aug 2017 8.01pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 16 Aug 17 8.08pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Not sure it does to be honest.
If say you put a statue of Obama next to or near Lee,would that not send the right message out.

I don't think so, it would put them as historical equals which is problematic as one was President and one lead an army in rebellion against the elected government.

Now, Obama's going to get his statues elsewhere, so I'm not saying that such things need to be reshuffled every time a prominent figure emerges. But putting a statue to, say, Frederick Douglas, next to Lee is going to increase the insult to those who already find Lee's statue insulting - that being the residents of Charlottesville.

They wanted Lee moved. Other towns will choose differently. This is why democracy is messy.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 16 Aug 17 8.16pm

Say there were statues of Hitler still standing in Germany, should they be left standing or perhaps should they be torn down and in some cases moved to museums where they can be studied in context. I say this because there are literally still statues of Hefferson Davis still standing all over the states despite what he and the confederacy represents.


Like I said, the problem is what these statues represent. It's all very well saying that pulling them down is airbrushing history, but there have been more going up in the early part of last century and a changing narrative is the south to the idea of "the lost cause". That's some serious revisionism by the right in America and people like Lee are being used as figures in this completely bullsh*t revisionist viewing of the civil war, hence the outrage from those from that part of the political spectrum at the statues coming down.


Call me simplistic, but if Neo nazis and the KKK are against you taking down a statue, that to me suggests it's a pretty good idea to take it down.

Edited by coulsdoneagle (16 Aug 2017 8.17pm)

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 16 Aug 17 8.19pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You are so full of nonsense. Jefferson Davis was the leader of the confederacy. Hitler led the Nazi party and Germany.

I'd have no problem with a statue of Rommel. There are statues of him in Germany. Like Lee he was a general under whom many died.

The statue of Lee was in the south. Having a statue of Rommel in the UK would be like having a statue of Lee in the north.

I'm getting fed up with your nonsense now.

Lee's statue was erected in the south 50 years after the end of the civil war. I equated that to a statue of Hitler being erected in Berlin 50 years after the end of WW2. You are making s*** up, attributing it to me and then accusing me of "nonsense".

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 16 Aug 17 8.21pm

Presumably many on here think that all copies of the Band's "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" should be destroyed and the song banned from the airways and Robbie Robertson should be tried for confederate sympathies - and that Joan Baez as she covered it too.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 16 Aug 17 8.31pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

But not those traitors so any monuments to them should be ripped down. Are you certain none of their descendants let out a good old rebel yell? Also Washington must appear nowhere, vile traitor and slave owner.

What's Yannick got to do with it? My idea would sort out everyones problems, a confederate soldier alongside perhaps a black soldier who fought on the Union or Confederate side (not many I grant you but there were some).


As I said, Washington et al were slave owners and there is no excusing that. Washington, while the leader of a revolution, is not a traitor to the crown as that was settled by the Treaty of Paris that ended the war and under which England recognised the independence of the United States.

Lee was pardoned by President Jackson at the end of the civil war, so he's not a traitor either. But Lee's statue isn't being taken down (solely) because he was a slave owner; it's being taken down because the people of Charlottesville want it so. And it's not to destroy the statue; they are moving it to a site of less prominence befitting their opinion of legacy of the man.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 16 Aug 17 8.32pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Presumably many on here think that all copies of the Band's "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" should be destroyed and the song banned from the airways and Robbie Robertson should be tried for confederate sympathies - and that Joan Baez as she covered it too.

I think you will find that Joan just liked the tune after her record company suggested she might record it.
She was as liberal as they get.

I'm sure you knew that.

 

johnno42000 Flag 16 Aug 17 8.39pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


As I said, Washington et al were slave owners and there is no excusing that. Washington, while the leader of a revolution, is not a traitor to the crown as that was settled by the Treaty of Paris that ended the war and under which England recognised the independence of the United States.

Lee was pardoned by President Jackson at the end of the civil war, so he's not a traitor either. But Lee's statue isn't being taken down (solely) because he was a slave owner; it's being taken down because the people of Charlottesville want it so. And it's not to destroy the statue; they are moving it to a site of less prominence befitting their opinion of legacy of the man.

Of course they were traitors, they rebelled against the King who ruled the colony. That makes them treacherous scoundrels who, if we had won, would rightly have been executed as traitors.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

wordup Flag 16 Aug 17 8.40pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

That is a fair point.

I'd need to be convinced that they were erected purely to celebrate 'racism' and slavery before I took a sledgehammer to them.

That would be unprovable I'd say though it is interesting to see when most of these monuments popped up.

Even if or when a monument was removed should a local community decide so do so, I wouldn't ever be in favour of it being destroyed. It's still a part of history and something we can learn from.

mon.JPG Attachment: mon.JPG (36.45Kb)

 

Page 4 of 30 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Confederate Statues