You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our greatest player ever
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our greatest player ever


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
fozzaisere Flag 15 Apr 18 2.12am

I have just got in from a day out and watched the motd highlights.

From my standpoint will we ever see a player greater than Wilf Zaha? I am 29 been supporting palace for 19 years so missed the glory years etc but it's not just the skill, trickery etc but the passion this guy shows for the club. The way he celebrates goals - particularly brighton ones - feels me with so much happiness. Maybe i am being silly but can't see another talismanic homegrown player like him coming along for a life time. Long live king Zaha

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 15 Apr 18 2.47am

If you were a little nerdy and had the time on your hands to score someone on loyalty, match winning performance, technical skill, dribbles, other stuff, hair, tattoos and worth, then I think Wilf would fair well. Everyone has their favourite. Of the current team I love Luka who was just as responsible for today’s result if not arguably moreso.

In days gone by Lombardo was immense. Always loved Clinton!!

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Blue'n'red Flag Field of Chels (Orpington) 15 Apr 18 4.07am

His reaction at the final whistle ... shouting “yes” at the HF ... ignoring Knockhart who was trying to shake his hand!!!

 


They say hard work never hurt anyone ... but why take a chance?

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 15 Apr 18 8.13am

Zaha without a doubt.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Apr 18 8.57am

Tough call because I saw Wrighty in his pomp. He also had a knack of scoring important goals when we needed him. However he spoiled my love for him in the manner of his leaving and his over celebrations when he returned. So for me it is Zaha.

However the players I loved the most were big Dave Swindlehurst and Mark Bright.

 


One more point

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 15 Apr 18 9.07am

Originally posted by pstrutt

If you were a little nerdy and had the time on your hands to score someone on loyalty, match winning performance, technical skill, dribbles, other stuff, hair, tattoos and worth, then I think Wilf would fair well. Everyone has their favourite. Of the current team I love Luka who was just as responsible for today’s result if not arguably moreso.

In days gone by Lombardo was immense. Always loved Clinton!!

Think your missing the point a bit, Foss was using a combination of skill with love of the club. Sure Lombardo was a great player, but you can't say he loved Palace. Other greats (Samson, for example) couldn't wait to go to BIG club, not blaming them, just saying.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 15 Apr 18 9.11am

I've supported Palace over fifty years. Wilf is overall the best player we've had in that time.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 15 Apr 18 9.15am

In his position 100%, Wright, Lombardo and Sansom you would have to say have had better careers. In terms of club legend no one comes close to zaha.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 15 Apr 18 9.17am

In my lifetime, without a doubt, Johnny 'Budgie' Byrne. If keepers only then John Jackson.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 15 Apr 18 9.31am

As far as having an influence on the team i would say yes. The fact he is an academy product makes him even more special. He bleeds red and blue and thats why we love him so much. I think Sansom is the greatest, he went on to have a stellar career with Arsenal and England. Wilf is undoubtably the most loved player though

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 15 Apr 18 9.33am

Originally posted by Uphill

In my lifetime, without a doubt, Johnny 'Budgie' Byrne. If keepers only then John Jackson.

Yeah, i remember him too with great affection, (and Denis your username) but did he love the club like Zaha does? think that's what the P/O is getting at.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 15 Apr 18 9.39am

I have too many to mention, so I couldn’t single anyone out...

 

chrys51 Flag poole 15 Apr 18 10.04am

Geoff Thomas for me. Wore his heart on his sleeve and his driving runs with elbow flailing. Though for excitement on the ball Zaha is up there

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 15 Apr 18 10.19am

Don Rogers was brilliant but was only around for about 18 months - 1972-1974.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 15 Apr 18 11.33am

Wilf. No question. Been palace since birth but only really remember since late 80’s but he has an influence that goes beyond just his performance. Can turn a game at any given moment regardless of how he’s playing, we are lucky to have him and if England weren’t so stupid they would have been too.

 

Jacey Flag 15 Apr 18 12.09pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

I've supported Palace over fifty years. Wilf is overall the best player we've had in that time.

Agree, it's Wilf for me and even Shearer has joined the fan club.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 15 Apr 18 12.15pm

[quote=Blue'n'red;3327597]

His reaction at the final whistle ... shouting “yes” at the HF ... ignoring Knockhart who was trying to shake his hand!!!

Agree with everything apart from ignoring Knockhart, when all is said and done it's a game of football and players should be able to show a bit of sportsmanship at the end of it. If Knockhart was trying to kick the sh!t out of him during the game, then fair enough.

 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 15 Apr 18 12.27pm

In terms of being a player who could get in the very best club or international team consistently in their position it would be Kenny Sansom-as evidenced by his international caps and career. For excitement, there was no better sight than Don Rogers running at a defender then rounding the keeper. For grace and thrills, maybe it is Wilf.As a goal scorer, I suppose it's Ian Wright. I only saw Byrne when he came back to us and was past his best. Different positions call for different skills and attributes, so this is an enjoyable, but unanswerable question for me.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 15 Apr 18 12.34pm

For me he's certainly in the top 3 with Sansom and Wright, but at the moment 3rd of those 3..!!

Has all the potential to be number one - but needs to do it consistently over a couple more seasons yet.

This has been his best season yet - without Zaha this season we would have dead and buried by now - his stats and our results without him prove that.

To be in the top 3 in the company of legends such as Sansom and Wright is a hell of an achievement - especially when you consider where he was when we took him back from Man U in 2014.

On the greatest ever if he keeps us up this year Roy must be in with a shout of being mentioned alongside Coppell and Venables (first time around) - given where we were when he took over - 34 points in 26 games after losing our first 7 with no goals..!!

Just hope Roy has enough in the tank and desire for another couple of seasons..!!

Next 4 games, close season and probably more importantly if we stay up our/Steve's dealing in the transfer window will be the determining factor.

COYP

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 15 Apr 18 12.54pm

Each era has had its own 'greatest player'. Unfair to judge Wilf against Kenny Samson, Ian Wright or Johnny Byrne. Much harder to play in current era I think. Probably Wrighty had the greatest impact on the club but as has been said his later behaviour ruined his reputation (for me anyway). If Wilf can keep us up this year and next then I think he will lead the way as the individual player that has had the greatest impact on our club (and therefore could be argued our 'greatest player'.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our greatest player ever