You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who is our Second-Greatest Ever Manager?
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who is our Second-Greatest Ever Manager?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
TheBigToePunt Flag 14 Dec 17 1.50pm

Whilst reading some of the positive comments about Roy Hodgson on another thread it struck me that it really doesn't take too much for a manager to become a potential CPFC managerial 'legend', or at least to be a serious contender for a place in our all time best top five.

Number one on the list is of course taken, most likely forever, by Steve Coppell (after whom the new stand absolutely must be named in my opinion) but after that there are fairly few obvious contenders.

We have quite a reasonable list to pick from when considering our five best ever players, but if you try to make a top five of managers it becomes quite hard work pretty quickly, which probably says quite a bit in itself.

Even so, who is your (second) greatest ever manager, and why?

Most of my nominations have some sort of black mark against their names which cancel out their achievements to some extent:

Freedman - Built a great side for a pittance in the championship which went on to get promoted and form the foundation for staying there (so far). Also buggered off to Bolton.

Dowie - Injected life into a corpse when he came in, created fantastic momentum which ended in promotion, and came a goal away from keeping us up. Then left to be 'closer to his family in the Northwest', which he achieved by managing Charlton.

Pulis - Easy to forget how dead in the water the team was when he came in. Rightly awarded League Manager of the Year for keeping us up, not only was this a near-miracle in itself, it was also the key to everything that the club has become since. Then walked out on the eve of the season leaving us in the lurch, lied to the club to get a load of money, and had to be dragged through the Courts where he was found, in no uncertain terms, to have acted with the utmost disdain for CPFC.

Any other ideas?


Edited by TheBigToePunt (14 Dec 2017 1.59pm)

 

jeeagles Flag 14 Dec 17 2.15pm

With Coppell, emotions aside, he took us to 3rd in the League, our first cup final and our joint second highest finish of 10th.

There's another guy who took us to 10th and a cup final but I'm sure mentioning his name would cause a meltdown.

Given the gigantic step between Coppell and anyone else, it's a tough choice.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 14 Dec 17 2.35pm

I'm gonna jump in with Lombardo. Love him!

I would state the case for Allison for the changes he made to the club, but that is more akin to stamping his mark a lot like the legacy SP is stamping on Selhurst and CPFC right now.

I wish I new more about Bert Head, but it is well before my time. I'd have to go with either Dowie or Smith as they got us promoted, but then I really don't like either of them. Might as well suggest Pardew.

Can I vote for Millen or Ray?

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Dec 17 3.22pm

We had a really good team under Smith in the 93/94 promotion season with Southgate, Armstrong, Gordon, etc. and crushed some of the opposition during that season (I remember the 5-1 win over Portsmouth particularly well). But then we sold Armstrong and didn't we replace him with Gabbiadini?

I'd never really thought about it, but the OP is right, the pickings are embarrassingly slim. I was too young, but what about Venables (in his first stint)?

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 14 Dec 17 3.49pm

Steve Bruce.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 14 Dec 17 4.24pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

We had a really good team under Smith in the 93/94 promotion season with Southgate, Armstrong, Gordon, etc. and crushed some of the opposition during that season (I remember the 5-1 win over Portsmouth particularly well). But then we sold Armstrong and didn't we replace him with Gabbiadini?

I'd never really thought about it, but the OP is right, the pickings are embarrassingly slim. I was too young, but what about Venables (in his first stint)?

I think anything that was achieved in his first stint (Team of the Eighties and all that) has been more than cancelled out by his second stint.

 

Park Road Flag 14 Dec 17 4.40pm

Edmund Goodman

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 14 Dec 17 4.51pm

Arthur Rowe

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

simlaboy Flag coulsdon 14 Dec 17 4.52pm

Malcolm, all day

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 14 Dec 17 5.11pm

Venables- first time around.

Don't even like mentioning him in the same breath as king Coppell though.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

est1905 Flag 14 Dec 17 5.23pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Whilst reading some of the positive comments about Roy Hodgson on another thread it struck me that it really doesn't take too much for a manager to become a potential CPFC managerial 'legend', or at least to be a serious contender for a place in our all time best top five.

Number one on the list is of course taken, most likely forever, by Steve Coppell (after whom the new stand absolutely must be named in my opinion) but after that there are fairly few obvious contenders.

We have quite a reasonable list to pick from when considering our five best ever players, but if you try to make a top five of managers it becomes quite hard work pretty quickly, which probably says quite a bit in itself.

Even so, who is your (second) greatest ever manager, and why?

Most of my nominations have some sort of black mark against their names which cancel out their achievements to some extent:

Freedman - Built a great side for a pittance in the championship which went on to get promoted and form the foundation for staying there (so far). Also buggered off to Bolton.

Dowie - Injected life into a corpse when he came in, created fantastic momentum which ended in promotion, and came a goal away from keeping us up. Then left to be 'closer to his family in the Northwest', which he achieved by managing Charlton.

Pulis - Easy to forget how dead in the water the team was when he came in. Rightly awarded League Manager of the Year for keeping us up, not only was this a near-miracle in itself, it was also the key to everything that the club has become since. Then walked out on the eve of the season leaving us in the lurch, lied to the club to get a load of money, and had to be dragged through the Courts where he was found, in no uncertain terms, to have acted with the utmost disdain for CPFC.

Any other ideas?


Edited by TheBigToePunt (14 Dec 2017 1.59pm)

If its judged on achievement only and working on the minutest of budgets-pretty much get the best out of what you have and ignore the negative circumstances of his departure, like or loathe him you'd have to say Terry Vennables was probably our best ever manager first time around.
Took on a struggling team, introduced youth prospects, got back to back promotions AND kept us in the top division (at one point for about 3 weeks we actually led the top division!)
No one had done that before. Only Coppell has done it since. Yes of course he quit Palace for QPR and took half our team with him which resulted in us tumbling down the league. He claims that was Raymond Bloye squeezing him out. Whatever, water under the bridge. But in terms of achievements, for me? Has to be Vennables

 

manoftaste Flag Hastings 14 Dec 17 6.18pm

Clearly Coppell tops the list and Est1905 is very persuasive in arguing that Venables (Team of the eighties and all that) comes second. Bert Head is obviously third as the manager who took us into the top division for the first time and kept us there against all the odds on a very modest transfer budget.

 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 14 Dec 17 6.42pm

I'd say it's between Bert Head who was the first manager to take us into the top flight or Venables first time around with the "Team of the 80s". Malcolm Alison had great charisma etc, but took us down two divisions and despite an F.A Cup semi-final while we were in the third tier never got us a promotion. Some would argue he laid the foundations for Venables, but his achievements can't justify the award going to him.
Coppell was clearly our greatest and an intelligent and nice man too.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 14 Dec 17 6.43pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

Clearly Coppell tops the list and Est1905 is very persuasive in arguing that Venables (Team of the eighties and all that) comes second. Bert Head is obviously third as the manager who took us into the top division for the first time and kept us there against all the odds on a very modest transfer budget.

^^^^^ This. Seconded. Agreed. ^^^^^

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

curlyeagle Flag crowborough 14 Dec 17 7.28pm

Burt Head or Big mal for me.

Absolutely loved the flamboyance of Alison.

 


Curly eagles dad, 45 years of Palace. Never ever a dull moment, Oh Happy Days

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 14 Dec 17 7.33pm

Cyril Spiers and Arthur Rowe ( did some scouting for him) Terry Venables (best Coach) Bert Head ( although he did buy a lot of players) Steve Coppell and Steve Bruce, possibly Roy Hodgson? Perhaps us armchair fans who find the job a doddle!

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 14 Dec 17 9.49pm

Steve Bruce. Such a shame it was so short lived.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 15 Dec 17 7.03am

by my definition of great, there's only Sir Steve in my living memory. If Roy could hack it for two seasons, the world could be his lobster.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Zimeagle Flag Harare 15 Dec 17 10.50am

For starting the club then taking over as manager for 25 years I'd say Edmund Goodman ( for that achievement he may even shade Steve Coppell ). Bert Head, Arthur Rowe and Dick Graham also brought success and progressed the club. Big Mal for the excitement and raising our profile, followed by Venables who built on Big Mal's work. It's difficult to choose one, given that they operated at different times under different constraints.

 

YT Flag Oxford 15 Dec 17 11.15am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

We had a really good team under Smith in the 93/94 promotion season with Southgate, Armstrong, Gordon, etc. and crushed some of the opposition during that season (I remember the 5-1 win over Portsmouth particularly well). But then we sold Armstrong and didn't we replace him with Gabbiadini?

I'd never really thought about it, but the OP is right, the pickings are embarrassingly slim. I was too young, but what about Venables (in his first stint)?

We wasted most of the pittance we received for Ian Wright on ‘Marco Goalo’ (not) Gabbiadini. Old age is affecting your memory

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who is our Second-Greatest Ever Manager?