You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Time for a radical political reset
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Time for a radical political reset


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Nov 22 6.09am

There is no point in doing a blame game on the state of the nation.

Things have been going wrong for decades.

Economically and socially since Blair up to Sunak.

Lack of planning, fiscal mismanagement, social deterioration have all come home to roost fuelled by unrealistic interest rates, lack of social cohesion, absurd expectations of something for nothing etc etc.

I can't see an end without a major political shake up. I have come around to the view we should try PR rather than FPTP. Sadly the only place we have tried is NI where it has been an abject failure.

We have allowed ourselves to get to a position where our elected class who levy tax and decide where it is spent do not seem to represent anyone from left to centre to right.

Am I being too pessimistic?

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 18 Nov 22 6.26am

My own opinions on a reset are based around a total overhaul of politics and the system. The 5 year General Election merry-go-round affords the country no longer-term planning. Successive Governments are able to fall-back on the "my predecessor messed-up" excuse.
Proportional Representation would perhaps kind of mellow the 2 party system, but it's not a complete solution.
In my Utopian vision the UK Government would be run by professionals in their field, in a similar way to how the Civil Service functions. For further example, not having a Prime Minister whose qualifications are a Degree in English Literature from Eton, but someone who has socio-economic experience, or someone dealing with Trade having a background in manufacturing/engineering.

I am fed-up with the "oh, we messed up a bit" excuse for people in Government clearly out of their depth and winging it.

Cromwell and Fawkes had the right idea to go about things, but I don't see the UK changing anything significant in the future. The political snouts are too well entrenched into the trough, and the enthusiasm for such a radical change has been much diluted using the media outlets.
The two-party system (in England) is successful in dividing the opinion of the population and conforms them into such a state.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (18 Nov 2022 6.28am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Nov 22 6.35am

Can't agree that Fawkes' mass murder terrorist attempt was the way to go.

I am not convinced PR is an answer but what we have now is not working and what other electoral system is there?

Anything that gives Scotland a speedy farewell would get my support.

Edited by HKOwen (18 Nov 2022 6.40am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Midlands Eagle Flag 18 Nov 22 6.57am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Anything that gives Scotland a speedy farewell would get my support.

But it isn't workable in practice unless you build a huge Trump style wall across the border

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 18 Nov 22 7.16am

as a slight aside, I studied A level Government and Politics in the mid-1980's at the height of Thatcherism.At the start of every lecture there was a heated debate between students about the latest happenings in Government between staunch Tories and their fellow to the left.
Interesting points was raised by both sides, to the detriment of the lecture, which always started late because of off-topic discussions. And when the lecture did start, was frequently interrupted.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Nov 22 8.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But it isn't workable in practice unless you build a huge Trump style wall across the border

Exactly, some may think this fantasy but I think it is a real possibility.

My brother lives in the north of England he runs a B&B and gets Scottish visitors coming to England to buy their booze because Wee Jimmie has put the tax up. Post independence I can only see this cross border buying increasing so the SNP maybe the ones doing border controls.

The SNP believe in open borders if they get their way migrants will fly to Scotland and then cross the border, at some point the UK government would be forced to stop this.

 


One more point

YT Flag Oxford 18 Nov 22 8.37am

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly, some may think this fantasy but I think it is a real possibility.

My brother lives in the north of England he runs a B&B and gets Scottish visitors coming to England to buy their booze because Wee Jimmie has put the tax up. Post independence I can only see this cross border buying increasing so the SNP maybe the ones doing border controls.

The SNP believe in open borders if they get their way migrants will fly to Scotland and then cross the border, at some point the UK government would be forced to stop this.

And imagine 'simple' issues like who qualifies to be classed as 'Scottish', with a right to live there? Is it everyone who lives there at a particular date? Will every UK citizen have the right to declare themselves as 'Scottish'? If so, what about the people they are married or civil partnered to or partnered with, or their children or step-children; what will their status be? What about all the people around the world who claim to be 'Scottish' - anecdotally there are many times more of these than the population of Scotland itself?

Edited by YT (18 Nov 2022 8.37am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 18 Nov 22 8.37am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Can't agree that Fawkes' mass murder terrorist attempt was the way to go.

I am not convinced PR is an answer but what we have now is not working and what other electoral system is there?

Anything that gives Scotland a speedy farewell would get my support.

Edited by HKOwen (18 Nov 2022 6.40am)

Giving people 'a choice' is actually a waste of time because in practice there isn't any. The self-indulgent ponce Johnson followed by the clueless moron Truss are indicative of the desperately poor calibre of people that put themselves forward these days. Perhaps a steady fascist dictatorship might be the solution to move the country forward?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Nov 22 8.40am

Originally posted by YT

And imagine 'simple' issues like who qualifies to be classed as 'Scottish', with a right to live there? Is it everyone who lives there at a particular date? Will every UK citizen have the right to declare themselves as 'Scottish'? If so, what about the people they are married or civil partnered to or partnered with, or their children or step-children; what will their status be? What about all the people around the world who claim to be 'Scottish' - anecdotally there are many times more if these than the population of Scotland itself?

Exactly to stop migrants coming to the UK through the back door the UK would have to draw a line and treat Scottish people the same as any EU subject.

The days of an unemployed unskilled jock jumping on a train to London and looking for work would have to go. Oddly enough I know quite a few Scots and Irish who just did and found work and paid taxes here.

The Scots may have forgotten that when they have no jobs England / London is always a good place for work. I would imagine Wee Jimmie would do her nut but what do you expect if you are independent you have no more rights than any other foreign worker.

Edited by Badger11 (18 Nov 2022 8.44am)

 


One more point

YT Flag Oxford 18 Nov 22 8.40am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Giving people 'a choice' is actually a waste of time because in practice there isn't any. The self-indulgent ponce Johnson followed by the clueless moron Truss are indicative of the desperately poor calibre of people that put themselves forward these days. Perhaps a steady fascist dictatorship might be the solution to move the country forward?

And you inadvertently forgot to mention the Labour party's hopeless previous leaders - Brown, Milliband and Corbyn.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Nov 22 8.43am

Originally posted by HKOwen

There is no point in doing a blame game on the state of the nation.

Things have been going wrong for decades.

Economically and socially since Blair up to Sunak.

Lack of planning, fiscal mismanagement, social deterioration have all come home to roost fuelled by unrealistic interest rates, lack of social cohesion, absurd expectations of something for nothing etc etc.

I can't see an end without a major political shake up. I have come around to the view we should try PR rather than FPTP. Sadly the only place we have tried is NI where it has been an abject failure.

We have allowed ourselves to get to a position where our elected class who levy tax and decide where it is spent do not seem to represent anyone from left to centre to right.

Am I being too pessimistic?

You need to look beyond NI for a model. That system doesn't work because the DUP only signed up to the Anglo Irish Agreement under protest, now only play lip service to joint rule and put up any obstacle they can to working with the nationalists. The previous leader would not resign over a patently resignable issue as it would have meant handing over the reigns to Deputy McGuiness. Now the protocol is just another disingenuous excuse, and I have little doubt they will paralyse their country in years to come over a.n.other excuse rather than work with Sinn Fein.

We have powerful political divisions but nothing like the entrenched Sectarian pish that still divides that place.

The continent has a whole range of better examples to follow of strong stable prosperous countries with a long tradition of coalition government.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 18 Nov 22 8.44am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Giving people 'a choice' is actually a waste of time because in practice there isn't any. The self-indulgent ponce Johnson followed by the clueless moron Truss are indicative of the desperately poor calibre of people that put themselves forward these days. Perhaps a steady fascist dictatorship might be the solution to move the country forward?

that thought had entered my head. too much electoral choice gives paralysis through analysis.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Nov 22 8.47am

PR sounds like a fair system however in practice it means that as no one has a majority they have to do deals to form a coalition which means inevitably that a small party has too much power e.g. DUP and Mrs May.

The tail should not wag the dog.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 18 Nov 22 8.48am

Originally posted by HKOwen

There is no point in doing a blame game on the state of the nation.

Things have been going wrong for decades.

Economically and socially since Blair up to Sunak.

Lack of planning, fiscal mismanagement, social deterioration have all come home to roost fuelled by unrealistic interest rates, lack of social cohesion, absurd expectations of something for nothing etc etc.

I can't see an end without a major political shake up. I have come around to the view we should try PR rather than FPTP. Sadly the only place we have tried is NI where it has been an abject failure.

We have allowed ourselves to get to a position where our elected class who levy tax and decide where it is spent do not seem to represent anyone from left to centre to right.

Am I being too pessimistic?

No you aren't and it's nice to be able to agree with you over something.

As FH says in his response I think not just PR is needed but a root and branch overhaul. How we get it is the problem. The Tories need to be honest and split. I see no long term future for Labour unless they are capable of genuine reform and I don't see any real sign of that.

I suspect things will need to get worse before they can get better. A couple of hung parliaments resulting in ineffective coalitions stitched together and then pulled apart, eventually leading to the adoption of PR for the next.

Then the emergence of new parties, some on the right, some the left but a dominant one in the centre. I am not sure I will see it though!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 18 Nov 22 9.07am

Originally posted by YT

And imagine 'simple' issues like who qualifies to be classed as 'Scottish', with a right to live there? Is it everyone who lives there at a particular date? Will every UK citizen have the right to declare themselves as 'Scottish'? If so, what about the people they are married or civil partnered to or partnered with, or their children or step-children; what will their status be? What about all the people around the world who claim to be 'Scottish' - anecdotally there are many times more of these than the population of Scotland itself?

Edited by YT (18 Nov 2022 8.37am)

Jocks hold a 'British Passport' so do the English, Welsh and Northern Irish. A friend of mine has gone to live and work in a small community near Inverness. He hasn’t been welcomed and he and his family have been singled out for unpleasant treatment by his immediate neighbours just because they are English. Clearly, a small town with very small minds but if this happens now you can probably imagine the intensity of discrimination after 'independence' if it ever happens?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 18 Nov 22 9.17am

Originally posted by YT

And you inadvertently forgot to mention the Labour party's hopeless previous leaders - Brown, Milliband and Corbyn.

I'm only recalling the last couple of months ... the list is extensive.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

mezzer Flag Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 18 Nov 22 9.41am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

But it isn't workable in practice unless you build a huge Trump style wall across the border

#votehadrian

 


Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.

YT Flag Oxford 18 Nov 22 9.56am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Jocks hold a 'British Passport' so do the English, Welsh and Northern Irish. A friend of mine has gone to live and work in a small community near Inverness. He hasn’t been welcomed and he and his family have been singled out for unpleasant treatment by his immediate neighbours just because they are English. Clearly, a small town with very small minds but if this happens now you can probably imagine the intensity of discrimination after 'independence' if it ever happens?

I often wonder whether the four-and-twenty virgins who came down from there and then returned 'without their virtue intact' are still going strong. Post-independence such an excursion may well need a visa.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 18 Nov 22 10.06am

Originally posted by YT

I often wonder whether the four-and-twenty virgins who came down from there and then returned 'without their virtue intact' are still going strong. Post-independence such an excursion may well need a visa.

You'd think they'd fit back in seamlessly.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 18 Nov 22 10.20am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Jocks hold a 'British Passport' so do the English, Welsh and Northern Irish. A friend of mine has gone to live and work in a small community near Inverness. He hasn’t been welcomed and he and his family have been singled out for unpleasant treatment by his immediate neighbours just because they are English. Clearly, a small town with very small minds but if this happens now you can probably imagine the intensity of discrimination after 'independence' if it ever happens?

I've lived in Scotland for five years and haven't had any problems, the people I've met have been friendly or at least not unfriendly - certainly more so than in London. My wife is Scottish and from round here, albeit having lived away for 30 years, so maybe that helps. On the whole the sort of English people Scots don't like are the same ones English people don't generally care for either.
Or maybe it's all a ruse and they're all building a Wicker Man.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Time for a radical political reset