You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bad recruitment


Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Mar 23 12.43pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Let's indulge in a spot of whataboutery eh? But as we're here, I'd say that recent acquisitions of Guehi, Andersen, and Doucoure were very good. Olise I'd put on the fringe.
Mateta, Eduoard, and Eze on the other hand represent a complete waste of money. What's that, about £40m for those 3? Chuck in Ahamada who can't get a game for another £10m and we're nearing £50m worth of mediocrity.
I refer you to the other posts made before I got to answer your post, which more or less sum up the dreadful recruitment and the fact that it's not all about money, it's about having a quality scouting system in place.

I cannot comment about the "Scouting system" at CPFC but in general terms one could point to every club and discover both Hits and Misses.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 24 Mar 23 12.52pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Let's indulge in a spot of whataboutery eh? But as we're here, I'd say that recent acquisitions of Guehi, Andersen, and Doucoure were very good. Olise I'd put on the fringe.
Mateta, Eduoard, and Eze on the other hand represent a complete waste of money. What's that, about £40m for those 3? Chuck in Ahamada who can't get a game for another £10m and we're nearing £50m worth of mediocrity.
I refer you to the other posts made before I got to answer your post, which more or less sum up the dreadful recruitment and the fact that it's not all about money, it's about having a quality scouting system in place.

I think you might be in the minority in thinking Olise is on the fringe, and that Eze is a waste of money. Their form is up and down (more the latter lately), but we've every chance of getting a profit on both after getting a few years of skill and excitement.

Mateta is s***. Edouard has ability but has been poor. So that's one duff (for a relatively small outlay for a striker) and one on which the jury is out.

More to the point, where and why do you start and stop when assessing signings? The same people have been behind all our signings for years, and we have had a period of relative success unparalleled in over a century of trying, all within a limited budget. Not exactly evidence that they are incompetent, tight, greedy etc is it?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Mar 23 12.52pm

Originally posted by Willo

I cannot comment about the "Scouting system" at CPFC but in general terms one could point to every club and discover both Hits and Misses.

True Willo, but we have a player still on the books who was a sick note when we bought him, and he's still a sick note note now, we paid Max Meyer £100k pw to sit on his arse, Benteke given a new contract despite the fact he couldn't score for toffee, the list goes on and on. Best not mention Sorloth ha ha.
Still, don't panic, a number of players contract's expire soon and we'll be on the lookout for the next bunch. I'm sure Dougie is on the case.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (24 Mar 2023 1.22pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 24 Mar 23 1.17pm

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

I don't think you're having a go at all, and I'm certainly not, but you're right, I'm not having it!

Signing promising young players, loaning them out and hoping they develop into assets is exactly what everyone tries to do. What do you think palace are doing with Plange etc, as well as all the academy players?

Brighton haven't built a team for £20 - 30m. Their spending brushed up against ffp censure a couple of seasons ago, hence the asset stripping since. How many players did Brighton sign that didn't end up good enough? How many youngsters from the Brighton and Hove area has their path blocked by a lad from Africa, South America or Iran under their 'model'? We have four or five lads from (or at least raised) in south London in our team most weeks, including a big Palace fan making his debut in goal (albeit due to injury).

Does that make our model preferable to theirs? Probably not when we lose, but there will be no shortage of positive press when we win, and others will be saying they wished their club was more like ours when they get relegated with a room full of foreign players that can't wait to get away (as commonly happens). Again, the results make the very minor differences between models look far more important than they are, for better or worse.

Finally, I can't follow the argument that Palace have failed to sign for the future. That's exactly what the academy is, and exactly the point of going for Eze, Olise, Guehi, Doucoure, ahamada, ebouwei, Plange...

There isn't a million miles between what we do, Brighton do, and everyone else. It just feels like that when the team don't play too well. There is a big difference between a couple of signings having failed and the system that found them having done so.

Good stuff.

Signing young, loaning out and selling on is of course what everyone is aiming to do. And I 100% agree that in Eze, Olise, Guehi, Doucoure, Ahamada etc we are signing or the future.

The key difference is in the levels of sophistication in the model. The players we are signing are good, I agree, but very different:


1. Our signings, partly as we have nothing else, are coming straight into the first team

2. They are hardly 'scouted'. Eze ripping up the champs, Olise young players of the season, Guehi captained England at every level, Doucoure a senior international. This isn't unearthing gems, its buying players with enough experience to make them sensible buys. Anyone, and I mean anyone who keeps us with football could scout these players.

They are signing players that nobody has even ever heard of.

They are also doing something that we aren't doing (apart from Sorloth), turn a profit on a player. Have we ever made profit off of another signing?

Their model is mature and working, our model could get there, but only time will tell.

And re blocking local players, not sure that's true either. dunk, March and Ferguson in the first team. Ben White sold recently.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Mar 23 1.30pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I would say that both Brentford and Brighton have a model we should aspire to. Both have squads busting with talent, and non of it cost much. Its having the right people and the right plan and sticking to it.

Yeah of course Brighton have signed some duffs. But most of their signings are relatively low cost and so they can afford for a few not to work.

And the fact that you don't rate their model is insane and also means you have no real understanding of how brilliant it is.

A few years ago, it was the Southampton model that we were supposed to follow, look where they are now. There is no perfect formula, not every purchase works out, many clubs have failures, but we don’t know about, as don’t follow those clubs.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 24 Mar 23 1.59pm

Originally posted by Painter

A few years ago, it was the Southampton model that we were supposed to follow, look where they are now. There is no perfect formula, not every purchase works out, many clubs have failures, but we don’t know about, as don’t follow those clubs.

It hard to know if Southampton had something really good (great local scouts or coaches) or just a purple patch with the academy. As I cant think of another decent player that's come though since JWP.

Similar to Utd, class of 92 was an anomaly. In Rashford and Greenwood they do still churn some out, but nothing like that period.

Whatever the ideals or model, something is wrong. Threadbare squad, and don't make any player profit.

 

PatrickA Flag London 24 Mar 23 2.06pm

There is no one fixed model; it evolves depending upon the circumstances of the club.
For example, we had a phase of buying established Premier League players like Cabaye, Sakho and Benteke to allow a quick step up in quality to improve our standing.
We then had a phase of having expensive players on long term contracts that curtailed our financial flexibility.
We just 'patched up ' the squad.
When we had greater flexibility we moved for talented younger players of potential, while at the same time reducing the wage bill.
While some of the above makes sense, it does mean we currently have an unbalanced squad with 3/4 players for some positions and perhaps just one (at least of sufficient quality) for others.
Those defending the club will say it takes a few transfers windows to wash through.
Others take the view that it all seems a bit disjointed

 

Joseph Paxton Flag Lancing 24 Mar 23 11.55pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

There is no one fixed model; it evolves depending upon the circumstances of the club.
For example, we had a phase of buying established Premier League players like Cabaye, Sakho and Benteke to allow a quick step up in quality to improve our standing.
We then had a phase of having expensive players on long term contracts that curtailed our financial flexibility.
We just 'patched up ' the squad.
When we had greater flexibility we moved for talented younger players of potential, while at the same time reducing the wage bill.
While some of the above makes sense, it does mean we currently have an unbalanced squad with 3/4 players for some positions and perhaps just one (at least of sufficient quality) for others.
Those defending the club will say it takes a few transfers windows to wash through.
Others take the view that it all seems a bit disjointed

Benteke was bought with a strategy in mind. We had the pacy wingers of Zaha and Bolasie and they were supposed to provide the ammunition for him to power home. When that didn't work out, and for all the outlay we seem to have been nonplussed at playing to strikers strengths since with a strategy.

Sorloth got 4 match starts under Roy. He has done well in Turkey and now Spain with Sociedad. It can't just be recruitment, it is coaching and strategy and tactics - and development too.

Connor G ended up unbalancing us and weve not adjusted this season. Midfield and Strikers coaching, need some ideas and guile.


 


Be where you are; otherwise you will miss your life.

southnorwoodhill Flag 25 Mar 23 6.37am

Originally posted by Joseph Paxton

Benteke was bought with a strategy in mind. We had the pacy wingers of Zaha and Bolasie and they were supposed to provide the ammunition for him to power home. When that didn't work out, and for all the outlay we seem to have been nonplussed at playing to strikers strengths since with a strategy.

Sorloth got 4 match starts under Roy. He has done well in Turkey and now Spain with Sociedad. It can't just be recruitment, it is coaching and strategy and tactics - and development too.

Connor G ended up unbalancing us and weve not adjusted this season. Midfield and Strikers coaching, need some ideas and guile.


An interesting way of putting it. By illustrating what is necessary to play at a improved level consistently over a season he rather led the way.

 

Wright stuff Flag Bexley 25 Mar 23 8.46am

Though I was not admirer of the man , Alex Ferguson’s achievements are unrivalled .
Obviously he had the team of 92 & money. However his ethos was to have 2 players in each position competing against each other & for back up in case 1 was injured.
When 1 of the players started to under achieve or just become too old Man U looked for a like for like replacement.
Therefore the team could function and play the system devised.
At the end it was difficult for him to replace players like Scholes & Giggs, but he carried on as he started.
Ferguson or whoever did the recruiitment was not afraid to blood every day players along side the better players, whichever made the team a team.
Unfortunately we do not keep a Manager long enough to build up a strategy of play all the current players & ones that come in can follow, however we should at least have 2 players for each position & moved on the players that are not up to it, like Luca, Ward, Thompkins etc.
There are bargains out there in other leagues waiting for their opportunity as Brighton, Brentford & Fulham have proved.
I really do think it is time Palace found an expert in recruitment, pay him well as it will pay dividends eventually, rather than Dougie Freedman, even though he has the clubs best interests at heart.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Mar 23 8.56am

Originally posted by Wright stuff

Though I was not admirer of the man , Alex Ferguson’s achievements are unrivalled .
Obviously he had the team of 92 & money. However his ethos was to have 2 players in each position competing against each other & for back up in case 1 was injured.
When 1 of the players started to under achieve or just become too old Man U looked for a like for like replacement.
Therefore the team could function and play the system devised.
At the end it was difficult for him to replace players like Scholes & Giggs, but he carried on as he started.
Ferguson or whoever did the recruiitment was not afraid to blood every day players along side the better players, whichever made the team a team.
Unfortunately we do not keep a Manager long enough to build up a strategy of play all the current players & ones that come in can follow, however we should at least have 2 players for each position & moved on the players that are not up to it, like Luca, Ward, Thompkins etc.
There are bargains out there in other leagues waiting for their opportunity as Brighton, Brentford & Fulham have proved.
I really do think it is time Palace found an expert in recruitment, pay him well as it will pay dividends eventually, rather than Dougie Freedman, even though he has the clubs best interests at heart.

Very few Premier clubs keep managers more than 2 seasons, Ferguson and Wenger were the exceptions rather than the rule.
People keep saying move players on, but if they have contract and nobody wants to buy them because of wages, you have to wait until their contract expires.

 

PatrickA Flag London 25 Mar 23 9.26am

Parish likes to surround himself with lots of Palace old boys at the club, including Bright, Freedman, McCarthy, Powell and Derry (formerly, although apparently still on the payroll).
Nothing wrong with this in itself as these are people he may well trust and who he believes have the club’s best interests at heart.
However, from a dispassionate standpoint are they the best qualified in their positions that could be hired from a professional standpoint?
We’ve used another former player James Scowcroft as a scout , mainly in France.
I can’t believe that best practice means only employing Palace old boys.
This extends to extolling the virtues of Roy because he’s a Croydon boy and a Palace fan as if this makes him a better manager.
As a matter of fact, he’s had a very solid career which means he’s qualified to do the job anyway so the local connection is incidental rather than the key reason for his recruitment.
I’m not sure the same could be said about some others employed.
Perhaps this seems harsh, but if we want to aspire to improve in scouting and across the board, we surely have to look outside the Palace network too.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 25 Mar 23 9.37am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Parish likes to surround himself with lots of Palace old boys at the club, including Bright, Freedman, McCarthy, Powell and Derry (formerly, although apparently still on the payroll).
Nothing wrong with this in itself as these are people he may well trust and who he believes have the club’s best interests at heart.
However, from a dispassionate standpoint are they the best qualified in their positions that could be hired from a professional standpoint?
We’ve used another former player James Scowcroft as a scout , mainly in France.
I can’t believe that best practice means only employing Palace old boys.
This extends to extolling the virtues of Roy because he’s a Croydon boy and a Palace fan as if this makes him a better manager.
As a matter of fact, he’s had a very solid career which means he’s qualified to do the job anyway so the local connection is incidental rather than the key reason for his recruitment.
I’m not sure the same could be said about some others employed.
Perhaps this seems harsh, but if we want to aspire to improve in scouting and across the board, we surely have to look outside the Palace network too.

Logically it follows that Palace will never win anything. Maybe a play-off or reach a cup final. Explains why Parish brought in FdB and PV, in the bold hope that their respective experience at a higher level would express itself on the field, but one needs a solid foundation first. One left back, two past it right backs,
two hopeless strikers, and a load of dead wood means that the struggle will continue for some time yet.


Edited by southnorwoodhill (25 Mar 2023 8.23pm)

 

Oxford Don Flag North West of SP 25 Mar 23 10.26am

What a really good thread this is turning out to be - thoughtful, intelligent and conducted in a relatively constructive manner. I've just re-read it from the beginning and now can't resist throwing in my own two penny worth!

I do think that canny recruitment is so central to any strategic plan for survival (or better) in the PL that we need to be looking at what makes others apparently better/more successful at it than we currently seem to be. Lots of good ideas/observations already made here but one that does seem to have slipped under the radar is something that both Brighton and Brentford (perhaps others?) use and that has helped both punch above their weight.

What both of those clubs seem to have recognised is that while having a good scouting network is a probably a given there is also another essential (more objective?) tool in the box: data analytics. It's probably no coincidence that the two Bs are both owned by men experienced in the world of professional gambling where data analytics is a key component in risk assessment. Nothing probably betters a good scouting network for identifying potential but data analytics provides assessment of the likelihood of that potential being realised. (It might possibly even be useful in assessing the potential of our academy players.)

If I'm right (more importantly, if they are right!) it won't take long before others cotton on so I just don't think we can afford not to start exploring its potential if we're not to be left far behind. Unfortunately it doesn't come cheap: Brighton's latest accounts reveal they paid a Data Analytics company £3mn for their services.

Finally, I'd have to say that I do have worries that our scouting network itself may not be up with the best and unless we get that sorted all the data analytics in the world won't count for a didley s***. I'd be interested in others' thoughts on that point.

 


You can't change the way things are but you can change the way you are with the way things are.

Zaha127 Flag 25 Mar 23 10.59am

Honestly though a lot of the recruitment has been decent.

Andersen, Guehi, Olise, Eze have all been good signings. Doucoure has been immense the unsung hero in the Palace side

Ahamada needs more time but could turn out to be decent player. Richards will be a decent player in my opinion has not played much but when he has played Richards has been decent. Same with Hughes has not played much but I think if he was given a run in the side he would do well.

Edouard, Mateta have not really done much yet. Edouard should easily be getting 10+ goals every season considering he has players like Zaha, Olise and Eze around him.


Most of the signings in the past few years have been decent considering that Palace do not have the same finances as West Ham, Leicester, Villa. Wolves, Everton. Really Edouard and Mateta need to score more goals and they have not shined yet.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 25 Mar 23 11.01am

Originally posted by Oxford Don

What a really good thread this is turning out to be - thoughtful, intelligent and conducted in a relatively constructive manner. I've just re-read it from the beginning and now can't resist throwing in my own two penny worth!

I do think that canny recruitment is so central to any strategic plan for survival (or better) in the PL that we need to be looking at what makes others apparently better/more successful at it than we currently seem to be. Lots of good ideas/observations already made here but one that does seem to have slipped under the radar is something that both Brighton and Brentford (perhaps others?) use and that has helped both punch above their weight.

What both of those clubs seem to have recognised is that while having a good scouting network is a probably a given there is also another essential (more objective?) tool in the box: data analytics. It's probably no coincidence that the two Bs are both owned by men experienced in the world of professional gambling where data analytics is a key component in risk assessment. Nothing probably betters a good scouting network for identifying potential but data analytics provides assessment of the likelihood of that potential being realised. (It might possibly even be useful in assessing the potential of our academy players.)

If I'm right (more importantly, if they are right!) it won't take long before others cotton on so I just don't think we can afford not to start exploring its potential if we're not to be left far behind. Unfortunately it doesn't come cheap: Brighton's latest accounts reveal they paid a Data Analytics company £3mn for their services.

Finally, I'd have to say that I do have worries that our scouting network itself may not be up with the best and unless we get that sorted all the data analytics in the world won't count for a didley s***. I'd be interested in others' thoughts on that point.

Your points on Brighton and Brentford are valid, but its taken them a longtime to reap the rewards, its not a quick fix. Palaces problem is they are already in the Premier and are try to change from buying older players and now investing in youth with the Academy. We are currently in our longest period in the top flight ever, so we must be doing something right, staying there is the prime objective until the Academy starts to deliver.
If your not backed by the wealth of an oil rich nation, you have to try something else, there is no easy answer.

 

PatrickA Flag London 25 Mar 23 11.03am

Very good points.
The evidence suggests that this type of analysis produces good results in the main rather than just being a flavour of the month for this year.
I wonder whether for example Brentford or Brighton would e.g have purchased an injured player (Ferguson) or a player with a poor injury record (Richards).
Sometimes it appears we take a punt with a view to getting a bargain.
Even somebody like Sakho ,who intially was outstanding for us persuading us to buy him.
You look at his full past history with his disciplinary and fitness issues and ask what was the evidence that this would that change with Palace in future seasons.
Some would argue that's the only reason we could get a player of that quality, but is it a good enough reason when you look at the downsides with him rarely showing up after that initial good period.
It's not hindsight if the evidence pointed to this direction of travel when signing him.


Originally posted by Oxford Don

What a really good thread this is turning out to be - thoughtful, intelligent and conducted in a relatively constructive manner. I've just re-read it from the beginning and now can't resist throwing in my own two penny worth!

I do think that canny recruitment is so central to any strategic plan for survival (or better) in the PL that we need to be looking at what makes others apparently better/more successful at it than we currently seem to be. Lots of good ideas/observations already made here but one that does seem to have slipped under the radar is something that both Brighton and Brentford (perhaps others?) use and that has helped both punch above their weight.

What both of those clubs seem to have recognised is that while having a good scouting network is a probably a given there is also another essential (more objective?) tool in the box: data analytics. It's probably no coincidence that the two Bs are both owned by men experienced in the world of professional gambling where data analytics is a key component in risk assessment. Nothing probably betters a good scouting network for identifying potential but data analytics provides assessment of the likelihood of that potential being realised. (It might possibly even be useful in assessing the potential of our academy players.)

If I'm right (more importantly, if they are right!) it won't take long before others cotton on so I just don't think we can afford not to start exploring its potential if we're not to be left far behind. Unfortunately it doesn't come cheap: Brighton's latest accounts reveal they paid a Data Analytics company £3mn for their services.

Finally, I'd have to say that I do have worries that our scouting network itself may not be up with the best and unless we get that sorted all the data analytics in the world won't count for a didley s***. I'd be interested in others' thoughts on that point.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 25 Mar 23 5.07pm

I would suggest that quite a few issues coming to light surely come down to having a pretty poor Director of Football.
Surely, recruiting is a major focus of DOF.
But also, if our coaching is poor, would that be noticed by a Director of Football?
I think we should look for an experienced Director of Football.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Oxford Don Flag North West of SP 25 Mar 23 5.22pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Very good points.
The evidence suggests that this type of analysis produces good results in the main rather than just being a flavour of the month for this year.
I wonder whether for example Brentford or Brighton would e.g have purchased an injured player (Ferguson) or a player with a poor injury record (Richards).
Sometimes it appears we take a punt with a view to getting a bargain.
Even somebody like Sakho ,who intially was outstanding for us persuading us to buy him.
You look at his full past history with his disciplinary and fitness issues and ask what was the evidence that this would that change with Palace in future seasons.
Some would argue that's the only reason we could get a player of that quality, but is it a good enough reason when you look at the downsides with him rarely showing up after that initial good period.
It's not hindsight if the evidence pointed to this direction of travel when signing him.


I don't know for sure but your point regarding fitness and disciplinary records being a likely part of the analytics makes absolute sense Patrick. Anything that reduced the risk to the potential investment would make perfect sense with this type of approach - I have heard that Brighton even do research on potential signings' social media profiles to ensure the best chance of a fit with their existing group.

 


You can't change the way things are but you can change the way you are with the way things are.

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 25 Mar 23 5.45pm

OK, going to play a bit of devil's advocate here and stick my head above the parapet (gets ready to duck).

Is our recruitment that bad?

In the last couple of years we have purchased Guehi, Andersen, Eze and Olise. I honestly think all of those players have been value for money.

I get everyone is looking at he likes of Brighton and Brentford and their recent success in recruitment which is notable I accept. It is interesting Brentford shut down their academy, are the resources that would otherwise have gone to that being used to fund their scouting and recruitment network. No possibility of `homegrown` local lads coming through the ranks there. how would the fanbase feel if we did not have an academy at all?

although Brighton and Brentford stand out at the moment, it is always the case that at different times different clubs seem to be in the ascendency with regards to recruitment. Not so long ago people were applauding the likes of Southampton for their ability to find players not to mention Swansea. Where are they now?

As much as there is a Brighton and Brentford there are also the clubs who have done a lot worse. Look at the likes of Everton! spent stupid amounts (Moise Keane, Sigurdsson) and news today they are being referred by the PL for breaking FFP.

 

Page 4 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bad recruitment