You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Max Meyer thread


Page 4 of 27 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Nov 18 10.46am

Originally posted by A89M

Yup. I remember the RLC comments as well and it seems to be the same for Meyer. Regarding his physicality I don't see a problem, its an outdated view in my eyes as the PL is full of slight players who are able to use their ball control to get out of tight areas or draw a foul from it.

Almost every game Meyer has come on, he has given the opposition more to think about than just Wilf e.g Watford away, Arsenal or Wolves. I personally believe he'd flourish as the no.10 but if Roy used him in the same role he did on Sunday against weaker opposition with Wilf drifting out wide also, I can see this working as they seem to have a good connection for such little time together.

Cabaye came in as a creative player who could score goals, he did very little of either but he kept the ball and kept us ticking over and we are now really missing him. Not all players have to either score or create goals to be a real asset to the team.

Edited by A89M (06 Nov 2018 9.23am)

The trend of smaller players playing in advanced positions in the premiership hasn’t gone unnoticed and it was talked over by Gullit and Danny Murphy on MOTD2 on Sunday. They were talking about Man City and Chelsea, but although it’s often the best teams that set the trend, you can see it elsewhere as well. Chris Hughton plays their Solly March and the talented South American who plays on the left and cuts in on his right foot.

Maybe Roy’s ways are becoming outdated before our eyes, and given the choice of players and selections, he won’t change. Remember he didn’t sign RLC and wouldn’t play him until he had to, same as Meyer. Roy actually only changes the team when he has to, yet last season we thought he wasn’t changing it because he couldn’t, but he probably wouldn’t have done anyway.

We need to change up and create chances. It’s as simple as that, and I hope Roy recognises this before we’re done and/or Roy is sacked. Our defence isn’t as good or disciplined as Pulis’s, which is surprising looking at the talent difference, but then we have AWB and PVA are very talented full backs. Start using them more as well. If we have 2 def mids in a 4-2-3-1 then you usually can.

However, I expect to see 4-4-2 from now on and hope we get the bounce of the ball or loose ball in the other box and score the first goal and at a good time in the match. The 89th-94th minute worked before, it’s sure to keep working.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Nov 18 11.27am

I can understand people having a moan about Meyer, it’s the instant success syndrome which people want nowadays.
He has come from a league that plays at a different pace than the Premier, so it’s going to take time for him to adapt. There have been plenty of players, who have struggled in their first season and blossomed in the second season. He has undoubted ability it’s just going to take time until we see the best of him.

 

louis01 Flag Llandudno 06 Nov 18 11.35am

I think he's quality and needs to be given a chance!

It's funny how some people did the same and spent three years slagging of Cabaye and saying we were going to get relegated every season. It's like groundhog day on here sometimes.

 


It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye!

mattteo Flag 07 Nov 18 12.43pm

Originally posted by louis01

I think he's quality and needs to be given a chance!

Absolutely. But if his rumoured salary is real and it's 9 million a year then he'll be judged according to that.

He was a great attacking player at age 20 in Germany. But then they changed him to central midfielder and he played there the entire 2017-18 season. Apparently the managers bought him (and gave him all that money, 35 million over 4 seasons) to play him in an attacking role again. But was it really worth it for a player who has gotten unaccustomed to that position? He has had no continuity in that role, he might remember how to sore and create again or he might not. The amount makes the gamble bad business though

Edited by mattteo (07 Nov 2018 12.51pm)

 

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 07 Nov 18 12.57pm

Disagreed with him in the past but the OP is bang on here. In fact I'd go one further and give Max a run up top...next AJ in the making I reckon!

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Nov 18 3.32pm

This is our strongest starting 11 in my opinion. The midfield 3 need to play tight in the middle of the park and drop back where necessary to allow our full backs to overlap and support the top 3 who need to play with total freedom, so as to cause as much confusion for the defenders as possible.

In all probability we will end up confusing ourselves, however this team needs Meyer in it without a doubt.

Hennessey

AWB, Tomkins, Sakho, PVA

McArthur, Milivojevic, Kouyate

Townsend, Zaha, Meyer

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 07 Nov 18 3.42pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Absolutely. But if his rumoured salary is real and it's 9 million a year then he'll be judged according to that.

He was a great attacking player at age 20 in Germany. But then they changed him to central midfielder and he played there the entire 2017-18 season. Apparently the managers bought him (and gave him all that money, 35 million over 4 seasons) to play him in an attacking role again. But was it really worth it for a player who has gotten unaccustomed to that position? He has had no continuity in that role, he might remember how to sore and create again or he might not. The amount makes the gamble bad business though

Edited by mattteo (07 Nov 2018 12.51pm)

If that was true - and I highly doubt that it is - then if I was Steve Parish I'd be asking some very serious questions of the manager as to why Meyer isn't starting every week

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 18 4.00pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Absolutely. But if his rumoured salary is real and it's 9 million a year then he'll be judged according to that.

He was a great attacking player at age 20 in Germany. But then they changed him to central midfielder and he played there the entire 2017-18 season. Apparently the managers bought him (and gave him all that money, 35 million over 4 seasons) to play him in an attacking role again. But was it really worth it for a player who has gotten unaccustomed to that position? He has had no continuity in that role, he might remember how to sore and create again or he might not. The amount makes the gamble bad business though

Edited by mattteo (07 Nov 2018 12.51pm)

£9 Mill a year equates to a weekly salary of nigh on £175,000.
I'll let others consider if he is on these terms !

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 07 Nov 18 6.30pm

Originally posted by Willo

£9 Mill a year equates to a weekly salary of nigh on £175,000.
I'll let others consider if he is on these terms !

Wow that's getting into man c type territory. Roger Schmidt (SP) certainly has the measure of Parish if this is correct.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 08 Nov 18 4.36am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

This is our strongest starting 11 in my opinion. The midfield 3 need to play tight in the middle of the park and drop back where necessary to allow our full backs to overlap and support the top 3 who need to play with total freedom, so as to cause as much confusion for the defenders as possible.

In all probability we will end up confusing ourselves, however this team needs Meyer in it without a doubt.

Hennessey

AWB, Tomkins, Sakho, PVA

McArthur, Milivojevic, Kouyate

Townsend, Zaha, Meyer

I like 4-3-3 as a formation....but sticking Meyer...possibly our most technical player with eye for a pass...out on the left wing...seems silly. For me:

Hennessy

AWB - TONK - SAKHO - PVA

LUKA

MCARTHUR-MEYER

PUNCHEON - SORLOTH - ZAHA

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Nov 18 8.40am

Originally posted by sprites

I like 4-3-3 as a formation....but sticking Meyer...possibly our most technical player with eye for a pass...out on the left wing...seems silly. For me:

Hennessy

AWB - TONK - SAKHO - PVA

LUKA

MCARTHUR-MEYER

PUNCHEON - SORLOTH - ZAHA

Sprites, if you read my post, we need to have fluidity in the front three. Just because I showed him on the left doesn't mean he plays left wing.

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 08 Nov 18 8.49am

Im pretty sure the rumour of him earning that much was squashed when he signed. From the reports that circulated here and alot of press sites hes earning in the region of £85k p/w not £175k.
I think when he plays he makes us more dangerous, hes got good feet and is always looking to go forward.
When i think to our good spells v Chelsea, especially first half, it was all going through him.
We're never going to see his full potential if hes only starting 1 in 3 games, he needs to be given a run.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Nov 18 8.50am

Originally posted by sprites

I like 4-3-3 as a formation....but sticking Meyer...possibly our most technical player with eye for a pass...out on the left wing...seems silly. For me:

Hennessy

AWB - TONK - SAKHO - PVA

LUKA

MCARTHUR-MEYER

PUNCHEON - SORLOTH - ZAHA

Puncheon in the team !
With respect you and I have a distinct variance of opinion on this matter.

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 08 Nov 18 9.54am

Originally posted by sprites

I like 4-3-3 as a formation....but sticking Meyer...possibly our most technical player with eye for a pass...out on the left wing...seems silly. For me:

Hennessy

AWB - TONK - SAKHO - PVA

LUKA

MCARTHUR-MEYER

PUNCHEON - SORLOTH - ZAHA


You can't of seen much of the Middlesbrough game, him playing was a waste of development time for Kirby, Williams etc. As for Sorearse how many strikers are 6ft4? ish and not an aerial threat?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Nov 18 10.02am

Originally posted by aj36094


You can't of seen much of the Middlesbrough game, him playing was a waste of development time for Kirby, Williams etc. As for Sorearse how many strikers are 6ft4? ish and not an aerial threat?

When Crouch first started out, even though he was 6ft 7in he was not that aggressive in the air for his height and never had that much of an impressive leap on him.Back in 2015 he went on to beat Alan Shearer's record of the most headed goals in the PL !

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 08 Nov 18 1.02pm

Square pegs, round holes: it's the Hodgson way.

 

the.universal 08 Nov 18 1.08pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

If that was true - and I highly doubt that it is - then if I was Steve Parish I'd be asking some very serious questions of the manager as to why Meyer isn't starting every week

Just what we need, the chairman picking the starting XI based on weekly wage.

 


Vive le Roy!

the.universal 08 Nov 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by sprites

I like 4-3-3 as a formation....but sticking Meyer...possibly our most technical player with eye for a pass...out on the left wing...seems silly. For me:

Hennessy

AWB - TONK - SAKHO - PVA

LUKA

MCARTHUR-MEYER

PUNCHEON - SORLOTH - ZAHA

Go to division 1, go directly to division 1, do not pass go, do not collect £200.

 


Vive le Roy!

mattteo Flag 08 Nov 18 8.08pm

Originally posted by Willo

Puncheon in the team !
With respect you and I have a distinct variance of opinion on this matter.

If Puncheon plays his usual position of right winger, he could actually do good.

The problem is that in the past 2 years they kept sending him in as central midfielder, where he sucks.

Maybe he doesn't have the speed he once had, but playing inverted winger (cause he's left and playing on the right would be how Robben plays for Bayern Munich) doesn't require that much speed, more like technical quality to cut inside. Central midfield probably requires more speed than that and Puncheon doesn't really know how to defend well.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 09 Nov 18 3.30am

If you look at Meyer's misses he is not a " pass it into the net " guy. He puts his laces though everything but also not afraid to attempt difficult shots when no other option, going for areas of goal where keeper will have no chance when he is on target. Am quietly confident his goals will come and will be praised as technically difficult when they do

Originally posted by Kant

Too much criticism of Roy here. Meyer was started yesterday and was not especially impressive. His finishing was particularly poor. Given the limited tools at his disposal I think Roy is doing a decent job and if he’d enjoyed the rub of the green we’d now be in a more comfortable position. It’s a shame that we’ve lost the momentum of last season but constantly slagging off Roy’s judgement is getting a little tiresome.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Page 4 of 27 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Max Meyer thread