This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I'll preface this post by observing that, criminal scumbag though he seemingly was, Floyd was certainly murdered, and that criminal charges against the (diverse) trio of policemen responsible were appropriate. That said, I agree entirely with your post. The problem you highlight began when commercial organisations developed manipulative and subtle form of advertising relating to social/political issues. We all wanted them to stop using third world sweatshops, trade fairly, not dump s*** in rivers, treat cattle humanely etc and so on, and once the commercial sector realised it couldn't avoid social responsibility, it began using it as a marketing tool instead. Adverts became less about the quality of the product and more about appropriately paid locals harvesting crops in Sri Lanka, poverty stricken Mexican lads being saved from a life of gang violence, or of drinking wells being constructed in Africa. Add in social media and soon enough everyone from craft breweries to lawnmower companies feel obliged to announce their socially progressive position on just about everything. Partly this is for free advertising, partly to try and do the right thing, and partly a response to fear of being shamed if they don't. The problem of course is that whilst there is no limit to the number and complexity of social/political issues, there certainly is a limit to the ability of commercial organisations to fully understand and address them, hence the trend for gross oversimplification. As you say, the most prominent example of this was the FA, Premier League and football broadcasters rushing to throw as much visible support behind BLM as possible without stopping to assess what they were doing. The process that followed still begars belief. Music or recorded applause being played at high volume at Wembley to drown out any dissent as the knee was taken, complete denial that respectful and reasonable opposition existed, regular misrepresentation of opposition as either flagrant racism or the result of ignorance (BLM were, all of a sudden, not a political organisation apparently), before they slowly and very privately designed a method to reverse out of it all without ever acknowledging possible error, let alone the damage done. All of which leads us to the decision to cancel football this weekend. It's not the decision itself I am frustrated by (incorrect though I think it is), it's the people and process leading to it. These are organisations labouring under the misapprehension that they are required to develop social/political views, that they are capable of doing so to an appropriate standard, and that they don't need to consider the views of the people who pay for the whole gravy train. They are are stuck in an ongoing addiction to the social media popularity contest, and this just feels like the latest consequence. Apologies for the long post, but I appreciate the opportunity to articulate my feelings. I'm sure the mods will move the post to a different thread if necessary. Good post and it covers everything except Di and Dodi. On a selfish point I am off for a few days to Dublin so not worried too much that the match is off.
Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course). |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
For those who remain baffled by the decision to call off games at all levels this weekend may be interested to learn that the Telegraph is reporting today that Eton college managed to play two games this weekend. Good to see an establishment of their standing blatantly ignoring the idiots that run football here.
|
|
|
Edited by dreamwaverider (12 Sep 2022 7.11am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I'll preface this post by observing that, criminal scumbag though he seemingly was, Floyd was certainly murdered, and that criminal charges against the (diverse) trio of policemen responsible were appropriate. That said, I agree entirely with your post. The problem you highlight began when commercial organisations developed manipulative and subtle form of advertising relating to social/political issues. We all wanted them to stop using third world sweatshops, trade fairly, not dump s*** in rivers, treat cattle humanely etc and so on, and once the commercial sector realised it couldn't avoid social responsibility, it began using it as a marketing tool instead. Adverts became less about the quality of the product and more about appropriately paid locals harvesting crops in Sri Lanka, poverty stricken Mexican lads being saved from a life of gang violence, or of drinking wells being constructed in Africa. Add in social media and soon enough everyone from craft breweries to lawnmower companies feel obliged to announce their socially progressive position on just about everything. Partly this is for free advertising, partly to try and do the right thing, and partly a response to fear of being shamed if they don't. The problem of course is that whilst there is no limit to the number and complexity of social/political issues, there certainly is a limit to the ability of commercial organisations to fully understand and address them, hence the trend for gross oversimplification. As you say, the most prominent example of this was the FA, Premier League and football broadcasters rushing to throw as much visible support behind BLM as possible without stopping to assess what they were doing. The process that followed still begars belief. Music or recorded applause being played at high volume at Wembley to drown out any dissent as the knee was taken, complete denial that respectful and reasonable opposition existed, regular misrepresentation of opposition as either flagrant racism or the result of ignorance (BLM were, all of a sudden, not a political organisation apparently), before they slowly and very privately designed a method to reverse out of it all without ever acknowledging possible error, let alone the damage done. All of which leads us to the decision to cancel football this weekend. It's not the decision itself I am frustrated by (incorrect though I think it is), its the people and process leading to it. These are organisations labouring under the misapprehension that they are required to develop social/political views, that they are capable of doing so to an appropriate standard, and that they don't need to consider the views of the people who pay for the whole gravy train. They are are stuck in an ongoing addiction to the social media popularity contest, and this just feels like the latest consequence. Apologies for the long post, but I appreciate the opportunity to articulate my feelings. I'm sure the mods will move the post to a different thread if necessary.
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
The same people who instead of reasoning a sensible response to some of the awful racism in the game albeit by a significant minority. wow - so minor criminal deserved to be killed based on previous misdemeanours. I don't think you understand what the BLM movement is all about. Regarding Qatar, you are spot on
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
I have changed my stance on this over the past few days... I think the reason other sports have been allowed to continue and football cancelled is due to the perceived (and probably rightly so) demographic of football fans. Unfortunately all clubs have an element of numpties who will feel the need to ruin the minutes silence. Liverpool fans are known for their dislike of the Queen, so it wouldn't go down well at Anfield. It's not a good look for football if fans show such a lack of respect when observing a minutes silence for such an important character for our nation. Minority ruining it for the majority as per usual.
|
|
|
The Brentford and Tottenham home games in London are both going ahead this weekend. Originally posted by Swindy
It is about not having to police certain games & numbers of police available in London for events and the funeral on Monday isn't it ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
The Brentford and Tottenham home games in London are both going ahead this weekend. Brentford and Tottenham are on different days and are low risk fixtures. Chelsea Liverpool would be a medium risk fixture and, being the later game on the Sunday, starts to cause issues for those that police it being back for work in the early hours of Monday for the funeral. I don't I've ever heard of a game being unpostponed and I doubt any of us on here can think of every barrier to that happening so whilst annoying, it's not surprising our game is still off. No idea on the situation surrounding United v Leeds, albeit it would be a high risk and therefore resource heavy fixtures. If you think about it, it really isn't much of a nonsense. The games last weekend definitely should have been played.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
The original reason for cancelling the game was the train strike. Originally posted by ambrose7
Brentford and Tottenham are on different days and are low risk fixtures. Chelsea Liverpool would be a medium risk fixture and, being the later game on the Sunday, starts to cause issues for those that police it being back for work in the early hours of Monday for the funeral. I don't I've ever heard of a game being unpostponed and I doubt any of us on here can think of every barrier to that happening so whilst annoying, it's not surprising our game is still off. No idea on the situation surrounding United v Leeds, albeit it would be a high risk and therefore resource heavy fixtures. If you think about it, it really isn't much of a nonsense. The games last weekend definitely should have been played.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
The original reason for cancelling the game was the train strike. You think people are accepting 'old junk' and your theory is that the game is off because Brighton don't fancy playing? As said, no-one on here knows what is required to put a game back on, or how many of Sussex police are being pulled into London. No-one has said Tottenham's game doesn't require policing, but no-one can reasonably think the requirements of Tottenham v Leicester on Saturday is anything on the scale of Brentford v Arsenal AND Chelsea v Liverpool on Sunday.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
You acknowledged yourself that the games should have been played last weekend so presumably question some of the ‘junk’ from the authorities.You buy the excuse for this weekend, I don’t. Originally posted by ambrose7
You think people are accepting 'old junk' and your theory is that the game is off because Brighton don't fancy playing? As said, no-one on here knows what is required to put a game back on, or how many of Sussex police are being pulled into London. No-one has said Tottenham's game doesn't require policing, but no-one can reasonably think the requirements of Tottenham v Leicester on Saturday is anything on the scale of Brentford v Arsenal AND Chelsea v Liverpool on Sunday.
|
|
|
Hi all
|
|
|
Originally posted by palace99
wow - so minor criminal deserved to be killed based on previous misdemeanours. I don't think you understand what the BLM movement is all about. Regarding Qatar, you are spot on Due to where he lives, he may well have more insight into BLM than you or I
|
|
|
Originally posted by peterboroeagle
Hi all
Signed
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.