You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mateta


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 10 Feb 21 8.58pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

It's amazing how many fans put wanted us to put all our eggs in one basket with him before seeing him play.

There's been plenty of comments about how we can get rid of Batshuayi and Benteke now we've got Mateta.

The problem with just saying, let's get rid of all our players and bring in better ones is that the only thing you can be sure of is that it will be very expensive with no guarantee of success.

Wasn't the best performance but he was hung out to dry a bit. Hopefully, he gets some more game time off the bench over our upcoming run. Then we'll see if he can become a premiership striker. Looking forward to seeing him again

As I remember there was plenty of caution. I had never even heard of him and wondered whether we would actually ever see him play. Well, I've been proved wrong on that. He has played. Hes probably wondering WTF team has he joined.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Feb 21 9.03pm

Originally posted by kevlee

As I remember there was plenty of caution. I had never even heard of him and wondered whether we would actually ever see him play. Well, I've been proved wrong on that. He has played. Hes probably wondering WTF team has he joined.

If he plays against Burnley he will be up against two capable centre-backs in Mee and Tarkowski so he could well find it difficult.

 

Jacey Flag 10 Feb 21 9.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

If he plays against Burnley he will be up against two capable centre-backs in Mee and Tarkowski so he could well find it difficult.

As will the rest of our rather aged squad.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Feb 21 9.31pm

Originally posted by Jacey


As will the rest of our rather aged squad.

A number of the Burnley squad are in their 30s :

Lowton,Peters,Mee,Westwood,Cork,Rodriguez,Barnes,Stephens,Barsdsley, Gudmundsson.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 10 Feb 21 11.02pm

Originally posted by Willo

A number of the Burnley squad are in their 30s :

Lowton,Peters,Mee,Westwood,Cork,Rodriguez,Barnes,Stephens,Barsdsley, Gudmundsson.

Probably the reason for their problems.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 10 Feb 21 11.22pm

I actually thought he looked ok. For a big lad he showed some nice touches and technique. Coming on in a game we had lost control of was not ideal. The whole team was struggling against a high pressing energetic and confident leeds ... so hard to judge him really.

 

Blue'n'red Flag Field of Chels (Orpington) 11 Feb 21 1.14am

Wasn’t AJ abysmal when he first started for us ... I’m hopeful JP will shine soon.

 


They say hard work never hurt anyone ... but why take a chance?

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 11 Feb 21 5.56am

he seems to have a decent touch, you can not judge him on the leeds game.

he is young & raw and can only improve.

i would be more than happy to see him, wilf & bats we our main 3 striikers for the start of next season.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Casual Flag Orpington 11 Feb 21 6.40am

Originally posted by jeeagles

It's amazing how many fans put wanted us to put all our eggs in one basket with him before seeing him play.

There's been plenty of comments about how we can get rid of Batshuayi and Benteke now we've got Mateta.

The problem with just saying, let's get rid of all our players and bring in better ones is that the only thing you can be sure of is that it will be very expensive with no guarantee of success.

Wasn't the best performance but he was hung out to dry a bit. Hopefully, he gets some more game time off the bench over our upcoming run. Then we'll see if he can become a premiership striker. Looking forward to seeing him again


‘All our eggs in one basket?’
It’s an extra forward on loan, when we didn’t see/can’t afford anyone else.
We’ve added him to our strikers without moving anyone on. So ‘we’ve added to our basket’
It’s an option hat we now have that will cost us in wages and if he turns out to be great , we can buy at an agreed price.
Who else was available on an 18 month loan in a ‘current’ decent goal scoring spell in a decent league , for a poor club, with I’m guessing (due to league position), few chances.
We haven’t got rid of Benteke or backed Batshui.
If he’s absolute toilet scores 3 goals in 50 games (benteke), walks about , doesn’t challenge for headers and has no comprehension of the offside rule (batshui), or is never fit to play (Wickham) , he will be the same as what we have.
I didn’t mind him, considering how poor we were. Just the act he ran about a bit was plus for me.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 11 Feb 21 8.07am

AJ & Glen both had very lacklustre 1st seasons with us.
Ironically, Benteke had a good 1st season.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

jeeagles Flag 11 Feb 21 8.29am

Originally posted by Casual


‘All our eggs in one basket?’
It’s an extra forward on loan, when we didn’t see/can’t afford anyone else.
We’ve added him to our strikers without moving anyone on. So ‘we’ve added to our basket’
It’s an option hat we now have that will cost us in wages and if he turns out to be great , we can buy at an agreed price.
Who else was available on an 18 month loan in a ‘current’ decent goal scoring spell in a decent league , for a poor club, with I’m guessing (due to league position), few chances.
We haven’t got rid of Benteke or backed Batshui.
If he’s absolute toilet scores 3 goals in 50 games (benteke), walks about , doesn’t challenge for headers and has no comprehension of the offside rule (batshui), or is never fit to play (Wickham) , he will be the same as what we have.
I didn’t mind him, considering how poor we were. Just the act he ran about a bit was plus for me.

I think its a smart deal by the club. Perhaps try reading thought what I said again.

 

Den1923 Flag 11 Feb 21 8.32am

Originally posted by babylonjohn

I actually thought he looked ok. For a big lad he showed some nice touches and technique. Coming on in a game we had lost control of was not ideal. The whole team was struggling against a high pressing energetic and confident leeds ... so hard to judge him really.

yep I agree not the best game to judge him on and his confidence would have been down after the mistake the led to the first goal. However he did seem to lack energy and awareness and did sometime remind me of Benteke in the way that he was watching rather than pressing!

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Feb 21 8.38am

The boy has had 60 minutes, in what was little short of a rear guard action. All we have proved is he might not be Lionel Messi, or another Ronaldo, as those two might have impressed as few other debutants would have in a team like that ,in a game like that.
No matter how good he actually can to be , he won’t find it easy to prove it with us. Look at Bamford , we wrote him off. It happens, but let’s be honest it wasn’t all his fault was it. Or he wouldn’t be doing the business now.

 

Den1923 Flag 11 Feb 21 9.12am

Originally posted by Putitout

The boy has had 60 minutes, in what was little short of a rear guard action. All we have proved is he might not be Lionel Messi, or another Ronaldo, as those two might have impressed as few other debutants would have in a team like that ,in a game like that.
No matter how good he actually can to be , he won’t find it easy to prove it with us. Look at Bamford , we wrote him off. It happens, but let’s be honest it wasn’t all his fault was it. Or he wouldn’t be doing the business now.

yes, although Roy can't be blamed for Bamford, I think that one was down to Pardew, The main problem we have really is our once solid but now very leaky defence and that is primarily down to us continuing with aged players who cannot really hack consecutive games a week apart let alone two a week as under the recent schedule. It all comes back to lack of succession planning and investment in key areas of the team over several transfer windows. I still do not consider we are safe this season as yet bearing in mind how we fell apart at the end of last season.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Feb 21 10.17am

Originally posted by Den1923

yes, although Roy can't be blamed for Bamford, I think that one was down to Pardew, The main problem we have really is our once solid but now very leaky defence and that is primarily down to us continuing with aged players who cannot really hack consecutive games a week apart let alone two a week as under the recent schedule. It all comes back to lack of succession planning and investment in key areas of the team over several transfer windows. I still do not consider we are safe this season as yet bearing in mind how we fell apart at the end of last season.

I agree , it is worrying ,
Mateta, has had some stick here for losing possession leading up to the first goal. He was robbed from behind, it happens to the best. The response of defenders was appalling . It’s not as if our defence is not used to the ball coming back to them in that situation. Wilf , will, and has lost it in those circumstances, Townsend , and Ayew, certainly have , its a fact it’s going to happen. The response is the all important thing, and it was no where near good enough on the night.
That can not be laid at Matetas, door, as he never he never actually had the ball under his control..

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 11 Feb 21 2.11pm

As Bamfored stated, Leeds players changed to rugby studs at half time to get some grip on the s***e pitch

Originally posted by Steve T

Just as well there are no supporters at Selhurst as by now they may have been a lynching or two. Palace were absolutely dire last night. No game plan and the passing was even worse than usual. Yes the pitch was a disgrace but Leeds seemed to make it work.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Feb 21 2.27pm

I don't know why people keep going on about Bamford. Until he went to Leeds nearly everyone thought he wasn't good enough for the PL, not just our club - even Biesla supposedly had his doubts. At Leeds he gets about 3-4 really good chances most games and misses some sitters that we would ridicule him for. He is doing well but I'm still not convinced and I think if they can afford to they will want to upgrade. Our strikers get about one chance a game if they're lucky.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Feb 21 2.35pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I don't know why people keep going on about Bamford. Until he went to Leeds nearly everyone thought he wasn't good enough for the PL, not just our club - even Biesla supposedly had his doubts. At Leeds he gets about 3-4 really good chances most games and misses some sitters that we would ridicule him for. He is doing well but I'm still not convinced and I think if they can afford to they will want to upgrade. Our strikers get about one chance a game if they're lucky.

It has been said about Bielsa that he improves players and Bamford is certainly one that has benefitted from Bielsa's coaching.

 

CT Charlie Flag 11 Feb 21 7.00pm

The big question is this: In the months ahead, will he prove to be more useful than Benteke, Batshuyi and/or Ayew? Ayew played well last season, but he has lost his touch lately. The other two haven't set a very high bar for Mateta to reach. I think he'll offer us more hope and a few more possibilities than they have.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Feb 21 7.09pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I don't know why people keep going on about Bamford. Until he went to Leeds nearly everyone thought he wasn't good enough for the PL, not just our club - even Biesla supposedly had his doubts. At Leeds he gets about 3-4 really good chances most games and misses some sitters that we would ridicule him for. He is doing well but I'm still not convinced and I think if they can afford to they will want to upgrade. Our strikers get about one chance a game if they're lucky.

I think a lot of strikers would like to play in that Leeds team. And probably do as well as Bamford does, the fact is they make real chances , and that alone can boost a reputation . The average punter doesn’t give a toss for the all round efforts of the so called striker if he isn’t scoring the once a game half chance.
And that’s the difference between where Bamford stands now, and the situation our strikers have been in for some time now, certainly since Murray, left. It’s all down to real chances, And ours don’t so much miss that many ,as not get them in the first place.

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mateta