You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and substitutes
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy and substitutes


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Osvaldo Flag Epsom 22 Oct 18 12.14pm

Totally agree with you. We are paying good money watching a lot of overpaid players under perform.
Then we have an ex England manager that can't discern when substitutions are required!
Then we have those responsible for buying (forwards) which were absolutely vital for this current season. This bunch of so called strikers can't score goals and we can't even score a penalty when it's put on the plate for us.
There is something drastically wrong somewhere and if we don't sought it out soon, we are going to be bottom of the league in 5/6 weeks and in 5/6 months relegation!
If the ordinary guy on the terrace can see it, what is happening with those who are paid a lot of dosh to get it right. I've lost my mojo too. Come on CPFC, get it right now otherwise we will pay later! Someone bite the bullet and make some drastic changes, not a few superficial ones. WE ARE IN BIG TROUBLE, it's called freefall! It's now or never, January will be too late!
PLEASE GIVE US SOMETHING TO SHOUT ABOUT and bring in some players who will show some fight on the field. Make substitutions a lot quicker not when the players are half dead with 4 minutes to go! WAKE UP PALACE!

 

Aray Flag South London 22 Oct 18 12.26pm

Who knows what would have happened had he reacted earlier or even been proactive. But doing nothing? He's starting to lose supporters because of it. If I were Parish I'd have my eyes on Benitez.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 1.10pm

Originally posted by Aray

Who knows what would have happened had he reacted earlier or even been proactive. But doing nothing? He's starting to lose supporters because of it. If I were Parish I'd have my eyes on Benitez.

I have just spoken to a Fulham supporter of many years who watched our game against Everton.He recognised our tactics as the same as those employed by Hodgson at Fulham with the shape,organisation, spaces between the back four and midfield etc etc. He confirmed that even at Fulham, Hodgson was a manager who stuck with his starting eleven as much as possible, depending of course on the circumstances in the game.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 22 Oct 18 2.04pm

Good managers like Roy set their teams up very well and live or die on that .The great ones also set their teams up very well but adapt change and respond during the course of the game . Roy though a good manager is not a great one
Its not as if we have the luxury of game changers on the bench and it wasn't that long ago some on here were having a fit when Pardew made changes in attempt to win games (granted he then lost most of them) the point being our bench has been weak for some years .

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Oct 18 2.12pm

Originally posted by Aray

Who knows what would have happened had he reacted earlier or even been proactive. But doing nothing? He's starting to lose supporters because of it. If I were Parish I'd have my eyes on Benitez.

I don't think you'll see Benitez take another job from a chairman who backs his managers only when there's a massive emergency, and then hopes they'll get by with what they've got when things look okay.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 22 Oct 18 3.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have just spoken to a Fulham supporter of many years who watched our game against Everton.He recognised our tactics as the same as those employed by Hodgson at Fulham with the shape,organisation, spaces between the back four and midfield etc etc. He confirmed that even at Fulham, Hodgson was a manager who stuck with his starting eleven as much as possible, depending of course on the circumstances in the game.

This would suggest he's open to changing things based on how a game is going...which he clearly isnt

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Oct 18 3.45pm

Originally posted by Aray

Who knows what would have happened had he reacted earlier or even been proactive. But doing nothing? He's starting to lose supporters because of it. If I were Parish I'd have my eyes on Benitez.

Is that the same Benitez that sold Gayle and Mitrovic, they now can’t score a goal as well. He plays strikers with a maximum height of 5ft7in and plays from the wing to cross into the box.


 

Aray Flag South London 22 Oct 18 4.36pm

Originally posted by Painter

Is that the same Benitez that sold Gayle and Mitrovic, they now can’t score a goal as well. He plays strikers with a maximum height of 5ft7in and plays from the wing to cross into the box.


Well only one of those appears to be a clearly bad decision - and I think he was promised funds for players which never turned up.

Every manager makes “mistakes” of this kind. The question is whether - if Roy can’t turn this around - would you turn down Benitez?

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 22 Oct 18 8.27pm

Benitez isn’t the answer. Look how bad Toon have been this season. You think Roy is negative? Watch how unambitious Rafa is when trying to win games.

Roy needs to turn it around or he needs to retire. The lack of subs is inexcusable now. It’s cost us too many points. We looked tired and leggy, yes the bench isn’t good enough, but we were under the kosh and it was painfully obvious.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Oct 18 7.03am

Hodgson has now switched firmly into Hodgson mode, which is to defend a 0-0. Don't get men forward, you don't score, easy as that.

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 23 Oct 18 8.21am

Couple of weeks and some will be putting Colin W up for manager given his team scored more than 50% of our seasons total last Saturday !!!!!

 

sheffieldgabor Flag Cardiff 23 Oct 18 9.29am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Hodgson has now switched firmly into Hodgson mode, which is to defend a 0-0. Don't get men forward, you don't score, easy as that.

Thing I dont get though is that if he WAS trying to defend the 0-0 why didnt he throw on Kelly? especially as Tomkins had had a whack to the head and was dazed. Surely if you are settling for a 0-0 it would be better to put some fresh legs into defence/midfield? Thats what I dont get...was he defending the 0-0 or still trying to hit on the break?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Oct 18 11.06am

In terms of the Everton game, the whole scenario changed once Luka missed the penalty.

Up until that point I thought we looked largely comfortable and at least a point a distinct possibility.

But the penalty miss galvanised Everton and now Palace are hanging on for that point.

So...what changes could Roy have made ? Well I wouldn't have disturbed the back 4 unless one of them was unable to continue. Midfield ? It can take players a few minutes to settle into the pace of the game, so maybe a reluctance to change at that particular stage of the game. Up front ? - He could have brought Ayew on as some fresh legs and potentially give Everton something different to think about, but based upon Ayew's performances to date maybe thought it wan't worth it.


Obviously that's only my take on it and my attempt to understand Roy's way of thinking.

The game ceased to be all about the eleven starting players many years ago now, so it's a concern that Roy seems either unable or unwilling to utilise his squad more effectively.


 


Old, Ungifted and White

gambler Flag Kent 23 Oct 18 1.05pm

This is from The Telegraph, a list of teams average time for 1st, 2nd and 3rd subs:

Team 1st sub 2nd sub 3rd sub
Arsenal 49.67 65.67 78.44
Bournemouth 65 79.22 84.86
Brighton 48.11 75 80.38
Burnley 54.22 71.67 79.29
Cardiff 61.56 73.56 81.29
Chelsea 63.44 69.89 79.78
Crystal Palace 75.78 79 83
Everton 57.44 79.78 84.63
Fulham 54.22 67.33 82.38
Huddersfield 49.44 69.56 84.71
Leicester 62.25 75.25 84
Liverpool 59.22 75.22 84.75
Man City 61 73 81.75
Man Utd 57 66.78 75.89
Newcastle 57.44 71.13 79.88
Southampton 62 71.56 80.29
Tottenham 67.67 76.44 88.13
Watford 69.22 79.78 86.57
West Ham 57.44 69 78.44
Wolves 62.56 72.78 83.13

We are far, far later than any other team to make substitutions. Is Roy too stuck in his ways? No plan B, or is it that he doesn't trust the subs bench? Whatever the subs bench they're still in a premier league squad and should be able to offer something? Also the fitness levels would have to be something else, and i don't believe they are, if we don't need to freshen up until far later than anyone else.

Edit - graphics haven't transferred too great, here is the link to the article:

[Link]

Edited by gambler (23 Oct 2018 1.06pm)

 

The_postman Flag Forest Row 23 Oct 18 1.07pm

An interesting piece in the Telegraph on subs being used in the Prem this season

[Link]

In short the article highlights that we have made less subs than any other team and made them later. The average time for the first sub this season is the 59th minute. Our average is the 75th minute. Does Roy think our bench is that bad? I would love to know his reasoning.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Oct 18 1.30pm

Originally posted by The_postman

An interesting piece in the Telegraph on subs being used in the Prem this season

[Link]

In short the article highlights that we have made less subs than any other team and made them later. The average time for the first sub this season is the 59th minute. Our average is the 75th minute. Does Roy think our bench is that bad? I would love to know his reasoning.

He is stuck in his ways and can't change. There were games last season where fresh legs were required (Cabaye was run into the ground) but he never made any changes. Same pattern this season so don't expect some "aha!" moment.
Why for doesn't Meyer start? He has that hint of creativity so desperately lacking. Schlupp is crap and he gets a game, I don't get it.

 

Jacey Flag 23 Oct 18 1.37pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

He is stuck in his ways and can't change. There were games last season where fresh legs were required (Cabaye was run into the ground) but he never made any changes. Same pattern this season so don't expect some "aha!" moment.
Why for doesn't Meyer start? He has that hint of creativity so desperately lacking. Schlupp is crap and he gets a game, I don't get it.

Perhaps Roy has passed his sell by date,has run out of steam and should consider a well deserved retirement???

 

Spitfire Flag Biggin Hill 23 Oct 18 1.38pm

Interesting article

Given all PL clubs employ analysts extensively now, is Roy's tendency for late subs a known target areas for opposition to plan for? If so it seems to be working especially given the number of late goals conceded.

Conversely all Evertons subs either scored or assisted on Sunday.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Oct 18 1.42pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Perhaps Roy has passed his sell by date,has run out of steam and should consider a well deserved retirement???

I think by Xmas that question will be answered. Parish has gone for a succession of managers who will more or less guarantee Prem survival - with De Boer he took a gamble which failed miserably. I think we can all be grateful for Hodgson stepping in and doing a good job, unfortunately this season we haven't kicked on where we left off and that is frustrating.

 

Username Flag Horsham 23 Oct 18 8.23pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

In terms of the Everton game, the whole scenario changed once Luka missed the penalty.

Up until that point I thought we looked largely comfortable and at least a point a distinct possibility.

But the penalty miss galvanised Everton and now Palace are hanging on for that point.

So...what changes could Roy have made ? Well I wouldn't have disturbed the back 4 unless one of them was unable to continue. Midfield ? It can take players a few minutes to settle into the pace of the game, so maybe a reluctance to change at that particular stage of the game. Up front ? - He could have brought Ayew on as some fresh legs and potentially give Everton something different to think about, but based upon Ayew's performances to date maybe thought it wan't worth it.


Obviously that's only my take on it and my attempt to understand Roy's way of thinking.

The game ceased to be all about the eleven starting players many years ago now, so it's a concern that Roy seems either unable or unwilling to utilise his squad more effectively.


All three are good points, and I would have agreed with you even up until a couple of years ago.

Even in the last few years, players are covering more and more ground. It sounds like Roy asks a lot from his teams in terms of their defensive discipline, that requires them to keep up concentration which is very, very difficult for 90 minutes.

Just one fresh set of legs could have made a huge difference. Ayew could have helped pressure, Wickham (depending on fitness) could have held the ball up and given the defence a break. Riedewald could have added more cover and fresh legs in the midfield. They brought on two big strikers, so we could have even brought on Kelly and gone to a back five for the last few minutes to see it out.

Those were all options and we had a team that was clearly tiring. Even just having a fresh set of legs and eyes helping to direct tired teammates into position could have helped.

You've hit the nail on the head with the last bit. We signed players to have a better squad for these situations. Being able to bring someone like Riedewald or Kelly off the bench is a pretty decent option for us. The game has changed, and we can't continue to play 11 v 14.

The All Blacks talk about their closers. Players who are there to come on and make a difference, not there just in case. Sure, you have different options so you can adapt to the situation, but you plan to bring them on and that is part of the system.

Dougie was actually really good of this when he was in charge. When we were struggling in 10/11 he often used to bring on Claude Davis as a third centre half to see out a 1-0 win and it worked on quite a few occasions:

[Link]
[Link]
[Link]

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and substitutes