You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Reading V 1st XI
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Reading V 1st XI


Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Gribbo Flag Bromley 31 Jul 21 6.56pm

Sorry Omph. Roy was safe with games to spare but still did not use any of the younger players to give them prem experience - wasted opportunity. Eze was a big buy so he had to play him.

 

CT Charlie Flag 31 Jul 21 7.02pm

Originally posted by Omph

Not fair on Roy that. He played Eze throughout despite the opposition and his not being a natural fit for the system. He schooled him through the season and he was noticeably more effective off the ball by season's end

He did us a big favour there as Eze success is likely a lure to other starlets - we're a club where you can get minutes. Compare and contrast Benrahma at West Ham - very few starts.

I agree. Roy was conservative and cautious regarding youngsters, but I don't think he was obstinate about it. Truth is, he had precious few with the quality that wouldn't be exposed in the Prem, so it was dangerous to put any newcomer anywhere but in the attacking third. And what were his options there?

I think his faith in Mitchell at LB was justified, but it was a risky move – and plenty of us opposed it.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Jul 21 7.07pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Sorry Omph. Roy was safe with games to spare but still did not use any of the younger players to give them prem experience - wasted opportunity. Eze was a big buy so he had to play him.

Correct

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Omph Flag Liverpool 31 Jul 21 7.15pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Sorry Omph. Roy was safe with games to spare but still did not use any of the younger players to give them prem experience - wasted opportunity. Eze was a big buy so he had to play him.

Fair comment in a way about the end of the season but can only think of Rak Sakyi as one who might have come on. Am I missing anyone else? And might he actually be still in development and probably a little way off from first team appearances. Not seen him even mooted as a first team starting player on here. Could be different come January. Not sure a few minutes off the bench at the end of the season is that big a deal.

Not sure you're right on Eze actually. There were times mid season where he could have been "protected" when we were in damage limitation mode and in all honesty his early season performances were nothing too special.

Likewise he wasn't afraid to bench PvA for Mitchell. Big call that one.

Not arguing that he was especially progressive but it doesn't add up to say that he would play experience over youth come what may as the original post had it. I'm pretty certain he'd have played Gallagher and Guehi - we were after Gallagher last time too after all - he just had an old squad and that was as much Parish and Dougie as him.


Edited by Omph (31 Jul 2021 7.16pm)

Edited by Omph (31 Jul 2021 7.18pm)

Edited by Omph (31 Jul 2021 7.25pm)

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jul 21 8.57pm

Too much currency is placed on the selection of youth players. Mclaren signed off his Middlesbrough career by picking a home-grown XI for an away game at Fulham. It allowed him to play to the galery without addressing any of the long term duties of care and responsibility. Look up the XI that day and see how many made it. I'll give you a clue - same amount that would have made it without the manager using them to make himself look good. What a c***.

Hodgson looked at what we had, how he wanted to play, and picked the side most likely to get enough points overall. If you got in his side it was because you were the best option, not because of some bizarre positive discrimination in favour of youth, and you know what? It was an effective filter. Wan Bisakka got in, we made a f***ing tonne for him. Mitchell got in, did fine.

I've said it a million times but I'll repeat it - if anyone can find me the youth player we released that proved the management wrong then I'll accept the subsequent criticism of Hodgson. But nobody can.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Jul 2021 8.58pm)

 

AuntyAnne70 Flag Tunbridge WElls 31 Jul 21 9.59pm

This x 2.

When will some get it into their heads, that managers, in this case Roy play the team they best think equipped to win a game.

 

inflikted Flag 31 Jul 21 10.21pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Too much currency is placed on the selection of youth players. Mclaren signed off his Middlesbrough career by picking a home-grown XI for an away game at Fulham. It allowed him to play to the galery without addressing any of the long term duties of care and responsibility. Look up the XI that day and see how many made it. I'll give you a clue - same amount that would have made it without the manager using them to make himself look good. What a c***.

Hodgson looked at what we had, how he wanted to play, and picked the side most likely to get enough points overall. If you got in his side it was because you were the best option, not because of some bizarre positive discrimination in favour of youth, and you know what? It was an effective filter. Wan Bisakka got in, we made a f***ing tonne for him. Mitchell got in, did fine.

I've said it a million times but I'll repeat it - if anyone can find me the youth player we released that proved the management wrong then I'll accept the subsequent criticism of Hodgson. But nobody can.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Jul 2021 8.58pm)


Well Levi Lumeka is now a Ligue 1 player, playing 15 games in Troyes' promotion winning campaign last term (missed a huge chunk of the season through injury).

 


Milkshakes Against Fascism

TheBigToePunt Flag 31 Jul 21 10.41pm

Originally posted by inflikted


Well Levi Lumeka is now a Ligue 1 player, playing 15 games in Troyes' promotion winning campaign last term (missed a huge chunk of the season through injury).

Good luck to him, but at the end of the day one lad has done OK in a standard comparable to the top of league one and the bottom of the championship, while we remain mid table in the richest, most competitive league in the world. Not exactly a terrible indictment on Hodgsons judgement.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 01 Aug 21 12.00am

What is the point on speculating what RH may or may not have done with players who were not in his squad.

The anti-Roy brigade wants an annual parade.

If our new signings don't look good against a poor Reading then we would really be in trouble.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Aray Flag South London 01 Aug 21 8.18am

Err…AWB was the only option as Ward was injured. He took his chance and couldn’t be dropped thereafter. Jairo played his socks off v Man City and was not seen again for over a year! Got a chance at left back, won player of the month and then was dropped again! There were plenty of games when us non-experts we’re disappointed to see the youth get zero minutes on the pitch. The end of the 19/20 season was particularly galling.

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Too much currency is placed on the selection of youth players. Mclaren signed off his Middlesbrough career by picking a home-grown XI for an away game at Fulham. It allowed him to play to the galery without addressing any of the long term duties of care and responsibility. Look up the XI that day and see how many made it. I'll give you a clue - same amount that would have made it without the manager using them to make himself look good. What a c***.

Hodgson looked at what we had, how he wanted to play, and picked the side most likely to get enough points overall. If you got in his side it was because you were the best option, not because of some bizarre positive discrimination in favour of youth, and you know what? It was an effective filter. Wan Bisakka got in, we made a f***ing tonne for him. Mitchell got in, did fine.

I've said it a million times but I'll repeat it - if anyone can find me the youth player we released that proved the management wrong then I'll accept the subsequent criticism of Hodgson. But nobody can.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (31 Jul 2021 8.58pm)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Aug 21 10.20am

Much as I like Mark Bright, for these ears he's a tough listen on Palace TV.

He did make an interesting statement about young players during yesterday's game though. Along the lines of not selecting them for the senior team just for the sake of it, they have to be good enough.

And that's a point that too many on here don't seem able to understand.

I question whether it's harder for youngsters to break through these days owing to the way football is structured.

In days gone by, a promising young player would get selected for the reserves. Team mates and opposition would be composed mainly of experienced players. That young player would be exposed to something akin to the physicality of League football and the standard of play required.

I don't think that U.23 football provides that learning curve. For evidence I look at our and other club's U.23 performances against the likes of Bromley where at times it resembles Men v Boys.

From personal experience ( albeit many moons ago ), when I was 16 and playing at a decent standard, my biggest problem was coping physically - and the only way to learn was to keep playing through it.

Thoughts ?

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 01 Aug 21 10.37am

Across the PL no one has a conveyor belt of young talent that makes it into the first team. Clubs can point to one or two but that applies to all of us so the issue is not that Palace or Brighton's academy is badly managed otherwise we would see evidence to the contrary from other clubs.

So I agree with your central point that U23 football is not good enough if it were lots of youngster would be making it into Pl first teams.

I don't know what the answer is but they have to improve reserve team football.

 


One more point

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Aug 21 10.41am

Unfortunately if your first team plays in a league that pays out over a million pounds per table place at the end of the season then its easy to see why experimenting with younger players happens less (unless of course injuries / suspensions intervene)


Originally posted by NEILLO

Much as I like Mark Bright, for these ears he's a tough listen on Palace TV.

He did make an interesting statement about young players during yesterday's game though. Along the lines of not selecting them for the senior team just for the sake of it, they have to be good enough.

And that's a point that too many on here don't seem able to understand.

I question whether it's harder for youngsters to break through these days owing to the way football is structured.

In days gone by, a promising young player would get selected for the reserves. Team mates and opposition would be composed mainly of experienced players. That young player would be exposed to something akin to the physicality of League football and the standard of play required.

I don't think that U.23 football provides that learning curve. For evidence I look at our and other club's U.23 performances against the likes of Bromley where at times it resembles Men v Boys.

From personal experience ( albeit many moons ago ), when I was 16 and playing at a decent standard, my biggest problem was coping physically - and the only way to learn was to keep playing through it.

Thoughts ?

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Aug 21 10.47am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Unfortunately if your first team plays in a league that pays out over a million pounds per table place at the end of the season then its easy to see why experimenting with younger players happens less (unless of course injuries / suspensions intervene)


Agreed. That's certainly another factor.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Gribbo Flag Bromley 01 Aug 21 11.12am

That's the point. Safe with games to play so he could have given Jes, Scott Banks, Hannam and perhaps Rob Street an outing. The other one to watch is RB Danny Imray. Good to see him back with the U23s after a nasty injury.

AWB got dropped in at the deep-end and did fabulously well. Lets not forget he was due to be loaned out to Colchester. Had a great season with us and netted £50m. Not sure that would have happened if Wardy had stayed fit.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Aug 21 11.17am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Unfortunately if your first team plays in a league that pays out over a million pounds per table place at the end of the season then its easy to see why experimenting with younger players happens less (unless of course injuries / suspensions intervene)


I think you have hit the nail on the head. There is a reluctance to try given the financial implications. In days gone buy if you were mid table and safe one or two of the youngsters would have got a run out at the end of the season

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Aug 21 11.23am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Much as I like Mark Bright, for these ears he's a tough listen on Palace TV.

He did make an interesting statement about young players during yesterday's game though. Along the lines of not selecting them for the senior team just for the sake of it, they have to be good enough.

And that's a point that too many on here don't seem able to understand.

I question whether it's harder for youngsters to break through these days owing to the way football is structured.

In days gone by, a promising young player would get selected for the reserves. Team mates and opposition would be composed mainly of experienced players. That young player would be exposed to something akin to the physicality of League football and the standard of play required.

I don't think that U.23 football provides that learning curve. For evidence I look at our and other club's U.23 performances against the likes of Bromley where at times it resembles Men v Boys.

From personal experience ( albeit many moons ago ), when I was 16 and playing at a decent standard, my biggest problem was coping physically - and the only way to learn was to keep playing through it.

Thoughts ?

Can agree with most of that. The physical side of the game is so hard for many to get to grips with. And if you are talking Premier league you have to be an all round top performance athlete.
It goes further you have be tactically completely aware. Banks, scored a brilliant free kick yesterday, but a few minutes before he completely failed to stay with an opponent and cut out what was an easy cross for the Reading man.
Lower division teams , are invariably organised, and mature, many under 23s are not even 20. And I think the friendlies we have played this year show clearly ,that it is not an easy transition into what we call men’s football. And it probably gives a clue as to why, even when our boys have gone to lower league clubs on loan they don’t get much game time..
My experience as a young player was as yours, many many years ,ago. The vast majority of lads that have had a sniff of pro football, in its entirety have failed in the first place for lack of physical presence.
In the Premier it’s got to be the full package. For me I’m really hopeful for Rak Sakai, Banks to, they can both play it really is, can they transition now. . Given a bit of patience they both might.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Aug 21 11.24am

Originally posted by Gribbo

That's the point. Safe with games to play so he could have given Jes, Scott Banks, Hannam and perhaps Rob Street an outing. The other one to watch is RB Danny Imray. Good to see him back with the U23s after a nasty injury.

AWB got dropped in at the deep-end and did fabulously well. Lets not forget he was due to be loaned out to Colchester. Had a great season with us and netted £50m. Not sure that would have happened if Wardy had stayed fit.

I think actually you have missed the point.

While there is a million pounds per placing to be played for it's difficult to justify the risk attached to blooding youngsters with that financial incentive in place.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Aug 21 11.41am

Also when Covid was at at worst there was also the whole "who is in which bubble scenario" to consider - with the first team playing mostly Sat / Sun & the U23 playing mostly on the Monday you couldn't take a player out of the U23 bubble during midweek to join up with the first team & then put them back into the U23 bubble for the Mondays game if you didn't use him at the weekend.


Originally posted by NEILLO

I think actually you have missed the point.

While there is a million pounds per placing to be played for it's difficult to justify the risk attached to blooding youngsters with that financial incentive in place.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 01 Aug 21 11.55am

The big teams used to be in favour of having a b team in the league below - I used to be against the idea because I felt that the only reason they did it was because they had such talent / resources at their disposal for some it was the only way they could get a competitive game regularly, and eventually you could end up with 2 Man City teams being in the Prem - however to a lesser degree for us to have a b team maybe in League 1 could actually be an answer to Neillos earlier mentioned dilemma.

Clearly - just making the point, there would have to be some considerable amount of water under the bridge & agreement on rules before it ever became a reality

 

Page 4 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Reading V 1st XI