This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Got to say that with the might of PIF (Saudi royal family) behind it, the purchase of Newcastle for £300m is now looking like a snip. I heard they were lacking in infrastructure, like not owning a dedicated training ground or facilities. I didn't particularly look into it.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I cannot understand for one minute, unless you are a palace fanatic, why anyone would spend money on buying 36% of the club, where you have no say on what happens and make no money from your investments This question is the elephant in the room and it needs answering. Fortunately, it's fairly easy to answer. Look, by and large people have always wanted to buy football clubs despite the fact that they've never made money for the buyer. Chelsea, for just one example, is going to cost some party or other a fortune to buy and even more to run, yet there are six bidders competing to jump in. Put a PL club on the market and mostly, it sells. Based on all these long-proven realities, I think we can all grasp and accept that people don't buy football clubs because they think it's a sound financial investment on which they're going to make a profit. They know that's not the case. So, why would anyone buy a football club? Simple. For the same reason today that people have bought football clubs since the Football League began. It used to be called "ego". Owning the local football club was how the local businessman made his mark in the community; showed he'd arrived. It was a high profile move for someone who liked a bit of show. Now, ego is just as likely to be called "sportshwashing". Football club ownership is a brand for corporate egos rather than individual ones. It's a way companies, or even countries, or very wealthy individuals who own one or the other flex their financial muscle and demonstrate the power of their brand(s) on the commercial landscape. Today, if you own a PL club you're not big in your local community like you once were. You're big in the whole world. You think Leicester City aren't well supported in Thailand, for instance? And that's an attractive proposition to a great many prospective buyers. So yes, you lose cash money when you buy a club. But you get an awful lot of priceless exposure in return. Why spend your money on advertising and media when you could just own an FC instead and it'll do an even better job of exposing your brand/country/ego/company? Do you think the Saudis could buy through media channels, minutes on TV, and pages in magazines what they get from owning Newcastle United? Not a chance. Whoever buys into Palace won't be doing it to make a profit. Let's put it this way: Had you ever heard of Facebank or John Textor before last August? I doubt it. But you have now.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
In theory if they have to get rid of their Palace shares quickly then Parish could get them for nothing
|
|
|
Originally posted by Vincehair
In theory if they have to get rid of their Palace shares quickly then Parish could get them for nothing If that was true, any of us could. The sad reality is that you don't get to be a billionaire by giving away £100 million worth of shares in anything, least of all a PL football club. Most likely, if they do get Chelsea and they don't have a buyer for their Palace shares already lined up (and frankly, I think it's almost certain that they do. Again, you don't get to be a billionaire without planning in advance for situations like this), I suppose there's no reason they couldn't do what Abramovich did before the government stepped in: simply assign their shares to an independent charity, foundation, or other third party vehicle until their sale was complete. It doesn't take a lot of imagination (or paperwork) to organise and we all know that what passes for "fit and proper" behaviour at PL HQ isn't much to write home about. While if they lose the Chelsea deal I don't expect, as someone mentioned above, they'll suddenly start spending profligate sums on Palace, just maybe being having had a closer look at Chelsea's books in the due diligence process will have taught them a little more about what's needed to build a winning football club. And just maybe as a result of that, they'll become a bit more willing to step up and invest more in Palace. Wishful thinking probably, but you never know. BTW I do think - just my own guess - that Harris and Blitzer's bid will win Chelsea. This country favours the establishment and a consortium led by a former chairman of BA and Sebastian "Tory" Coe is about as establishment as you can get.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
| deleted 25 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
If that was true, any of us could. The sad reality is that you don't get to be a billionaire by giving away £100 million worth of shares in anything, least of all a PL football club. Most likely, if they do get Chelsea and they don't have a buyer for their Palace shares already lined up (and frankly, I think it's almost certain that they do. Again, you don't get to be a billionaire without planning in advance for situations like this), I suppose there's no reason they couldn't do what Abramovich did before the government stepped in: simply assign their shares to an independent charity, foundation, or other third party vehicle until their sale was complete. It doesn't take a lot of imagination (or paperwork) to organise and we all know that what passes for "fit and proper" behaviour at PL HQ isn't much to write home about. While if they lose the Chelsea deal I don't expect, as someone mentioned above, they'll suddenly start spending profligate sums on Palace, just maybe being having had a closer look at Chelsea's books in the due diligence process will have taught them a little more about what's needed to build a winning football club. And just maybe as a result of that, they'll become a bit more willing to step up and invest more in Palace. Wishful thinking probably, but you never know. BTW I do think - just my own guess - that Harris and Blitzer's bid will win Chelsea. This country favours the establishment and a consortium led by a former chairman of BA and Sebastian "Tory" Coe is about as establishment as you can get. I don't know if 100 million is much to lose if the figure being bandied about as the Chelsea price is for sale at . Don't know if a 3rd party can be involved if buying another club. Abramovich is a unique situation and he isn't set to benefit financially if you can believe what is reported. April 11th is the date mentioned as preferred bidder and will one will be put forward to complete deal by end of April.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pstrutt
So Textor seems a brighter future certainly, but a 40m investment doesn't buy all that much. I guess it just ups his stake in CPFC2010 or whatever the current Holding name is. As far as I can parse it, Textor bought 40% of the club for £89 million at the start of the season. Harris and Blitzer apparently own 22% of the club so the £40 million would not really be invested in CPFC per se (typical careless headline-grabbing). In reality it would simply be money that enabled Textor to acquire Harris and Blitzer's 22%. Or in other words, they (as sellers) and not the club itself would pocket that "investment". The £40 million is simply Blitzer and Harris' RoI on their original purchase. If 40% of the shares cost £89 million in September and 22% are now selling for £40 million, given that the club's market value has probably slightly increased over the past nine months as a result of recent successes on the pitch, Textor is picking up the deal at a slight discount to true value, probably because buying from a partner owner eases the path for Harris and Blitzer to move quickly on Chelsea if they need to do so. In short, the number makes sense for all parties. Having established that the £40 million is NOT really an investment in CPFC (a real investment in CPFC would be any money Textor put into the club above and beyond the £40 million he's spending to buy the shares), the key question is whether Textor becoming the clear majority shareholder (since after such a transaction, he would own 62% of Palace) is something we should be happy about? On the plus side of the ledger, first, he seems genuinely committed to Palace beyond the club being simply an investment. To coin a phrase, his "hearts in it". Second, at least to date, he's been supportive in both operational and financial senses and has let Parish do what he does well. There's no reason to think that wouldn't continue, so he represents operational continuity at a time when continuity is good. And third, he seems to generally be a responsible executive (not a Mel Morris, Mike Ashley, or someone who seems likely to lead us up the garden path to ruin). In spite of his showbiz industry background, he appears to be a low-profile, responsible character and if you can read anything into his education, raised with conservative protestant values. On the downside of the ledger (if it is a downside) he is most decidedly not a billionaire. His wealth is largely paper, not cash, and his net worth is around $250 million which is certainly rich by your standards and mine but it's not top six rich by any stretch of the imagination. If the financial markets were to suddenly go south for any reason, his paper wealth could be rapidly and severely compromised. No reason at present to think this could or would happen, but you know the disclaimer: your investment in shares can go down as well as up, etc. Given this landscape and the extent of his wealth, I'd imagine his investments in the likes of Palace are probably quite highly leveraged, and that he's carrying some debt. This makes him more of a Glazer than an Abramovich, at least from a balance sheet perspective. All in all, personally I'm happy with Textor picking up Harris and Blitzer's shares when taking the above into consideration. But I'm not kidding myself; this is not the arrival of Christmas. It's not going to mean a sudden influx of cash and a wild spending spree and if, indeed, that happened it would be bad news, not good news, because the spending would be highly leveraged and as every football fan should know by now, that's little more than an invitation to trouble. As I see it, Textor puts the shares and ownership of Palace in a safe pair of hands and it means the responsible, somewhat cautious, but effective approach and business model Parish has developed over the last ten years can be expected to continue operating much as it has done so far. That's something to celebrate.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
What a great and informative post; I also share your conclusions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
As far as I can parse it, Textor bought 40% of the club for £89 million at the start of the season. Harris and Blitzer apparently own 22% of the club so the £40 million would not really be invested in CPFC per se (typical careless headline-grabbing). In reality it would simply be money that enabled Textor to acquire Harris and Blitzer's 22%. Or in other words, they (as sellers) and not the club itself would pocket that "investment". The £40 million is simply Blitzer and Harris' RoI on their original purchase. If 40% of the shares cost £89 million in September and 22% are now selling for £40 million, given that the club's market value has probably slightly increased over the past nine months as a result of recent successes on the pitch, Textor is picking up the deal at a slight discount to true value, probably because buying from a partner owner eases the path for Harris and Blitzer to move quickly on Chelsea if they need to do so. In short, the number makes sense for all parties. Having established that the £40 million is NOT really an investment in CPFC (a real investment in CPFC would be any money Textor put into the club above and beyond the £40 million he's spending to buy the shares), the key question is whether Textor becoming the clear majority shareholder (since after such a transaction, he would own 62% of Palace) is something we should be happy about? On the plus side of the ledger, first, he seems genuinely committed to Palace beyond the club being simply an investment. To coin a phrase, his "hearts in it". Second, at least to date, he's been supportive in both operational and financial senses and has let Parish do what he does well. There's no reason to think that wouldn't continue, so he represents operational continuity at a time when continuity is good. And third, he seems to generally be a responsible executive (not a Mel Morris, Mike Ashley, or someone who seems likely to lead us up the garden path to ruin). In spite of his showbiz industry background, he appears to be a low-profile, responsible character and if you can read anything into his education, raised with conservative protestant values. On the downside of the ledger (if it is a downside) he is most decidedly not a billionaire. His wealth is largely paper, not cash, and his net worth is around 0 million which is certainly rich by your standards and mine but it's not top six rich by any stretch of the imagination. If the financial markets were to suddenly go south for any reason, his paper wealth could be rapidly and severely compromised. No reason at present to think this could or would happen, but you know the disclaimer: your investment in shares can go down as well as up, etc. Given this landscape and the extent of his wealth, I'd imagine his investments in the likes of Palace are probably quite highly leveraged, and that he's carrying some debt. This makes him more of a Glazer than an Abramovich, at least from a balance sheet perspective. All in all, personally I'm happy with Textor picking up Harris and Blitzer's shares when taking the above into consideration. But I'm not kidding myself; this is not the arrival of Christmas. It's not going to mean a sudden influx of cash and a wild spending spree and if, indeed, that happened it would be bad news, not good news, because the spending would be highly leveraged and as every football fan should know by now, that's little more than an invitation to trouble. As I see it, Textor puts the shares and ownership of Palace in a safe pair of hands and it means the responsible, somewhat cautious, but effective approach and business model Parish has developed over the last ten years can be expected to continue operating much as it has done so far. That's something to celebrate.
Edited by dreamwaverider (29 Mar 2022 5.03pm) Edited by dreamwaverider (29 Mar 2022 5.14pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Agree with all this. I think we're saying essentially the same thing, but my interpretation verged towards the optimistic whereas perhaps yours leans towards a more sober interpretation of the realities. What is clear, and we both agree on, is that Textor isn't close to "football magnate wealthy" and the wealth he does have is largely paper, subject to fluctuations in value that can be severe. Those who think, if he does add to his holding and becomes the controlling shareholder at Palace, that we're in for a period of significant investment are probably going to be severely disappointed. The upside is that there's no reason to think the club won't continue to be well run by Parish if Textor takes over the lead, but if anything the purse strings may be even more tightly managed than they are now. As we've both said, whatever they choose to spend or not, Harris and Blitzer are seriously wealthy. At a minimum, that gives us security. Textor is not in their league.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
This question is the elephant in the room and it needs answering. Fortunately, it's fairly easy to answer. Look, by and large people have always wanted to buy football clubs despite the fact that they've never made money for the buyer. Chelsea, for just one example, is going to cost some party or other a fortune to buy and even more to run, yet there are six bidders competing to jump in. Put a PL club on the market and mostly, it sells. Based on all these long-proven realities, I think we can all grasp and accept that people don't buy football clubs because they think it's a sound financial investment on which they're going to make a profit. They know that's not the case. So, why would anyone buy a football club? Simple. For the same reason today that people have bought football clubs since the Football League began. It used to be called "ego". Owning the local football club was how the local businessman made his mark in the community; showed he'd arrived. It was a high profile move for someone who liked a bit of show. Now, ego is just as likely to be called "sportshwashing". Football club ownership is a brand for corporate egos rather than individual ones. It's a way companies, or even countries, or very wealthy individuals who own one or the other flex their financial muscle and demonstrate the power of their brand(s) on the commercial landscape. Today, if you own a PL club you're not big in your local community like you once were. You're big in the whole world. You think Leicester City aren't well supported in Thailand, for instance? And that's an attractive proposition to a great many prospective buyers. So yes, you lose cash money when you buy a club. But you get an awful lot of priceless exposure in return. Why spend your money on advertising and media when you could just own an FC instead and it'll do an even better job of exposing your brand/country/ego/company? Do you think the Saudis could buy through media channels, minutes on TV, and pages in magazines what they get from owning Newcastle United? Not a chance. Whoever buys into Palace won't be doing it to make a profit. Let's put it this way: Had you ever heard of Facebank or John Textor before last August? I doubt it. But you have now. I can understand what you are saying if your are the one making the decisions, But H & B are just going to be bit part players.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I can understand what you are saying if your are the one making the decisions, But H & B are just going to be bit part players. In Chelsea, yes. But if you track the history of Harris and Blitzer (and HBSE) it's clear that they are not cut from that cloth. For them, it's not ego. They historically view their investment in sports teams as just that; an investment. Their approach has been to buy low-priced assets, stabilize them, and sell them on for a much higher price after 3-5 years. They acquired the Sixers for $200 million. They're presently valued at $700 million. What they've done with Palace is completely consistent with this model. When they bought in, the club was worth around £150 million. Today, it's worth around £225 million give or take. Chelsea, of course, is a different kettle of fish so you'd be right to ask why would they be interested in them? The best answer I can come up with is that their real long-term strategy and underlying goal is owning an NFL franchise, not Chelsea. So they don't need and they're not looking to own a majority share in the club. This (a London team) seems unlikely anytime soon (the NFL has openly expressed reservations about placing a team outside mainland USA in the near future) but if true, having a holding in Chelsea might be considered a suitable vehicle to further that cause. If their bid is successful, what price the new Stamford Bridge (or its replacement elsewhere) is, like Spurs, an NFL-ready facility with partial investment from source? And let's be honest, Chelsea would be a pretty good twin for an incoming central London NFL team, arguably much more so than Palace.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by sydtheeagle
In Chelsea, yes. But if you track the history of Harris and Blitzer (and HBSE) it's clear that they are not cut from that cloth. For them, it's not ego. They historically view their investment in sports teams as just that; an investment. Their approach has been to buy low-priced assets, stabilize them, and sell them on for a much higher price after 3-5 years. They acquired the Sixers for 0 million. They're presently valued at 0 million. What they've done with Palace is completely consistent with this model. When they bought in, the club was worth around £150 million. Today, it's worth around £225 million give or take. Chelsea, of course, is a different kettle of fish so you'd be right to ask why would they be interested in them? The best answer I can come up with is that their real long-term strategy and underlying goal is owning an NFL franchise, not Chelsea. So they don't need and they're not looking to own a majority share in the club. This (a London team) seems unlikely anytime soon (the NFL has openly expressed reservations about placing a team outside mainland USA in the near future) but if true, having a holding in Chelsea might be considered a suitable vehicle to further that cause. If their bid is successful, what price the new Stamford Bridge (or its replacement elsewhere) is, like Spurs, an NFL-ready facility with partial investment from source? And let's be honest, Chelsea would be a pretty good twin for an incoming central London NFL team, arguably much more so than Palace. I just can’t see NFL going big here. Especially with teams from USA. Its all for the money.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I just can’t see NFL going big here. Especially with teams from USA. Its all for the money. Well, you have much in common with the NFL itself which, at least for the forseeable future, can't see the NFL being ready to come here either. So you're right about that. I think an NFL team WILL come here one day, but that's probably 20 years or so into the future. These guys are savvy; they're not going to make the move until they've really laid a platform for it to be successful. And having one isolated team in Europe isn't that. Part building Spurs' stadium, playing multiple games in London every year, next season expanding overseas games into other European countries are all part of laying the path but it's a long road to build and the NFL is patient and sensible. When the NFL does expand into Europe, it won't be with just a London team. I'd expect five teams across Europe to be created simultaneously with thus, a European division from day one. The league knows that's the way to do it for a whole variety of reasons. And as I said, that's probably at least 20 years away. But that's almost without doubt the long term direction of travel. Edited by sydtheeagle (30 Mar 2022 9.39am)
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Got to say I’m deeply unhappy about what these guys are up to. They bought into us and now they are trying for an upgrade to Chelsea. I posted on here a couple of seasons ago that these guys are tight arsed investors all wrong for football. Just chasing the money. You are right, but it completely mystifies me why you are unhappy about it. Harris and Blitzer are INVESTORS. It says that on the tin. It's what they do. They have never, ever pretended to be anything else. And we (Palace) were more than happy to have them invest in us at a time when we needed investment. They did us a favour (buying in) and we've done them a favour (as the value of the club has increased). Everybody won. That's how it's supposed to be. The investor benefits from a shrewd investment and good management. The business benefits from the investment. What the hell is there to be unhappy about? And how can they be "all wrong for football" when, since they invested, almost everything that has happened at Palace has been good? Do you think fans make better owners than serious investors? Do you want Simon Jordan or Mark Goldberg back? Sorry to be blunt, but you statements strike me as nonsensical. We may never have warmed to Harris and Blitzer but we have absolutely nothing to excoriate them for.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.