You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are we in this mess?
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are we in this mess?


Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Mr. Talons Flag Southampton 02 Oct 17 5.13am

It all started to go wrong when Parish started listening to that certain voice in his left ear, telling him who we should buy.

Three certain players and £80 million later, we're worse off than we were before, with seemingly no way out.

We could have and should have spent much more wisely.

Before anyone replies with words to the effect of "Hindsight is a wonderful thing", I've been saying this since before we bought Benteke.

 

tangerineeagle Flag cleveleys,lancs 02 Oct 17 11.12am

SP has done more good than bad,but for me two monumental mistakes were sanctioning the sale of Dwight gayle,and buying benteke

 


clowns to the left of me,jokers to the right

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Oct 17 11.20am

Originally posted by tangerineeagle

SP has done more good than bad,but for me two monumental mistakes were sanctioning the sale of Dwight gayle,and buying benteke

I agree with your first comment that SP has done more good than bad but I don't agree that either selling Gayle or buying Benteke were bad mistakes

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 02 Oct 17 12.06pm

too many short-term strategies all bandaged together have lead us to this mess. FDB's sacking and Roy's appointment is the straw that broke the camel's back.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 02 Oct 17 12.32pm

Originally posted by oldstand

Big Sam appears to avoid any criticism, his walk out has contributed to this mess. Bought players to get us over the line, not players to take us forward.

Never a truer word said. BFS was only after his bonus for keeping us up and it was HIS choice to leave NOT SP giving him the boot or not enough transfer funds. SP was as shocked as we were when BFS went into the office and handed his notice in. His decision to retire was because a very close friend had just died plus he was losing interest in football in general. He has said this many times since. Remember he has to pay our club a couple of million quid if he takes another managers appointment within two years of leaving us.
He bought in players that did the job for HIM and not a long term future and SP put up the money for them so why SPO gets all the flack for what has happened I just do not know. OK he made a few mistakes but is man enough to admit it and is in the process of putting things right. The striker situation was only partly his fault as he was digging out trying to get a good deal with Liverpool for Sakho who we all wanted back with Palace, this he did and the strikers he wanted to bring in either through agents being greedy or ones that opted against joining us. Benteke cost us a bomb and has not delivered this term and has got quite lazy and our other two strikers Ladapo and Wickham do not feature in the team. Having gone seven matches without even one goal is soul destroying to us all but lets get on with just supporting the lads in the hope that their confidence comes back and Roy can kick them into top gear and get them proud to wear a Palace shirt. We have seen dark times before and there will be more to come but lets look forward to better times and some goals in the near future.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 02 Oct 17 12.48pm

This is about more than the manager.

Since January of 2016 we have played 64 league games and scored 52 points.

If that was not bad enough, take out Sahko last season (and that miraculous spell of results) and it is played 56 and scored 36 points. There is something more fundamentally wrong than just the manager, playing style, etc.

Sam made it clear that the players were not listening to him and that is took a monumental slice of luck to get the results we did to stay up. FDB also made similar comments about player power, and whatever one thinks of him his spotlighting Mutch, Ward, Delaney, Hennessey, and Lee as not being good enough was not wrong. Yet, they are all still at the club.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 Oct 17 12.54pm

Player purchase is one neat and easy diagnosis. Save for the well-healed segment of this division, there are 13 teams between which you can barely pass a cigarette paper such is the fine margins that separate them. Thus, a Palace or Stoke side - if it were able to field a fully fit 1st XI each week - should finish 8th - 12th. The skill is to have at least one player standing by who is almost as good as the first XI to cope with rotation, suspension, injury etc.

The latter Pardew months saw a lot of fans get on his back. You simply can't convince them - even now - that it was anything but his fault... FOR EVERYTHING. I (partly) disagree. Our side was unbalanced by the Souare injury. While there was cover elsewhere, we had no appropriate LB substitute. Fryers could not cut it, so we had to field players out of position. In what should have been evenly matched games where we could have won by the odd goal we lost by the odd goal. This should not have happened had we sold Fryers and bought an upgrade that summer. It was a colossal error. January came; we got 2 left sided players thereby restoring the balance (as well as bolstering the CB); the results came; and Allardyce took the credit (would Pardew have been stuffed 4-0 at home by the bottom team???).

This time, same story; but its strikers. True, a better keeper, RB and (I can only dream) someone almost as good as Zaha would be nice. However, the coffers are only so deep. Nevertheless, could have bought a striker in the summer; should have bought; didn't learn.

Manager selection also has to play its part. I do appreciate the pool for us is small and not that good. If we can't persuade Dyche to leave Burnley for us that leaves us with the risk of inexperienced managers from the lower leagues or managers with no experience of English football - together with all the accompanying risk - or else a "safe pair of hands" currently kicking around since their last sacking. We chose the former.

True, I can see the dream. 3 times title winner in Holland followed by an ignominious sacking in Italy (that was not his fault?). It could have been great. Sadly: right manager; right place; wrong time. We are still reeling from the disturbance and our confidence is shot. Hence we have had to opt - once again - for the latter short term option.

On player buying fault is relatively easy to attribute. On management I think the task is harder. With Sam dumping us like he did, there was insufficient time to do the sort of due diligence clubs in our league do. Nevertheless, are we right to expect that - 5 seasons in - we should have a settled team and player management? Possibly.

However, I fear we may still be handicapped and haunted by our not too distant past. We are weighed down by our dilapidated infrastructure which diverts funds, ring-fences the international investment and hamstrings us under FFP rules; at the same time we are hell bent on running a tight fiscal ship and never fall into financial ruin again. Even if relegated. No team in this division - even the newly promoted ones - have these problems.

Transform the ground (but not into a soulless bowl!), upgrade the support facilities and vastly increase our corporate non-TV earnings while, at the same time, maintaining our top flight status means we can probably then lure and afford better players and managers. Meanwhile, we have to operate at a healthy profit with what we have while keeping fickle over-expectant fans on side.

Senior management is dead easy!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Oct 17 1.00pm

Parish going on holiday to massage Zaha's about a day or two after Sam resigned when Silva was out of work doesn't look too clever now does it?

His agent must've said that Watford wanted to tie it up by the weekend so why Parish thought them using up 2 critical days flying to Spain was reasonable I don't know. When there's a man in demand you go to charm and chase him, not expect him to chase you.

Then there's the dithering and having to take Frank because of the delay. And not taking Dyche seriously.

There were 2 managers with prem experience he barely bothered with. Prem experience is his prerequisite and he signed Frank. Look at Watford and Burnley and look at us. There are issues aside from the manager one but if we hired either of those 2 we'd be in better shape and if we did get relegated by bad luck under Dyche than rank incompetence then there aren't many I'd prefer as our manager.

 


COYP

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 02 Oct 17 1.03pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Player purchase is one neat and easy diagnosis. Save for the well-healed segment of this division, there are 13 teams between which you can barely pass a cigarette paper such is the fine margins that separate them. Thus, a Palace or Stoke side - if it were able to field a fully fit 1st XI each week - should finish 8th - 12th. The skill is to have at least one player standing by who is almost as good as the first XI to cope with rotation, suspension, injury etc.

The latter Pardew months saw a lot of fans get on his back. You simply can't convince them - even now - that it was anything but his fault... FOR EVERYTHING. I (partly) disagree. Our side was unbalanced by the Souare injury. While there was cover elsewhere, we had no appropriate LB substitute. Fryers could not cut it, so we had to field players out of position. In what should have been evenly matched games where we could have won by the odd goal we lost by the odd goal. This should not have happened had we sold Fryers and bought an upgrade that summer. It was a colossal error. January came; we got 2 left sided players thereby restoring the balance (as well as bolstering the CB); the results came; and Allardyce took the credit (would Pardew have been stuffed 4-0 at home by the bottom team???).

This time, same story; but its strikers. True, a better keeper, RB and (I can only dream) someone almost as good as Zaha would be nice. However, the coffers are only so deep. Nevertheless, could have bought a striker in the summer; should have bought; didn't learn.

Manager selection also has to play its part. I do appreciate the pool for us is small and not that good. If we can't persuade Dyche to leave Burnley for us that leaves us with the risk of inexperienced managers from the lower leagues or managers with no experience of English football - together with all the accompanying risk - or else a "safe pair of hands" currently kicking around since their last sacking. We chose the former.

True, I can see the dream. 3 times title winner in Holland followed by an ignominious sacking in Italy (that was not his fault?). It could have been great. Sadly: right manager; right place; wrong time. We are still reeling from the disturbance and our confidence is shot. Hence we have had to opt - once again - for the latter short term option.

On player buying fault is relatively easy to attribute. On management I think the task is harder. With Sam dumping us like he did, there was insufficient time to do the sort of due diligence clubs in our league do. Nevertheless, are we right to expect that - 5 seasons in - we should have a settled team and player management? Possibly.

However, I fear we may still be handicapped and haunted by our not too distant past. We are weighed down by our dilapidated infrastructure which diverts funds, ring-fences the international investment and hamstrings us under FFP rules; at the same time we are hell bent on running a tight fiscal ship and never fall into financial ruin again. Even if relegated. No team in this division - even the newly promoted ones - have these problems.

Transform the ground (but not into a soulless bowl!), upgrade the support facilities and vastly increase our corporate non-TV earnings while, at the same time, maintaining our top flight status means we can probably then lure and afford better players and managers. Meanwhile, we have to operate at a healthy profit with what we have while keeping fickle over-expectant fans on side.

Senior management is dead easy!

SP took 6 weeks to due come to a decision as to a new manager. We must hold the record! The rest as they say is history.

 


Bring back Brolin

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Oct 17 1.04pm

Good read Silvertop.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Oct 17 1.13pm

The left back debacle happened for 2 reasons.

1. When we're waiting to do a big deal, which we could do a little earlier and end up paying the same, we, for some reason, can't do another one. And money isn't an excuse because after signing Benteke we would only be spending £10 mil net. We then spent more in January than we would've done in the first place.

Similar with Sakho and no striker and prepared to put up over £10 mil for a striker.

2. Parish and Pardew were too close so a left back wasn't raised, or wasn't needed in their collective view and non challenging relationship.

I do wonder what freedman was advising as the deadline was getting closer and we weren't making enough moves in getting a striker in.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (02 Oct 2017 1.19pm)

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Oct 17 1.14pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Parish going on holiday to massage Zaha's about a day or two after Sam resigned when Silva was out of work doesn't look too clever now does it?

His agent must've said that Watford wanted to tie it up by the weekend so why Parish thought them using up 2 critical days flying to Spain was reasonable I don't know. When there's a man in demand you go to charm and chase him, not expect him to chase you.

Then there's the dithering and having to take Frank because of the delay. And not taking Dyche seriously.

There were 2 managers with prem experience he barely bothered with. Prem experience is his prerequisite and he signed Frank. Look at Watford and Burnley and look at us. There are issues aside from the manager one but if we hired either of those 2 we'd be in better shape and if we did get relegated by bad luck under Dyche than rank incompetence then there aren't many I'd prefer as our manager.

Makes a nice story, but there is no evidence of any truth in the Silva and Dyche part.
Unless you have inside information, you are just guessing.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Oct 17 1.22pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

SP took 6 weeks to due come to a decision as to a new manager. We must hold the record! The rest as they say is history.

It was more important to take Zaha on holiday a day or two after Sam resigning. I mean all chairmen do it. Don't they?

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Oct 17 1.29pm

Originally posted by Painter

Makes a nice story, but there is no evidence of any truth in the Silva and Dyche part.
Unless you have inside information, you are just guessing.

So if you are right, that Dyche and Silva laughed us off, which I doubt both did, then Parish was waiting for Southampton to choose their manager and effectively ours. It's not a coincidence we both announced our managers within 48 hours of each other. Because of all that we ended up with the one successful at the biggest club in his country, in a tinpot league McLaren won and a year after being sacked asap in Italy.

It looked odd to me then as it does now. I can only think it was either to do with time pressure if not for Frank's BS in interview. But then Frank wouldn't bullsh1t, would he?

 


COYP

Palace in the Blood Flag 02 Oct 17 1.39pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Must say Dyche has got Burnely playing very well. Also looks to have made good signings.

unfortunately we have tried to run before we can walk Much as I think Sakho and Benteke are great players I feel that by paying such a large proportion of our budget on these two the squad is paper thin elsewhere. Dyche has built on Burnley's lower table squad by purchasing some hard working lower to mid table EPL players. This was what we needed to do.

Whose fault ? Who knows.

Picking up afew points of other posts.

DF was very close to sack when we lost to BC in cup. Delaney, Bolasie and afew others then joined and we started to climb. However in my view DF has shown in other positions he is not a good manager. He got lucky so why is he back as Director of Football

Pullis wanted his own players which in someways is fine but SP wanted a resale value players like crouch didn't offer that. Also Pullis didn't want Zaha.

Pardew did fine first season and first part of second. Then the train hit the buffers. We suffered injuries particularly to Bolasie and that hurt us. We got to cup final and lost slightly unluckily. I think the mistake was then an attempt to change style and rather than trying to increase depth of squad we bought Benteke and Townsend and also sold Bolasie. Bolasie wanted to go no doubt but the previous few months had shown our backup wingers were not adequate so effectively he wasn't replaced. Rather than spending Bolasie money on Benteke we should have got 2 good pros. Left Back problems who could have foretold he would be involved in the car crash.

FDB I think was given money to spend, he just didn't spend it. I think he was told you have £40-£50 million We suggest Sakho, but by deadline day we had 1 player and 2 loanees and no-0ne had left. We had lost our games and he didn't seem to be learning lessons of EPL. So I think that is point SP and DF took over and got Sakho and tried to get striker over line.

Can we get out of this mess? I think we can. But players like Ward, Hennessey Puncheon are who we have, there is no point in moaning. There confidence is low so support them rather than slag them off

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Oct 17 1.44pm

Oh I support when I go, until everyone goes quiet. I might be close to just being silent from the off though.

 


COYP

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 02 Oct 17 1.47pm

1. Experienced Premier League managers like Pulis and Allardyce would rather defenestrate than spend another season with us.
2. Lack of long-term planning, and of the infrastructure and personnel which might allow us to plan for the long term.
3. On a related note, we always seem to be a transfer window behind, looking to plug obvious gaps that should have been filled months earlier in the previous window. Come January, this will be the case again; we should be in a position where we are looking forward, but we will be looking back.
4. A squad with too many players that are no longer good enough/were never good enough, who we haven't been able to sell and replace.
5. A squad with too many players who should still be useful at this level but who look like their form and confidence are shot after a dreadful couple of years.

Issues like these will continue to undermine the current and future manager(s).

Edited by the despotic banana (02 Oct 2017 1.48pm)

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

Croydon Sunset Flag London 02 Oct 17 1.59pm

Good post, some very relevant points made.

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

If anyone wants a breakdown of the figures, here is our league record since the moment Yannick Bolasie injured himself celebrating Chungy's winner at Stoke City just before Xmas 2015.

Won : 14


Lost : 40


Draw : 12


That is a devastating amount of losses for any team, at any level to absorb.

I think the YB injury did hurt us and that was also the season we jettisoned Glenn Murray and by mid-season had hired footballing mercenary Emmanuel Adebayor.

As important people declined (Jedi) in other areas we made terrible signings (Alex McCarthy) Remember him? and suddenly people like Patrick Bamford, who were never, ever going to be Palace were on board.

We have lost a core group and failed to replace them with players of the same mentality and toughness with a point to prove.

We lack Leaders and Winners........

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Oct 17 2.02pm

Originally posted by Painter

Makes a nice story, but there is no evidence of any truth in the Silva and Dyche part.
Unless you have inside information, you are just guessing.

We discussed Silva before, he was always going to Watford.
Not sure if Dyche wanted to move South.?
And we all wanted Zaha to sign because he was going to leave again.?
And because both Burnley and Watford have started well Parish is at fault as usual.
All the Holers praising Bournemouth and Evertons transfer policies have gone quiet.
Early days though we just need a WIN.
All we are saying is give us a goal.!!!!

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 Oct 17 2.34pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

SP took 6 weeks to due come to a decision as to a new manager. We must hold the record! The rest as they say is history.


You must be joking right? You seriously think Manure don't have other options for Mourinho waiting in the wings right now where provisional terms are being thrashed out? I suspect even Burnley have. Have you not noticed that teams that sack managers usually "find" their replacement with indecent speed. All managers know this. It is part and parcel of what they do and they are paid handsomely for it.

The big clubs take about a year over prospective new managers and players for full due diligence. That includes a full stress test, serious courting, secret discussions with agents etc. If nothing comes of it as the manager performs, both stay in their current role and no-one is any the wiser.

We weren't prepared as, unlike Watford who had clearly planned for this, we were completely taken by surprise. 6 weeks is not a record for slowness; it is the blink of an eye compared to the time and effort that normally goes into selecting a successor.

 

Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are we in this mess?