This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by tonymair
For all that has been achieved since 2010… Some interesting questions, my thoughts. Academy Major Trophy Ownership All of the above is doable so I am not that downhearted but there is a whiff old same old palace. Edited by Badger11 (12 Jan 2023 10.09pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Some interesting questions, my thoughts. Academy Major Trophy Ownership All of the above is doable so I am not that downhearted but there is a whiff old same old palace. Edited by Badger11 (12 Jan 2023 10.09pm) Are there any prem teams who this actually applies to? Only Chelsea spring to mind. For me 1 new academy player regularly competing for a starting position every 2 years would be a sign of progress. Mitchell is currently the only recent graduate, I wonder how long it'll be before the next genuine contribution. Hopefully not too long, I can't see many stepping up this season but sometimes it comes out of nowhere e.g AwB Edited by samprior (12 Jan 2023 10.34pm) Edited by samprior (12 Jan 2023 10.35pm) Edited by samprior (12 Jan 2023 10.41pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by tonymair
For all that has been achieved since 2010… Touched upon it in another thread however I would say that, despite little to no knowledge. this would be my guess: Firstly, I don't think you're alone or unjust in feeling this way. Secondly, I would suggest that football is dictated by money these days, the 'top' clubs are always going to be the richest clubs. Newcastle look like the only team to be breaking into that small circle now and not shockingly as they've been bought with the Saudi blood money (controversial statement... or not). I think beyond major investment, we're probably punching near as best we can at our weight now with top half finishes perhaps slightly above or an improvement. Without the extra money it will be hard to buy top players, acquire a top, top manager and improve the club as a whole (stadium for one thing - always something in the pipeline however little movement). We've seen some rocky times just trying to stay in the Prem and I would again suggest this has halted or hampered our ability to fund continuous improvement. We had one big spending spree recently and that was out of absolute necessity given the state of the squad. Was more a revamp than an improvement. The thing about that for me was I thought it hailed a new dawn however it would seem to be a one off out of the necessity. If we were to all get our wish, and splash another triple-figure million squid on some full backs, midfielders, a winger and striker, I would question as to just how we would financially justify that and then actually sustain it without immediate success. Could very well be a short lived shot for glory but inevitable catastrophe of a 'boom and bust'. The proposed model now of investing in young players and an academy I think again is a medium to long term plan for us. As for a cup we certainly have a shout but a lot of luck is needed there.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by samprior
For me 1 new academy player regularly competing for a starting position every 2 years would be a sign of progress. Mitchell is currently the only recent graduate, I wonder how long it'll be before the next genuine contribution. Although Mitchell was an academy player he was really a product of Brentford's academy until they closed it and we snapped him up
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Although Mitchell was an academy player he was really a product of Brentford's academy until they closed it and we snapped him up I did think that but he did at least develop for a year or two with us before making the first team so I thought I'd include him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I think we have reached the Ceiling as a club, unless some billionaire comes along, if we had a 40.000 seat stadium, we wouldn't fill it every week, sustainability is what it is all about, mid table and a cup one day (hopefully) should be our ambitions, trying to play like Man City without the players is ridiculous and will end up with relegation, as for the academy it questionable if it is worth the money is debatable, if you provide one premier league standard a year then yes, if not go down the Brentford route and not have one. I totally agree.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I think we have reached the Ceiling as a club, unless some billionaire comes along, if we had a 40.000 seat stadium, we wouldn't fill it every week, sustainability is what it is all about, mid table and a cup one day (hopefully) should be our ambitions, trying to play like Man City without the players is ridiculous and will end up with relegation, as for the academy it questionable if it is worth the money is debatable, if you provide one premier league standard a year then yes, if not go down the Brentford route and not have one.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
"There has been a recent change in Premier League rules which means that, by the start of the 2024/25 season, all Premier League clubs must have an Academy at Category Three level or higher. The opening of a Category Four Academy is a step towards eventually complying with the new regulations. It is also necessary to have an Academy in order to gain a licence to compete in UEFA competitions". Thanks for that Willo. That should put to bed arguments about whether or not to have an Academy. Edited by doombear (13 Jan 2023 9.21am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Personally I regard 'the Academy' as tick-box exercise bulls***. I hope I'm proved wrong and it goes on to produce "the team of the thirties" to celebrate the 50th anniversary of a previous accolade, but I very much doubt that it will. That is my concern also, Southampton I guess is one club that had a batch of players come through but that seems to have dried up for now. I think we are being oversold the benefits of an Academy, of course we need one but I suspect we will only produce the odd player. I guess the best we can hope for is like the bigger clubs we produce a steady stream of lower league players who we hopefully get a transfer fee for.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
"There has been a recent change in Premier League rules which means that, by the start of the 2024/25 season, all Premier League clubs must have an Academy at Category Three level or higher. The opening of a Category Four Academy is a step towards eventually complying with the new regulations. It is also necessary to have an Academy in order to gain a licence to compete in UEFA competitions". Thanks for that Willo. That should put to bed arguments about whether or not to have an Academy. Edited by doombear (13 Jan 2023 9.21am) My pleasure.You are very welcome.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I think we have reached the Ceiling as a club, unless some billionaire comes along, if we had a 40.000 seat stadium, we wouldn't fill it every week, sustainability is what it is all about, mid table and a cup one day (hopefully) should be our ambitions, trying to play like Man City without the players is ridiculous and will end up with relegation, as for the academy it questionable if it is worth the money is debatable, if you provide one premier league standard a year then yes, if not go down the Brentford route and not have one. Agree, Although I think that it's not unreasonable to think that we can see some improvement on the playing side over time. There's been some good work behind the scenes, which I think everyone acknowledges, but for this not to be for nothing, then we must not neglect the playing side.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
"There has been a recent change in Premier League rules which means that, by the start of the 2024/25 season, all Premier League clubs must have an Academy at Category Three level or higher. The opening of a Category Four Academy is a step towards eventually complying with the new regulations. It is also necessary to have an Academy in order to gain a licence to compete in UEFA competitions". Thanks for that Willo. That should put to bed arguments about whether or not to have an Academy. Edited by doombear (13 Jan 2023 9.21am) So in 18 months' time, the Academy will become Premier-League-and-UEFA-mandated tick-box exercise bulls***.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by tonymair
For all that has been achieved since 2010… I don’t think you’re alone with that. My perception is that the likes of Brentford and Brighton have less ownership issues. Although Parish runs the day to day club business, he’s reliant on the buy-in of the other three owners/investors when it comes to the big decisions. And of course that includes funding. Tony Bloom has brought in top administrative talent eg Barber, Ashworth etc., but he’s ultimately the owner and decision maker, albeit guided by the aforementioned ( although of course Ashworth is now at Newcastle ). That gives them a huge advantage over our set up. So I think that at least two of our owners, Harris and Blitzer , are unwilling to do anything more than see Palace remain a mid table club. Without the ability to regularly, as opposed to in two/ three year cycles, compete in the transfer market we need to develop our own talent. Hence the investment in the Academy. That in itself provides no guarantees that it will be successful, but to have a competitive edge it is needed. As for the playing side, I think that Vieira did a very good job last season. That should have laid the foundations for an incremental improvement this season. But that has taken a step backwards largely because the squad wasn’t invested in and outgoing players not replaced. Although points wise it’s much the same, this season hasn’t had the feel good factor of last year. As for the stadium development, I’m pretty ambivalent about it. I understand the pro’s of getting it done but it’s dragged on for so long now that I’ve lost interest. It will inevitably mean that financial resources will be pointed in that direction. The danger is that we have a lovely new stand in which to watch Championship football. Blimey, I need cheering up…..apologies for length of post
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
I think the whole thing will feel better once/if a digger starts pulling down the main stand and the replacement starts going up. Until then, the week to week experience of a Palace fan is only ever a relegation away from watching pretty average players play pretty average teams in a stadium that has slightly better seats in some stands than it did 10 years ago. Being able to point at something and say 'that's better' will be a good milestone. I take it you're not a civil engineer or a health and safety professional then!
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Its great to have ambition and want for more. The difficulty we are in is having to temper that ambition. As even the teams in and around us spend significantly more than we do. But even with investment, its no guarantee of stability or progress. Look at Wolves, Everton, West Ham, all in trouble and big spenders/ Every so often teams will have a purple season and punch way above their weight, but in almost all occasions its a 1 off, and they soon sink back down the table to a more reasonable position. Whilst in the context of the footballing pyramid we are doing really well, its really hard to be happy with middle table every season. Relatively comfortable midtable finish every season I'd be very happy with comfortably mid table every season, and certainly Statistically that's where we are. It's the manner of how we are achieving it that's worrying. Always looking over our shoulders. Consistency of performance being a mythical beast that no one has seen for eons. Consistency gives a platform to build on. Last season was the first that gave real hope for the future for a long time, but it was clear to everyone that it was just a start, and more was needed, but it wasn't built on and now we feel somewhat like we are back where we were when RH left - in need of Another overhaul.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.