This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
I blame pardew
|
|
|
Originally posted by Canterbury Palace
In my opinion Alan Pardew's early success with us was built on the firmly embedded defensive organisation that lingered on after the Pulis reign the previous season, he merely injected us with the attacking adrenaline shot that he, the ultimate impact manager, can give. Months later that inherited defensive steel crumbled to dust and it became patently clear that he couldn't organise a defence to save his life. That was why we saw his spell in two violenty contrasting halves, the first when our form was that of a European qualifier and the second, relegation candidates. If he hadn't gone we would 100% have gone down that season. He is a fraud of a manager and, from all accounts, is also a dreadful bloke. The son of a former Newcastle director was a client of mine briefly and told me some horror stories about his antics at the club. They were apparently thrilled to get rid of him in the end and, from the sounds of it, we were lucky to do the same. For the record I am now strongly in favour of Roy departing. Though his brand of football is undeniably effective, the game has moved on and we stick out as the worst side to watch in the division. Saturday afternoon's have become akin to having a dementor suck out your soul. However, Pardew vs. Hodgson shouldn't even be in question as the latter is superior in almost every aspect, whether in terms of experience, knowledge, general managerial ability or just as a gentleman. Edited by Canterbury Palace (21 Oct 2020 12.08am) Although I'm not Roy's biggest fan I have to agree that I will not have him compared to Pardew.... Remember that news of the world story about a Premiership manager who was having an affair and texting his bit on the side about how boring training his players was??... Now Obviously from a legal standpoint I'm not saying it was Pardew but who knows hey????!!! Pards was a big time Charley who didn't like any players who were bigger than him, hence the dropping of Speroni, Murray and Jedinak... I dont ever claim to be in the know but one thing I do know is that Pardew and Jedi hated each other..
Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!! |
|
|
Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot
Although I'm not Roy's biggest fan I have to agree that I will not have him compared to Pardew.... Remember that news of the world story about a Premiership manager who was having an affair and texting his bit on the side about how boring training his players was??... Now Obviously from a legal standpoint I'm not saying it was Pardew but who knows hey????!!! Pards was a big time Charley who didn't like any players who were bigger than him, hence the dropping of Speroni, Murray and Jedinak... I dont ever claim to be in the know but one thing I do know is that Pardew and Jedi hated each other.. Pards was a big time Charley..Agreed
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
In Pardew's last game the back 5 were Hennessey, Ward, Delaney, Dann, Kelly (Friars 84). Roy has been a lot more fortunate in that regard.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HesHereHesThere
Pardew sold him...Murray Played in Pardews first game at Dover...Warnocks lost it and his eyebrows ..very unnecessary and Pardew made two huge mistakes with losing Murray and keeping Hennessey in goal, he was basically a total idiot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
In Pardew's last game the back 5 were Hennessey, Ward, Delaney, Dann, Kelly (Friars 84). Roy has been a lot more fortunate in that regard. Hodgson would not be able to save us with that lot, not a chance.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Why is Hodgson better than Pardew, both never won anything worth winning, both been sacked regularly, Pardew gung ho, Hodgson ultra defensive, Hodgson by a mile. Pardew was taking us down. Hodgson has kept us up against all odds (0 points, 0 goals in first 8 games) when he rescued us from Frank the crank.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
..very unnecessary and Pardew made two huge mistakes with losing Murray and keeping Hennessey in goal, he was basically a total idiot. Selling Murray was parish's fault and he has held his hand up to it as one of his biggest errors. That said while I defended him while in office I now heartily concur with your assessment of that knob-out
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by est1905
Hodgson by a mile. Pardew was taking us down. Hodgson has kept us up against all odds (0 points, 0 goals in first 8 games) when he rescued us from Frank the crank. Hodgson came in after 4 games with a team that finished the previous season in great form and got to the cup final the year before. They have brought in £80m worth of players in the previous 6 months. Of those 4 games, we only really would have expected to lose 2. It wasn't a great deficit to catch up. There's only so long he can trade off that success. Pardew may have been taking us down. But Hodgson has won 2 in 13 games (against two teams that played 1 friendly each). Pardew won 3 of his last 13 games gaining 11 points to Roy's 8. In Pardew's last games Kelly regularly had a nightmare trying to fill in the left back role after Souare's accident and Hennessey always had a mistake in him. We pretty much started games 1-0 down. At the moment, Hodgson's form is worst than Pardew's last games and a damn site less entertaining with a much better side. Not trying to protect Pardew, he had to go.
|
|
|
Originally posted by est1905
Hodgson by a mile. Pardew was taking us down. Hodgson has kept us up against all odds (0 points, 0 goals in first 8 games) when he rescued us from Frank the crank.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Chalk and cheese. Totally different people, and football managers. Pardew is too far down one road, while Roy is too far down the other. You need some of Pardew like having some guts, having a go at teams, and taking the shackles off..... But you want a bit of Roy in there, solid shape when out of possession and well drilled. You need to strike a balance. If we could strike that balance we could be much higher up the league table, and approaching an FA cup semi final. You know what both are s*** at though? Coming up with a plan b when plan a isn’t working out, during a game. I agree... but I don't really want to talk or go back to the Pardew years. It's Roy now. My worry is that Roy has one way of playing and everyone knows it so every team we face knows how we play and will prepare for it. They know there is no plan B and what they see at kick off is what they will see at 90 minutes. That to me is a big handicap. This league has become more dynamic over the years.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth. |
|
|
Originally posted by redshift
I agree... but I don't really want to talk or go back to the Pardew years. It's Roy now. My worry is that Roy has one way of playing and everyone knows it so every team we face knows how we play and will prepare for it. They know there is no plan B and what they see at kick off is what they will see at 90 minutes. That to me is a big handicap. This league has become more dynamic over the years. Not checked out whether it’s true but someone told me Brighton have the youngest squad in the Premier League.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
It is an insult to compare Roy to Pardew. Pardew galvanised us for a while, when bold words mattered more than the content of his character. And I completely agree he unwittingly benefited from the lingering discipline that Pulis had instilled in us. Once that was gone, Pardew was a busted flush. It seems we may have gone full circle, regaining the ability to defend but completely losing and ability to attack.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gribbo
Like it or not, Potter is doing a good job - should have beaten Chelsea (hit the woodwork 5 times), should have beaten us (no shots on target from open play). Roy on the other hand continues to manage us like he did Inter Milan in the last century - hang out for the clean sheet and hope to nick a goal, home or away, Man C or Brighton - with no Plan B. Time's up for the old fella I am afraid. We need to be on the front foot changing hi out though. If he goes in a fit if pique we will be left with Dougie in charge. I am not sure that moves us any further forward. Potter doing a good job? He has won 4 of the last 25 Premier games. This plan B is a misnomer, we play 442 and 433 in different matches, which one is plan B.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.