You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Let's criticise our managers.eh?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Let's criticise our managers.eh?


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Kant Flag exeter 16 Apr 19 8.55pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

What rubbish, Watford looked 10 times better than us last night against Arsenal, in every department, (maybe not goal keeper) no sitting back, they went at Arsnel from the beginning,even with 10 men after 10 mins.
i am not a Watford fan bye the way. i hate the club, just wish we would play like them.

Keep up Old Geezer. I didn’t say Watford are no good. I pointed out that finishing 7th 8th 9th is a fleeting achievement. It’s not the holy grail of PL stability that people suggest. If you look at the teams that have finished in that position in recent years half of them were plying their trade in the Championship shortly after. It is on this basis alone that I made the somewhat tongue in cheek aside that with any luck Watford will follow in their footsteps in quick time. The serious point is that finishing top half one season guarantees nothing for the following season. Every year 14 teams are slugging it out to avoid the drop. Unfortunately we cannot transcend that truth.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 16 Apr 19 10.36pm

Originally posted by Kant

Keep up Old Geezer. I didn’t say Watford are no good. I pointed out that finishing 7th 8th 9th is a fleeting achievement. It’s not the holy grail of PL stability that people suggest. If you look at the teams that have finished in that position in recent years half of them were plying their trade in the Championship shortly after. It is on this basis alone that I made the somewhat tongue in cheek aside that with any luck Watford will follow in their footsteps in quick time. The serious point is that finishing top half one season guarantees nothing for the following season. Every year 14 teams are slugging it out to avoid the drop. Unfortunately we cannot transcend that truth.

Yes, the top six will always be the top six, everyone else has to fight it out and no one knows where anyone is going to finish every season Watford could very easily go down next season.

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Apr 19 10.56pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes, the top six will always be the top six, everyone else has to fight it out and no one knows where anyone is going to finish every season Watford could very easily go down next season.

Its more likely to be us with the current squad!

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 16 Apr 19 11.50pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes, the top six will always be the top six, everyone else has to fight it out and no one knows where anyone is going to finish every season Watford could very easily go down next season.

Bollox.

Arsenal will always be top 4.
Leeds too big to be relegated.
Man city who?
Leicester to win the league: fat chance.
20 times united, they'll never miss out on top 4.
And on. And on. And on.

Nothing is set in stone.

 

Eustace H. Plimsoll Flag Aldershot 17 Apr 19 1.34pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Bollox.

Arsenal will always be top 4.
Leeds too big to be relegated.
Man city who?
Leicester to win the league: fat chance.
20 times united, they'll never miss out on top 4.
And on. And on. And on.

Nothing is set in stone.

The fact that you've dredged up (a semi-) something from 2004 (Leeds) suggests that "And on. And on. And on." is probably a little over-blown. And, more significantly, this was a result of massive financial mismanagement - in the event - as a result of gambling a future on breakiing into the elite. Which is, handily, kind of the point. (Though I doubt anyone is suggesting we attempt similar extravagence, even if we could. Oh, and their predicament meant it was scarcely a giant shock by then.)

Of course nothing is absolutely set in stone. Any apparently absolutist statments are only for colour. There will always be evolution (big teams having periods of under-performance), occasional seismic shifts (Chelsea, Man City) and the exceptional freakish aberration (Leicester), but these are asides. The fact is that the notion that finishing top-half is a given stepping stone to future prosperity is simply not borne out by the evidence. (Nor does it represent a particularly glorious achievement, to my mind, but that's far more arguable and need not detain us.)

The issue is more the manner of finishing 13th (let's say), I think. As many have said. If we could swing more of our victories to being at home, and do so with a little more of a flourish in our game, the progression argument would be less .

I would prefer that, certainly. I find it all a bit tedious at the minute too. But then I always expected to find the Premier tedious after the initial excitement. It is an incredibly boring league if you're not fighting at the top or the bottom. (Same as all leagues of course but it's particularly so with the Premier as there's so little scope for anybody to compete for honours outside of the established set.) Fancy-pants certainly and you can get a smashing latte at some places, but it's f***ing sterile and soulless in the main.

Hitting 7th (if we're lucky) or 9th or 10th or whatever isn't going to change that suddenly. We might progress from there, certainly. Might. But it's a big "might". And every bit as much we might not. And is it that big a deal anyway? Because beyond that is very unlikely indeed.

A change to our tactics might do well to improve the mood, definitely, but we'd need to accept we could very well go down in trying that, is all. It's not easy to stay in the Premier, as the margins are so fine. Which is why Roy is doing such a good job. So for me it comes down to what's most important. I've always thought our natural environment is slugging it out in the second tier. The glory of the promotion years. The (retrospective) sad poetry of willingly following years of inevitable losses to Shrewsbury. I really love all that. But it turns out we tend to very nearly go bust a lot if not set in the PL. And that's a real s***ter.

 


As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 18 Apr 19 1.16pm

Originally posted by Kant

Keep up Old Geezer. I didn’t say Watford are no good. I pointed out that finishing 7th 8th 9th is a fleeting achievement. It’s not the holy grail of PL stability that people suggest. If you look at the teams that have finished in that position in recent years half of them were plying their trade in the Championship shortly after. It is on this basis alone that I made the somewhat tongue in cheek aside that with any luck Watford will follow in their footsteps in quick time. The serious point is that finishing top half one season guarantees nothing for the following season. Every year 14 teams are slugging it out to avoid the drop. Unfortunately we cannot transcend that truth.

Okay, fair point, looks eminent relegation for Palace though, Watford are almost unbeatable at home, while we are s***e, but as you say, it could all be different next season and Watford could be poor, i con't see Palace getting any better, but we live in hope.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Apr 19 7.13am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Dunno where you're getting this from. Seems to me that the majority on here blindly defend Hodgeson to the point of personal embarrassment. The few amongst us who show dissatisfaction quickly get insulted off the thread.

you still talking?

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


ChrisGC Flag Wantage 19 Apr 19 8.38am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

you still talking?

Prime example of what I mean. What an embarrassing response.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 19 Apr 19 8.47am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes, the top six will always be the top six, everyone else has to fight it out and no one knows where anyone is going to finish every season Watford could very easily go down next season.

Doubt it as their manager knows how to get the best out of his players home and away.

 


Bring back Brolin

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 19 Apr 19 9.13am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Doubt it as their manager knows how to get the best out of his players home and away.

Bollux. He's only won two more games than our Manager which doesn't make him that much better.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 19 Apr 19 10.44am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Bollux. He's only won two more games than our Manager which doesn't make him that much better.

..... which is 6 points!

 


Bring back Brolin

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Apr 19 11.05am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

..... which is 6 points!

The point being how thin the dividing lines are.

West Ham are currently 3 points better off than us with a worse goal difference. This after investing over £100m in the transfer market.

It's possible that we could still finish above Watford, West Ham and Bournemouth and even Everton and end up in that much coveted ( by some ) position of 9th.

While I think that's unlikely, it is still possible. And just as it is still possible that we get relegated - more unlikely I would say. But thin dividing lines...

 


Old, Ungifted and White

davehuggins Flag 19 Apr 19 11.17am

I keep saying this but we must be careful that we don't set our expectations too high. RH IMO has done a brilliant job with what he has had available. Yes, our home form could be a lot better but he knows this and accepts we need to change things, but not at PL survival expense. RH I'm sure is given the remit every season that survival is success, so all he is doing is his job. Thanks from me!!

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 20 Apr 19 4.04pm

Top 8 is meaningless apart from prize money, 8-17 simply survive.

7th might get European football if many other stars align

Originally posted by ChrisGC

I'm not a new fan and I think the ambition should be to push for top 8.

The past is completely irrelevant. What you describe is a fear of failure.

Just keep slogging out survival is not success and is completely unsustainable.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

southnorwoodhill Flag 20 Apr 19 4.13pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

Top 8 is meaningless apart from prize money, 8-17 simply survive.

7th might get European football if many other stars align

How can the top 8 be meaningless? Imagine you are player with a bit of ambition, are you going to settle for fighting against relegation every season? You can say ta ta to any decent prospects coming or staying with that viewpoint.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 20 Apr 19 4.59pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

How can the top 8 be meaningless? Imagine you are player with a bit of ambition, are you going to settle for fighting against relegation every season? You can say ta ta to any decent prospects coming or staying with that viewpoint.

Agree. What a staggeringly illogical thing to come out with.

No difference between 8th and 17th ffs.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 20 Apr 19 9.33pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

How can the top 8 be meaningless? Imagine you are player with a bit of ambition, are you going to settle for fighting against relegation every season? You can say ta ta to any decent prospects coming or staying with that viewpoint.

To player finishing 8th - 14th is of little consequence to them. You seem to think they all have an ambition to win something, unless they are stupid, they know the chances are very slim with a team outside the top 3. All they are concerned about is the amount of money they can get, why do you think Benteke and Sakho came? A decent player/prospect will come to any Premier club, knowing if he shines in a team that relegated, he will be picked up by another Premier team by the next season, example being Luca currently.

 

Eustace H. Plimsoll Flag Aldershot 21 Apr 19 12.36am

Originally posted by Painter

To player finishing 8th - 14th is of little consequence to them. You seem to think they all have an ambition to win something, unless they are stupid, they know the chances are very slim with a team outside the top 3. All they are concerned about is the amount of money they can get, why do you think Benteke and Sakho came? A decent player/prospect will come to any Premier club, knowing if he shines in a team that relegated, he will be picked up by another Premier team by the next season, example being Luca currently.

Correct.

Furthermore, I understand it's incredibly rare indeed for clubs in contract negotiations with transfer targets to expressly stipulate that the stated club targets/thinking are formed strictly in line with a thorough review of the overriding trends of thought of various supporters' online forums. (Should I be misguided, however, I hope I can speak for us all when I say I approve a sales pitch that might project ambition beyond this, wicked though that might be.)

 


As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 21 Apr 19 5.55am

There only one thing worth saying on this subject. Brighton would give their lives to be where Palace are in the table, Palace are probably about tho lose two games on the trot against clubs with huge resources in comparison and can only play within the confines of their own limited resourses. This Palace are doing and it is proving to be adequate.
What now, gamble it all on a style not favoured by Roy with all his knowledge and experience? If he says this is the way Palace need To play to achieve another season in this much dosho league that is enough for me. Next season will be the deciding season with an aging squad and the probable loss of the best two men in the squad. So lets all get together and undermine the management just one last time before Palace drop out of the league. This should do it....well done everyone. I just cannot wait to be watching the likes of Rochdale every week. At least we will have no trouble getting tickets.
Oh what short memories many have. Or perhaps they are so young they have no memories of the bad old days.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 21 Apr 19 8.50am

Originally posted by billtheglazier

Ive been viewing, and occasionally been posting topics on this forum for many years and as I get older I must admit to memory failure at times, but one thing i have noticed is the common theme that has been a regular topic or comment,for many,which is regular criticism of our managers.
This in my memory goes back years to the days of Neil Warnock/Peter Taylor/ Iain Dowie from memory.
Before then I didnt use computers.(Parish is also an object of negativity)
Yes I agree its what forums are for but,you know what,I think Roy has done an excellent job to keep us in the 'First tier' of English football.I have spent most of the years I have supported Palace watching us in the lower divisions.
I do wonder whether many of those who criticise his management are also in the habit of attacking others in authority positions outside of football.
It can be quite addictive!
Just a thought.

I have thought about it, and the facts are we have won only 4 games at home all season and we have been dreadful. However you want to look at it, the criticism is fully justified in my mind. The manger picks the team, he makes the call when subs are used and at home his decision making has been questionable.

On the flip side our away form has been outstanding and the counter attacking style has been our main stay and kept us up for sure.

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Let's criticise our managers.eh?