This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Blaming the players is always a sign of a bad manager. Cabaye, Zaha, Townsend, RLC, AWB, none of them good enough. Not to mention the poor guys time at England, we just don't have the same resources as Iceland. As you ignored previously, when offered resources, he chose Bats over Gallagher. If you miss him, don't worry, some badly run club will be stupid enough to employ the national embarrassment again, and we can all laugh at his next failure When we had the likes of these players in the team, we played some sensational football under Roy. It can’t be denied that the results we ground out with our less than average and ageing squad under RH has been fantastic over the past 2 years. It was utter turgid and miserable to watch, but effective. If we had been expansive I’m certain we’d have been relegated, but as it were, we were never even close. Vieira has just been given a £90m war chest to rebuild the squad and this is a luxury Roy never had. It was the right time for RH to go due to his age and he should hold his head held high. He was terrific for us and stabilised the club. I agree he failed at England, but why should that concern us as Palace fans? Dougie was useless at Bolton and Forest but a genius for us. There are moronic comments suggesting that the RH appreciators want Vieira to fail. What a load of bush1t. Everyone wishes PV every success and he has made an excellent start which gives us all hope for the future.
|
|
|
Originally posted by bicycle repair man
You state that Roy wouldn't play Andersen, Guehi or Gallagher if he had them in his squad, that really is nonsense. The best striker of the ball as Roy picked in his squad - And didn’t pick a corner taker. Bloody hell, this is like trying to debate with Dianne Abbot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
There are moronic comments suggesting that the RH appreciators want Vieira to fail. What a load of bush1t. Everyone wishes PV every success and he has made an excellent start which gives us all hope for the future. Roy's job was to keep us in the PL and run down the inflated wage bill contracts so we could get younger quality in on half the wages .He did a fantastic job of that and Vieira is reaping the benefits.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by bicycle repair man
You state that Roy wouldn't play Andersen, Guehi or Gallagher if he had them in his squad, that really is nonsense. Ohhh, finally a genuine rebuttal, but with a disingenuous answer. How is stating that Roy wouldn't play Gallagher nonsense? Roy turned Gallagher down for a striker that he didn't play! Kane failed to find an England player in the area with 5 out of 6 of the corners he took. Hodgson has one of the most dangerous players in the world at his disposal and could have picked any English player to simply get the ball to him. Instead, he chose to take away our most dangerous threat, and rely on the limited aerial threat of Chris Smalling instead. This is the problem with Roy's support base, they see him as immune from criticism, yet dodge any discussions about his decision making ability. Roy came up with a simple, tedious, formula, that was enough to get by. It didn't get the best out of players, and was found wanting in many areas. It worked in the short term, producing average results, but in the long term no more than managing a slow decline. Townsend and Palace players have shown huge signs of improvement without him. I'd like to leave you alone, your debate skills are so terrible I have no other option but to drum home the bleeding obvious. Honestly, I think it's best you give up? Or just dont be a dick in your replies.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
When we had the likes of these players in the team, we played some sensational football under Roy. It can’t be denied that the results we ground out with our less than average and ageing squad under RH has been fantastic over the past 2 years. It was utter turgid and miserable to watch, but effective. If we had been expansive I’m certain we’d have been relegated, but as it were, we were never even close. Vieira has just been given a £90m war chest to rebuild the squad and this is a luxury Roy never had. It was the right time for RH to go due to his age and he should hold his head held high. He was terrific for us and stabilised the club. I agree he failed at England, but why should that concern us as Palace fans? Dougie was useless at Bolton and Forest but a genius for us. There are moronic comments suggesting that the RH appreciators want Vieira to fail. What a load of bush1t. Everyone wishes PV every success and he has made an excellent start which gives us all hope for the future. I don't disagree with most of your points. I do think "fantastic" is an exaggeration, just look at the teams that went down. And Hodgson isn't someone I'd trust with a warchest to rebuilt a squad, especially as retirement was always a likelihood in the very near future. It's fair comment to say we did just enough to get where we needed to with a team of experienced professionals and a formulaic approach. There were many, many shortfalls in the approach which were incredibly frustrating to watch. When posters ignore all arguments, won't admit to the slightest fault, and start with petty digs, I think they deserve a bit of a wind up or dressing down. What kind of adult ends a post with "end of" too? Always, a sign of stupidity.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Ohhh, finally a genuine rebuttal, but with a disingenuous answer. How is stating that Roy wouldn't play Gallagher nonsense? Roy turned Gallagher down for a striker that he didn't play! Kane failed to find an England player in the area with 5 out of 6 of the corners he took. Hodgson has one of the most dangerous players in the world at his disposal and could have picked any English player to simply get the ball to him. Instead, he chose to take away our most dangerous threat, and rely on the limited aerial threat of Chris Smalling instead. This is the problem with Roy's support base, they see him as immune from criticism, yet dodge any discussions about his decision making ability. Roy came up with a simple, tedious, formula, that was enough to get by. It didn't get the best out of players, and was found wanting in many areas. It worked in the short term, producing average results, but in the long term no more than managing a slow decline. Townsend and Palace players have shown huge signs of improvement without him. I'd like to leave you alone, your debate skills are so terrible I have no other option but to drum home the bleeding obvious. Honestly, I think it's best you give up? Or just dont be a dick in your replies. This one paragraph shows how clueless you are, along with you're childish insults
|
|
|
Originally posted by Qwijibo
Yeah, Andros, Gray and Benitez have all got off to a really good start. All revitalised from a fresh start. Ironic that the year Everton are skint they find their most effective transfers. And then end up just about finishing in the top ten.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
Ohhh, finally a genuine rebuttal, but with a disingenuous answer. How is stating that Roy wouldn't play Gallagher nonsense? Roy turned Gallagher down for a striker that he didn't play! Kane failed to find an England player in the area with 5 out of 6 of the corners he took. Hodgson has one of the most dangerous players in the world at his disposal and could have picked any English player to simply get the ball to him. Instead, he chose to take away our most dangerous threat, and rely on the limited aerial threat of Chris Smalling instead. This is the problem with Roy's support base, they see him as immune from criticism, yet dodge any discussions about his decision making ability. Roy came up with a simple, tedious, formula, that was enough to get by. It didn't get the best out of players, and was found wanting in many areas. It worked in the short term, producing average results, but in the long term no more than managing a slow decline. Townsend and Palace players have shown huge signs of improvement without him. I'd like to leave you alone, your debate skills are so terrible I have no other option but to drum home the bleeding obvious. Honestly, I think it's best you give up? Or just dont be a dick in your replies. Of the 11 players Palace released only Townsend is getting a game in the Premier, all the rest have gone to lower leagues or are squad players. So, dont make out they have improved now not being managed by RH.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I doubt whether Roy had much say in recruitment
|
|
|
I watched the Everton Game Townsend looks like he's lost a stone in weight it shows the fat t*** was just going through the motions at Palace
|
|
|
Originally posted by MARKY
I watched the Everton Game Townsend looks like he's lost a stone in weight it shows the fat t*** was just going through the motions at Palace But no let's blame Roy!
|
|
|
Originally posted by AuntyAnne70
But no let's blame Roy! We will never know what Roy would have done if he had money to spend or what PV would have done with the aging squad we had last year so cany comparison is impossible. Roy had a job to do which was keep club in EPL with very little spend until high wage owners could be allowed to leave. He did this , we all accept the football was dire at times but I feel this was necessity not his aim. If you listen to pros who have played for Roy they all mention his man management skills and his attention to detail. Townsend has started well for Everton but he has always had purple patches let see if it lasts. I think he was offered a new contract at Palace but on less wages so he decided as is his right to move on, Good luck to him. The fact is our wage bill was paralysing club and stopping us moving forward. The players who extended have all accepted lower money than before. As a club we can not afford players on more than 100k per week
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I don't disagree with most of your points. I do think "fantastic" is an exaggeration, just look at the teams that went down. And Hodgson isn't someone I'd trust with a warchest to rebuilt a squad, especially as retirement was always a likelihood in the very near future. It's fair comment to say we did just enough to get where we needed to with a team of experienced professionals and a formulaic approach. There were many, many shortfalls in the approach which were incredibly frustrating to watch. When posters ignore all arguments, won't admit to the slightest fault, and start with petty digs, I think they deserve a bit of a wind up or dressing down. What kind of adult ends a post with "end of" too? Always, a sign of stupidity. It was the 2017/18 season when we had the above mentioned names and Roy steered us from rock bottom with 0 points, 0 goals and no morale after 3 games to finish 11th (our highest finish in the Prem). A few highlights of the season were beating Leicester 8-0 on aggregate and 0-0 against the unstoppable Man City which we almost nicked at the end. I think 'fantastic' is a fair assessment for a few of those performances. Agree that Hodgson couldn't be trusted with the money but only because of his age and impending retirement. A younger manager was needed to see us through the transition. If Roy was 15 years younger I'd trust him 100% because he's a proven top class manager. His lack of substitutions towards the end was frustrating, however, did we ever have any game changers on the bench? It was mostly journeyman midfields and defenders making up the numbers. He recognised that we would struggle to score so he had us well drilled to make ourselves hard to beat. His brief was to keep us up on a shoestring budget and he achieved it comfortably every season. He will go down in history as a Palace hero for successfully navigating us through a tough period. We are where we are now because of Roy. He's paved the way for PV to take us to the next level (before he moves to Arsenal!).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
It was the 2017/18 season when we had the above mentioned names and Roy steered us from rock bottom with 0 points, 0 goals and no morale after 3 games to finish 11th (our highest finish in the Prem). A few highlights of the season were beating Leicester 8-0 on aggregate and 0-0 against the unstoppable Man City which we almost nicked at the end. I think 'fantastic' is a fair assessment for a few of those performances. Agree that Hodgson couldn't be trusted with the money but only because of his age and impending retirement. A younger manager was needed to see us through the transition. If Roy was 15 years younger I'd trust him 100% because he's a proven top class manager. His lack of substitutions towards the end was frustrating, however, did we ever have any game changers on the bench? It was mostly journeyman midfields and defenders making up the numbers. He recognised that we would struggle to score so he had us well drilled to make ourselves hard to beat. His brief was to keep us up on a shoestring budget and he achieved it comfortably every season. He will go down in history as a Palace hero for successfully navigating us through a tough period. We are where we are now because of Roy. He's paved the way for PV to take us to the next level (before he moves to Arsenal!). That is a fair and honest assessment of Roy's vital contribution to CPFC.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MARKY
I watched the Everton Game Townsend looks like he's lost a stone in weight it shows the fat t*** was just going through the motions at Palace
|
|
|
I think he will fizzle out as the season goes on. Not a player I disliked though, but things have to move on and times change.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.